- 1 - !"# $"% "" " & &'() & (( * !"!#$ ! !"!#$ % & ' ( ( )!"!#* " Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( + ! !"!# % & ( ( ( ' ( !" ( &' +" ( & ' ( ( ( ( *"+ ( #! " ( #! ( (( *$&' *"&+' *&!' ( #* ( ( (* &'( ( ( - 3 - , -./01234 .3/0/012 05 67 /83 .3/0/012395 -::;534 .395125 533<02= >;-5802= 1? /83 .91:33402=5 .32402= 02 90@3 1" #! 1? 81A< 1B0:3 /-/012 -B-6;9-=0 ?19/831??32:3.;2058-6B3;24393:/0125*$&'*"&+' 93-4A0/83:/012 *&!' 1? 8-9-/07- 7-7- -280/- #* .32402=12/83?0B31?44B0C0B;4=3&'-24( 1;9/-B-6;9-=0 83 =9-C-@32 1? /83 :1@.B-02/ 05 /8-/ /83 :1@.B-02-2/D5?-/839B-/38933@-2/BB-BA80B3539C02=-5 - 09:B3 1B0:3 25.3:/19 -/ 9-@02 1B0:3 /-/012 -B-6;9-=0 8-4 :124;:/34 - 9-04 -=-025/ :-22-605 :;B/0C-/195A80:8-BB3=34B7.91C1<34-2-55-;B/67-@16 1? -61;/ +#)!# .395125 A02= /1 /83 =903C1;5 02E;9035 5;5/-0234 83 93>;0934 -4C-2:34 @340:-B /93-/@32/ -24 A-5 580?/34 /1 32=-B;9; ;902= /805 .39014 /83 :1@.B-02-2/:B-0@5/8-/83A-5:125/9-0234/132/9;5//83 4-7 /1 4-7 @-2-=3@32/ 1? ;B-E- 8-C-20 3/91B3;@ - 4 - ;@. /1 /83 .93532/ .3/0/012395 / 05 -BB3=34 /8-/ /-<02= ;24;3 -4C-2/-=3 1? /83 :1@.B-02-2/D5 -6532:3 /83 .3/0/012395 A81 -93 ?;BB 691/8395 @05;534 /83 /9;5/ 93.153402/83@-24@05-..91.90-/34/835-B3.91:33451? ?;3B -24 -BB034 .914;:/5 83 :1@.B-02-2/ -5539/5 /8-/ ;.12 C390?0:-/012 1? /83 /;921C39 -::1;2/5 -24 /83 /-F -;40/93.19/?19/83?02-2:0-B73-9#*)#+0/:-@3/1 B0=8/ /8-/ ?;245 /1 /83 3F/32/ 1? 5G##### A393 50.812341??80593C3B-/012.91@./34/83B14=02=1?/83 :1@.B-02/ :;B@02-/02= 02 /83 93=05/9-/012 1? /83 .93532/ :90@3 * 83 .3/0/012395 8-C3 51;=8/ >;-5802= 1? /83 .91:33402=5 :12/32402= /8-/ /83 ?095/ .3/0/01239 8-4 230/839-;/8190/7219935.125060B0/7/18-24B3/83?02-2:0-B 19 6-2<02= 1.39-/0125 1? /83 .3/91B .;@. -24 /8-/ 805 -BB3=34 91B3 -5 - @-2-=39 05 53901;5B7 405.;/34 83 53:124.3/0/01239A8105/83691/8391?/83?095/.3/0/01239 B0<3A053 432035 8-C02= -27 91B3 02 @-02/-0202= 19 @-2-=02=/83-::1;2/51?/83?09@/05?;9/839:12/32434 - 5 - /8-//83-BB3=-/012502/83:1@.B-02/3C320?/-<32-/?-:3 C-B;30240:-/3-632-@0-99-2=3@32/A80:8053F.9355B7 .918060/34 ;2439 /83 918060/012 1? 