Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9027 (KAR)

SHRISHAIL v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

WP/200163/2025 · 2025-01-20

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!# $%" " & ' !!"# $ ##%% !# %% &&&!# "# # !&!# '# # !&!# # (# # !&!# # Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - (## !&!# # (## !&!# )# #%* % ' (# # !&!# # #+* % '& (# # !&!# ,# #+* '& (# # !&!# !&# #*** % (# # !&!# !!# #* % (# # !&!# !"# #%* '& (# # # !&!# !'# # (# # # !&!# - 3 - !# # * " (# # !&!# !# # -" (# # !&!# ! # # %% ' (# # !&!# !)# # * ', (# # !&!# !# # % % ') (# # !&!# !,# # % '& (# # !&!# $ #%% ! '. "&#&!#"&" *. "&#&!#"&"#% % ) !, * "" "") - 4 - * ( &'#&!#"&" #'+ * ( ( #) !,&!&!"&"+ * /## 01213434561781469301271:4;1635<7=> =6?0=@=3 =>8=94 4: 81<571 304: 5A73 ?0=BB169469 301 ?5771?361:: 5< 301 6534?1 ;=31; &'#&!#"&" 4::A1; 8@ 71:256;163 5#' 27525:469 35 05B; 301 >113469 5< 301 >1>817: 5< 301 2=6?0=@=3 56 "!#&!#"&" 35 ?56:4;17 = >534565<65?56<4;16?1# "# 012134345617?56316;:30=3:01C=:1B1?31;=: = 71:4;1635<301 =6?0=@=3=6;C=:;4:?0=7946904:;A3@ 35301:=34:<=?34565<=BB301>1>817:#*01630469::355; 30A: 301 >1>817: >5D1; =6534?1 5< E5 ?56<4;16?1F 56 &#!!#"&" C04?0 C=: GA1:34561; 46 C743 21343456 5#"&'',"&"# 04: 5A73 46 317>: 5< 301 57;17 ;=31; - 5 - & #!"#"&" =BB5C1; 301 C743 21343456 =6; GA=:01; 301 6534?1 5< 301 >113469 5< 301 >1>817: 35 ?56:4;17 301 >53456 5< 65 ?56<4;16?1# 1 ?56316;: 30=3 46 301 71271:163=3456 :A8>4331; 8@ 301 >1>817: 46 57> 5#! 3016=>15<5615<301>1>817:C=::05C6=:>3#=H>4 0=6;7=:01I0=7=?0=;=;#=317=65301771271:163=3456 C=::A8>4331;8@301>1>817:56&!#&!#"&"C0171301 6=>1 5< >3#=H>4 =JA =?0=;=; C=: <5A6;# 5C1D17 30171:256;1635#'C4305A3:=34:<@469301?5771?36=>1 5<301>1>817?=:A=BB@4::A1;=6534?1A6;17AB1'"5< %=76=3=I= =6?0=@=3=J534565<65?56<4;16?1=9=46:3 ;0@=I:0= =6; 2=;0@=I:0= 5< 7=> =6?0@=30 AB1: !,, 27525:469 35 05B; = >113469 5< 301 >1>817: 56 "!#&!#"&"# 01 2134345617 4: 30171<571 81<571 304: 5A73 ?0=BB169469301:=4;6534?1# '# 01B1=761;?5A6:1B<573012134345617:A8>4331; 30=35615<301>1>817:=6;53017:0=;1=7B417:A8>4331; =71271:163=34564657>5#!C01710176=>1C=::05C6 =: >3#=H>4 =J:01I0=7 =?0=;=;# 5C1D17 46 301 - 6 - 71271:163=3456560=6;0176=>14::05C6=:>3#=H>4 =JA =?0=;=;# 0171<571 :01 ?56316;: 30=3 301 71271:163=3456 4: <4B1; 46 = ?=:A=B >=6617 =6; 301 71:256;1635#'0=:6531H216;1;34>135D174<@C013017 301 217:56: C05 :A8>4331; 301 71271:163=3456 0=; 916A461B@:A8>4331;43#0171<571:01?56316;:30=3301 275?1;A71 <5BB5C1; 8@ 301 71:256;163 5#' 4: C05BB@ 477=3456=B=6;46=?=:A=B>=6617# # 17?5637=3011=761;;;43456=B5D176>163 ;D5?=31 :A8>4331; 30=3 301 217:56 C05 :A8>4331; 301 71271:163=3456 =B569 C430 53017: ?=7741; 301 6=>1 5< >3#=H>4=JA=?0=;=;#1?56316;:30=3463011=7B417 71271:163=3456 017 6=>1 C=: :05C6 =: >3#=H>4 =J:01I0=7=?0=;=;#130171<571:A8>43:30=3301:=4; 217:564:561=6;301:=>1217:56=6;30121343456170=: 653;4:2A31;30=3301:=4;>3#=H>4C=:=>1>8175<301 =6?0=@=3#0171<57101?56316;:30=31D164<301714:= >4:3=I146>1634564690176=>1 30=3 ;51: 653 =<<1?3 301 275?11;469:46=6@>=6617C0=3:51D17# - 7 - # 01B1=761;?5A6:1B74#=61:0=4I=221=7469 <57301274D=3171:256;163::A8>4331;30=3=B569C430301 71271:163=34564657>5!301>1>817:0=;<A764:01; 30147 =;0=7 ?=7; =6; 1B1?31; >1>817 ?1734<4?=31# 0171<571 01 ?56316;: 30=3 30171 4: 65 ;4:2A31 30=3 301 217:56: C05 0=; :A8>4331; 301 71271:163=3456 C171 =BB >1>817:5<301 =6?0=@=3# # 0=D1 ?56:4;171; 301 :A8>4::456: 5< 301 B1=761;?5A6:1B<573012134345617=6;301B1=761;?5A6:1B <57274D=3171:256;163: =: C1BB=: 3011=761; ;;43456=B 5D176>163;D5?=31# )# 46?130156B@?5631634567=4:1;8@301B1=761; ?5A6:1B <57 301 2134345617 C=: 30=3 301 71:256;163 5#' ;4; 653 =:?173=46 301 6=>1: =6; 301 217:56: C05 0=; :4961;30171271:163=3456=217A:=B5<30171271:163=3456 ;=31; &!#&!#"&" :05C: 30=3 301 71271:163=3456 C=: 71?14D1; 8@ 301 71:256;163 5#'# 3 =B:5 :05C: 30=3 301 217:56: C05 0=; :A8>4331; 301 71271:163=3456: 0=; <A764:01;30147=;0=7?=7;6A>817:=6;1B1?31;>1>817 - 8 - ?1734<4?=31:4::A1;8@301713A764695<<4?17#0171<5711D16 4< 43 4: =::A>1; 30=3 6=>1 5< >3#=H>4 C=: C7569B@ >1634561; =: >3#=H>4 =JA =?0=;=; 30=3 ;4; 653 46 =6@C=@>=3174=BB@=<<1?3301275?11;469:5<301>113469# 0171<5713014>2A961;6534?14::A1;8@30171:256;163 5#'?=66538101B;3581;1<1?34D1# # 6;17 301 ?47?A>:3=6?1: 301 21343456 B=?I: >1743=6;4:# () &"' " 4:35#"B5#"