Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 91915 (KAR)

MR. SYED RAMEEZ RAHIL v. THE COMMISSIONER

WP/38023/2025 · 2025-12-16

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#$ %#&& '( ! "#$ % & '! ! '! ( ! &!!( !"$ ! ! "#$ ' & ( ) "#$# ! ! !"$ ! ! "#$ * Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "#$ % + ! $ ! , ' -# ' $ #" ! &( ! ! +! )" !! ! + . ! . / ! 012134345617089:08;;16<1=8275>494568;57=17?18746< 5 =831= -# 28991= ?@ 301 719256=163 5 A6=17 1:3456 &( 5B 301 876838C8 A64:428;!57257834569 :3-$&016:1B573071B1771=3589/301 ! :3-$/( &4(012134345617:56316=9308301493015D6175B8 B;83 ?18746< 5 46 86 82873E163 :56937A:31= 56 2752173@ ?18746< 59 86= 943A831= 83 8664E86382 /!/ 8@5A3 86=4 508;;8 @9A7A 1 :;84E9 3083 301 :56937A:3456 49 46 8::57=86:1 D430 301 2;86 986:34561= - 3 - 5D1>17 301 719256=163 5 ?891= 56 :5E2;84639 ;5=<1= ?1B571 301 719256=163 59 35 08= 499A1= 8 ;13317 =831= 8;;1<46< :173846 >45;834569 5B 913?8:C 657E9 01 2134345617 712;41= 35 301 984= 6534:19 86= 71E5>1= 301 =1:57834>1 ;4<039 89 9A<<1931= ?@ 301 719256=163 59 35 01 2134345617 :;84E9 3083 719256=163 5 822758:01= 3049 !5A73 46 +5## :08;;16<46< 301 A68A30574F1= :56937A:34562A3A2?@04E86=3049!5A7346317E95B8657=17 =831=##938@1=BA73017:56937A:3456 &44( 049 !5A73 301718B317 =471:31= 301 8A305743419 35 46921:3 301 2752173@ 46 301 271916:1 5B 301 2134345617 1 :56316=9 3083 301 719256=163 5 D05 5D69 86 8=G8:163 2752173@ 089 8;95 >45;831= 301 913?8:C 657E9 86= 089 16:758:01=46350492752173@86=308335=4>173833163456B75E 049 5D6 4;;1<8;43419 301 719256=163 5 089 ?116 B4;46< B8;91 86=>1H8345A9:5E2;846398<846933012134345617 &444( 01 2134345617 :;84E9 3083 301 719256=1639 D4305A3 499A46< 82275274831 6534:19 86= D4305A3 :56=A:346< 8 9253 46921:345689=471:31=?@3049!5A7346+5##089 8<846 499A1= 8 275>494568; 57=17 =831= -# A6=17 - 4 - 1:34565B301! :3-$0121343456174930171B571 ?1B5713049!5A73:08;;16<46<301984=275>494568;57=17 01 ;18761= :5A691; B57 301 2134345617 46>431= 301 833163456 5B 301 !5A73 35 86 187;417 57=17 28991= ?@ 8 !5" 57=4683116:05B3049!5A7346+5##D01713049 !5A73 =471:31= 301719256=1635 &@9571 !43@ !5725783456( 35 :56=A:3 8 9253 46921:3456 86= >174B@ D013017 301 :56937A:3456 A6=1738C16 ?@ 301 719256=163 59# 86= 49 46 8::57=86:1D430301986:34561=2;8686=D013017301714986@ >45;8345646913?8:C657E95753017822;4:8?;171<A;834569 1 :56316=9 3083 3049 !5A73 BA73017 =471:31= 3083 D04;1 :56=A:346< 9A:0 46921:3456>174B4:83456 719256=163 5 908;; 499A1 27457 6534:1 35 719256=163 59# 86= 86= 8BB57= 301E 86 522573A643@ 5B ?146< 0187= 46 8::57=86:1 D430 301 2746:42;195B683A78;GA934:11:56316=93083301213434561749 561 5B 301 5D6179 5B 301 B;83 86= 3083 301 719256=163 5 D4305A3B5;;5D46<30157=1728991=?@3049!5A73089499A1=301 4E2A<61=275>494568;57=17 # B 301 719256=163 5 089 28991= 301 275>494568; 57=17 D4305A3 :5E2;@46< 301 57=17 28991= ?@ 3049 !5A73 46 - 5 - +5## 43 49 B57 301 2134345617 35 B4;1 8 9A438?;1 712;@ 35 301 275>494568; 57=17 1 49 8;95 ?5A6= 35 98349B@ 301 719256=16353083301:56937A:34562A3A249468::57=86:1 D4303012;86986:34561=B301719256=1635B11;9301611= B578646921:345643908;;=5954B43496538;718=@=56189217 301 57=17 5B 3049 !5A73 46 +5## 86= 301718B317 275:11= 46 8::57=86:1 D430 ;8D 3 86@ 7831 301 719256=163 5:8665328998:56B47E8345657=17D4305A3:5694=1746<301 712;@ 3083 E8@ ?1 B4;1= ?@ 301 2134345617 6 57=17 35 169A71 :5E2;486:1 5B 3049 301 2134345617 908;; 16:;591 8 :52@ 5B 3049 57=17D016019A?E439049712;@?1B571301719256=1635 01D743213434569386=9563018?5>1 317E9 )* '&( & 4935.;5.-