32-@0 91.39/7 9-25-:/0125 :/ "" 83 ?095/ .3/0/01239 8-5 -B51 -5539/34/8-/12B7-4;B7>;-B0?034-24:1@.3/32/.39512 :-2 63 -..102/34 -5 - @-2-=39 1? - :1@@39:0-B 35/-6B058@32/ 2 /8353 .93@0535 0/ 05 ;9=34 /8-/ /83 405.;/3 05 .;93B7 :0C0B 02 2-/;93 -24 /8-/ /83 53:124 935.12432/ :1@.B-02-2/ 8-5 @05;534 /83 :90@02-B B-A @-:802397/153//B3-:0C0B405.;/3A-99-2/02=>;-5802=1? /83.91:33402=5 + 39 :12/9- /83 B3-9234 0=8 1;9/ 1C392@32/ B3-439 12 - .39;5-B 1? /83 @-/390-B5 -C-0B-6B3 -/ /805 5/-=3A1;B45;6@0//8-//83-BB3=-/0125405:B153- .90@- ?-:03:-531?:90@02-B693-:81?/9;5/02C1BC02=40C3950121? 5;65/-2/0-B ?;245 A80:8 23:355-90B7 :-BB5 ?19 - /8191;=8 02C35/0=-/012 / 05 /8393?193 :12/32434 /8-/ /83 .91:33402=5:-221/6302/3940:/34-//83/893581B4 - 6 - ! 83 B3-9234 32019 1;253B -..3-902= ?19 /83 53:124 935.12432/ 8-5 ?0B34 - 43/-0B34 5/-/3@32/ 1? 16E3:/0125 -B12= A0/8 53C39-B 41:;@32/5 /1 5;65/-2/0-/3 /8-//83?095/.3/0/01239A-532/9;5/34A0/8/83.3/91B.;@. 02/83:-.-:0/71?-@-2-=39-24A-502:1@.B3/3:12/91B 1? 0/5 4-7 /1 4-7 -??-095 3B0-2:3 05 .B-:34 12 41:;@32/-97 @-/390-B /1 581A /8-/ /83 53:124 .3/0/01239 A-5 @-2-=02= /83 -::1;2/5 1? /83 ?09@ 02:B;402= 60BB5 9-0534028052-@3/839367:12/9-40:/02=8054320-B1?-27 -::1;2/02= 91B3 3?39902= /1 /83 -;40/ 93.19/ -24 6-2< -::1;2/5/-/3@32/50/05:12/32434/8-/40C3950121?5-B3 .91:3345 ?1BB1A34 67 5;653>;32/ 93 :9340/ 1? 5;65/-2/0-B -@1;2/5 A832 >;35/01234 .90@- ?-:03 35/-6B05835 /83 02C1BC3@32/1?61/8.3/0/01239502@05-..91.90-/0121?/83 ?09@D5?;245B-:02=93B0-2:312/83.902:0.B3532;2:0-/34 02/-/31? -24 /83 E;4=@32/ 1? /83 12D6B3 ;.93@3 1;9/ 02 ! 1 $#+ - 7 - " 0/ 05 -9=;34 /8-/ 3:121@0: 1??32:35 5/-24 12 - 405/02:/ ?11/02= 8-C3 A0439 51:03/-B 9-@0?0:-/0125 -24 /8393?193 :-221/ 63 >;-5834 -/ /83 2-5:32/ 5/-=3 1? 02C35/0=-/012 83 B3-9234 32019 1;253B -::19402=B7 ;9=35 /8-/ /83 2C35/0=-/02= ??0:39 63 .39@0//34 /1 :1@.B3/3/8302C35/0=-/012-24/8-//8050521/-?0/:-53?19 3F39:0531?E;90540:/012;24393:/012+"1?9 $ -C02= 83-94 /83 B3-9234 :1;253B -..3-902= ?19 /83.-9/035-2412.39;5-B1?