- 1 - !! " !# # $ %&"""!#!' (% ) ! "# $ %# & ! # ' !! $ ( # ) ## ## Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) % ) ' ! "# %$ % * + & ! * ((' * * ! !!! * * *+ )(, ! * # * ! ' * ! ,(' * * $ * ! * -.* ! * /# $ ! "! /# $ & 01 2314156 21676785 74 9: ;1<15;=56 8 75 601 4>76 75 8,(' ?08 0=4 @0=AA15B1; 601 83;13 8< 601 - 3 - 637=A 8>36 2=441; 85 )(, ?01319: 8 <7A1; 9: 601 ;1<15;=56 8 >5;13 1@6785 3? 3;13 ' >A1 8< ! 0=4 9115 ;74C7441; ?760 @8464 ( 01 9371< <=@64 C=;1 8>6 =5; =4 =31 31A1D=56 68 601 ;74284=A 8< 601 2314156 C=6613 74 60=6 601 2A=7567<< 0=; <7A1; 4>76 75 8,(' 411E75B <83 2=4475B 8< = 231A7C75=3: ;1@311 2136=7575B 68 601 4@01;>A1 2382136714 68 601 1F6156 8< 0=A< 40=31 8< 601 2A=7567<<+ 2=44 = ;1@311 <83 @=5@1AA=6785 8< 601 31B746131; C836B=B1 ;11; 1F1@>61; 9: ;1<15;=56 8 75 <=D8>3 8< ;1<15;=56 84( =5; )+ =5; <83 = ;1@A=3=6785 60=6 601 4=C1 =31 586 975;75B 85 601 2A=7567<< 75 31421@6 8< 601 0=A< 40=31 8< 601 2A=7567<< 75 601 4>76 4@01;>A1 2382136714+ ;1@311 <83 238<764 8< 4. 75 <=D8>3 8< 601 2A=7567<< =4 =B=7546 ;1<15;=56 84 68 ) ) >375B 601 @8>341 8< 4>@0 238@11;75B4 8 @=C1 68 91 <7A1; 9: 601 2A=7567<< 411E75B <83 =C15;C156 8< 601 2A=756 411E75B 68 ;1A161 @136=75 761C 75 601 4>76 4@01;>A1 =5; =A48 411E75B 68 =;; @136=75 - 4 - =D13C1564 =4 ;16=7A1; =6 2=3= 8)"=& =4 ?1AA =4 2=3= 8"=& 6 74 601 @=41 8< 601 ;1<15;=56 8 60=6 4=7; =22A7@=6785 @=C1 68 91 <7A1; ?760 =5 =<<7;=D76 ?07@0 85A: C1567854 60=6 601 2382841; =C15;C156 ?=4 586 48>B06 1=3A713 ?07@0 74 = C746=E1 =5; 60=6 @0=5B14 75 601 4>3D1: 5>C913 @=C1 68 601 2A=7567<<G4 E58?A1;B1 4>941H>156A: =5; =@@83;75BA: 601 =22A7@=6785 ;1413D14 68 91 =AA8?1; 01 4=7; =22A7@=6785 @=C1 68 91 <7A1; 85 ((, =5; 4=7; =22A7@=6785 ?=4 01=3; =5; ;742841 8< 85 601 4=C1 ;=: =4 74 1D7;156 <38C 601 238@11;75B 31<A1@61; 75 601 83;13 40116 85 ((, 6 74 601 @=41 8< 601 ;1<15;=56 8 60=6 =22A7@=6785 74 =AA8?1; ?7608>6 =<<83;75B =5 822836>576: 68 601 ;1<15;=564 68 <7A1 46=61C156 8< 89I1@67854 68 601 4=7; =22A7@=6785 =5; =@@83;75BA: 601 ;1<15;=56 8 0=4 48>B06 68 <7A1 =5 =22A7@=6785 >5;13 1@6785 3? 3;13 ' >A1 8< ! 411E75B 68 31D71? 