Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9171 (KAR)
M/S PADMAVATI ENTERPRISES RAICHUR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WP/200240/2025 · 2025-01-27
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9171 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9171 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
$# %
!"
#
$
"
"
" %
" &
'
!!!"
("
'&'
'
" '
!!!"
)"
&
'
*
!"
#
$
"'' *
%
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
& ' '((&
&
&
+
$!%
,'
'
- $ )% & &
+ ' & ' ' &
' &
&
"(!(( ! ( ""(!( $) %
&
' & & ' &
'&
&
" ' *
'
' ( &
(!(( . ") "
& '
/'
"*
"
*
01 2134345617 089 95:;03 <57 8 =743 46 301 683:71 5< 17345787435>:89025463$!%:6?17301@823456,1A4;4B4A43C @7431748- 46 301 316?17 6534<4@83456 B18746; 5"(!( ( ! ?831? ( ""(!( 46 71921@3 5< 9:22AC 5< <55? 8734@A19<55?;78469D1;138BA19<7:439E183@04@F16<4901;;
86? E49@1AA8615:9 8734@A19 35 4G8C82:78 16378A 74956 :6?17 '53( <57 301 C187 (!((!(" 01 2134345617 089 8A95 95:;03 <578=74346301683:715<E86?8E:935?471@3719256?1635") 35 ?4921691 301 71>:471E163 5< @1734<4@83456 5< 661H:71 35 301 B4? ?5@:E163 89 2719@74B1? :6?17 25463 $% 5< 301
- 3 -
316?176534<4@83456" 0121343456170898A9595:;03<578=74346 301683:715<E86?8E:9?471@346;719256?16359"(86?)653 3571@8AA3012719163316?176534<4@83456B18746;5"(!( ( ! ?831? ( ""(!( 86? 38F1 43 35 439 A5;4@8A @56@A:9456BC8AA5=46;30121343456173528734@42831" (" 05:;0 301 2134345617 089 <4A1? 8 275378@31? =743 2134345643=5:A?9:<<4@13571@57?301B1A5=E1634561?<8@39 308387161@19987C<573012:725915<?1@4?46;3049=74321343456" )" 01 2134345617 @56316?9 3083 719256?163 5") 08? 499:1? 8 6534<4@83456 ?831? "!)"(!( <57 9:22AC 5< <55? 8734@A19D1;138BA19<7:43986?E1834G8C82:7816378A74956 46 317E9 5< 6534<4@83456 ?831? "!)"(!(" 01 2134345617 28734@42831? 46 301 984? B4? 86? <:764901? 8AA 301 71>:471? ?5@:E1639" 5=1D17 301 984? B4? =89 @86@1AA1?" 01718<317 86530176534<4@83456=89499:1?56(("!"(!(=04@08;846=89 @86@1AA1?"
19256?163 5") 3016 499:1? 8 6534<4@83456 B18746; 5"(!(( ! ?831? ( ""(!( <57 301 D17C 98E1 2:72591" 01 2134345617 @56316?9 3083 25463 $!% 5< 1A4;4B4A43C@7431748E86?831?308395AD16@C@1734<4@831905:A?653 B1187A4173086E563092745735301A893?8315<9:BE4994565<
- 4 -
301 B4?" 4E4A87AC 2134345617 @56316?9 3083 25463 $% E86?831930838@1734<4@83146661H:7135301B4??5@:E163 905:A? B1 ?:AC @1734<41? BC 8 5D176E163 8:305743C" 01 2134345617 @56316?9 3083 43 089 <:764901? 95AD16@C @1734<4@831 ?831? !("!"(!( 86? !"!"(!( <57 8 9:E 5< 9"(!!!!!!! 86? 9")!!!!!!! 71921@34D1AC =04@0 =171 275?:@1? 8A56; =430 301 B4?9 9:BE4331? 187A417" 01 2134345617 @56316?9 3083 301 95AD16@C@1734<4@831 499:1? BC 301 86F5<875?849<57821745?5<C187=04@0491D4?163<75E 8 ?1@A8783456 E8?1 BC 43 89 217 661H:71+" 01 2134345617 @56316?9 3083 46 71921@3 5< 275@:71E163 BC 53017 2749569 46 C9571 1AA874 087=8? 86? 04D8E5;;8 301 95AD16@C @1734<4@8319 =04@0 871 D8A4? <57 E56309 27457 35 301 B4? 871 8@@1231?" 0171<5714349@56316?1?30832719@74B46;E56309 D8A4?95AD16@C@1734<4@8314987B43787C86?477834568A"
"
695<87 89 @A8:91 $% 71A8346; 35 <:7649046; 8 @1734<4@83146661H:714349@56316?1?3083301213434561749 8A718?C 71;493171? :6?17 301 @3 86? 301 2134345617 089 275?:@1?8@1734<4@831?:AC94;61?BC3016D4756E1636;46117 5<43C:64@428A5:6@4A
84@0:7" 0171<57101@56316?93083 3018<571984?1A4;4B4A43C@7431748 905:A?
