- 1 - !"!# $%" " &% ' !! ! !! " #$ % & $$ ! ! $ ' $ (! ) ) (! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - *+ ! (! ! * ), (! ' )' (! ) (! , ) (! * + ) ( !! ) ( !! ! $ ) $ ( !! - 3 - ) $ ! $ ( !! $ ! $ ( !! $ $ ) $ ( !! $ !' $ ( !! ' $ * ! $ ( !! $ !! ( !! , $ ! ( !! ! $ ! ( !! ! $ ' - 4 - ( !! !! $$ +- * , $ $ + $ ( ! !) $ $ $+ $ ( ! ! $ + $ ( ! ! ( !! ! $ $ $ $ + $ ( ! !' ( !! ! + ( ! - 5 - !, $ ! + ( ! ) $ $ + $ ( ! ) )' $ ( !! " # * *. !!!! *!,. !!! ) $% $ * !!' * * + * * !! / !! / ( * $ 0 0 1 - 6 - 234564673898:;3<=3>=657?< @3A9=?6<3=?=?6< 6 !! 43<8?<: A6<7?835B=?6< >3C653 =23 3<?65 ?D?E 98:3 B<8 * 9883>?2BE B53 >3C653 =2?7 695= A2BEE3<:?<: B< 65835 8B=38 !! ?779?<: 6;;?77?6<35$B55B<==63@3A9=3BBE3338?<CBD6956C =23B77?:<336C=2383A53326E8357 ! 79?=?<6' !FB7C?E38C65743A?C?A 435C65;B<A3 6C B< B:533;3<= 6C 7BE3 ?< CBD65 6C =23 45383A377656C53746<83<=767!=6,A6;456;?73FB7 3<=3538 ?<=6 >3C653 =2?7 695= ?< 6'!' !! ?< =35;7 6C F2?A2 =23 D3<865 2B8 B:5338 =6 A6<D3G =23 456435=G=6=2345383A377656C=2353746<83<=67!=6, B=35=2345383A377656C53746<83<=67!=6,B77?:<38 =2383A533?<CBD6956C53746<83<=6?<=35;76CB7BE3 8338 8B=38 !!!! 23 53746<83<= 6 =297 ?<?=?B=383@3A9=?6<456A338?<:7?< 6 !! ) <=23;3B<F2?E3=2353746<83<=67=6) F26 B53 =23 H98:;3<= 83>=657 3@3A9=38 B 46F35 6C - 7 - B==65<3G?<CBD6956C =23 43=?=?6<35 6 2353?< ?<53743A= 6C=23D35G7B;3456435=G=2B=FB7=2379>H3A=;B==356C =23 B:533;3<= 6C 7BE3 B<8 =23 83A533 4B7738 ?< 6'!' !! 23 43=?=?6<35 6 >B738 6< =23 7B?8 46F35 6C B==65<3G 3@3A9=38 B 7BE3 8338 ?< 2?7 6F< CBD65B<8=23<A6<D3G38?==6=2343=?=?6<356!B<86<3 B<:B<<B 23 53746<83<= 67 =6 , C?E38 B< B44E?AB=?6< =6 ?;4E3B8 =23 43=?=?6<357 2353?< B7 F3EE B7B<:B<<BB7 H98:;3<= 83>=65 67! ! B<8 ! 23 <6=?A3 6C =23 B44E?AB=?6<FB7735D386<=234564673898:;3<=3>=657 6! B<8 =23 43=?=?6< FB7 E?7=38 C65 2?7 B443B5B<A3 6< !!! < B44E?AB=?6< FB7 BE76 C?E38 C65 ?<=35?; ?<H9<A=?6< B:B?<7= =23 45646738 98:;3<= 3>=657 6! B<8! 233@3A9=?<:695=?<=35;76C=23658358B=38 !!! :5B<=38 B< 65835 6C ?<H9<A=?6< B:B?<7= =23 4564673898:;3<=3>=6576!B<8! B<8537=5B?