- 1 - ! "# !$ %! # &'(&)*+'&** % ! ! ! " # $ $ # % ! " # &'# "&# $" ((& # Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ # ## &" )& (" *"# (( # ! ++# # $ ,+ ! $+ ,+ ! $+ " --./01 23 42*0 5 ((& 4062/70401 89 :;:8.4:62 279 $5*03 5;2-0 7:7253 :;:8.4:62 -279 <54 7=05<<03-0/>.32/=:8;0.3104 0-7253/ &")& (" *"5< =:4:729:9:9: :3=27:(( <54/=547?7=0 ((@"2/ 80<540 7=2/ 5.47 .3104 0-7253 &' 5< 4 & 5< =:4:729::6:42A: .4:A/=: :3=27:((/00A236406.;:4 8:2; ( 0:417=0;0:4301-5.3/0;<547=0>:4720/ # 23 42*0 5 ((& B:/ 4062/70401 89 :;:8.4:62 279 $5*03 5;2-0 7:7253 :;:8.4:62 -279 :6:23/77=0>072725304=04023<547=0:<540/:215<<03-0/537=0 - 3 - 8:/2/5<7=0<24/723<54*:72531:701((((&40-02C01<45* 7=0 C2-72*;:19 :601 :85.7 ( 90:4/ .4236 7=0 -5.4/0 5< 23C0/726:72535<7=0-:/07=0>072725304=04023B:/:440/701 53 ((((& =0 8:2; :>>;2-:7253 <2;01 89 =2* 80<540 7=0 D.42/12-7253:;5.47234;2/-5 ((B:/40D0-70153 ((:317=040<540=02/80<5407=2/5.47 & # 2342*05 ((&=:/80034062/7040189 :;:8.4:62 279 $5*03 5;2-0 7:7253 :;:8.4:62 -279 <54 7=0:<540/:215<<03-0/:6:23/77=0>072725304537=08:/2/5< 7=0 <24/7 23<54*:7253 1:701 ((((& /.8*27701 89 7=0 C2-72*;:19:601:85.7(90:4/ 37=0<24/723<54*:7253272/ /7:7017=:7/=02/*:44201755304:DA.*:4:31<45*7=0 B01;5-A /=0 =:/ 657 7B5 -=2;1403 #54 7=0 ;:/7 <2C0 90:4/ /=02//7:9236/0>:4:70;9<45*=04=./8:31 =0=:1653075 :;:8.4:62 279 $5*03 5;2-0 7:7253 :85.7 ) *537=/ >4254757=0;5162365<7=0# :/:B2730//23:=530974:> -:/0 =0 >072725304 =04023 B=5 2/ : >5;2-0 -53/7:8;0 B:/ >40/037237=0>5;2-0/7:7253:31=0=:1-5;;0-701=04>=530 3.*804 :31 7=040:<704 =0 /7:4701 -:;;236 =04 0 :;;0601;9 23<54*01=047=:7=0B:/23;5C0B27==04:31=023703101 - 4 - 75;0:1=2/;2<0B27==04=0>072725304:;;0601;9-:*0757=0 =5./05<7=0C2-72*;:19:31=:1/0E.:;23704-5.4/0B27==04 :6:23/7=04B2/=B27=:3://.4:3-075*:449=04=2/:-75< =2/B:/8023640>0:701:3123/>2705<7=0C2-72*;:19:/A236 =2* 75 *:449 =04 =0 B:/ 0C:1236 7=0 /:21 40F.0/7 =040:<7047=0C2-72*;:19:;536B27==04-=2;1403:;;0601;9 /7:4701 40/21236 23 7=0 =5./0 5< 7=0 >072725304 :31 7=0 >072725304=:1/0E.:;23704-5.4/0B27=7=0C2-72*;:190C0323 =2/ =5./0 .8/0F.037;9 =0 755A =04 75 : ;5160 53 (((&:31=:1/0E.:;23704-5.4/0B27==04=040:<704 =0755A=0475=2/<42031@/=5./0:31=:1/0E.:;23704-5.4/0 B27= =04 =0 C2-72* =:/ /7:701 7=:7 53 ((& :<704 /=0 =:1 F.:440;01 B27= 7=0 >072725304 /=0 =:1 -53/.