Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9045 (KAR)

SANJUKUMAR S/O KALLAPPA KUMBAR v. ASHOK AND ANR

MFA/200862/2019 · 2025-01-21

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! " "!#$# % $" $" ""&&' ( ) * !"#" $ % & ! " ! "#" '' "( '' $ % ' ) #"## " & LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.22 09:06:58 - 0800 - 2 - ' ' "*+ %"& ' ' ,, #" ' ' % & ' ""#"#"( ,, #" % & ' - #### ,. -"##### ". ' / $! % / & 01- 233425 1- 61547 89 :04 ;521<2=: 1= >,, #" 2--2151=? :04 @A7?<4=: 2=7 2B2C7 72:47 ""#"#"( 32--47 89 :04 542C=47 771:1>=25 2=7 771:1>=25 1-:C1;: 2=7 4--1>=- A7?4 172C %1::1=? 2: 025D1& - 3 - # 42C7 :04 542C=47 ;>A=-45 6>C :04 2334552=: 542C=47 ;>A=-45 6>C :04 C4-3>=74=: > #+ 04 32C:14- B155 84 C464CC47 2- 34C :041C C2=D- 846>C4 :04 C18A=25 # 04 8C146 62;:- >6 :04 ;2-4 2C4 :02: >= !"#" :04 34:1:1>=4C B2- C171=? 2- 2 31551>= C174C >= <>:>C;9;54 842C1=? 4?>+(*,#) 2: 28>A: +# 3< :04 C174C C>74 :04 -2<4 1= 2 C2-0 2=7 =4?51?4=: <2==4C 2=7 89 233591=? :04 8C2D4- -D17 >= :04 C>27 2=7 6455 7>B= B04C489 :04 34:1:1>=4C -A-:21=47 6C2;:AC4 >6 0427 >6 C271A- 2=7 71-5>;2:1>= 4 B2- -016:47 :> ?>E4C=<4=: >-31:25 2: 025D1 04C426:4C 04 :>>D :C42:<4=: 1= >:04C >-31:25 6>C <>C4 :02= "# 729- # 04 34:1:1>=4C B2- 7>1=? 8A-1=4-- >6 1C2=2 2=7 4=4C25 :>C4- 2=7 42C=1=? Rs.#### 34C <>=:0 04 34:1:1>=4C ;>=:4=747 :02: 04 B2- 2 8A-1=4--<2= CA==1=? 2 8A-1=4-- 2=7 04 02- -A664C47 34C<2=4=: 71-28151:9 2=7 :04C46>C4 04 1- 4=:1:547 6>C 274FA2:4 ;><34=-2:1>= - 4 - #, 04 34:1:1>= B2- >33>-47 89 :04 C4-3>=74=: > G 1=-AC2=;4 ;><32=9 >= :04 ?C>A=7 :02: :04 2;;174=: B2- 7A4 :> :04 =4?51?4=;4 >6 C174C >6 :04 <>:>C;9;54 04 2?4 >;;A32:1>= 2=7 1=;><4 >6 :04 34:1:1>=4C 1- 74=147 04 ;><34=-2:1>= ;521<47 1- 01?059 4H>C81:2=: 2=7 1<2?1=2C9 #* 04 C18A=25 6C2<47 :04 233C>3C12:4 1--A4- 2=7 :04 34:1:1>=4C B2- 4H2<1=47 2- " 2=7 7>;:>C B2- 4H2<1=47 2- H- " :> " B4C4 <2CD47 1= :04 4E174=;4 04 C4-3>=74=:- 717 =>: 5427 2=9 4E174=;4 8A: H" :> H+ B4C4 <2CD47 1= :04 4E174=;4 #! 6:4C 042C1=? 8>:0 :04 32C:14- :04 C18A=25 02- 2B2C747 ;><34=-2:1>= A=74C 71664C4=: 0427- 2- 845>B 5 > 427- ><34=-2:1>= B2C747 " >-- >6 6A:AC4 42C=1=?- -"### 471;25 H34=-4- -, ## + 21= 2=7 A664C1=? -#### >=E492=;4 2=7 ::4=72=: -" ### '>>7 2=7 >AC1-0<4=: -" ### , >-- >6 1=;><4 7AC1=? 5217 A3 34C1>7 -"+### >:25 -((## >A=747 >66 >:25 - #### - 5 - #( 04 542C=47 ;>A=-45 23342C1=? 6>C :04 34:1:1>=4C B>A57 -A8<1: :02: :04 C18A=25 02- 2--4--47 :04 71-28151:9 >= :04 5>B4C -174 2=7 => ;><34=-2:1>= 02- 844= 2B2C747 A=74C :04 0427 >6 5>-- >6 2<4=1:14- 1= 5164 4=;4 04 -44D- 6>C 4=02=;4<4=: >6 :04 ;><34=-2:1>= "# 4C ;>=:C2 :04 542C=47 ;>A=-45 23342C1=? 