Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9175 (KAR)
MANOJKUMAR CHILAKURI AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/200127/2023 · 2025-01-27
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9175 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9175 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
! #$
" % &" ! $ '(')*+(' ** &
!""!##
##
!""!##
! !""!##
$
! !""!##
%
!#&&#
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! !'
!'(
) *
+
,
,
*
!'$'+
-
& ,
!'!&
)
* ,
,+
, $' ,
,
. &#&& '&& * "##&&+ , ,,
$('*+ !&# $( ,$, %
,
,, ,
,
- 3 -
/
*
/ +
001234 52 65 ! 783 93:583 6;<2 5186 1=438 306<5= $' 5: 8 ><6; 7 ?87@38 65 A172; 6;3 3=6<83 ?850334<=B2<=5"##&&?3=4<=B93:5836;305186 5:44<6<5=7C<D<C14B3E,<=4;7=1878<2<=B5165: 5'&&:586;35::3=032?1=<2;79C31=438306<5= $#'*+!>$(5:7=4306<5=2E$5:5>8@ 85;<9<6<5=06
37846;3C378=34051=23C:586;3?786<32
378=34 051=23C :58 6;3 ?36<6<5=382 219F<62 6;76 ?36<6<5= F7@ 93 4<2F<2234 72 =56 ?832234 72 7B7<=26 70012345?36<6<5=385 $ <2219F<22<5=<2?C70345=830584 ! ;3 ?36<6<5= <2 4<2F<2234 72 =56 ?832234 72 7B7<=26 70012345?36<6<5=385
- 4 -
# 3 219F<62 6;76?8<58 65 :<C<=B 6;3 ?8<D763 05F?C7<=6 9@832?5=43=65;383<= 6;370012345;747C8374@ 7??8570;346;3G18<24<06<5=7C,7F<C@5186767D7=7B383 <= 5'&& 233H<=B 7 430833 :58 8326<616<5= 5: 05=G1B7C8<B;62:638C3B7C=56<032>3833I0;7=B34<=6;3 27<4 ?850334<=B2 6;3 832?5=43=6 5 ;72 :<C34 6;3 ?8<D76305F?C7<=6F7H<=B:7C237=49723C3227CC3B76<5=272 7B7<=267CC 6;3 83C76<D32 5:7001234 5 001234 52 65!783832<4<=B23?78763C@7=46;3@>383=3D38832<4<=B 7C5=B ><6; 7001234 5 7=4 ;<2 ><:3 >;5 <2 6;3 832?5=43=65;383<=700584<=BC@;3?87@2657CC5>6;3 ?36<6<5=
" 38 05=687 C378=34
<B; 5186 5D38=F3=6 C37438 7=4C378=34051=23C:586;3832?5=43=65;7D35??5234 6;3?36<6<5= ' 378=34 051=23C :58 832?5=43=6 5 219F<62 6;76 6;383 >72 05=267=6 ;78722F3=6 <= 6;3 F768<F5=<7C ;5123 9@7CC6;37001234?3825=27=46;3@>38343F7=4<=B6;3 832?5=43=656598<=B744<6<5=7C45>8@7=46;3@>383
- 5 -
:580<=B ;38 65 B36 &$ 70832 5: C7=4 :85F ;38 ?783=62 00584<=BC@6;3@?87@654<2F<226;3?36<6<5= ( 7638<7C5= 830584 >51C4B5 652;5>6;76 F788<7B3 5:70012345><6;832?5=43=65>7225C3F=<J345= &&'&' 76 <=4;7=181 CC3B76<5= <= 6;3 ?8<D763 05F?C7<=6 6;76 >72 :<C34 5= &&&& <2 6;76 7:638 F788<7B36;3832?5=43=6>;5<26;305F?C7<=7=6 >72;7872234<=;38F768<F5=<7C;51239@7CC6;37001234 ?3825=2 ;383 >383 23D387C ?7=0;7@762 916 =5 :81<6:1C 6;<=B2 ;7??3=34 936>33= 6>5 :7F<C<32 ;3= 6;3 F76638 26554 6;12 2;3 8303<D34 C3B7C =56<03 5= &&( :85F ;38;1297=47=46;327F3>7283?C<349@;386;851B;;38 051=23C 7=4 6;3837:638 2;3 ;74 7??8570;34 6;3 G18<24<06<5=7C 5186 5: 7B<268763 7=4 :<C34 7 ?8<D763 05F?C7<=6 & 38127C 5: 6;3 219F<22<5= F7H3 <= 6;3 ?8<D763 05F?C7<=6>51C4B5652;5>6;76832?5=43=65 05F?C7<=7=6;74=5605F?C<346;383A1<83F3=65:306<5=2 !$*+ 7=4 !$*+ 5: 8 93:583 :<C<=B 6;3 ?8<D763
- 6 -
05F?C7<=6;37CC3B76<5=2:51=4<=6;3?8<D76305F?C7<=6 7B7<=266;3?36<6<5=382;383<=783B3=387C7=45F=<912
7638<7C5=830584>51C4B5652;5>6;763D3=?8<58 65:<C<=B5:6;3?8<D76305F?C7<=69@832?5=43=65C3B7C =56<032>3833I0;7=B34936>33=6;3?786<327=47?38127C 5: 6;3 F7638<7C 5= 830584 >51C4 B5 65 2;5> 6;76 832?5=43=6 ><:3 ;74 C3:6 6;305F?7=@ 5:;38;1297=4 5= &(8<58656;766;383>727?7=0;7@76936>33= 6;3 F3F9382 5: 6>5 :7F<C<32 7=4 6;3 ;1297=4 7=4 ><:3 ;74 67H3= 1?7 83=634?83F<232 767D7=7B383 7=46;3@ >383 832<4<=B 23?78763C@
5>3D38 6;3 83C76<5=2;<?
936>33= 6;3 ;1297=4 7=4 ><:3 4<4 =56 <F?85D3 3D3= 6;3837:6387=4 6;383:583 6;3 832?5=43=6 ><:3 ;74C3:6 6;3 05F?7=@ 5: ;38 ;1297=4 7=4 ;74 67H3= 2;3C638 <= ;38 ?783=6K2 ;5123 001234 52 E 783 6;3 ?783=62 5:
7001234 5 ;1297=4 7=4 7001234 5$ <2 6;3 F788<34 2<26385:7001234570012345!<227<465936;3:78 83C76<D35:70012345;3@7837CC832<4<=B23?78763C@
- 7 -
;3
5=/9C3 1?83F3 5186 <= 6;3 0723 5:
;72;3C472:5CC5>27872 &E! ! "#
" #$
% # # # # #$
1 (2010) 7 SCC 667
- 8 -
& '(
8374<=B 5: 6;3 7D38F3=62 :51=4 <= 6;3 ?8<D763 05F?C7<=6>51C4B5652;5>6;767CC3B76<5=2F7437B7<=26 7001234 52 65 ! 783 B3=387C 7=4 5F=<912 <= =76183 5=6<=176<5=5:6;3<F?1B=3408<F<=7C?850334<=B297234 5= 210; 7CC3B76<5=2 F743 7B7<=26 6;3F >51C4 7F51=6 65 791235:?8503225:C7> $
=438 6;3 0<801F267=032 7F 5: 6;3 5?<=<5= 6;3 ?87@38 F743 :58 A172;<=B 6;3 08<F<=7C ?850334<=B2 72 7B7<=26 7001234 52 65 ! =3342 65 93 B87=634 00584<=BC@?85033465?7226;3:5CC5><=B
7+ ;3?36<6<5=<2?786C@7CC5>34 9+ ;3?36<6<5=<24<2F<223472=56?83223472 7B7<=26 7001234 5 7=4 7CC5>34 7B7<=26 70012345265! 0+ ;33=6<83?850334<=B2<=5"##&& ?3=4<=B 93:583 6;3 05186 5: 44<6<5=7C
- 9 -
<D<C14B3E,<=4;7=1878<2<=B5165: 5'&&:586;35::3=032?1=<2;79C3 1=438 306<5= $#'*+ !&# 8> $( 5:
7=4 306<5=2 E $ 5: 5>8@ 85;<9<6<5= 06<2A172;347B7<=2670012345265! ,+
' % &" !*
"
<265C5(