Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9093 (KAR)
SIDDARAM @ SIDDU v. STATE AND ANR
CRL.A/200024/2025 · 2025-02-13
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9093 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9093 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "# $"
!%%&' &(( $
!"!#$
% &
'
# (
( )!"!#$
*
+ *(
* )!"!#$,
%
&
(# ('
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( #) &' ( &' * #!$#$! & ' - $ ( ( (( #"-&' #-#&' #-#&,' ##!&' ##"&#' #$- ,! #-$ #$,&#' (
,&#'&.'&/',&'&0'( ((
( *
1
*
"! &1
*'
223/45 6 78 9427:; :/4 & ' 6- $ 948578< =4>6.4 ?@4 63.? 6> 557?768:; 7/?.72? :85 4//768/ 35<4 9427:; 35<4 :;:=3.:<7 :.7/78< 63? 6> .7A4 6- $ .4<7/?4.45 =B 8704./7?B 6;724 ?:?768 :;:=3.:<7 >6. ?@4 6>>48/4/ 9387/@:=;4 3854. /42?768/ #"-&' #-#&' #-#&,' ##!&' ##"&#' #$- ,! #-$ :85 #$,&#' 6> @:.:?7B: B:B: :8@7?: $, &>6./@6.?C$,D':853854.42?768/,&#'&.'&/':85 ,&'&0' 6> 2@453;45 :/?4/ :85 2@453;45 .7=4/ &.4048?768 6> ?.627?74/' 2? #-"- &>6. /@6.? 1
- 3 -
&'2?1'7/=4>6.4?@7/63.?78?@7/:994:;>7;453854. 42?768 #&'&' 6> &' 2? ://:7;78< ?@4 6.54. 5:?45 #!$#$! 9://45 =B ?@4 63.? 6> 557?768:; 7/?.72? :85 4//768/ 35<4 9427:; 35<4 :;:=3.:<7 78 9427:; :/4 & ' 6- $ E@4.478 ?@4 :99;72:?768 >7;45 =B ?@4 :994;;:8? 3854. 42?768 ", 6> @:.:?7B: :<:.7F 3.:F/@: :8@7?: $, &>6. /@6.? C$,D'/44F78<.4<3;:.=:7;@:/=448.4G42?45
4:.5;4:.8452638/4;>6.?@49:.?74/ , ( 78 .7A4 6- $ E:/ .4<7/?4.45 =B 8704./7?B 6;724 ?:?768 :;:=3.:<7 >6. ?@4 6>>4824/ 9387/@:=;43854./42?768/#"-&'#-#&'#-#&,'##!&' ##"&#' #$- ,! .4:5 E7?@ 42?768 #-$ 6> $, :<:78/? 684
:.38F3A:. :85 >704 6?@4./ 68 ?@4 =:/7/ 6> ?@4 >7./? 78>6.A:?768 5:?45 #$-$ .4247045 >.6A .4/968548? 6 @4.478 E@6 7/ ?@4 A6?@4. 6> 5424:/45 3A44?@4:994;;:8?@4.4787/:..:B45:/:223/456 78 ?@4 ( 3.78< ?@4 263./4 6> 7804/?7<:?768 @4 E:/ :..4/?45 68 $-$ :85 /3=/4H348?;B .4A:8545 ?6
- 4 -
