- 1 - ! "#$ %# " &'()&*+,'-(&++ % ! ! "#$#%&' ! ! ($ ! %%' )&)( " ! !! (*$ Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &)&( )&% (( ! ! !! ! + ,,-./0 1% 23 425/ 1%%' )&)( 4/62.7/4/0 89 -8" 48:3 1;2,/ 7:7213 :;8-4:62 <14 7=/ 1<</3,/. >-32.=:8;/ -30/4(*$&)&(%(*1<:30/,7213?(1<1@49 41=2827213,7%*A%2.8/<14/7=2.1-47.//B2364/6-;:48:2; -30/4/,7213($1<)&) ) /:407=/;/:43/0,1-3./;<147=/>:472/. !23425/1#) )&)(@:.4/62.7/4/023272:;;989 7=/:5:;:>-41;2,/7:7213<147=/1<</3,/.>-32.=:8;/-30/4 /,7213(*$%(%('%($&)&(4/:0@27=%(*1< :30/,7213:30(1<1@4941=2827213,7%*A%:6:23.77=/ >/727213/4:30.2C17=/4.137=/8:.2.1<<24.723<145:72130:7/0 )&&#)&)( 4/,/2D/0 <415 7=/ <:7=/4 1< 0/,/:./0 5:.=4// =/4/:<7/4<14@:371<E-42.02,72137=/.:20!@:.74:3.</44/0 71 7=/ -8"-48:3 1;2,/ 7:7213 :;8-4:62 :30 4/62.7/4/0 23 425/ 1%%' )&)( <14 7=/ :<14/.:20 1<</3,/. -4236 7=/ - 3 - ,1-4./ 1< 23D/.726:7213 >/727213/4 =/4/23 @:. :44/.7/0 13 ))&#)&)(3D/.726:72131<7=/,:./2.,15>;/7/0:30,=:46/ .=//7=:.8//3<2;/0:6:23.77=/>/727213/4:307@117=/4.<14 7=/:<14/.:201<</3,/.:2;:>>;2,:7213<2;/0897=/>/727213/4 8/<14/ 7=/ -42.02,7213:; /..213. 1-47 23 4; 2., 1%(%* )&)( @:. 4/E/,7/0 13 &*&*)&)( =/4/<14/=/ 2. 8/<14/7=2.1-47 ( /:43/0 ,1-3./; <14 7=/ >/727213/4 .-8527. 7=:7 >/727213/4@=1=:.3117=/4,42523:;:37/,/0/37.2.23,-.7109 <147=/;:.7514/7=:3/26=75137=.3D/.726:72131<7=/,:./ 2. ,15>;/7/0 :30 ,=:46/ .=//7 =:. 8//3 <2;/0 8-7 7=/ >1.75147/5 4/>147 1< 7=/ 0/,/:./0 01/. 317 .->>147 7=/ ,=:46/ .=//7 :;;/6:7213. / :,,140236;9 >4:9. 71 :;;1@ 7=/ >/727213 # /4,1374:;/:43/0=:.1>>1./07=/>/727213 A 3 7=/ ,=:46/ .=//7 @=2,= 2. <2;/0 :6:23.7 7=/ >/727213/4:307@117=/4.272.:;;/6/07=:7:<7/45:442:6/7=/ 0/,/:./0 @:. 2;;"74/:7/0 23 =/4 5:7425132:; =1-./ 23 <-47=/4:3,/ 1< 0/5:30 <14 84236236 :0027213:; 01@49 =/ 0/,/:./07=/4/<14/=:0;/<77=/,15>:391<=/4=-.8:30:30 - 4 - =:0 7:B/3 .=/;7/4 23 =/4 >:4/37. =1-./ 3 %#&#)&)( 7=/ >/727213/4 =:0 613/ 71 7=/ =1-./ 1< >:4/37. 1< 0/,/:./0 5:.=4// :30 :<7/4 :..-4236 71 ;11B :<7/4 7=/ 0/,/:./0 >41>/4;9=/=:0841-6=7=/4:;136@27==2.0:-6=7/4::3D271 =2. =1-./ 3 %*&#)&)( @=/3 >/727213/4 4/7-43/0 =15/ :<7/4 ,15>;/7236 =2. @14B 23 : =17/; =/ <1-30 7=/ 0/,/:./0 F-:44/;236@27=:,,-./01.):30@=1:4/=2.8417=/4:30 .2.7/423;:@4/.>/,72D/;9-8./F-/37;9:,,-./01.