653@5E146301=8C5<
- 5 -
719256?163 5") 71G1@346; 301 31@064@8A B4? 9:BE4331? BC 301 2134345617"
" '18761? @5:691A <57 301 2134345617 714317831? 301 8B5D19:BE499456986?9:BE4331?30833012134345617089B116 9:22AC46; <55? E831748A 35 301 2749569 86? 49 86 1938BA4901? B:946199E86" 1 @56316?9 3083 719256?163 5") 089 8<317 @86@1A46; 301 316?17 6534<4@83456 3=4@1 089 653 499:1? 301 6534<4@83456 <57 301 98E1 2:72591" 130171<571 @56316?9 3083 301 2134345617 @86653 B1 1H21@31? 35 5B3846 8 <7190 95AD16@C @1734<4@83186?=0831D1749275?:@1?905:A?E1133011A4;4B4A43C @7431748" 1 8A95 @56316?9 3083 301 2134345617 49 8 ?18A17 71;493171? :6?17 301 275D494569 5< 55?9 86? 17D4@1 8H <:73017 ;5D176E163 5<<4@17 49 653 61@19987C" 05:;0 301 2134345617 089 <:764901? 661H:71 ?:AC @1734<41? BC 86 6D4756E163<<4@17"
" 01A18761???434568A5D176E163?D5@83156301 53017 086? 9:BE4331? 3083 301 95AD16@C @1734<4@831 E16345646; 3011A4;4B4A43C@74317484961@19987C35169:713083301B4??17089 8AA 301 <4686@48A 1A4;4B4A43C 35 28734@42831 46 301 316?17" 1 9:BE439 3083 3049 49 8 E86?8357C 317E 46 301 316?17 =04@0
- 6 -
@86653B1?4A:31?57?4921691?" 695<878930171>:471E16335 <4A1661H:71019:BE439308330494956AC35169:713083301 B4??17 089 8 <4H1? 2A8@1 5< B:946199" 1 30:9 @56316?9 3083 30191 3=5 @56?434569 871 E8?1 822A4@8BA1 35 8AA B4??179 86? 30171<5713012134345617@86653@A84E86C1H@123456"
"
08D1@5694?171?3019:BE4994565<301A18761? @5:691A <57 301 2134345617 86? 301 A18761? ??434568A 5D176E163?D5@831<57719256?1639"
" 5463 $% 71A8346; 35 1A4;4B4A43C 2719@74B19 89 <5AA5=9 7431748 5@:E16387C1D4?16@1
!"
- 7 -
" 661H:71718?989<5AA5=9 661H:71 $
1;493783456@1734<4@831<75E@56@1761?5D3":305743C% $ 5B1499:1?86?@1734<41?BC5D176E163:305743C%
0171BC ?1@A871 3083 9############$8E1 5< 301 9:22A417<47E5E286C7;864I83456 86? 439 5=6179% 08D1 9:BE4331? 301 822A4@83456<57301499:15<
1;493783456@1734<4@831"
<:730179383130839##########"$8E15<3019:22A417<47E 5E286C7;864I8345686?4395=6179%0898#####"$5=671631?A1891?% 71;4937834565<E8465<<4@1786@05<<4@146<5AA5=46;8??7199"
8E15<301 &47E ??71995<301 846 <<4@1786@0 <<4@1 8315< 1;4937834565< 8465<<4@1 8315< 1;4937834565< 786@05<<4@1
8E1194;6834564;683:715<301@56@1761?5D3":305743C" 18A 831
- 8 -
!"
34965346?492:3130833012134345617498?18A17 71;493171? :6?17 301 @3 86? 01 49 8A95 8 ,378?17- A4@1691?BC30112:3C471@3575<;74@:A3:78A87F1346; 84@0:7"
3 49 8A95 71;493171? 89 8 @5EE17@48A 1938BA490E163:6?17301876838F8052986?5EE17@48A 938BA490E1639 @3 " 012134345617089 16@A591? 8AA 30191?5@:E16398A56;=430049B4??5@:E163"10898A95 <:764901? 661H:71 93831? 8B5D1 ?:AC @1734<41? BC 86 6D4756E1636;46117
84@0:7"
" 9 8 E83317 5< <8@3 25463 $% 86? $% 5< 301 B4??5@:E163 E86?8319 3083 301B4??17 E:93 08D1 8 D8A4?
