- 1 - ! " # $ " %&'%()*'%)) $ ! " # $ % & $ ' && ( && & & )*+* " #$ % Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & +&# % *+ & # !% ' # % & & && ++ & &&$ & & ! , $! # , $! % -././01-2/34-502-.6/3072.8/.69:29;-2.0<7936 .6- -1./2- :20=-->/1?3 /1 0 :-1>/1? 4-502- .6- =072. 05 /@/A 7>?- B & 9. 9>?/2 92/3/1? 07.05 0 -92> .6- A-921-> =0713-A 502 .6- :-././01-2 91> A-921->/?6072.0@-21C-1.A-9>-2860/3>/2-=.->.0 .9D-10./=-502.6-2-3:01>-1. 2/@9.-=0C:A9/1./1 0 893374C/..-> 4;.6-2-3:01>-1.E2/6929194939@9C-C4-2059:/> <79> 01D9A /@/3/01 727C/.D9A -?/3A9./@- 33-C4A; - 3 - 013./.7-1=; 9>?/2 9AA-?/1? .69. :-././01-2 69> =0CC/..->055-1=-71>-2-=./01++05 1.6-:2/@9.-=0C:A9/1././39AA-?->.69./1@/0A9./01 05 .6- :-2C/33/01 .6- :-././01-2 69> 73-> * 5A9?3 4-A01?/1? .0 .6- 6929./;9 919.9 92.; 01 91>8933--1=91@933/1?502.6--A-=./01/159@07205.6- =91>/>9.-056929./;9919.992.; * 6- A-921-> 9?/3.29.- 01 2-=-/:. 05 .6- =0C:A9/1. 69>/337->37CC013.0.6-:-././01-2-/1?9??2/-@->4; .6-39C-:-././01-2/34-502-.6/3=072. F -921-> =0713-A 502 .6- :-././01-2 69@/1? 2-/.-29.-> .6-?2071>372?->/1.6-:-././01374C/.3.69.-@-1/5.6- 9@-2C-1.3 C9>- /1 .6- =0C:A9/1. 92- :2-37C-> .0 4- .27- .6- 055-1=- :71/3694A- 71>-2 -=./01 ++ 05 =9110. 4- C9>- 07. 9?9/13. .6- :-././01-2 - 374C/.3 .69. A-921-> 9?/3.29.- 8/.607. .9D/1? =0?1/G91=- 05 .6- 9AA-?-> 055-1=- 693 :20=-->-> .0 /337- 37CC013 .0 .6- :-././01-286/=6/349>/1A98 - 4 - -2 =01.29 A-921-> /?6 072. 0@-21C-1. A-9>-2 6930::03->.6-:-././01 + :-2739A05.6-C9.-2/9A012-=02>807A>?0.03608 .69. :2/@9.- =0C:A9/1. 893 5/A-> 9AA-?/1? .69. 6- 69> @/0A9.-> .6- =01>/./013 05 .6- :-2C/33/01 ?291.-> .0 6/C 91>8935071>=922;/1?*5A9?3056929./;9919.992.; 86/A-6-893:-2C/..->.0=922;01A;01-5A9? -=./01++052-9>39350AA083 ! - 5 - &20C 9 2-9>/1? 05 9502-39/> :20@/3/013 05 A98 /. /3 @-2; =A-92 .69. >/304->/-1=- 05 .6- 02>-2 3607A> 69@- =973->02.-1>3.0=973-043.27=./019110;91=-02/1H72; .0 91; :-2301 A9857AA; -C:A0;-> 02 37=6 >/304->/-1=- =973-302.-1>3.0=973->91?-2.067C91A/5-6-9A.602 395-.; 02 =973-3 02 .-1>3 .0 =973- 2/0. 02 95529; 6-2-502- 1-=-3392; /1?2->/-1.3 502 /1@0D/1? 055-1=- :71/3694A-71>-2-=./01++059?9/13..6-:-././01-2 92-10.5071>/1.6-=0C:A9/1. 6- A-921-> 9?/3.29.- 8/.607. 9::2-=/9./1? .6/3 93:-=.05.6-C9..-291>9A308/.607..9D/1?=0?1/G91=-05 .6- 9AA-?-> 055-1=-3 693 :20=-->-> .0 /337- 37CC013 .0 .6- :-././01-2 1>-2 .6- =/2=7C3.91=-3 9C 05 .6- 0:/1/01 .69. .6- /C:7?1-> :20=-->/1?3 /1/./9.-> 9?9/13. - 6 - .6- :-././01-2 /5 9AA08-> .0 =01./17- 807A> 9C071. .0 9473-05:20=-3305A98==02>/1?A;.6-50AA08/1? 9% 6-:-././01/39AA08-> 4% 6- -1./2- :20=-->/1?3 /1 0 :-1>/1?4-502-.6-=072.05/@/A7>?-B& 9. 9>?/2 92/3/1? 07. 05 0 502 .6-055-1=-:71/3694A-71>-2-=./01++05 /36-2-4;<7936-> +* %# $ ) /3. 0A 0