%71 :;;/6/0;9,13.>24/071,155277=/5-40/41<5:.=4//:3013 7=/326=71<%*&#)&)(7=/9:;;/6/0;9:..:-;7/07=/0/,/:./0 @27=@110/3,;-8.:30,155277/0=/45-40/4 =/4/:<7/47=/ <24.723<145:37%@:.23<145/01D/4>=13/7=:7=2.0:-6=7/4 @:.317@/;;:30137=//:4;9=1-4.1<)&&#)&)(7=/:,,-./0 1%:;136@27=)#711B7=/0/:081091<5:.=4//23:,:4 71 7=/ =1-./ 1< 7=/ <24.7 23<145:37 :30 23<145/0 =25 7=:7 5:.=4//2.317@/;;55/02:7/;97=/4/:<7/4%.-5513/0 4:4:.25=:G))@=10/,;:4/07=:75:.=4//@:.0/:0 72.237=2.8:,B641-30!@:.23272:;;94/62.7/4/0:6:23.77=/ >/727213/4:30.2C17=/4. ' =/23D/.726:72131<7=/,:./2.31@,15>;/7/0:30 7=/,=:46/.=//7=:.8//3<2;/0/727213/4@=1=:.3117=/4 - 5 - ,42523:;:37/,/0/372.23,-.7109<147=/;:.7514/7=:3/26=7 5137=. =/ /3724/ ,:./ 1< 7=/ >41./,-7213 2. 8:./0 13 ,24,-5.7:3,/. =/>1.75147/54/>1471<7=/0/,/:./0@1-;0 6171.=1@7=:7.=/=:0.-<</4/0:.5:39:.7@/37923E-42/.13 =/48109 =/1>232131<7=/01,714<147=/,:-./1<0/:7=1< 0/,/:./02.5/37213/0:.0/:7=2.0-/71H.>=9C2::.:4/.-;7 1< :.>24:7213 1< <110 >:472,;/. :..1,2:7/0 @27= /5144=:62, .=1,BI =/4/<14/:.>/4>1.75147/54/>1477=/0/:7=2.317 :024/,74/.-;71<7=/:..:-;75:0/897=/:,,-./013.20/4236 7=/ :<14/.:20 :.>/,7. :30 :;.1 =:D236 4/6:40 71 7=/ <:,7 7=:7 7=/ ,:./ 1< 7=/ >41./,-7213 2. 8:./0 13 7=/ ,24,-5.7:372:; /D20/3,/:51<7=/1>232137=:77=/>/727213/4=:.5:0/1-7 >425: <:,2/ ,:./ <14 64:37 1< 4/6-;:4 8:2; ,,140236;9 7=/ <1;;1@236140/4 $ =/>/7272132.:;;1@/0 =/>/727213/42.024/,7/071 8/ /3;:46/0 13 8:2; 23 425/ 1%%' )&)( 1< -8 G 48:3 1;2,/ 7:7213 :;8-4:62 02.742,7 4/62.7/4/0 <14 7=/ 1<</3,/. >-32.=:8;/ -30/4 /,7213. (*$ &) &( %(* 1< :30 /,7213 ? ( 1< 1@49 41=2827213 ,7 %*A% .-8E/,7 71 7=/ <1;;1@236,13027213. - 6 - : =/ >/727213/4 .=:;; /C/,-7/ >/4.13:;8130 <14 : .-5 1< .%&&&&& " @27= 7@1 .-4/72/. <14 7=/ ;2B/.-5 71 7=/ .:72.<:,7213 1< 7=/ E-42.02,7213:; 1-47J 8 =/ >/727213/4 .=:;; :>>/:4 4/6-;:4;9 13 :;; 7=/0:7/.1<=/:42368/<14/7=/ 42:;1-47-3;/.. 7=/ 42:; 1-47 /C/5>7. =2. :>>/:4:3,/ <14 D:;20 4/:.13.J , =/ >/727213/4 .=:;; 317 024/,7;9 14 23024/,7;9 7=4/:7/3147:5>/4@27=7=/>41./,-7213@273/../.J 0 =/ >/727213/4 .=:;; 317 23D1;D/ 23 .252;:4 1<</3,/.23<-7-4/J / =/>/727213/4.=:;;317;/:D/7=/E-42.02,72131< 7=/ 42:;1-47@27=1-7>/452..2131<7=/.:201-47 -372;7=/,:./4/62.7/4/0:6:23.7=252.02.>1./01<< ., &$ %# + # 2.71%;1$