Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9134 (KAR)
NAGARAJ S/O KAMPLEPPA GANADAL v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/200117/2025 · 2025-02-18
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9134 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9134 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#
$% &$ ! # '()'*+,( )'++ &
!"# $
%
#
"
" %
""
"&'
(((
!"% ) #$
%
'* %! $' %
" !+$
" '*,&
"% -"
'
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
+ % %%"
',. % . % +
% +
/"
#+
! /"
#+$
001234 56 730589 823 :'*,& 736456; <3=:>3 ?@3 :1>? := 445?5:689 52?>50? 864 3225:62 14;373058914;3850@1>25??56;8?564@861>8>5256;
:1? := >5A3 :& >3;52?3>34 <B 1>C5@89 :9503 ?8?5:6 850@1> =:> ?@3 :==36032 71652@8<93 1643> 30?5:62 ',. := 864 30?5:62 864 . := ?@3 0?52<3=:>3?@52:1>?1643>30?5:6':="&'
38>4938>6340:16239=:>?@378>?532
' % 56 >5A3 :& D82 >3;52?3>34 <B 1>C5@89:9503?8?5:6850@1>=:>?@38=:>32854:==36032 8;8562? 16E6:D6 73>2:6 :6 ?@3 <8252 := ?@3 =5>2? 56=:>A8?5:6 48?34 && >3035C34 =>:A @594
- 3 -
3C39:7A36? >:F30? ==503> 1>C5@89 6 ?@3 =5>2? 56=:>A8?5:6 5? 52 2?8?34 ?@8? ?@3 C50?5A ;5>9 D@: 52 ?@3 481;@?3> := >327:6436? : @3>356 D82 =:164 ?: <3 7>3;686? 41>56; @3> A345089 3G8A568?5:6 864 ?@3>3=:>3 ?@3=5>2?56=:>A86?@84877>:80@34?@37:95031>56;?@3 0:1>23 := 56C32?5;8?5:6 := ?@3 0823 73?5?5:63> @3>356 D82 8>>32?34 :6 '&&& 864 21<23H136?9B >3A86434 ?:
F1450589 012?:4B 6C32?5;8?5:6 := ?@3 0823 52 0:A793?34 8640@8>;32@33?@82<336=59348;8562??@373?5?5:63>=:> ?@3 8=:>32854 :==36032 @3 <859 8779508?5:6 =5934 <B ?@3 73?5?5:63><3=:>3?@3>589:1>?56>9520:'*& D82>3F30?34:6&@3>3=:>3@352<3=:>3?@52 :1>? 38>6340:16239=:>?@373?5?5:63>21<A5?2?@8? ?@373?5?5:63>864?@3C50?5A;5>98>309:23>398?5C32@3 73?5?5:63> 8;34 8<:1? B38>2 52 56 012?:4B =>:A '&&& 864 @3 @82 6: :?@3> 0>5A5689 86?303436?2 @3 C50?5A ;5>9 @82 6:? A843 86B 8993;8?5:6 8;8562? ?@3
- 4 -
73?5?5:63>56@3>2?8?3A36?>30:>4341643>30?5:6.:= >00:>456;9B@37>8B2?:899:D?@373?5?5:6
3> 0:6?>8 938>634 5;@ :1>? :C3>6A36? 93843> =:> >327:6436? : @82 :77:234 ?@3 73?5?5:6 @3 21<A5?2 ?@8? 56 ?@3 3C36? 73?5?5:63> 52 3698>;34 :6 <859@35295E39B?:?8A73>D5?@?@37>:2301?5:6D5?632232
. % 56 ?@3 7>3236? 0823 D82 21<A5??34 <B ?@3 @5943C39:7A36?>:F30? ==503>1>C5@898=?3>?@3C50?5A ;5>9 D@: D82 A3450899B 3G8A5634 D82 =:164 ?: <3 7>3;686? 2 73> ?@384@8> 08>4:= ?@3C50?5A ;5>9 2@3 H8;34<39:D8<:1?B38>286456?@52<80E;>:164?@3 =5>2? 56=:>A86? @84 877>:80@34 ?@3 7:9503 1>56; ?@3 0:1>23 := 56C32?5;8?5:6 ?@3 2?8?3A36? := ?@3 C50?5A ;5>9 1643>30?5:6.:=>D82>30:>434:6&*& @3 C50?5A ;5>9 @82 2?8?34 ?@8? 25603 2@3 D82 21==3>56; =>:A 2?:A80@ 7856 2@3 @84 877>:80@34 ?@3 @:275?89 8? 564@861> 864 21<23H136?9B 2@3 @84 877>:80@34 ?@3 @:275?89 8? 850@1> 864 56?@3 2854 @:275?89 2@308A3 ?:
E6:D ?@8? 2@3 D82 7>3;686? @3 @82 6:? A843 86B
- 5 -
8993;8?5:6 8;8562? ?@3 73?5?5:63> 2?8?56; ?@8? @3 52 ?@3 >382:6=:>@3>7>3;6860B@373?5?5:63>@8C56;6::?@3> 0>5A5689 86?303436?2 52 56 012?:4B =>:A '&&& 6C32?5;8?5:6 := ?@3 0823 52 0:A793?34 864 0@8>;3 2@33? @82<336=5934@3A8?3>589:6>30:>4D:194;:?:2@:D ?@8? ?@3 73?5?5:63> 864 C50?5A ;5>9 8>3 09:23 >398?5C32 327:6436?
: D@: 52 7>3236? <3=:>3 ?@3 :1>? 56 73>2:6 21<A5?2 ?@8? @3 @82 6: :<F30?5:6 ?: ;>86? <859 ?: ?@373?5?5:63>
, :62543>56;?@38=:>3285482730?2:=?@3A8??3> 8A:=?@3:7565:6?@8??@37>8B3>A843<B?@373?5?5:63> =:> ;>86? := >3;198> <859 63342 ?: <3 862D3>34 8==5>A8?5C39B00:>456;9B=:99:D56;:>43>52782234
@30>5A568973?5?5:652899:D34 @373?5?5:63>80012345245>30?34?:<33698>;34:6 <859 56 730589 823 :'*,& 736456; <3=:>3 ?@3 :1>? := 445?5:689 52?>50? 864 3225:62 14;3 850@1> 25??56; 8? 564@861> 8>5256; :1? := >5A3
- 6 -
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
- 7 -
:1>? 16?59 ?@3 0823 >3;52?3>34 8;8562? @5A 52 4527:234:==
6 C53D := 4527:289 := A86 73?5?5:6 736456; 8779508?5:65=86B4:326:?21>C5C3=:>0:62543>8?5:6
-,
'% &$ !+ $
52?:9:'