Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9023 (KAR)
HDFC ERGO GEN. INS. CO. LTD v. ZAIBUNNISA AND ORS
MFA/200048/2020 · 2025-01-27
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9023 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9023 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#"
$
#
# %%&'( '
! "
! # $
%
& &
'
% &'
&
! % ('%'
)
*##
+ %
,
! ##( ! LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.30 11:08:34 - 0800
- 2 -
% ! ) #+' ! # '( #
!##
"
! #-'. ! +. !! +# /
)
#'#
#%'#
!)
/
) ! & & 0)
)
# & 0)
)
1 234 5678472 69 :623 234 56;784< 234 =>224? @8 2>A47 ;B 96? 9@7>< C@8B68>< 236;D3 @2 @8 8<>24C 96? >C=@88@67
- 3 -
3@8 >BB4>< @8 C@?4524C >D>@782 234 E;CD=472 >7C >F>?C C>24C #'# B>884C @7 6#%'# :1 234<4>?74CCC<
47@6?@G@<);CD4>7C6==@88@674? 96? =B<6144/8 6=B478>2@67 ><>:;?>D@ 34?4@7>924? ?494??4C26>8H /96?836?2 ' 1 234 @=B;D74C E;CD=472 234 6==@88@674? 3>8 >F>?C4C >8;=69 8*##'% >8 56=B478>2@6726 234 B42@2@674?8 26D4234? F@23 @724?482 >2 #'I B> >7C C@?4524C23478;?>7546=B>71?48B67C472 6'234?4@7 26 C4B68@2 234 8>=4 4@7D >DD?@4G4C :1 234 8>=4 234 78;?>7546=B>71@8:496?423@86;?2@7>BB4>< + 4>?C 234 <4>?74C 56;784< >BB4>?@7D 96? 234 >BB4<<>72 >7C 234 <4>?74C 56;784< >BB4>?@7D 96? 234 ?48B67C4728
4>?74C56;784< 96? 234>BB4<<>72 8;:=@2823>2 234C454>84C4=B<6144F>8F6?A@7D;7C4?234?48B67C472
6%8
6<>B;?@674?D1
1824=8G22C348>@C %8
6<>B;? @6 74?D1
1824=8 G2 2C 3>C 47D>D4C ?48B67C472 6+ %8 <@J@? 7D@744?@7D G2 2C >8 >
- 4 -
5672?>526? 34 >BB4<<>72 78;?>754 6=B>71 3>C 4724?4C @726 5672?>52;>< 6:<@D>2@678 ;7C4? 234 B6<@51 F@23 ?48B67C472 6+ %8 <@J@? 7D@744?@7D G2 2C 34?496?4 234 >BB4<<>72 @8 762 <@>:<4 26 B>1 234 56=B478>2@67 6F4G4? 23@8 >8B452 @8 56G4?4C :1 > E;CD=472 69 234 B4J 6;?2 @7 234 5>84 69
F34?4@7@2@834<C23>2@9 234 5672?>526? @8 > =4?4 5>=6;9<>D4 234 B?@75@B>< 4=B<614? @8 <@>:<4 7 234 5>84 67 3>7C %8 <@J@? 7D@744?@7DG22CF>8762>=4?45>=6;9<>D4
34 84567C >8B452 567247C4C @8 >:6;2 234 >=6;72B>@C:1?48B67C472 6262345<>@=>728 67 >556;72 69 C4>23 69 234 4=B<6144 :G@6;8<1 >7 B>1=472:1?48B67C472 6C676256=4F@23@7 234 5672?>52;>< 6:<@D>2@678 69 ?48B67C472 6+ F@23 234 >BB4<<>72 34?496?4 23@8 5672472@67 5>7762 :4 > 8;:82>72@><K;482@6769<>F
1 '#(
#
- 5 -
34 23@?C >8B452 @8 F4>234? 234 >BB4<<>72 @8 <@>:<4 26 B>1 234 @724?482 >8 B4? 234 B?6G@8@678 69 234 =B<6144/8 6=B478>2@67 52 #'+L 3@8 >8B452 @8 ><86 56G4?4C :1 > E;CD=472 69 234 B4J 6;?2 @7 234 5>84 69
! " #
"$ % ( 34?496?4 :1 96<<6F@7D 234 E;CD=472 @7 234 5>84 69 ! " #
" $ 234 >BB4<<>72 @8 762 <@>:<4 26 B>1 234 @724?482 B>?2 69 234 56=B478>2@67 >=6;72 C424?=@74C :1 234 <4>?74C 6==@88@674?
3;8 26 23>2 4J2472 234 >BB4>< C484?G48 26:4><<6F4C * 4754 234>BB4>< @8 & >7C 234 @=B;D74C E;CD=472 >7C >F>?C @8 =6C@9@4C :1 9>8247@7D 234 @724?482 B6?2@67 67 ?48B67C472 6+ %8 <@J@? 7D@744?@7DG22CBB4><@8C@8B684C699>556?C@7D<1
2 '
#'
- 6 -
34 >=6;72 @7 C4B68@2 :496?4 23@8 6;?2 @8 6?C4?4C26:42?>78=@224C26234?@:;7><
C% &
# ( #
@82 6&#
< 6&