Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9168 (KAR)
SHARANABASAPPA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WP/200278/2025 · 2025-02-03
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9168 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9168 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
#$%%
& '
! "
! #
" ! "
! $
%
"
&
'
!! ""
%
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
&
%
"(
""
! &)
! & *
!! "
" + ! !"
&#
,
"
%%$ %%)
"
"
,
"
, *
! ('%%&
& ) )' %%%%
! ( %%% ) %%&
! "
! ,! ! -! ./ 0/121234/5 .67 8.699/4:/; 64 35;/5 </6524: 3 & /81234) 270=1/ 3)' %%% ;61/; '%%&0677/;<>1./5/7034;/413%8648/924:1./
- 3 -
/9/81234 3? 1./ 0/121234/5 13 1./ 0371 3? 25/8135 3? 1./ 5/7034;/41 3& 64; 1./ 8347/@=/41 35;/5 ;61/; %%%0677/;<>1./654616A600/9961/52<=46924 00/693) %%&<>B.28.1./35;/53?1./5/7034;/41 3%B67834?25C/;
% ./ 0/121234/5 64; 1./ 5/7034;/41 3 7=<C211/;1./2543C24612347611.//9/81234131./03713? 25/81353?1./5/7034;/413&11./716:/3?785=124> 3?43C246123471./0/121234/53<D/81/;6:62471688/01648/ 3? 43C2461234 3? 1./ 5/7034;/41 3 8347/@=/41 13 B.28. 1./ /1=5424:
??28/5 5/D/81/; 1./ 43C2461234 3? 5/7034;/413341./:53=4;1.611./5/7034;/413 B676C/C</53?1B38330/5612E/7382/12/764;.6;1.=7 248=55/; 1./ ;27@=692?2861234 67 8341624/; 24 /81234)#;#3?1./654616A6330/5612E/382/12/7 81 FF G./5/246?1/5 5/?/55/; 13 67 1./ H IJ ./ 5/7034;/41 3 8.699/4:/; 1./ 762; 35;/5 3? ;27@=692?2861234 67 B/99 67 1./ /9/81234 3? 1./ 0/121234/5 </?35/ 5/7034;/41 3% 24 6 7161=135> 600/69 ./
- 4 -
5/7034;/413%6?1/583472;/524:1./C61/5269345/835; B6776127?2/;1.611./5/7034;/413B674316C/C</5 3? 1B3 8330/5612E/ 7382/12/7 3? 1./ 76C/ A24; 67 34 1./ ;61/3?/9/81234131./03713?25/81353?5/7034;/413& B67;/8965/;
16973./9;1.611.//1=5424: ??28/5.6; 43D=527;28123413;27@=692?>1./5/7034;/413=49/7764 6005305261/35;/5 B67 0677/; =4;/5 /81234 )'#3? 1./ 813?FF347/@=/419>./6993B/;1./600/6964;7/1 672;/ 1./ /9/81234 3? 1./ 0/121234/5 .27 B67 1./4 8.699/4:/; <> 1./ 0/121234/5 </?35/ 1./ 654616A6 00/9961/ 52<=469 ./ 52<=469 6?1/5 E/52?>24: 1./ 5/835;7;27C277/;1./600/69241/5C73?6435;/5;61/; %%%/24:6::52/E/;<>1./6?35/762;35;/571./ 0/121234/527</?35/1.273=51
' /654/; /4235 3=47/9 ?35 1./ 0/121234/5 8341/4;71.611./5/7034;/413864431</6C/C</53? C35/ 1.64 34/ 8330/5612E/ 7382/1> 8655>24: 34 <=724/77 3? 1./ 76C/ A24; / 7=<C217 1.61 1./ 5/7034;/41 3 B67 431 349> 6 C/C</5 3? 6E69:6 <=1 6973 6
- 5 -
C/C</5 3? =C72 64; 1./5/?35/ ./ .6; 248=55/;
1./ ;27@=692?2861234 =4;/5 /81234 )#;# 3? 1./ 81 3? FF B.28. B67 6973 6 ;27@=692?2861234 =4;/5 /81234%F.#3?1./813?FF/69738341/4;/;1.61 1./ /1=5424:
??28/5 27 <3=4; 13 785=1242K/ 1./ 43C24612347 24 1./ C644/5 053E2;/; =4;/5 =9/ & 3? 1./ 654616A6 330/5612E/ 382/12/7 =9/7 F$ G./5/246?1/55/?/55/;13671./H IJ3?B.28.1./ 5/9/E64127=9/&%#B.28.5/6;767?3993B7 L
!" # $ ! $ $ !"
# $
%$
&
$
" $ $
# $'
%
%
! ! (
)
) !$
#*
+
- 6 -
,) ! "
$
$
! (
)
( $ $! ! +
,)
"
$ $
#! '
!
