Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9174 (KAR)

ARUNKUMAR D KULARNI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

WP/200516/2023 · 2025-01-07

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#"$ %&# # ' ( ! "# $ " % & ' " ( " ( & '"" " " ) " Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - *" " +" &,' " % &" "( *- +' ) ( . ( ( ) ( "" / 0 ( ( ( ( "" ( ""## ""##* 1 ( ( ( 0 1 " ( 23 ) - 3 - 4 0 "0 56768989:;6<5=>>:?@58A:<=B<989;856;=8?<6:A C=;D=C?> 8: E:;>9D6< 59> <67<6>6;8=89:; D=86D ""=;DE:?;859>7=>8>6<F9E6A<:C""##8: ""##*A:<8567?<7:>6:A76;>9:;=<GH6;6A98>" " 56 768989:;6< E:;86;D> 85=8 56 B=> =77:9;86D => =; ;@I9>5 I6E8?<6< :; ""##" 9> =77:9;8C6;8 B=>=77<:F6D:;""##" =86<59>=77:9;8C6;8B=> =DC9886D8:>=I=<G@<=;8:;""##*"6>7:;D6;8:"* @<=;86D 856 H6;6A98 :A 856 7=G >E=I6 => 7<6F=I6;8 9; <6>7:;D6;8:""56768989:;6<E:;86;D>85=89;856:<D6< @<=;89;@ 856 7=G >E=I6 D=86D "."##* 98 B=> C6;89:;6D85=8856768989:;6<9>6;898I6D8:E:?;859>7=>8 >6<F9E6 A:<856 7?<7:>6 :AI6=F6 =;D 76;>9:;=<GH6;6A98>" 56 768989:;6< E:;86;D> 85=8 56 <689<6D A<:C >6<F9E6 :; *""" 9> 76;>9:;=<G H6;6A98> B6<6 >688I6D HG 8<6=89;@ 59> >6<F9E6 A<:C ""##*" 56 768989:;6< =;D :856<>=77<:=E56D859>:?<89;)<9868989:;:>"#. - 4 - *+ A:< = D9<6E89:; 8: 856 <6>7:;D6;8> 8: E:?;8 856 7=>8 >6<F9E6 <6;D6<6D HG 856C A:< 856 7?<7:>6 :A A9J=89:; :A 7=G >E=I6 >6;9:<98G 9;E<6C6;8> 76;>9:; 68E" 56 >=9D B<98 768989:;> B6<6 D9>7:>6D :AA 9; 86<C> :A 856 :<D6< D=86D *""+ :; 856 >=C6 I9;6> => 9; )<98 68989:;:"#+*=;DE:;;6E86DB<98768989:;>B59E5 B=> =AA9<C6D HG 856 9F9>9:; 6;E5 :A 859> :?<8 9; )<98 776=I:"+=;DE:;;6E8B<98=776=I>=;DHG856 :;3HI6 ?7<6C6 :?<8 9; &9F9I' :>". " 56 768989:;6< E:;86;D> 85=8 <6>7:;D6;8 :>"=;D5=F6;:B7<:C?I@=86D856=<;=8=K=<9F=86 9D6D D?E=89:;=I ;>898?89:;> C7I:G66> &6@?I=89:; :A =G 6;>9:; =;D :856< 6;6A98>' E8 + 9; 86<C> :A B59E58567=>8>6<F9E69>;:8E:?;86DA:<8567?<7:>6:A D686<C9;9;@ 856 76;>9:;=<G H6;6A98>" 56 768989:;6< 856<6A:<6 >?HC9886D <67<6>6;8=89:; D=86D "" <6L?6>89;@ 856 <6>7:;D6;8> 8: E:;>9D6< 856 7=>8 >6<F9E6 9"6" A<:C ""## A:< 8567?<7:>6 :A D686<C9;9;@ 856 76;>9:;=<G H6;6A98> 7=G=HI6 =;D =EE:<D9;@IG <6F9>6 856 76;>9:; A9J6D" 56 768989:;6< >?HC98> 85=8 856 :<D6< - 5 - 7=>>6D 9; )<98 68989:; :>"#.