6>C :04 C4-3>=74=: > -A8<1:- :02: :04 ;><34=-2:1>= 2B2C747 89 :04 C18A=25 1- @A-: 2=7 3C>34C 04C4 1- => =447 6>C 4=02=;4<4=: >6 ;><34=-2:1>= "" 04 34CA-25 >6 :04 C4;>C7- B>A57 -0>B :02: :04 34:1:1>=4C ;521<- :> 84 7>1=? 2 1C2=2 8A-1=4-- 2=7 42C=1=? Rs.#### 34C <>=:0 : 1- B>C:0 :> =>:4 :02: B04= 2 34C->= 1= 1C2=2 8A-1=4-- 027 -A664C47 :04 6C2;:AC4 >6 :04 458>B :04C4 ;2==>: 84 2=9 7>A8: :02: -A;0 1=@AC9 B>A57 C4-A5: 1= 34C<2=4=: 71-28151:9 04 <471;25 >661;4C 02- -:2:47 :02: :04 71-28151:9 :> :04 51<8 1- +. 04 C18A=25 2--4--47 :04 6A=;:1>=25 71-28151:9 2: "#. = :04 ;>=-174C47 >31=1>= >6 :01- >AC: :04 -217 71-28151:9 ;2==>: 84 1=:4C64C47 B1:0 B01;0 1- -51?0:59 <>C4 :02= " +C7 >6 :04 71-28151:9 >6 :04 51<8 >B4E4C :04 C18A=25 02- 2 ;>=-174C47 :04 =>:1>=25 1=;><4 2: Rs.,### 34C <>=:0 - 6 - " 04 ?A17451=4- 1--A47 89 :04 6>C -4::54<4=: >6 71-3A:4- 846>C4 >D7252:0 3C4-;C1847 2 =>:1>=25 1=;><4 >6 -* ## 34C <>=:0 6>C :04 942C #" = A<3:44= =A<84C >6 @A7?<4=:- :01- >AC: 02- 0457 :02: :04 ?A17451=4- 1--A47 89 :04 2C4 1= ?4=4C25 ;>=6>C<1:9 B1:0 :04 B2?4- 61H47 A=74C :04 1=1<A< 2?4- ;: 04C46>C4 :049 2C4 2;;43:2854 4=;4 :04 =>:1>=25 1=;><4 >6 :04 34:1:1>=4C 1- ;>=-174C47 2: -* ## 04C46>C4 :04 5>-- >6 6A:AC4 1=;><4 1- ;25;A52:47 2- Rs.* ## H " H "! H "#. I Rs.",### 89 :2D1=? 2 <A5:13514C >6 "! 6>C :04 2?4 >6 942C- "+ >=-4FA4=:59 :04 ;><34=-2:1>= A=74C :04 0427 >6 02- :> 84 4=02=;47 :> - ## :C42:1=? -A;0 5217 A3 34C1>7 2- #+ <>=:0- " 04 C18A=25 02- =>: 2B2C747 2=9 ;><34=-2:1>= A=74C :04 0427 >6 2=7 :04 -2<4 1- 2--4--47 89 :01- >AC: 2: - ### - 7 - " 04 C18A=25 02- 2B2C747 C42->=2854 ;><34=-2:1>= 2<>A=: :>B2C7- 04 -2<4 =447 =>: 84 71-:AC847 ", 04C46>C4 :04 ;521<2=: 1- 4=:1:547 6>C :>:25 4=02=;47 ;><34=-2:1>= >6 - ,### A=74C :04 6>55>B1=? 0427- 5 > 427- ><34=-2:1>= B2C747 89 :01- >AC: " >-- >6 6A:AC4 1=;><4 -",### >-- >6 1=;><4 7AC1=? :C42:<4=: 34C1>7 - ## + >-- >6 2<4=1:14- - ### 471;25 4H34=-4- -, ## 21= 2=7 -A664C1=? -#### , >=E492=;4 2=7 2::4=72=: -" ### * '>>7 2=7 >AC1-0<4=: -" ### >:25 4-- B2C747 89 :04 C18A=25 -+#,### - #### >:25 4=02=;4<4=: - ,### "* 4=;4 233425 74-4CE4- :> 84 255>B47 1= 32C: 04C46>C4 :04 6>55>B1=?) - 8 - ! 04 233425 1- 255>B47 1= 32C: 04 2334552=: 1- 4=:1:547 6>C 2 -A< >6 - ,### 1= 2771:1>= :> B02: 02- 844= 2B2C747 89 :04 C18A=25 25>=? B1:0 1=:4C4-: 2: :04 C2:4 >6 ,. 32 6C>< 72:4 >6 34:1:1>= :155 :04 72:4 >6 743>-1: 4-: >6 :04 >C74C 32--47 89 :04 C18A=25 C4?2C71=? 743>-1: 4:; C4<21= A=25:4C47 7 ' $" ) $! 1-: > " 5 > !