G35727:; 23/?65B @4 7804/?7<:?768 6> ?@4 2:/4 7/ 26A9;4?45 :85 2@:.<4 /@44? @:/ =448 >7;45 :<:78/? 47<@? :223/45 94./68/ :85 ?@4 :994;;:8? 7/ :..:B45 :/ :223/45 678?@42@:.<4/@44?@4=:7;:99;72:?768>7;45=B?@4 :994;;:8? =4>6.4 ?@4 .7:; 63.? 78 9427:; :/4 & ' 6- $E:/.4G42?4568#!$#$!@4.4>6.4@47/ =4>6.4?@7/63.?78?@7/:994:;
4:.845 2638/4; >6. ?@4 :994;;:8? @:078< .47?4.:?45 ?@4 <.6385/ 3.<45 78 ?@4 :994:; /3=A7?/ ?@:? :223/456/,:85":<:78/?E@6A/7A7;:.:;;4<:?768/:.4 >638578?@42@:.<4/@44?@:04=448<.:8?45.4<3;:.=:7; =B?@7/63.?:85:223/456/!?6+@:04=448<.:8?45 .4<3;:. =:7; =B ?@4 G3.7/572?768:; 4//768/ 63.? 4 /3=A7?/ ?@:? :994;;:8? @:/ 86 6?@4. 2.7A78:; :8?424548?/ :85:226.578<;B9.:B/?6:;;6E?@4:994:;
! 4. 268?.: ;4:.845 7<@ 63.? 604.8A48? ;4:54. >6. .4/968548? 6# :85 ;4:.845 2638/4;
:994:.78< >6. .4/968548? 6 @:04 6996/45 ?@4 9.:B4. A:5478?@4:994:;@4B/3=A7??@:??@4:994;;:8?7/?@4
- 5 -
94./68 E@6 @:5 =.63<@? ?@4 F87>4 :85 @:8545 604. ?@4 /:A4?6:223/456#E@6@://?:==45?@45424:/45E7?@ ?@4/:A4226.578<;B?@4B9.:B?657/A7//?@4:994:;
4.3/:; 6> ?@4 A:?4.7:; :0:7;:=;4 68 .426.5 E63;5<6?6/@6E?@:?>7./?78>6.A:8?D//68:2@78E:/78 ;604E7?@?@4:223/456+
:7/@8:07E@67/?@4/7/?4. 6> :223/45 6# )
:.38F3A:.
223/45 6# :85 @7/ >:A7;B A4A=4./ E4.4 6996/78< ?@4 .4;:?768/@79 :85 ?@4.4>6.4 ?@4.4 E:/ : >7<@? =4?E448 ?@4 ?E6 >:A7;74/ 68 #-$-$ 8 $$-$ :223/45 6# :;68< E7?@ :223/45 6/ ?6 :85 " @:5 :..7045 84:. ?@4 @63/4 6> >7./? 78>6.A:8? 78 :8 :3?6.72F/@:E :85 :/F45 ?@4 >7./? 78>6.A:8??69.65324@4./68:2@78=4>6.4?@4A??@:? ?7A4:223/456/!:85+:;/6:..704584:.?@4@63/4 6>>7./?78>6.A:8??7/:;;4<45?@:??@4:223/4594./68/ H3:..4;45 E7?@ ?@4 >7./? 78>6.A:8? :85 ://:3;?45 @4. ? ?@:? ?7A4 5424:/45 3A44? E@6 7/ ?@4 B638<4. /68 6> >7./? 78>6.A:8? ?.745 ?6 78?4.>4.4 :85 :;; ?@4 :223/45 94./68/:;;4<45;B://:3;?45@7AE7?@?@47.@:85/223/45
- 6 -
6# :/F45 :223/45 6 ?6 =.78< ?@4 F87>4 E@72@ E:/ F49? 78 ?@4 :3?6.72F/@:E 78 E@72@ ?@4B @:5 :..7045 226.578<;B :223/45 6 =.63<@? ?@4 F87>4 E@72@ E:/ F49? 78 ?@4 :3?6.72F/@:E :85 :223/45 6# ://:3;?45 3A44? E7?@ ?@4 /:75 F87>4 :85 :/ : .4/3;? 3A44? E@6 /3>>4.45 <.74063/ 78G3.B E:/ /3=/4H348?;B /@7>?45 ?6 :