)
)
'-
& ./5/?35/ ./ 8341/4;7 1.61 1./ /1=5424:
??28/5B67/41219/;13933A24131./@=/71234B./1./51./ 5/7034;/41 3 .6; 248=55/; 64> ;27@=692?2861234 ?35 </24: /9/81/; 67 6 25/8135 3? 1./ 365; =4;/5 1./ 053E2723473?1./81
46;;21234./8341/4;71.61</?35/ 1./ /1=5424:
??28/5 1./ 5/7034;/41 3 .6; C6;/ 6 861/:35287161/C/411.61./B676C/C</561<31. 6E69:664;=C72/1./5/?35/7=<C2171.611./
- 7 -
35;/5 0677/; <> 1./ 654616A6 00/9961/ 52<=469 16A24: 241383:42K648/1./9/11/5;61/;%%%B67;3=<1?=9 2467C=8. 67 2? 1.61 9/11/5 B67 24 1./ .64;7 3? 1./ 5/7034;/41 3 431.24: 05/E/41/; .2C 13 053;=8/ 21 </?35/ 1./ /1=5424:
??28/5 13 ;/82;/ .27 8962C 1.61 ./ B67 43 934:/5 6 C/C</5 3? 6E69:6 .=7 ./ 8341/4;7 1.61 1./ 35;/5 0677/; <> 1./ /1=5424: 3??28/5 ;27@=692?>24:1./5/7034;/413B67D=7164;0530/564; 1.=7056>71.611./2C0=:4/;35;/57</7/1672;/
,
1./ 9/654/; /4235 3=47/9 ?35 5/7034;/41 3 7=<C217 1.61 ;27@=692?2861234 =4;/5 /81234 )#;#3? 1./ 81 3? FF 27 431 6=13C6128 <=1 1./ 0538/;=5/ 05/7852</; =4;/5 /81234 )'# .6; 13 </ 83C092/; / 7=<C217 1.61 1299 ;61/ 1./5/ 27 43 35;/5 0677/;<>1.//:271565.39;24:1.611./5/7034;/413 27 ;27@=692?2/; ?35 </24: 6 C/C</5 61 =C72 / 8341/4;7 1.61 =4;/5 =9/& 1.//1=5424: 3??28/5 864 16A/83:42K648/3?64>35;/50677/;=4;/5/81234)'# 64; 5/D/81 1./ 43C2461234 <=1 ./ .67 43 D=527;281234 13
- 8 -
.39;1.611./5/7034;/413.6;248=55/;;27@=692?2861234 64;1./5/<>5/D/81.2743C2461234.=7./8341/4;71.61 1./ 2C0=:4/; 35;/5 0677/; <> 1./ /1=5424:
??28/5 B67 248355/8164;<67/;346B534:241/505/1612343?96B.27 60651 ./ 8341/4;7 1.61 5/7034;/41 3 B67 431 6 C/C</5 3? <31. 1./ 7382/12/7 67 8341/4;/; 67 1./ 5/7034;/41 3 .6; 5/72:4/; ?53C 1./ C/C</57.20 3? 6E69:6 34 )% 217/9? 64; C/C</57.20 ?// B67 5/?=4;/; 13 .2C / 8341/4;/; 1.61 1./ .2/? M/8=12E/ ??28/5 3? 6E69:6 .6; 6;;5/77/; 6 83CC=42861234;61/;%%%716124:1.611./46C/3? 1./ 5/7034;/41 3 B67 /5534/3=79> C/41234/; 24 1./ E31/57I 9271 1.3=:. ./ .6; 8/67/; 13 </ 6 C/C</5 34 % 217/9? / B67 6973 /M6C24/; </?35/ 1./ 5/7034;/413%64;./0968/;345/835;65/8/2013?1./ 9/11/5 ;61/; %% ?35 8937=5/ 3? C/C</57.20 3? 5/7034;/41 3 / 6973 6;C211/; 1.61 <> 3E/572:.1 1./ 46C/ 3? 5/7034;/41 3 ?2:=5/; 24 1./ E31/57I 9271 3? 6E69:6 64; 1.61 5/7034;/41 3 ;2; 431 0651282061/241.//9/81234./9;131./25/81357.203? - 9 -
6E69:634%F%%64;./1./5/?35/8341/4;71.611./ 5/7034;/413.67431248=55/;64>;27@=692?286123464;
1./5/?35/ 1./ 5/7034;/41 3% 64; 1./ 654616A6 00/9961/52<=469B/5/D=712?2/;247/1124:672;/1./35;/5 0677/;<>1.//1=5424:
??28/567B/99671.//9/812343? 1./0/121234/5
$ / 7=<C211/; 1.61 7248/ 1./ 8348/54/; 6=1.35212/7.6E/;/82;/;60=5/@=/712343??6811.273=51 C6> 431 /M/5827/ D=527;281234 13 241/5?/5/ B21. 1./ 0538//;24:7=4;/551289/%%)3?1./347121=12343? 4;26 47=003513?1.278341/41234./5/92/;=0341./D=;:C/41 3?
