- 1 - !" #$ %# "&&'()'** % ! " #$ % & ' ! $ & $ $ ( $$ ( ! " #$ & & (% & )& #% $ * $ Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ((!()$ +(!() & $ ((!() $ & && $ !+!)!((!(( (& , #(%#% & (! & & * -$ * #" # -$ * % ../,01 2 34 5360 2((!() 5073,80501 9: ;60; 2;3.0 8<8324 3=<:<>/5 3,853.8 ?25 2??04.0, >/43,@<9;0/41050.8324,!+!)!((!(( (2? <410.8324,#(%#A%2? 60416048.8(! 3,90?2508@3, 2/58348@3,<>>0<;/41050.8324 )#%#(% 2? #%60416048.8 BB <,,<3;3478@025105 1<801! ((!()><,,0134 5;3,.2 +(!()9:8@0 2/58 2? 1138324<; 3,853.8 C 0,,324, <41 >0.3<; /1703=<:<>/5 ( 0<518@0;0<5401.2/4,0;?258@0><5830, - 3 - & 34 5360 2((!() D<, 5073,80501 9: ;60; 2;3.08<8324 3=<:<>/5 <7<34,8 8@0 <>>0;;<48 @05034 ?25 8@0 2??04.0, >/43,@<9;0 /4105 0.8324, ( ( !+ !) 2? 24 8@0 9<,3, 2? 8@0 ?35,8 34?256<8324 1<801 !! (!() 50.03A01 ?526 <;39< 2 <48<>>< 39@/83@<;;3 ,/9,0E/048 82 5073,85<8324 2? & 34=/501 <48<>>< @<1 1301 <41 0.8324 !( 2? D<, 34A2F01 <7<34,88@0<>>0;;<48/53478@0.2/5,02?34A0,837<8324 <>>0;;<48 @05034 D<, <550,801 24 ((!(!() <41 ,/9,0E/048;:506<410182=/13.3<;./,821:4A0,837<8324 2? 8@0 .<,0 3, .26>;0801 <41 .@<570 ,@008 3, 42D ?3;01 <7<34,8 >05,24, >>0;;<48 @05034 @<, <55<:01 <, <../,012 348@0.@<570,@008 3,9<3;<>>;3.<8324?3;01 90?250 8@0 /53,13.8324<; 0,,324, 2/58 34 5;3,.2 +(!() D<, 50=0.801 24 ! ((!() @050?250<>>0;;<483,90?2508@3, 2/58 ) 0<5401 .2/4,0; ?25 8@0 <>>0;;<48 ,/9638, 8@<8 <>>0;;<483,<?5/38A04125@<A34742.53634<;<480.01048, 0 D<, < 828<; ,85<4705 82 8@0 ?35,8 34?256<48 <41 @3, ?<8@05D@23,8@010.0<,01348@0>50,048.<,04.31048 - 4 - 34 E/0,8324 @<1 8<F04 >;<.0 <,<50,/;8 2? 52<15<70 <41 8@050 D<, 42 6283A0 25 348048324 82 .26638 8@0 .5360 4A0,837<83242?8@0.<,03,<;50<1:.26>;0801<41.@<570 ,@008@<,9004?3;01>>0;;<483,<6<553016<4@<A347 8@500 63425 .@3;1504 <41 @3, D3?0 3, 42D >5074<48 ..251347;:@0>5<:,82<;;2D8@0<>>0<; 05 .2485< ;0<5401 37@ 2/58 2A0546048 ;0<105 <41;0<5401.2/4,0;?2550,>2410482(@<A02>>2,018@0 >5<:056<10348@0<>>0<; 0<5401 .2/4,0; ?25 50,>241048 2( ,/9638, 8@<8 ?35,834?256<483,<40:0D3840,,828@034.3104834E/0,8324 <41 <>>0;;<48 @<, 9004 8@50<804347 @36 D38@ 1350 .24,0E/04.0,<418@0503,<8@50<8828@0?35,834?256<48 34.0 8@050 3, < 8@50<8 82 8@0 ?35,8 34?256<48 @0 >5<:, 8@<88@0<>>0<;6<:9013,63,,01 + 05/,<;2?8@0?35,834?256<8324,/96388019:8@0,242? 10.0<,01 D2/;1 72 82 ,@2D 8@<8 24 !! (!() D@04 8@0:D05085<A0;347348@0356282593F0?5268@02>>2,380 - 5 - 1350.8324 < >05,24 34 < 6282593F0 .<60 34 ?5248 2? 8@0 6282593F02?8@0?35,834?256<48<41@3,?<8@05*@048@0 ?35,834?256<48<41@3,?<8@05E/0,832401@36<,82D@:@0 952/7@8 @3, 6282593F0 34 ?5248 2? 