Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9048 (KAR)
SIDDALINGAYYA v. ALLA SAB AND ANR
WP/200231/2025 · 2025-01-27
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9048 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9048 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%""
&% '(
! "
#
$%
#&
! $
'
"
%
'
( ) ' ' %
'
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
' ' %
*
& +) && " % '
,
' % *
*
'
%
-
$
$
./ 012345366 34 7 && 74 5./ 631/ 76 /4378 3931 $:;</ 24; $' $/=28<3 3> ?/678/ 5.3> 7:85 @.211/4<34< 5./ @788/@54/>> 76 24 78;/8 ;25/; &##&& ?A =.3@. 5./ 0/535374/8 =2> @211/; :074 57 02A 5./ ;:5A 24; 0/4215A 2> 0/8 5./ 8/0785 8/@/39/; 687B 5./ 7663@/ 76 5./ 3>583@5
/<3>5828 ;25/; &&
./ >:35 34 7 && =2> 631/; 678 >0/@363@ 0/8678B24@/ 76 24 2<8//B/45 ;82=4 :0 74 2 >52B0 020/8 ;25/; ##&&#C ./ >:35 =2> @745/>5/; ?A 5./ ;/6/4;245 %./4 5./ >:35 =2> >/5;7=4 678 /93;/4@/ 5./ 012345366 =.7 =2> /D2B34/; 2> %# 08707>/; 57 B28E 5./ >21/ 2<8//B/45 7=/9/8 5./ B28E34< 76 5./ >23;
- 3 -
;7@:B/45 =2> 7007>/; @74>/F:/45 57 =.3@.
5./ @7:85 ./1; 087@//;34<> 24; 02>>/; 24 78;/8 ;25/; &#&& 3B07:4;34< 5./ ;7@:B/45 24; 678=28;34< 35 57 5./ 3>583@5 /<3>5828 678 @7B0:525374 76 >52B0 ;:5A 24; 0/4215A ./ 3>583@5
/<3>5828 2;;8/>>/; 2 @7BB:43@25374 ;25/;
&& 8/078534< 5.25 07>>/>>374 76 5./ 0870/85A =2> 475 ;/139/8/; :4;/8 5./ 2<8//B/45 24; 5.25 5./ 0/535374/8 =2> ?7:4; 57 02A 5./ >52B0 ;:5A :4;/8 853@1/ !/"!3" 76 5./ 284252E2 52B0 @5 #C) 24; 5./8/678/ ;/5/8B34/;
5./ >52B0 ;:5A 02A2?1/ 25 G 76 5./ @74>3;/825374 24;
8/F:38/; 5./ 0/535374/8 57 ;/07>35 )CC&& ?/34< 5./ ;/63@35 >52B0 ;:5A ./ 8321 7:85 5./8/265/8 @211/; :074 5./ 0/535374/8 57 02A 5./ >52B0 ;:5A 2> 0/8 5./ 8/0785 76 5./ 3>583@5
/<3>5828 /34< 2<<83/9/; ?A 5./ >2B/ 5./ 0/535374/8 3> ?/678/ 5.3> 7:85
/284/; @7:4>/1 678 5./ 0/535374/8 @745/4;> 5.25 5./ 07>>/>>374 76 5./ 0870/85A =2> 475 ;/139/8/; :4;/8 5./ 2<8//B/45 24; 5./8/678/ 5./ 0/535374/8 =2> ?7:4; 57 02A
- 4 -
>52B0 ;:5A 2> 08793;/; :4;/8 853@1/ !/"!33" 24; 475 :4;/8 853@1/ !/"!3" 76 284252E2 52B0 @5 #C) + ./ 1/284/; ;;3537421 79/84B/45 ;97@25/ 265/8 0/8:>34< 5./ 8/0785 76 5./ 3>583@5
/<3>5828 >:?B355/; 5.25 5./ 3>583@5
/<3>5828 .2> 8/F:38/; 5./ 0/535374/8 57 02A 5./ ;/63@35 >52B0 ;:5A :4;/8 853@1/ !/"!3" 76 5./ 284252E2 52B0 @5 #C) / 5./8/678/ >:?B35> 5.25 5./ 0/535374/8 =2> ?7:4; 57 @7B01A 24; 02A 5./ >52B0 ;:5A 2> 0/8 5./ 8/0785 76 5./ 3>583@5 /<3>5828
34@/ 5./ ;3>0:5/ 34 5.3> 0/535374 741A 8/125/> 57 02AB/45 76 ;/63@35 >52B0 ;:5A 5./ ;3>0:5/ 3>?/5=//4 5./ 0/535374/8 24; 5./ 8/>074;/45 7 24; ./4@/ 4753@/ 57 8/>074;/45 7# 3> 475 78;/8/; ( 0/8:>21 76 5./ 2<8//B/45 76 >21/ >.7=> 5.25 5./ 07>>/>>374 76 5./ 0870/85A =2> 475 ;/139/8/; :4;/8 5./ 2<8//B/45 ./ >21/ @74>3;/825374 =2> 2 >:B 76 #(&&&&& 7:5 76 =.3@.
#+&&&&& =2> 0:80785/;1A 023; 24; 5./ ?2124@/ &&&&& =2> 02A2?1/ 265/8 5./
- 5 -
8/>074;/45 7# 8/@/39/; 2 >.//5 ./8/678/ 5./ 0/535374/8 =2> ?7:4; 57 02A 5./ >52B0 ;:5A 2> 08793;/;
:4;/8 853@1/ !/"!33" 76 5./ 284252E2 52B0 @5 #C) 24; 475 :4;/8 853@1/ !/"!3" 76 5./ 284252E2 52B0 @5 #C) 34@/ 5./ 0/535374/8 =2> ?7:4; 57 02A 2 B2D3B:B >52B0 ;:5A 76 &&&& 5./ 8/0785 76 5./ 3>583@5 /<3>5828 8/F:3834< 5./ 0/535374/8 57 ;/07>35 &&&& 3> 5./8/678/ 475 0870/8 24; ./4@/ =288245> 345/86/8/4@/ ) 4 5.25 93/= 76 5./ B255/8 5.3> =835 0/535374 3> 2117=/; 34 0285 74>/F:/451A 5./ ;38/@5374 76 5./ 8321 7:85 57 02A >52B0 ;:5A 2> 0/8 5./ 8/0785 76 5./ 3>583@5 /<3>5828 3> >/5 2>3;/
./ 0/535374/8 3> ;38/@5/; 57 02A 2 B2D3B:B >52B0 ;:5A 76 &&&& 24; 2 >:B 76 &&& 2> 0/4215A ./ 2B7:45 218/2;A 023; 74 5./ >21/ 2<8//B/45 >.211 ?/ ;/;:@5/; =.31/ 02A34< 5./ ;/63@35 >52B0 ;:5A C .3> >.211 ?/ @7B013/; ?A 5./ 0/535374/8 =35.34 2 0/837; 76 74/ =//E 687B 5./ ;25/ 76 8/@/305 76 2 @70A 76 5.3> 78;/8 6 5./ >52B0 ;:5A 24; 0/4215A 2> B/45374/;
- 6 -
2?79/ 3> 023; 5./ 8321 7:85 >.211 B28E 5./ ;7@:B/45 24; 087@//; 34 2@@78;24@/ =35. 12= #& /284/; ;;3537421 79/84B/45 ;97@25/ 3> 0/8B355/; 57 631/ 2 B/B7 76 200/2824@/ 678 8/>074;/45 7 =35.34 5/4 ;2A>
)'
&"(
"
3>5 7 # 1 7