<38 =23; C56; BE?3<B=?<: =23 79?= 7A2389E3 456435=G 23 3@3A9=?6<43=?=?6<FB7=23<B8H695<38=6!!23 - 8 - 3@3A9=?6< 43=?=?6< FB7 =23< B8DB<A38 =6 !!B<8 B< B44E?AB=?6< 9<835 5835 // 9E3 6C FB7 C?E3823AB73FB7=23<B8H695<38=6!!<=23 7B?8 8BG =23 45646738 98:;3<= 3>=657 6! B<8 ! 3<=3538 B443B5B<A3 =2569:2 A69<73E 23 <6=?A3 =6 =23 4564673898:;3<=3>=6576!F2?A2FB76583538>G 79>7=?=9=38 735D?A3 =2569:2 4B435 49>E?AB=?6< FB7 BE76 BAA34=38 B738 6< =23 53I937= 6C =23 53746<83<= 6 B77?:<33 6C 3A533 26E835 6' C?E38 >G 2?; 9<8355835//9E3FB7A6<7?83538B<8=237B;3 FB7 BEE6F38 B<8 B< B8D6AB=3 FB7 B446?<=38 B7 B 6;;?77?6<35=63@3A9=3B7BE38338?<2?7CBD6953?<: B::5?3D38>G=237B?865835=2398:;3<=3>=6576! B<8!B53>3C653=2?7695= 23 E3B5<38 A69<73E C65 =23 43=?=?6<357 79>;?==38 =2B= =23 43=?=?6<357 F353 ?;4E3B838 >G =23 83A53326E8357?<=233@3A9=?6<43=?=?6<B<8=23AB73FB7 E?7=38 6< !! 3 79>;?=7 =2B= 3D3< >3C653 =23 43=?=?6<357 A69E8 C?E3 6>H3A=?6<7 =6. #?% =23 B44E?AB=?6< =6 - 9 - ?;4E3B8=23;?<=233@3A9=?6<43=?=?6<#??%=233@3A9=?6< 43=?=?6< B<8 #???% =23 B44E?AB=?6< C?E38 9<835 5835 // 9E3 6C =23 3@3A9=?<: 695= BEE6F38 =23 B44E?AB=?6<C?E389<8355835//9E3B<8B446?<=38B 6;;?77?6<35 =6 3@3A9=3 B 7BE3 8338 3 C95=235 A6<=3<838 =2B= =23 3@3A9=?<: 695= 8?8 <6= A6;4EG =23 456A3895373=69=9<8355835//9E3)6CB<8B 85BC= 6C =23 7BE3 8338 FB7 BE76 <6= C95<?7238 2353C653 23 A6<=3<87 =2B= =23 3<=?53 456A38953 B864=38 >G =23 3@3A9=?<:695=?7?;456435B<823<A3=237B;3?7E?B>E3 =6>39<86<3>G73==?<:B7?83=23658358B=38!! B<8 =6 :5B<= B< 64465=9<?=G =6 =23 43=?=?6<357 =6 A6<=37= =23 B44E?AB=?6< =6 ?;4E3B8 =23; ?< =23 456A338?<:7 B<8 A6<=37==233@3A9=?6<43=?=?6<3BE76A6<=3<87=2B==23 3@3A9=?<:695=8?8<6=A6;4EGF?=25835//9E3 6C ?<76CB5B7?=53EB=38=6B77?:<;3<=6C=2383A533>G =2345383A377656C=2353746<83<=67!=6,?<CBD6956C =2353746<83<=6 - 10 - 35 A6<=5B =23 E3B5<38 3<?65 69<73E B443B5?<:C65=2383A53326E835 53746<83<=679>;?=7 =2B==2398:;3<=3>=6576!B<8!F353769:2==6 >3?;4E3B838=269:2?;456435EGB7=23GF353 495A2B7357B<823<A3F353<6=3<=?=E38=6644673=23 3@3A9=?6< 456A338?<:7 3 BE76 A6<=3<87 =2B= B7 435 A6;456;?73 83A533 ?