8@035 6282593F0 <41 <,F01@36825310@3,62825.:.;0248@0,3102?8@052<1 @0<;;0701;:<9/,018@06<41<,,</;8018@0?35,834?256<48 D38@@3,@<41*@048@010.0<,01853018234805A040,<31 >05,24 0A04 <,,</;801 @36 D38@ @3, @<41 <41 8@050<?805 952/7@8<F43?0?526@3,6282593F0<41,8<990110.0<,01 <48<>><24@3,,826<.@66013<80;:8@050<?805.058<34 >05,24,.<608@050<418@0,<31>05,24D@2@<1,8<9901 <48<>><F0>8@3,F43?034@3,6282593F0<410,.<>01?526 8@0 ,>28 @050<?805 <48<>>< D<, <1638801 82 8@0 @2,>38<;<419<,01248@0?35,834?256<832450.03A01?526 @3, ,24 & D<, 34383<;;: 5073,80501 <7<34,8 8@0 <>>0;;<48 @05034 ?25 2??04.0, >/43,@<9;0 /4105 ,0.8324, ( ( !+ !) 2? 4 !! (!() <48<>>< D@2 D<, <1638801 82 8@0@2,>38<; @<11301<41 8@050<?805 2??04.0 >/43,@<9;0/41050.8324!(2? D<,34A2F01 - 6 - 4 8@0 >05/,<; 2? 8@0 <;;07<8324, ?2/41 34 8@0 ?35,8 34?256<8324 <, D0;; <, .@<570 ,@008 38 3, <>><5048 8@<8 <>>0;;<48<418@0A3.836D050,85<4705,<418@034.3104834 E/0,8324 @<1 8<F04 >;<.0 <, < 50,/;8 2? 52<1 5<70 @050?25038.<442890,<318@<8<>>0;;<48@<1<4:6283A0 2534804832482.266388@06/51052?10.0<,01<48<>>< 8 <>>0<5, 8@<8 34.31048 34 E/0,8324 @<1 8<F04 >;<.0 <8 < ,>/52?8@0626048<?8058@0><5830,@<1E/<550;01<7<34,8 0<.@28@05413,>/801;:<>>0;;<48@<,4228@05.53634<; <480.01048, 34A0,837<8324 2? 8@0 .<,0 3, .26>;0801 <41 .@<570 ,@008 @<, 9004 ?3;01 >>0;;<48 3, ,<31 82 90 < 6<55301 6<4 @<A347 8@500 63425 .@3;1504 <41 @3, D3?0 3, ,<31829042D>5074<48 B 4105 8@0 .35./6,8<4.0, <6 8@0 2>34324 8@<8 @3, >5<:05 ?25 75<48 2? 507/;<5 9<3; 4001, 82 90 <4,D0501 <??356<83A0;:..251347;:8@0?2;;2D347 @0.53634<;<>>0<;3,<;;2D01 - 7 - @0 25105 1<801 ! ((!() ><,,01 34 5;3,.2 +(!() >041347 24 8@0 ?3;0 2? 11; 3,853.8 C 0,,324, <41 >0.3<; /170 3=<:<>/5< 3, ,08 <,310 @0 <>>0;;<48 3, 1350.801 82 90 04;<5701 24 9<3; 34 5360 2((!() 2? ;60; 2;3.0 8<8324 3=<:<>/5 3,853.8?252??04.0,>/43,@<9;0/41050.8324,!+!) !( (!( ( ( 2? <41 0.8324, #(%#A% 2? 60416048 .8 (! >041347 24 8@0 ?3;0 2? 11; 3,853.8C0,,324,<41>0.3<;/1703=<:<>/5<,/9=0.8 828@0?2;;2D347.24138324, <%@0 <>>0;;<48 ,@<;; 0G0./80 >05,24<; 9241 ?25 < ,/6 2? , !!!!! D38@ 8D2 ,/50830, ?25 8@0 ;3F0,/6 82 8@0 ,<83,?<.8324 2? 8@0 =/53,13.8324<; 2/58H 9%@0 <>>0;;<48 ,@<;; <>>0<5 507/;<5;: 24 <;; 8@0 1<80,2?@0<534790?2508@053<; 2/58/4;0,,8@0 53<; 2/58 0G06>8, @3, <>>0<5<4.0 ?25 A<;31 50<,24,H - 8 - .% @0 <>>0;;<48 ,@<;; 428 1350.8;: 25 341350.8;: 8@50<804 25 8<6>05 D38@ 8@0 >52,0./8324 D3840,,0,H 1%@0<>>0;;<48,@<;;42834A2;A034,363;<52??04.0, 34?/8/50H 0%@0 <>>0;;<48 ,@<;; 428 ;0<A0 8@0 =/53,13.8324 2? 8@0 53<; 2/58 D38@2/8 >0563,,324 2? 8@0 ,<31 2/58 /483; 8@0 .<,0 5073,80501 <7<34,8 @36 3, 13,>2,012?? +( '$ %# * # 3,82 ;2