<604.8A48? @6/97?:; :? :;:=3.:<7 =3? @4 5745 68 #$-$ @4.4 7/ 86 :;;4<:?768 :/ :<:78/? ?@4 :994;;:8? :223/45 6:=63? @4://:3;?78<?@45424:/45 E7?@:8BE4:968@4:;;4<:?768:/:<:78/?:223/456/ ?6 " :=63? ://:3;?78< ?@4 5424:/45 3A44? 7/ /7A7;:. 857/93?45;B ?@4 :994;;:8? @:/ 86 6?@4. 2.7A78:;
:8?424548?/ :85 @4 7/ 78 23/?65B >.6A $-$ @4 7804/?7<:?768 6> ?@4 2:/4 7/ 26A9;4?45 :85 2@:.<4 /@44? @:/ =448 >7;45 @4 6?@4. :223/45 94./68/ E7?@ /7A7;:. :;;4<:?768/ 6> ://:3;?78< ?@4 5424:/45 E7?@ ?@47. @:85/ @:04=448<.:8?45.4<3;:.=:7; +
854. ?@4 27.23A/?:824/ :A 6> ?@4 6978768 ?@:??@49.:B4.A:54=B?@4:994;;:8?>6.<.:8?6>.4<3;:. - 7 -
=:7; 8445/ ?6 :8/E4.45 :>>7.A:?704;B 226.578<;B ?@4 >6;;6E78<6.54. @42.7A78:;:994:;7/:;;6E45
@46.54. 5:?45#!$#$!9://45=B?@463.?6> 557?768:; 7/?.72? :85 4//768/ 35<4 9427:; 35<4 :;:=3.:<7789427:;:/4& '6- $E@4.478 ?@4:99;72:?768>7;45=B?@4:994;;:8?3854.42?768",6> $,/44F78<.4<3;:.=:7;7/@4.4=B/4?:/754 @4 :994;;:8? :223/45 6 7/ 57.42?45 ?6 =4 48;:.<45 68 =:7; 78 9427:; :/4 & ' 6- $ 948578< =4>6.4 ?@4 63.? 6> 557?768:; 7/?.72? :85 4//768/ 35<4 9427:; 35<4 :;:=3.:<7 :.7/78< 63? 6> .7A4 6- $ .4<7/?4.45 =B 8704./7?B 6;724 ?:?768 :;:=3.:<7 >6. ?@4 6>>48/4/ 9387/@:=;4 3854. /42?768/ #"-&' #-#&' #-#&,' ##!&' ##"&#' #$- ,! #-$ :85 #$,&#' 6> $, :85 3854. /42?768 ,&#'&.'&/' I ,&'&0' 6> &' 2? /3=G42? ?6 ?@4 >6;;6E78<26857?768/
- 8 -
:'@4 :994;;:8?
/@:;; 4J423?4 94./68:; =685 >6. :
/3A 6> /#$$$$$ ) E7?@ ?E6 /3.4?74/ >6. ?@4 ;7F4/3A ?6 ?@4 /:?7/>:2?768 6> ?@4 G3.7/572?768:; 63.?K ='@4 :994;;:8? /@:;; :994:. .4<3;:.;B 68 :;; ?@4 5:?4/6>@4:.78<=4>6.4?@4.7:;63.?38;4//?@4 .7:; 63.? 4J4A9?/ @7/ :994:.:824 >6. 0:;75 .4:/68/K 2' @4 :994;;:8? /@:;; 86? 57.42?;B 6. 7857.42?;B ?@.4:?48
6. ?:A94. E7?@ ?@4 9.6/423?768 E7?84//4/K 5'@4:994;;:8?/@:;;86?7806;0478/7A7;:.6>>4824/ 78>3?3.4K 4'@4 :994;;:8? /@:;; 86? ;4:04 ?@4 G3.7/572?768 6> ?@4 .7:; 63.? E7?@63? 94.A7//768 6> ?@4 /:75 63.? 38?7; ?@4 2:/4 .4<7/?4.45 :<:78/? @7A 7/ 57/96/456>>
)'
&# $" (
"
7/?6#;6"