*01 >52/53:31B:/:1*27701237=0=5/>27:;3((&/=0 B:/ 12/-=:4601 <45* 7=0 =5/>27:; :31 53 (&((& 7=0 >072725304 =:1 7:A03 =04 <45* :;:8.4:62 75 036:;.4. :31 ;0<7 =04 23 : ;5160 23 0;:*:36:;: :7 036:;.4. :31 7=040:<704 =2/ *582;0 >=530 B:/ /B27-=01 5<< 7 2/ 23 7=2/ 8:-A645.31/=0=:1:>>45:-=017=0>5;2-053((((& - 5 - #45* 7=0 40:1236 5< 7=0 <24/7 23<54*:7253 27 2/ :>>:4037 7=:7 7=0 >072725304 :31 7=0 C2-72*;:19 :40 857= *:44201>04/53/ 37=0<24/723<54*:72537=0C2-72*;:19=:/ /7:701 7=:7 /=0 2/ /7:9236 :B:9 <45* =04 =./8:31 <54 7=0 ;:/7 <2C0 90:4/ :31 27 :>>0:4/ 7=:7 7=040:<704 /=0 657 :-F.:23701 B27= 7=0 >072725304 :31 7=09 =:1 : -53/03/.:; /0E.:;40;:7253/=2>=0:;;06:7253237=0<24/723<54*:72532/ 7=:7 7=0 >072725304 B=5 =:1 >45*2/01 75 *:449 7=0C2-72* ;:19 =:1 /.8/0F.037;9 40<./01 <54 7=0 /:*0 =0 <:-7 40*:23/ 7=:7 7=0 >072725304 :/ B0;; :/ 7=0 C2-72*;:19 857= :40 *:44201 >04/53/ :31 7=024 *:442:60 2/ /72;; /.8/2/7236 =0 >072725304 B=5 2/ : >5;2-0 -53/7:8;0 2/ 23 7=0 -./7519 <45* ((((& =0 *:D54 >547253 5< 7=0 23C0/726:7253 2/ :;40:19 -5*>;0701 3104 7=0 -24-.*/7:3-0/ :* 5< 7=0 5>232537=:77=0>4:904*:10897=0>072725304<5464:375< 406.;:48:2;3001/7580:3/B0401:<<24*:72C0;9--541236;9 7=0<5;;5B23654104 =0>07272532/:;;5B01 - 6 - =0 >072725304 2/ 1240-701 75 80 03;:4601 53 8:2; 23 42*0 5 ((& 5< :;:8.4:62 279 $5*03 5;2-0 7:7253 :;:8.4:62 -279 4062/70401 <54 7=0 5<<03-0/ >.32/=:8;0 .3104 0-7253/ &" )& (" *" 5< =:4:729: 9:9: :3=27: (( >031236 80<540 7=0 5.47 5< 1127253:; 2C2; +.160 +4 3" :31 +# .;:8:46: /.8D0-7757=0<5;;5B236-53127253/ :"=0>072725304/=:;;0E0-.70>04/53:;8531<54: /.* 5< / B27= 7B5 /.40720/ <54 7=0 ;2A0/.* 75 7=0 /:72/<:-7253 5< 7=0 D.42/12-7253:; 5.47G 8"=0 >072725304 /=:;; :>>0:4 406.;:4;9 53 :;; 7=0 1:70/5<=0:423680<5407=042:;5.47.3;0//7=0 42:; 5.47 0E0*>7/ =2/ :>>0:4:3-0 <54 C:;21 40:/53/G -" =0 >072725304 /=:;; 357 1240-7;9 54 231240-7;9 7=40:703 54 7:*>04 B27= 7=0 >45/0-.7253 B2730//0/G 1"=0 >072725304 /=:;; 357 23C5;C0 23 /2*2;:4 5<<03-0/23<.7.40G - 7 - 0"=0 >072725304 /=:;; 357 ;0:C0 7=0 D.42/12-7253 5< 7=0 42:; 5.47 B27=5.7 >04*2//253 5< 7=0 /:21 5.47 .372; 7=0 -:/0 4062/70401 :6:23/7 =2* 2/ 12/>5/015<< ,+ &$ %! * ! ! 2/75 ;5%