< 6'!' !! =23 4677377?6< 6C =23 79?= 456435=G FB7 BE53B8G 83E?D3538 =6 =23 45383A37765 ?< =?=E3 6C =23 53746<83<= 67! =6 , 2353C65323A6<=3<87=2B==2343=?=?6<357F353<6=53BEEG <3A377B5G =6 >3 456A33838 B:B?<7= ?< =23 3@3A9=?6< 43=?=?6< ' $23< =2?7 A695= I935?38 B7 =6 26F =23 3@3A9=?<: 695= A69E8 456A338 C95=235 3D3< >3C653 =23 43=?=?6<357 F353 >569:2= 6< 53A658 B<8 3D3< >3C653 =23 43=?=?6<357A69E8>3:5B<=38B<64465=9<?=G=6A6<=37==23 3@3A9=?6< 43=?=?6< =23 E3B5<38 3<?65 69<73E A6<=3<838 =2B= =23 43=?=?6<357 F353 <3?=235 <3A377B5G <65 456435 4B5=?37 =6 =23 3@3A9=?6< 456A338?<: B<8 =2B= =23 - 11 - B44E?AB=?6< FB7 C?E38 =6 ?;4E3B8 =23; 9<835 B ;?7=BJ3< <6=?6<6CEBF3BE7679>;?==38=2B==2353746<83<=6 F69E8 =BJ3 ?;;38?B=3 7=347 =6 F?=285BF =23 B44E?AB=?6< C?E38=6?;4E3B8=2343=?=?6<3572353?<B7H98:;3<=83>=657 67!B<8!>3C653=233@3A9=?<:695= <A6<=?<9B=?6<6C=23BC6537B?879>;?77?6<=23 E3B5<38A69<73EC6553746<83<=62B7C?E38B;3;66< !!!F2?A253B87B7C6EE6F7 !"#$% &'% & () * && % + , - & % '' % .'%/ & () * % & % / % ()* && - 12 - 0 , ?<A3 =23 53746<83<= 6 ?7 <6= 45377?<: =23 B44E?AB=?6< C?E38 =6 ?;4E3B8 =23 43=?=?6<357 2353?< B7 H98:;3<=83>=657?<=233@3A9=?6<43=?=?6<=2343=?=?6<357 F69E8 <6= 2BD3 B<G E6A97 7=B<8? =6 A2BEE3<:3 =23 456A338?<:7 6C =23 3@3A9=?6< 43=?=?6< 23 A6<=3<=?6<7 95:38 >G =23 E3B5<38 A69<73E C65 =23 43=?=?6<357 B53 BDB?EB>E3 6<EG =6 =23 H98:;3<= 83>=657 >3C653 =23 3@3A9=?6< 43=?=?6< 2353C653 =23 43=?=?6<357 F26 B53 495A2B7357 AB<<6= 7266= C56; =23 7269E835 6C=23H98:;3<=83>=657 53746<83<=67=6) < D?3F 6C =23 ;3;6 C?E38 >G =23 E3B5<38 A69<73E C65 =23 53746<83<= 6 B<8 ?< D?3F 6C =23 AB=3:65?ABE 7=B=3;3<= =2B= =23 B44E?AB=?6< C?E38 >G =23 83A53326E835 53746<83<=6>3C653=233@3A9=?<:695= =6?;4E3B8=2343=?=?6<3572353?<F69E8>3F?=285BF<<6 ?<89E:3<A3 AB< >3 726F< =6 =23 43=?=?6<357 2353?< =6 73= - 13 - B7?83=23658354B7738>G=233@3A9=?<:695=3<A3=23 43=?=?6<7=B<876<=23B>6D3=35;7 6F3D35 ?C =23 43=?=?6<357 B53 ?<=3537=38 =6 644673 =23 3@3A9=?6< 43=?=?6< =23G ;BG 86 76 ?< BAA658B<A3F?=2EBF ! EEA6<=3<=?6<7B53J34=643< () &"' " ?7=60E60, 0