601 83;13 ;=61; ((, ?01319: 601 75613A8@>683: =22A7@=6785 <7A1; 9: 601 2A=7567<< - 5 - @=C1 68 91 =AA8?1; =5; 0=4 48>B06 <83 416675B =47;1 8< 601 4=7; 83;13 =5; 411E4 213C744785 68 <7A1 46=61C156 8< 89I1@67854 68 601 4=7; 75613A8@>683: =22A7@=6785 01 @8>541A <83 601 ;1<15;=56 8 0=4 <7A1; C1C83=5;>C 8< <=@64 75 31421@6 8< 601 4=7; =22A7@=6785 =5; 4>9C764 60=6 601 ;1<15;=56 8 ;7; 586 0=D1 =5: 822836>576: <83 01=375B =5; =22A7@=6785 ?=4 =AA8?1; 85 601 4=C1 ;=: 6 ?=4 421@7<7@=AA: =D1331; 75 601 C1C83=5;>C 8< <=@64 60=6 601 2382841; =C15;C1564 9: ?=: 8< =441367854 75 601 2A1=;75B4 0=4 601 1<<1@6 8< C=6137=AA: =A61375B 601 5=6>31 @A=7C =5; @0=3=@613 8< 601 4>76 ' 6 ?=4 4>9C7661; 60=6 601 83;13 2=441; 4><<134 <38C 13383 85 601 <=@1 8< 31@83; =5; =@@83;75BA: 83;13 8< ((, 8>B06 68 91 31D71?1; =5; 822836>576: 91 B7D15 B3=5675B 822836>576: 68 601 ;1<15;=56 8 68 <7A1 46=61C156 8< 89I1@67854 867@1; 60=6 601 ?376 21676785 @=C1 68 91 <7A1; 75 601 :1=3 (( =5; 756137C 83;13 ?=4 B3=561; 85 - 6 - ((( =5; C=6613 31C=754 75 601 4=C1 46=B1 ;142761 A=241 8< =98>6 <8>3 :1=34 01 @85614675B 314285;156 74 314285;156 8 ?08 74 601 2A=7567<< 91<831 601 637=A 8>36 4 601 =22A7@=6785 ?=4 <7A1; 9: 601 2A=7567<< 85A: @85614675B 2=36: 74 601 2A=7567<< 8?1D13 601 2A=7567<< 608>B0 413D1; ?760 5867@1 0=4 586 =221=31; 91<831 6074 8>36 548<=3 =4 601 86013 314285;1564 =31 @85@1351; ;1<15;=56 8 74 3123141561; 9: A1=351; ;;76785=A 8D135C156 ;D8@=61 ?07A1 601 86013 ;1<15;=564 5=C1A: ;1<15;=56 84( =5; ) =31 @8.;1<15;=564 =5; 5867@1 C=: 91 ?=7D1; =4 31B=3;4 4>@0 @8.;1<15;=564 =4 601 ;1<15;=56 8 4><<7@7156A: 3123141564 601 75613146 8< 601 86013 ;1<15;=564 68 601 1F6156 8< 89I1@6785 9175B 3=741; 68 601 =C15;C156 =22A7@=6785 , @@83;75BA: 5867@75B 60=6 601 2A=7567<< 0=4 9115 413D1; C=6613 74 6=E15 >2 =<613 ?=7D75B 5867@1 68 601 86013 @8.;1<15;=564 71 314285;156 84( =5; ) ?08 =31 601 ;1<15;=564 91<831 601 637=A 8>36 - 7 - 01 4>76 74 851 <83 2=3676785 22A7@=6785 <83 =C15;C156 0=4 9115 <7A1; 411E75B 68 =C15; 601 4@01;>A1 =4 ?1AA =4 68 754136 @136=75 =D13C1564 9: ?=: 8< 2382841; =C15;C1564 213>4=A 8< 601 2382841; =C15;C156 ?8>A; 75;7@=61 60=6 =5 =A613=6785 8< 4@01;>A1 74 48>B06 7548<=3 =4 601 ;14@3726785 8< 601 2382136: 9: ?=: 8< ;1A16785 8< : 8)' 2=36 <38C 4>@0 =C15;C156 601 2A=7567<< 0=4 48>B06 <83 754136785 8< 2=3=.)"=& ?013175 60131 74 = 421@7<7@ =D13C156 60=6 60131 ?=4 58 2=3676785 =C85B46 601 2=36714 75 31421@6 8< 4>76 4@01;>A1 2382136: 60=6 601 2A=7567<< 0=4 0=A< 40=31 75 601 4>76 4@01;>A1 2382136: =A85B ?760 ;1<15;=56 8 *>36013 421@7<7@ =D13C1564 =31 C=;1 75 2382841; 2=3=."