378?1 A4@1691 71;493783456 @1734<4@831 =04@0 49 1H378@31?B1A5= 7431748 5@:E16387C 1D4?16@1
# $
#%
# #
# &
#
- 9 -
# ## ##
'
# #
#
'
$(
$( )
* $(
$(
(" 01 2134345617 089 @5E2A41? 301 8B5D1 82873 <75E 301 1A4;4B4A43C @7431748 46 25463 $% 5< 301 316?17 ?5@:E163" 0171<571 30171 =89 9:<<4@4163 ?5@:E16387C 1D4?16@1 35 1938BA490 3083 301 2134345617 49 86 16343C 71;493171? :6?17 D8745:9 168@3E1639 86? 089 8 F65=6 2A8@15<B:946199" 0171<5711D164<4349899:E1?BC3083 301661H:71<:764901?BC301213434561749653@1734<41? BC 8 ;5D176E163 8;16@C 3016 35 301 B4? 9:BE4331? BC 301 2134345617 @86653 B1 71G1@31? 56 301 ;75:6? 3083 301
- 10 -
2134345617 089 653 @5E2A41? 25463 $% 5< 301 1A4;4B4A43C @7431748" )"
695<87 89 25463 $!% 5< 301 B4? ?5@:E163 71A8346; 35 <:7649046; 5< 95AD16@C @1734<4@831 43 718?9 89 :6?17 7431748 5@:E16387C1D4?16@1 $
+ ,
'
)$
-
*
$ %
. " 01 2719@7423456 5< <:7649046; 8 95AD16@C @1734<4@831895615<3011A4;4B4A43C@74317484935169:713083 301 B4??17 089 301 <4686@48A 8B4A43C 35 1H1@:31 301 316?17
- 11 -
86? 30171<571 3049 49 E86?8357C 71>:471E163 5< 86C 316?17 275@199" 01 2134345617 089 <:764901? 95AD16@C @1734<4@8319?831?!("!"(!(86?!"!"(!(<5789:E5< 9"(!!!!!!! 86? 9")!!!!!!! 71921@34D1AC" 0191 95AD16@C @1734<4@8319 =171 275?:@1? BC 301 2134345617 8A56; =430 301 B4? ?5@:E163 9:BE4331? B:3 =04@0 =171 @86@1AA1?" 05:;0 301 2134345617 @56316?1? 308330195AD16@C@1734<4@831987146<57@1<57821745?5< C187 <75E 301 ?831 5< 30147 499:86@1 30171 49 65 ?1@A8783456 E8?1 BC 86C B86F 46 3083 71;87?" 01 ?5@:E163 275?:@1? BC 301 2134345617 =04@0 49 8 @1734<4@83456BC30186F5<875?871;87?46;>:19345686? 869=1725931?56439=1B9431@8665301A2301213434561746 86C E86617 =083951D17" 8D46; 984? 3083 301 2134345617 @86653 B1 3075=6 5:3 5< <78C BC 8 E171 275?:@3456 5< 8 95AD16@C@1734<4@831=04@049B1C56?30134E12719@74B1? B:386522573:643C905:A?B1;78631?35301213434561735 <:764908<719095AD16@C@1734<4@831"
- 12 -
"
63083D41=5<301E833173049=7432134345649
" 01 2134345617 49 ?471@31? 35 <:76490 8 A83193 95AD16@C @1734<4@831 B1<571 301 31@064@8A B4? 49 52161?" < 8 <7190 95AD16@C @1734<4@831 49 <:764901? 719256?163 59"( 86? ) 908AA 8@@123 43 86? 275@11? 46 8@@57?86@1=430A8="
" 9 71;87?9 301 71>:471E163 35 <:76490 @1734<4@8345689217661H:711D164<3012134345617089 653 <:764901? 661H:71J 57 =0831D17 49 <:764901? ?519 653E113301@74317482719@74B1?:6?1725463$!%5<301 B4? ?5@:E163 30131@064@8AB4? 5< 301 2134345617908AA B1 52161?BC@5694?1746;30171;493783456@1734<4@831<:764901? BC04E8921725463$%5<301B4??5@:E163" <301B4? 9:BE4331?BC30121343456174971925694D146530178921@39 301 719256?163 59"( 86? ) 908AA @5694?17 301 B4?
46 8@@57?86@1 =430 A8=" 3 49 611?A199 35 E163456 4< 301 2134345617 @A1879 301 31@064@8A B4? 439 <4686@48A B4? 908AA 8A95B152161?"
- 13 -
" '18761? ??434568A 5D176E163 ?D5@831 49 217E4331?35<4A1E1E55<82218786@1=43046!?8C9<75E 35?8C"
&'
$ %
* '4935"A5")