- 1 - !"!# $%" " &% ' ! "# $ $ % & $ $ '(&) & % * $ % & $ $ '(&) + " ! $ # ! ! % ! , % !,* '*--& Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - $ & % ! % ! $ '(- ) $ $ '(&) $ $ $ '(&) + " $! ! $ &. ! ! ) # % &&* &&/ % % -&-&&0) &-&-& &$ % - 3 - 1 23 4356567839: ;<=6>68? 57 @3 523 >3>@39: 7A = ;7>>65533 ;78:565B53C 57 =C>686:539 523 %=DA 2=E3 A6<3C 526: 43565678 ;2=<<38?68? =8 38C79:3>385 @3=968? 7% -&-&&0) C=53C &-&-& " 883FB93#6::B3C@G93:478C3857&23G=<:7:33D A79 :B;2 75239 93>3CG =: >=G @3 83;3::=9G 68 523 A=;5: =8C;69;B>:5=8;3:7A523;=:3 & 23 4356567839: ;78538C 52=5 =9?=2 =H9=52 2=6D =93CBCC68 =8:7796 "B886# =8E6 6: = 8756A63C %=DA23G;78538C52=543565678397@368?=93:6C385 7A=839:5I26<3;7>>655337A=8=?3>385JB3:56783C523 =;5 7A 93:478C385 7 =44768568? =8 =C>686:59=579 @G A6<68?=4497496=53497;33C68?:@3A7935233;935=9G57523 7E398>385 7A !=98=5=D= 34=95>385 7A 687965G %3<A=93 38?=<B9B 23 3;935=9G 68 539>: 7A 523 79C39 C=53C 0-&-0 C693;53C 523 263A F3;B56E3 AA6;39 7A 523 %=DA 7=9C 57 =447685 =8 68C3438C385 439:78 =: =8 - 4 - =C>686:59=579 =4497E3 523 83I @G3<=I: =8C =<:7 ;78:565B53=>=8=?68?;7>>65533I652685I7>7852:=A539 ;78CB;568?=?3839=<@7CG>33568?7A523>3>@39:=:439 523=4497E3C@G3<=I:23G;78538C52=5526:79C39I=: ;2=<<38?3C@G523=C>686:59=579I27I=:5238687AA6;368 %7&-&&&-023:=6CI96543565678I=:C6:>6::3C 68539>:7A52379C39C=53C0-*&-&4=E68?I=GA79523 263A F3;B56E3 AA6;39 57 5=D3 :534: =: C693;53C @G 523 3;935=9G34=95>3857A687965G%3<A=93234356567839: ;78538C52=5=8756;3;78E3868?523?3839=<@7CG>33568? I=:6::B3C57=<<523>3>@39:=8C>33568?:I39323<C78 -&-(&-& -0-(&-& =8C *-(&-& I2393=5 65 I=: B8=86>7B:<G 93:7<E3C 57 3<3;5 523 7AA6;3 @3=939: 7A 523 =8=?68? 7>>65533 7A 523 %=DA 356567839 7 I=: 3<3;53C=:523493:6C385=8C523=8=?68?;7>>65533I=: CB<G;78:565B53C23G;78538C52=54356567839768E653C 93:478C385 7& 57 5=D3 4=95 68 523 >33568?: 7A 523 =8=?68?;7>>65533@B593:478C3857&A=6<3C57C7:7 23 4356567839: ;78538C 52=5 =A539 523 >3>@39: 7A 523 =8=?68? ;7>>65533 I393 3<3;53C 523 :=>3 I=: :385 - 5 - =<78? I652 = ;74G 7A 93:7<B5678 57 93:478C385 7& A79 83;3::=9G=4497E=<=8C9383I=<3:478C3857&C6C875 A79I=9C 65 57 93:478C385 7 2393A793 523 4356567839: @368?=??963E3C@G52368=;5678785234=957A93:478C385 7&68A79I=9C68?5236949747:=<5793:478C3857A6<3C %96535656787&--)&-&I2393526:7B952=:6::B3C 8756;3 57 523 4=9563: 23 4356567839: ;78538C 52=5 523 C6:4B53 93?