=& 60=6 31B=3;75B @0=5B1 75 601 31D15>1 1563714 =5; 31@67<7@=6785 8< 1@83; 8< 7B064 9: ?=: 8< 31D15>1 238@11;75B4 0131 74 <83@1 75 601 4>9C744785 8< ;1<15;=56 8 60=6 601 2382841; =C15;C1564 31H>731; =5 822836>576: <83 ;1<15;=56 8 68 <7A1 89I1@67854 7548<=3 =4 601 =D13C1564 31A=675B 68 ;14@3726785 8< 2382136: 9: D736>1 - 8 - 8< 238@11;75B4 85 601 31D15>1 47;1 =31 <=@6>=A =441367854 60=6 31H>731; = 319>66=A 6 74 4>9C7661; 60=6 7< 822836>576: 74 586 B3=561; 76 C=: 0=D1 @8541H>15@14 75 601 1D156 601 4>76 74 ;1@311; =6 601 67C1 8< <75=A ;1@311 238@11;75B4 ?013175 ;1C=3@=6785 8< 601 2382136: 74 31H>731; 68 91 C=;1 6 74 4>9C7661; 60=6 601 @0=5B1 75 601 4>3D1: 5>C9134 =4 74 5=33=61; 75 601 2382841; =C15;C156 =31 C=66134 60=6 0=D1 68 91 @A=37<71; 9: 601 ;1<15;=56 ?07@0 ?8>A; 91 284479A1 85A: 7< 822836>576: ?=4 B3=561; 68 <7A1 89I1@67854 68 601 75613A8@>683: =22A7@=6785 <83 =C15;C156 ( !13>41; 601 83;13 <83 =C15;C156 2=441; 85 ((, 3;13 2=441; =A85B ?760 =22A7@=6785 74 9=A; ?760 58 31=4854 =447B51; <83 =AA8?75B 4>@0 =22A7@=6785 ) !13>41; 601 83;13 ;74C74475B 8 <7A1; 411E75B 31D71? 8< 601 83;13 01 637=A 8>36 0=4 89413D1; 60=6 601 ;1<15;=56 8 8>B06 68 0=D1 @0=AA15B1; 2=4475B 8< 83;13 8< =C15;C156 75 =2238237=61 238@11;75B4 =5; 8>B06 586 68 0=D1 <7A1; =22A7@=6785 411E75B 31D71? 8< 601 83;13 6 74 =A48 89413D1; 60=6 =22A7@=6785 <7A1; =4 8 - 9 - 74 4>228361; 9: C1C83=5;>C 8< <=@64 =5; 601 4=C1 0=4 9115 <7A1; 91A=61;A: 01 287564 <83 @8547;13=6785 =31 60=6 7& 016013 601 4>9C744785 8< @8>541A <83 601 ;1<15;=56 8 60=6 601 =22A7@=6785 C=: 0=D1 9115 631=61; =4 851 68 31@=AA 601 83;13 =5; 238D7;1 =5 822836>576: 8< <7A75B 89I1@67854 68 =22A7@=6785 <83 =C15;C156 8< 2A=756 <7A1; 9: 601 2A=7567<< 31H>7314 =@@126=5@1J 77& 016013 B38>5;4 =31 C=;1 8>6 68 75613<131 ?760 601 83;13 2=441; 9: 601 637=A 8>36J 1=3; 601 A1=351; @8>541A <83 601 ;1<15;=56 8 4 287561; 8>6 =98D1 83;13 =AA8?75B =C15;C156 74 @3:267@ 58 31=4854 =31 =447B51; =4 37B06A: 287561; 8>6 9: 601 ;1<15;=56 8 !382841; =C15;C156 ?07@0 75@A>;14 2=3=B3=20."=& ?013175 89413D=67854 =31 C=;1 31B=3;75B 31.5>C91375B 8< 4>3D1: 5>C9134 =5; 4>@0 =421@6 ?8>A; 0=D1 =5 7C2A7@=6785 =4 31B=3;4 7;15676: 8< 2382136: - 10 - 1421@7=AA: =6 601 46=B1 8< <75=A ;1@311 238@11;75B4 =4 37B06A: =441361; 9: @8>541A <83 ;1<15;=56 8 867@1; 60=6 4=7; =22A7@=6785 ?