Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9060 (KAR)

TANAJI S/O SHESHRAO v. DEEPAK

MFA/200858/2018 · 2025-02-12

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # # $ ! ! " #$ # $# % $ ! # # !! &' $ $ $( # $# & % # # #) # # #* # # +& # # # * # # # + # $ # $ , # # # Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #$ &)) # * # # # # *# # # -$ # -$ ./012./03.145637.2/88./093:;50<=./88.22/3< /318.067.1<=.>/<.09/2/?/92/@2.530.4501 =. /88.22/3< A=5 A/7 8.<9<953.0 93 5&))53<=.;92.5;<=.560<5;<=..39509?9261:. /31/31.>@.0 ,60/1$;507=50< B<=. 09@63/2C97@.;50.<=97560<7..D93:.3=/34.>.3<5; <=.45>8.37/<953 =. 09@63/2@E9<7F61:>.3</31/A/01 1/<.1 + =/7 /A/01.1 / 45>8.37/<953 5; 7+)&GA9<=93<.0.7</<'H8.0/336>;05><=.1/<.5; 8.<9<953<9229<78/E>.3< & =. @09.; ;/4<7 5; <=. 4/7. 5; <=. /88.22/3< 8.<9<953.0<=/<A=92.=.A/78054..193:53=97>5<504E42.=. A/7 =9< @E /35<=.0 >5<504E42. @./093: 5&!&G - 3 - A=94= A/7 5A3.1 @E <=. 0.78531.3< =. 8.<9<953.0 767</93.1 =./1 93F60E /31 93F60E <5 <=. 09:=< 2.: >>.19/<.2E =. A/7 7=9;<.1 <5 <=. .3.0/2 5789</2 $91/0 939<9/22E /7 =. A/7 63453749567 /31 <=.0./;<.0 =. A/7 7=9;<.1<5<=.=5789</2/<E1.0/@/1;50=9:=.0;/4929<9.7 =. 8.<9<953.0453<.3<.1<=/<=.=/776;;.0.17.?.0.197/@929<E53 /44563< 5; <=. 93F609.7 767</93.1 < A/7 7</<.1 <=/< <=. >5<504E42. 5A3.1 @E 0.78531.3< A/7 35< 93760.1 /31 <=.0.;50. <=.0. A/7 35 93760/34. /?/92/@2. 3 7.0?94. 5; 35<94. <=. 0.78531.3< 191 35< /88./0 @.;50. <=. 09@63/2 /31/7764==.A/782/4.1.I8/0<. ) =. 8.<9<953.0 .I/>93.1 =9>7.2; /7 * /31 I7 <5 ) A.0. >/0D.1 93 <=. .?91.34. =. 09@63/2 /;<.0 /77.7793: <=. .?91.34. 53 0.4501 /A/01.1 45>8.37/<953/7@.25A 5A/01725775;/>.39<9.7 7 5A/017>.194/2<0./<>.3< 7&)&G & 5A/01725775;/>.39<9.7 7 5</2 7+)&G - 4 - $.93: /::09.?.1 @E <=97 >./:.0 45>8.37/<953 /A/01.1<=.8.<9<953.097@.;50.<=97560<93/88./2 G ./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 <=. /88.22/3< =/7 76@>9<<.1 <=/< <=. /88.22/3< =/1 76;;.0.1 ;0/4<60. 5; .I<0/ 160/2 =.>/<5>/ A9<= ;053<58/09.</2 76@160/2 =.>500=/:. A9<= ;0/4<60. 5; <=. 09:=< 791.7 7D622 @5/017 . A/7 76@F.4<.1<5760:.0E5;09:=<;053<58/09.</240/395<5>E/31 .?/46/<9535;.I<0/160/2=.>/<5>/.A/79>8/<9.3<;05> &) <5 &) 93 <=. =5789</2 =. 8.<9<953.0 453<.31.1 <=/< =. 97 76;;.093: ;05> 8550 ?97953 /31 <=.0.;50.=.631.0A.3<7.?.0/2<0./<>.3<7 + =. 2./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 <=. 8.<9<953.0 76@>9<7<=/<<=.7.197/@929<9.7/3193F609.7A.0.35<8058.02E 453791.0.1@E<=. 09@63/2 =.0.;50.=.76@>9<7<=/<<=. 45>8.37/<953 /A/01.1 631.0 <=. =./1 2577 5; />.39<9.7 93 29;.7=5621=/?.@..3.3=/34.10./753/@2E5A93:<5<=.;/4< <=/< <=.0. 97 35 2577 5; ./0393: 4/8/49<E .34. =. 7..D7 .3=/34.>.3<5;<=.45>8.37/<953 - 5 - 3 4/0.;62 8.067/2 5; <=. >.194/2 0.45017 /?/92/@2. 53 0.4501 9< /88./07 <=/< <=. 45>8.37/<953 /A/01.1 @E <=. 09@63/2 631.0 <=. =./17 5; 8/93 /31 76;;.093: /< 7 /31 2577 5; />.39<9.7 93 29;. /< 7 7=5621 @. .3=/34.1 0./753/@2E .34. 9; 45>8.37/<953631.0<=.=./18/93/3176;;.093:97.3=/34.1 <5 7) /31 2577 5; />.39<9.7 93 29;. 97 .3=/34.1 <5 79<A5621>..<<=..3175;F67<94. ' 60<=.0 <=. 09@63/2 =/7 35< /A/01.1 /3E 45>8.37/<953 <5A/017 <=. /<<.31/3<C7 4=/0:.7 /31 453?.E/34. .<4 .?.3 <=56:= <=.0. 97 .?91.34. <5 7=5A <=/< =. A/7 7=9;<.1 <5 E1.0/@/1 ;50 =9:=.0 >.194/2 <0./<>.3</31<0./<.1/7938/<9.3<93<=.=5789</2.34./ 76>5; 797/A/01.1<5=9>631.0<=97=./1 =.45>8.37/<9535; 7&)&/A/01.1@E<=. 09@63/2<5A/017>.194/2.I8.37.797F67</318058.0 3/22<=.8.<9<953.097.3<9<2.1;5045>8.37/<953 5; 7+ 93 /119<953 <5 <=. 45>8.37/<953 /A/01.1 @E <=. 09@63/2 - 6 - 3?9.A5;<=./@5?.<=.;5225A93: # i) =./88./297/225A.1938/0< ii) =. /88.22/3< 97 .3<9<2.1 ;50 45>8.37/<9535; 7+/253:A9<= 93<.0.7< /< <=. 0/<. 5; GH 8.0 /336> ;05><=.1/<.5;8.<9<953<9229<71.8579< 93/119<953<5A=/<=/7@..3/A/01.1@E <=. 09@63/2 iii) =. 0.78531.3< 97 190.4<.1 <5 1.8579< <=. 45>8.37/<953 />563< A9<= 93<.0.7< @.;50. <=. 09@63/2 A9<=93 / 8.0951 5; .9:=< A..D7 ;05> <=. 1/<. 5; <=97 F61:>.3< iv) .7<5;<=.501.08/77.1@E<=. 09@63/2 0.:/0193: 0.2./7. 5; <=. 45>8.37/<953 />563<0.>/9363/2<.0.1 1 % # & # $ 97<525G' !