1./ 0/M 3=51 24 1./ 867/ 3? ) /654/; 2:. 3=51 3E/54C/41 9/6;/5 7=00351/; 1./ 8341/412347 3? 1./ 9/654/; /4235 3=47/9 ?355/7034;/413
./001
- 10 -
1 27 431 24 ;270=1/ 1.61 1./ 0/121234/5 64;
5/7034;/413.6;?29/;1./2543C24612347?351./03713? 25/8135 3? 1./ 5/7034;/41 3& ,./4 1./ 43C24612347 B/5/ 785=1242K/; 34 %$%% 1./ 0/121234/5 3<D/81/;
6:62471 688/0124: 1./ 43C2461234 3? 1./ 5/7034;/41 3 341./:53=4;1.611./5/7034;/413B676C/C</53? =C7264;6E69:6/1./5/?35/8341/4;/; 1.611./5/7034;/413B67;27@=692?2/;?53C8341/7124: 131./03713?25/81353?1./5/7034;/413&
435;/513 6005/8261/1./6<3E/3<D/81234721274/8/7765>135/?/513 /81234 ) 3? 1./ 81 3? FF B.28. ;/697 B21. ;27@=692?2861234 ?53C C/C</57.20 64; 1./ 5/9/E641 053E272345/6;767?3993B7 2 !"' 3 ! ! ! )
$
! $
! ) $ $ ! &
*
- 11 -
14$%
#
! )
! ! ! $ )$ ! %
'-
F =9/&3?1./=9/7F$5/6;767?3993B7 2
5 $ $! $ )
$ )
!"
# #
$
)
! !$
'
!" # $ ! $ $ !"
# $
%$
&
$
" $ $
# $
- 12 -
% %
! ! (
) ) !$
#*
+
,) ! "
$
$
! (
)
( $ $! ! +
,)
"
$ $
#! ' ! )
) '
1
"
" # ! "
'
- 13 -
.4
$ )
! 6
"
) ! ! 7 ) ) $
894: $
#
)
! )
! ' $
! ! ! $
$'-
5/6;24: 3? =9/ & 3? 1./ =9/7 F$ C6A/7 21 C35/ 1.64 60065/41 1.61 1./ /1=5424: ??28/5 86416A/83:42K648/3?6435;/53?;27@=692?28612340677/;
=4;/5 64> 053E272347 3? 1./ 81 1./ 5=9/7 64; 1./ <>/ 96B7 / .67 43 7161=135> 52:.1 13 0677 64> 35;/5 ;27@=692?>24:1./43C24//64;5/D/811./43C2461234?29/; ?1./0/121234/5B676B65/3?1./?6811.611./5/7034;/41 3B676!/C</53?1B37382/12/73?1./76C/A24;1./ 0/121234/5C=71.6E/16A/41./762;277=/1321793:2869/4;
</?35/ 1./ 6005305261/ 6=1.3521> 67 053E2;/; =4;/5 /81234 ) 3?
1./ 81 FF 3B/E/5 1./ 0/121234/5 <>
- 14 -
?2924: 3<D/812347 </?35/ 1./ /1=5424:
??28/5 64;
83C0/9924: .2C 13 5/D/81 1./ 43C2461234 34 1./ :53=4;
1.61 5/7034;/41 3 .6; 248=55/; ;27@=692?2861234 B67 24 ?681 <65A24: 1./ B534: 15// ./5/?35/ 1./ /1=5424:
??28/5 B67 431 B/99 6;E27/; 13 5/D/81 1./ 43C2461234 3? 5/7034;/413E/431./5B27/67431/;<>5/7034;/41 3% ?53C 1./ /E2;/48/ 3? 1./ .2/? M/8=12E/ ??28/5 3? 6E69:6 B.3 B67 /M6C24/; 67 ,% 1./ 5/7034;/41 3 .6; 695/6;> B21.;56B4 .27 !/C</57.20 34 % ./5/?35/ 1./5/ 27 43 D=712?2861234 ?35 5/D/8124: 43C2461234 3? 5/7034;/41 3 64; ./48/ 1./ 2C0=:4/;35;/50677/;<>5/7034;/413%64;=0./9;<> 654616A600/9961/52<=46927D=7164;0530/5241./?6817 64; 8258=C71648/73? 1./ 867/64; ;3/7431 B65564164> 241/5?/5/48/241.27B5210/121234/48/1./B5210/12123427 ;27C277/; ()
&%' % , 271393%