/8341:;@32/5.914;:3467 /8353:124935.12432//8051;9/21/35/8-/-B/81;=867 19439 4-/34 *#! -2 02/390@ .91/3:/012 A-5 =9-2/34 12 /83 .93@053 /8-/ /83 :1@.B-02-2/ 8-4 -2 3??0:-:01;5 :0C0B 93@347 /83 5;653>;32/ .914;:/012 1? :1;2/39 41:;@32/567/8353:124935.12432/23:3550/-/35 - :B1539 3F-@02-/012 1? /83 @-//39 2 /8-/ C03A 1? /83 @-//39/83?1BB1A02=.102/5-9053?19:1250439-/012 2 #!!G - 8 - H0' 83/839 02 /83 ?-:/5 -24 :09:;@5/-2:35 1? /83.93532/:-53/83.3/0/0123958-C3@-431;/ -:-53?19>;-5802=1?/83.91:33402=5I 00' 83/839 ;.12 :1250439-/012 1? /83 90C-B :12/32/0125 -24 /83 @-/390-B .B-:34 12 93:194 /83 405.;/3 05 35532/0-BB7 :0C0B 02 2-/;93 19 A83/839 0/ 405:B1535 - .90@- ?-:03 :-53 1? :90@02-B 693-:8 1? /9;5/ A-99-2/02= ?;9/839 02C35/0=-/012IJ +,-+,.,/+,01+2,-++ G 9402-90B7A8393/8051;9/?0245/8-/-405.;/305 .9341@02-2/B7 :1@@39:0-B 19 :0C0B 02 2-/;93 0/ A1;B4 02 3F39:0531?0/53F/9-19402-97E;90540:/012;24393:/012!" 1?/838-9-/07--=-90<;9-<58--280/-#*B3-202 ?-C1;9 1? =9-2/02= 024;B=32:3 /1 /83 B0/0=-2/5 1A3C39 /83 ?-:/;-B @-/90F 1? /83 .93532/ :-53 5/-245 12 -2 32/093B740??3932/?11/02=81;=861/8/83.3/0/0123958-C3 C383@32/B7 432034 /8309 935.3:/0C3 91B35 /83 @-/390-B - 9 - .B-:34 12 93:194 67 /83 :1@.B-02-2/ -/ /805 .90@- ?-:03 5/-=30240:-/351/839A05383:1@.B-02-2/8-56332-6B3 /143@125/9-/3/8-//83?095/.3/0/01239A-532/9;5/34A0/8 /83935.125060B0/71?@-2-=02=/83.3/91B.;@.-24A-502 :1@.B3/3 :12/91B 1? 0/5 4-7 /1 4-7 -??-095 0<3A053 /83 :1@.B-02-2/ 8-5 .90@- ?-:03 35/-6B05834 /8-/ /83 53:124 .3/0/01239 A81 05 /83 ?;BB 691/839 1? /83 ?095/ .3/0/01239 A-58-24B02=-241C3953302=/83-::1;2/51?/83?09@ " //8055/-=3/83:1@.B-02-2/8-5-B516332-6B3 /1581A/8-//835-B3.91:33451?/83?09@A39391;/34/1 /83 .39512-B 6-2< -::1;2/ 1? /83 53:124 .3/0/01239 A81 A-5 32/9;5/34 A0/8 -::1;2/02= 935.125060B0/035 83 -??04-C0/1?;2439/-<02=3F3:;/3467/83?095/.3/0/0123902 A80:8/8353:124.3/0/0123905581A2-5-A0/2355.90@- ?-:03 -550=25 -24 -:<21AB34=35 /83 91B3 1? /83 ?095/ .3/0/01239 -5 /83 .;@. @-2-=39 (;9/839 -5 .102/34 1;/ 67/83B3-9234:1;253B-..3-902=?19/83:1@.B-02-2//83 6-2< 5/-/3@32/5 1? /83 ?09@ 405:B153 /8-/ 5;65/-2/0-B -@1;2/5 A80:8 A393 020/0-BB7 40C39/34 /1 /83 .39512-B - 10 - -::1;2/ 1? /83 53:124 .3/0/01239 A393 5;653>;32/B7 :9340/346-:</1/83?09@D5-::1;2/8353:09:;@5/-2:35 :1;.B34 A0/8 /83 /-F -;40/ 93.19/ 93B034 ;.12 67 /83 :1@.B-02-2/ 9-053 53901;5 >;35/0125 A80:8 23:355-90B7 93>;093 - 43/-0B34 02C35/0=-/012 67 /83 2C35/0=-/02= ??0:39 2 - 81B05/0: 3F-@02-/012 1? /8353 :1;2/39 41:;@32/5 /805 1;9/ 05 21/ .395;-434 /1 -::3./ /83 :12/32/012 /8-/ /83 405.;/3 05 .;93B7 :0C0B 02 2-/;93 83 :1@.B-02-2/ 8-5 5.3:0?0:-BB7 .B3-434 /8-/ 1A02= /1 -2 ;2/1A-94 02:0432/ 02 A80:8 805 ?-/839 A-5 -BB3=34B7 -55-;B/34 02 - :90@02-B :-53 -24 A-5 :1@.3BB34 /1 580?/ /3@.19-90B7/132=-B;9;?19@340:-B/93-/@32//8332/093 @-2-=3@32/ -24 -??-095 1? /83 .3/91B .;@. A393 32/9;5/34/1/83?095/.3/0/01239/0502/8056-:<491./8-/ -BB3=-/0125 8-C3 5;9?-:34 /8-/ /83 ?095/ .3/0/01239 02 :1BB;5012A0/8/8353:124.3/0/01239A81A-58-24B02=/83 -::1;2/5 40C39/34 /83 5-B3 .91:33451? /83 ?09@ ?19 /8309 .39512-B 6323?0/ 83/839 5;:8 -:/5 :125/0/;/3 :90@02-B - 11 - 693-:81?/9;5/-24-BB0341??32:35?-BB02=A0/802/83-@60/ 1? 3:/0125 *$&' *"&+' 93-4 A0/8 3:/012 *&!' 1? /83 8-9-/07-7-7--280/-#*05-@-//39A80:85>;-93B7 ?-BB5 A0/802 /83 41@-02 1? 02C35/0=-/012 8393?193 /805 1;9/051?/83:125043934C03A/8-//83-BB3=-/0125:-221/ 6369;5834-5043-//83/893581B4-24/8-//8050521/-?0/ :-53 /1 02/3940:/ /83 02C35/0=-/012 19 /1 >;-58 /83 .91:33402=5-//8052-5:32/5/-=3 # 83 .902:0.B35 32;2:0-/34 67 /83 ;2E-6 -24 -97-2- 0=8 1;9/ -5 A3BB -5/83B-AB-04 41A2 67 /83 12D6B3 ;.93@3 1;9/ 02 02358 8-9@- &5;.9-' -93 5>;-93B7 -//9-:/34 /1 /83 ?-:/5 1? /83 .93532/ :-53 :121@0: 1??32:35 67 /8309 C397 2-/;93 5/-24 12 - 405/02:/ ?11/02= -24 8-C3 A0439 9-@0?0:-/0125 -24 /8393?193/8302C35/0=-/0C3.91:3551;=8/21//1635/0?B34 -/ /83 02:3./012 ..B702= /83 -?1935-04 .902:0.B35 /805 1;9/ ?0245 21 @390/ 02 /83 .93532/ .3/0/012 A80:8 05 -::19402=B7B0-6B3/163405@05534 - 12 - / 05 81A3C39 :B-90?034 /8-/ /805 1;9/ 8-5 21/ 3F.935534 -27 1.02012 12 /83 @390/5 1? /83 :-53 27 16539C-/0125@-43839302-9312B7?19/83B0@0/34.;9.153 1?43:0402=/83.93532/.3/0/012-2458-BB21/02?B;32:3/83 2C35/0=-/02= ??0:39A8158-BB0243.32432/B7:124;://83 02C35/0=-/012 ;23-9/8 /83 /9;/8 -24 ?0B3 - ?02-B 93.19/ 5/90:/B702-::194-2:3A0/8B-A::19402=B7/83.102/5?19 :1250439-/012-93-25A393402/8323=-/0C3 2/83935;B//83.3/0/0125/-245A0/8 /83-61C316539C-/0125 -) & ""( % 051B1*