=9C68? 523 38565<3>385 57 ;78568B3 523 =8=?68? 7>>65533 6: 438C68? ;78:6C39=5678 @3A793 523 93:478C385:=B52796563:23G;78538C52=55239B:68523 =9?=2 I7B<C @3 23<C @35I338 &-&-& =8C &/-&-& 23G ;78538C 52=5 68 523 493E67B: G3=9 CB968? =8B=9G &-& = :6>6<=9 :65B=5678 =97:3 =8C 523 C3E7533: 68;<BC68? 523 4356567839: =4497=;23C 93:478C3857&:33D68?439>6::67857;3<3@9=535239B: =8C 7AA39 =8C=< 3:478C385 7& ?9=853C 439>6::678 439>65568?5234356567839:239368=8C783G3CC96: =C96 =@57439A79>9B:=8C=8C=<2393A7935234356567839: ;78538C52=53E38526:G3=9577523:=>3497;3CB932=: 57 @3 A7<<7I3C =8C 523 4356567839: :27B<C @3 ?9=853C - 6 - 439>6::678 57 439A79> 9B: =8C =8C=< 23 4356567839: ;78538C 52=5 93:478C385 7& 2=: 6::B3C 523 6>4B?83C 38C79:3>385 93K3;568? 523 93JB3:5 7A 523 4356567839: 57 ;78CB;5 9B: =8C =8C=< 23 4356567839: =93 52393A793 @3A793526:7B95 ) 23<3=983C;7B8:3<A795234356567839:;78538C 52=5 523 4356567839: =93 <=IAB<<G 3<3;53C >3>@39: 7A 523 =8=?68?7>>65533=5=?3839=<@7CG7A5233>@39:7A 523%=DA352393A793;78538C:52=55234356567839:2=E3 = @35539 96?25 57 439A79> 9B: =8C 7AA39 =8C=< 3 =<:7 ;78538C: 52=5 3E38 68 523 4=:5 523 4356567839: I393 =B52796H3C57439A79>9B:=8C=8C=<=8C52393A79352393 ;=8 @3 87 C6AA6;B<5G 68 439>65568? 523 4356567839: 57 ;78568B3523:=6C59=C65678 7I3E39 523 <3=983C ;7B8:3< A79 93:478C385 7& :B@>65: 52=5 523 4356567839: =93 >3>@39: 7A = :3<A :5G<3C ;7>>65533 =: 523 263A F3;B56E3 AA6;39 7A 523 %=DA 7=9C 2=: 875 ;78:565B53C 523 ;7>>65533 =: 439 3;5678(7A523%=DA ;500=8C=:439523C693;5678: - 7 - 7A 523 3;935=9G 34=95>385 7A 687965G %3<A=93 3 52393A793 ;78538C: 52=5 523 4356567839: 2=E3 87 57 =::395 52=5 523G =93 >3>@39: 7A = =8=?68? 7>>65533 =8C 52393A793 523G ;=8875 ;7>43< 52=5 523G :27B<C@3439>6553C57439A79>9B:=8C7AA39=8C=<3 ;78538C: 52=5 =: 439 523 79C39 7A 523 3;935=9G 34=95>3857A687965G%3<A=93:534:=93@368?5=D38A79 =447685>385 7A =8 68C3438C385 439:78 =: =8 C>686:59=579 3 AB95239 :B@>65: 52=5 52393 =93 68A6?2568?:@35I3385234356567839:=8C75239>3>@39:7A 523%=DA=8C5237523968:565B5678:;<=6>68?23?3>78G68 >=5539:7A=C>686:53968?523%=JA=8C52393A793=<<7I68? 