=4 =AA8?1; 85 601 4=C1 ;=: 85 ?07@0 76 ?=4 <7A1; 601 83;13 74 2=441; 75 D78A=6785 8< 2375@72A14 8< 5=6>3=A I>467@1 =4 ?1AA 7548<=3 =4 ;1<15;=56 8 8>B06 68 0=D1 9115 =AA8?1; 4><<7@7156 822836>576: 68 <7A1 46=61C156 8< 89I1@67854 68 601 4=7; =22A7@=6785 D15 7< ;1<15;=56 8 ?131 2A=@1; 60131 74 58 9=3 85 601 ;1<15;=56 8 <38C 89I1@675B 68 4>@0 =22A7@=6785 <83 =C15;C156 8 ;8>96 601 637=A 8>36 0=4 89413D1; 60=6 601 =22A7@=6785 <83 31D71? 8>B06 586 68 0=D1 9115 156136=751; =5; 601 ;1<15;=56 @8>A; 0=D1 @0=AA15B1; 601 D=A7;76: 8< 601 4=7; 83;13 75 =2238237=61 238@11;75B4 6 74 = 4166A1; 28476785 60=6 238@1;>3=A 31H>731C1564 31A=675B 68 238D74785 8< A=? >5;13 ?07@0 =22A7@=6785 74 <7A1; C>46 91 @85463>1; A7913=AA: E11275B 75 C75; 15;4 8< I>467@1 5 601 2314156 @=41 608>B0 601 =22A7@=6785 74 <7A1; ;14@37975B 76 68 91 =5 =22A7@=6785 411E75B 31D71? 8< - 11 - 601 83;13 2=441; 601 =22A7@=6785 @8>A; 91 @85463>1; =4 851 <7A1; 411E75B 68 75D8E1 75013156 28?134 68 31@=AA 601 83;13 8< =C15;C156 =AA8?1; ?7608>6 01=375B 8< 601 ;1<15;=56 8 >946=5@1 8< 601 =22A7@=6785 <83 31D71? 74 68 31@=AA 601 83;13 =AA8?75B 601 =22A7@=6785 =5; 213C76 601 ;1<15;=56 8 68 <7A1 46=61C156 8< 89I1@67854 01 =22A7@=6785 608>B0 <7A1; =4 = 31D71? C=: 91 631=61; 68 91 851 <7A1; 411E75B 68 31@=AA 601 83;13 2=441; =5; 68 =<<83; =5 822836>576: 68 <7A1 46=61C156 8< 89I1@67854 =E75B 5861 8< 601 <=@6>=A C=637F =4 5867@1; =98D1 601 =22A7@=6785 <7A1; C=: 91 631=61; 68 91 =4 851 411E75B 68 31@=AA 601 83;13 2=441; 85 ((, =5; 68 213C76 601 ;1<15;=56 8 68 <7A1 46=61C156 8< 89I1@67854 68 601 4=7; 75613A8@>683: =22A7@=6785 @@83;75BA: 6074 8>36 <75;4 60=6 637=A 8>36 0=4 =;8261; >5;>A: @85413D=67D1 =2238=@0 75 ;74C74475B 601 =22A7@=6785 5 A7B06 8< 601 ;74@>44785 C=;1 =98D1 601 287564 <83 @8547;13=6785 =31 =54?131; 75 601 <<73C=67D1 - 12 - ' @@83;75BA: 601 ?376 21676785 74 ;742841; 8<< 01 83;13 8< ((, =AA8?75B 601 =C15;C156 =22A7@=6785 74 416 =47;1 =5; 8 74 =AA8?1; 1@144=3: 46=61C156 8< 89I1@67854 68 91 <7A1; 68 75613A8@>683: =22A7@=6785 <83 =C15;C156 ?76075 = 21378; 8< 6?8 ?11E4 37=A 8>36 68 6=E1 >2 75613A8@>683: =22A7@=6785 <83 =C15;C156 =5; 31.@8547;13 601 4=C1 75 =@@83;=5@1 ?760 A=? "*+ (""!#!') &! # 746 8 A 8 )