*+ 9> E5=II6;@6D9;)<98776=I:"+.=;D856>=C69> 76;D9;@ E:;>9D6<=89:;" 6 >?HC98> 85=8 = ::<D9;=86 6;E5 :A 859> :?<8 9; )<98 68989:; :"** 5=D 76<C9886D 856 768989:;6< 8: C=K6 =77<:7<9=86 <67<6>6;8=89:; 8: <6>7:;D6;8 :>" =;D 8: E:?;8 856 ?;=9D6D 76<9:D A:< >6<F9E6 H6;6A98> => B6II => A:< 76;>9:;=<G H6;6A98> =A86< D9>7:>=I :A )<98 776=I :"+. =;D E:;;6E86D =776=I>" 6 856<6A:<6 E:;86;D> 85=8 856 768989:;6< =I>: H6 6J86;D6D 856 >=C6 H6;6A98 =;D 856 768989:;6< H6 76<C9886D 8: A9I6 =; =77<:7<9=86 <67<6>6;8=89:; =A86< D9>7:>=I :A )<98 776=I :"+." *" 6=<;6D9@5:?<8:F6<;C6;8I6=D6<:;856 :856< 5=;D E:;86;D6D 85=8 856 768989:;6<3> =77:9;8C6;8 B=>=DC9886D8:>=I=<G@<=;8B9856AA6E8A<:C""##* =;D 856<6A:<6 856 768989:;6< E=;;:8 E:C76I 856 <6>7:;D6;8> 8: E:?;8 7=>8 >6<F9E6 B56; 59> =77:9;8C6;8 B=> ;:8 =DC9886D 8: >=I=<G @<=;8" 6 >?HC98> 85=8 856 - 6 - I9=H9I98G 8: 7=G 76;>9:; 9> :;IG A<:C 856 D=86 856 =77:9;8C6;8 :A 856 768989:;6< B=> =DC9886D 8: >=I=<G @<=;8" 5?> >56 E:;86;D> 85=8 856 768989:;6< 9> ;:8 6;898I6DA:<=;G<6I96A9;859>B<98768989:;" +" 9;E6 = ::<D9;=86 6;E5 :A 859> :?<8 A:II:B9;@856M?D@C6;89;)<9868989:;:"#+*5=> D9>7:>6D :AA )<98 68989:; :>"#.*+ A9I6D HG856768989:;6<=;D:856<>B59E59>7<6>6;8IGE5=II6;@6D HG 856 8=86 :F6<;C6;8 9; )<98 776=I :"+. 856:;IG<6I96A85=8E=;H66J86;D6D8:856768989:;6<9>8: 76<C98 856 768989:;6< 8: A9I6 =77<:7<9=86 <67<6>6;8=89:; <6L?6>89;@ <6>7:;D6;8 :>" =;D 8: E:;>9D6< E:?;89;@ 856 ?;=9D6D 76<9:D A:< >6<F9E6 H6;6A98> => B6II => 76;>9:;=<G H6;6A98> =A86< D9>7:>=I :A 856 )<98 776=I :"+.=;DE:;;6E86D=776=I>":;>6L?6;8IG856 A:II:B9;@:<D6<9>7=>>6D 9' 56)<9868989:;9> " - 7 - 99' 56 768989:;6< 9> 76<C9886D 8: >?HC98 = <67<6>6;8=89:; 8: <6>7:;D6;8 :>" =;D <6L?6>89;@856C8:E:?;8856?;=9D6D76<9:D:A >6<F9E6 A:< D686<C9;=89:; :A 856 86<C9;=I H6;6A98>=>B6II=>85676;>9:;=<GH6;6A98>"59> >5=II H6 :;IG =A86< D9>7:>=I :A )<98 776=I :"+.=;DE:;;6E86D=776=I>" 999' A = <67<6>6;8=89:; 9> C=D6 <6>7:;D6;8 :>" =;D >5=II E:;>9D6< 856 >=C6 9; =EE:<D=;E6 B985 I=B =;D 9; 856 I9@58 :A 856 M?D@C6;8 85=8 C=GH67=>>6D9;)<98776=I:"+." )* '#( # 9>8:"I:"++ 8>9