523 4356567839: 57 439A79> 9B: =8C 7AA39 =8C=< I7B<C 93:B<568=8=IDI=9C:65B=5678=8C=<6D3<G<=I=8C79C39 497@<3>2393A79323;78538C:52=5523263AF3;B56E3 AA6;39 =<78? I652 523 6:596;5 %=DA AA6;39 =8C 523 =2:6<C=97A523=8E6=<BDI7B<C439A79>5239B:=8C 7AA39=8C=<=8C=<:7:B439E6:352393<6?67B:=;56E6563: - 8 - 2=E3;78:6C393C523:B@>6::678:>=C3@G523 <3=983C;7B8:3<A795234356567839:=8C523<3=983C;7B8:3< A7952393:478C385: * 439B:=<7A52379C394=::3C@G5233;935=9G 5752334=95>3857A687965G%3<A=93C=53C0-&-0 :27I: 52=5 =8 =C>686:59=579 I27 I=: =4476853C I=: 79C393C57@393>7E3C=8C=83B59=<439:78I=:C693;53C 57 @3=4476853C =:=8 =C>686:59=579 23263A F3;B56E3 AA6;39 7A 523 %=DA 7=9C I=: C693;53C 57 ;78:565B53 = ;7>>65533I652685I7>7852:=A539;78CB;568?=>33568? 7A5233839=<7CG26:79C39I=:;2=<<38?3C@3A793526: 7B95 68 %965 3565678 7&-&&&-0 =8C 523 :=6C I965 43565678 ;=>3 B4 A79 ;78:6C39=5678 78<G 78 0-*&-& 26: 7B95 68 539>: 7A 523 79C39 C=53C 0-*&-& C6:>6::3C523435656784=E68?I=GA79523263AF3;B56E3 AA6;39 57 5=D3 :534: =: 439 523 79C39 4=::3C @G 523 3;935=9G34=95>3857A687965G%3<A=9368;3523263A F3;B56E3 AA6;39 2=: 875 ;78:565B53C = ;7>>65533 7A >=8=?3>385 7A 523 %=DA 65 =443=9: 52=5 523 4356567839: - 9 - 523>:3<E3:2=E3;78:565B53C=;7>>655337A>=8=?3>385 =8C 2=E3 :5=D3C 52369 ;<=6> 57 439A79> 9B: =8C 7AA39 =8C=<8>=5539:7A526:8=5B93656:523263AF3;B56E3 AA6;39I27=<7836:38565<3C57;78:565B53=;7>>655337A >=8=?3>385 68 93:43;5 7A = 8756A63C %=DA B8C39 3;5678 (7A523%=DA ;5002393A7935234356567839:@368? :3<A:5G<3C7AA6;3@3=939:7A523;7>>655337A>=8=?3>385 ;=8875<=G=;<=6>57439A79>=8G93<6?67B:=;56E6563:68523 68:565B5678 2393A793 93:478C385 7& I=: KB:56A63C 68 93K3;568?52393JB3:57A5234356567839:57;78CB;55239B: =8C7AA39=8C=<38;3523936:87833C5768539A393I652 52379C394=::3C@G93:478C3857&I26;26:6>4B?83C68 526:I96543565678 / 68;3523<3=983C;7B8:3<:B@>65:52=5=<<:534: =935=D38A79439A79>=8;37A9B:=8C7AA3968?7A=8C=< 523 :=>3 :2=<< @3 C783 @G 523 263A F3;B56E3 AA6;39 =<78? I652 523 6:596;5 %=DA AA6;39 I652 523 23<4 7A 523 =:6<C=97A=8E6=<BD=8C523G:2=<<38:B9352343=;3AB< ;78CB;57A52393<6?67B:=;56E6563:6852368:565B5678 - 10 - ( 8G7@:39E=5678:>=C368526:I96543565678I6<< 875;7>368523I=G7A5234356567839:;<=6>68?57@3523 CB<G3<3;53C >3>@39: 7A523 >=8=?68? ;7>>65533 6A 656: =4497E3C@G93:478C3857& 23I96543565678:5=8C:@B5:B@K3;557523 =A793:=6C 497E6:678: >=C3 A79 439A79>=8;3 7A 9B: =8C 7AA3968?=8C=<=8C752397@:39E=5678: () &"' " 6:57<7&