Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 8998 (KAR)
SHARADA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WP/200146/2025 · 2025-01-17
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8998 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8998 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#"
$%#!#
& '
!"#$%
&
%%
#%
% '
%%
()))#%
*%
(!")#%
+%
(!"#$%
"% '
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
+
!"#$%
%
+"
(!"#$%
%
! (!"#$%
$%
+
(!"#$%
!%
'
"$
(!"#$%
,%
+
(!"#$%
#)% ' +
(!"#$%
- 3 -
##%
"$
(!"#$%
#*% ' - ++
(!"#$%
#+% ' +! (!"#$%
#"% +$
(!"#$%
#% ' - # %
(!"#$%
#%
")
(!"#$%
#$%
"! (!"#$%
#!% ' '
"
(!"#$%
#,% ' #
- 4 -
(!"#$%
*)%
"! %
(!"#$
*#% ' *,
(!"#$%
**% ' +
(!"#$%
*+% +
(!"#$%
&
%% #*
**
* % (+!)#)#(*)* )+%)#%*)* -( %
- 5 -
.'%'
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
- 6 -
3BB03:01A076:0:05B6<10<>6%*3<13778H01/8558?<3>@:0 6< >/0 :0B:050<>3>86<% @:>/0: 8> 85 =6<>0<101 >/3> :05B6<10<>6%*855@013<6>8=08<6:;6%*@<10:@90 +* 67 >/0 @905 #,," 3<1 =6<E0<01 3 ;00>8<? 67 >/0 ;0;A0:5 67 >/0 3<=/323> 6< **%)#%*)* >6 =6<5810: 3 G<6=6<7810<=0;6>86<C% +% /0B0>8>86<0:=6<>0<15>/3>:05B6<10<>65%" >6*#/3103:980:5@A;8>>013:0B:050<>3>86<>6:05B6<10<> 6%* :0I@05>8<? /8; >6 =6<E0<0 3 ;00>8<? >6 =6<5810: 3 ;6>86< 67 G<6 =6<7810<=0C 3<1 >/3> :05B6<10<> 6%+ /31 B@> /85 5039 3<1 58?<3>@:0 >/0:06<% > 85 =6<>0<101 >/3> >/0 5381 <6>8=0 D35 =/3990<?01 A076:0 >/85 6@:> 8< :8> 0>8>86< 6%*)++!*)*"% /85 6@:> 3996D01 >/0 D:8> B0>8>86< 3<1 I@35/01 >/0 <6>8=0 855@01 A2 :05B6<10<> 6%*% /0 B0>8>86<0: 85 >/0:076:0 A076:0 >/85 6@:> =/3990<?8<?>/0<6>8=013>01)+%)#%*)*B:6B658<?>6/691 >/0 ;00>8<?
67 >/0 ;0;A0:5 67 >/0 3<=/323> 6< **%)#%*)*%
- 7 -
"% 03:<01 =6@<509 76: >/0 B0>8>86<0: @:?01 >/0 76996D8<?=6<>0<>86<58<5@BB6:>67>/85B0>8>86< 8 /3> :05B6<10<> 6%+ /31 ;310 =0:>38< :0;3:45 6< >/0 :0B:050<>3>86< 67 >/0 :05B6<10<>65%">6*+3<1>/0:076:0>/00<>8:0 B:6=0018<?5/31>6A0I@35/0135D3516<0A2 >/856@:>8<:8>0>8>86<6%*)++!*)*"% 88 /3> :05B6<10<> 6%* 85 A6@<1 8< 93D >6 35=0:>38< 3A6@> >/0 3990?3>86<5 ;310 3?38<5> >/0B0>8>86<0:3<15@A;8>3:0B6:>D8>/8<50E0< 1325% 0 /6D0E0: 5>:3<?092 =6<>0<101 >/3> >/0:0 3:0 <6 3990?3>86<5 ;310 3?38<5> >/0 B0>8>86<0: A@> D0<> 6< >6 =6<>0<1 >/3> >/0 <6>8=0 855@01 D8>/6@> 5@=/ 3 :0B6:> 85 =6;B90>092D:6<?3<18<E8693>86<67>/0@905 #,,"% 888 /3>:05B6<10<>65%#)>6#+#$3<1#,>6 *+ /31 <6> 3778H01 >/08: 58?<3>@:05 6< 6:;
- 8 -
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
- 9 -
<6>8=0 @<10: @90 +* 67 >/0 @905 #,,"% /0:076:0 /0 =6<>0<15 >/3> 58<=0 >/85 :0I@8:0;0<> 85 <6> =6;B9801 >/0 D/690 B:6=0018<?590318<?>678H8<?313>067;00>8<? 67>/0;0;A0:585983A90>6A0I@35/01% % /0 903:<01 8?/ 6@:> 6E0:<;0<> 90310: 5@A;8>>01 >/3> >/0 :0I@8:0;0<> 67 >/0 3:<3>343 3<=/323> 3F 6>86< 67 6(6<7810<=0 3?38<5> 1/2345/3 3<1 B31/2345/3 67 :3; 3<=/323> @905 #,," 76: 5/6:> G>/0 @905 #,,"C 85 >/3> >D6 ;0;A0:5 58?<8<?
>/0 :0B:050<>3>86< 5/6@91 3BB03: A076:0 >/0 5585>3<> 6;;85586<0: 3<1 5@A;8> >/0 :0B:050<>3>86<% /0 =6<>0<15 >/3> >/0 :0B:050<>3>86< B:61@=01 A2 >/0 B0>8>86<0: 8>5097 5/6D5 >/3> 6@> 67 # ;0;A0:5 D/6 /31 58?<01 >/0 :0B:050<>3>86< /31 3BB03:01 B0:56<3992 A076:0 >/0 5585>3<> 6;;85586<0:% /0 >/0:076:0 =6<>0<15 >/3> >/85 D35 5@778=80<> =6;B983<=0 67 @90 +# 67 >/0 @905 #,,"% /0 7@:>/0: =6<>0<15 >/3> 0=>86<
",*67>/0
3:<3>3433<=/323>3F=>#,,+76:5/6:>
- 10 -
G>/0=>67#,,+C/35A00<:0B039013<1>89913>0<6:@905 3:07:3;01>6=6<5810:3G<6=6<7810<=0;6>86<CA35016< 3990?3>86<53?38<5>>/01/2345/33<1B31/2345/3%/0 >/0:076:0 =6<>0<15 >/3> >/0 B0>8>86<0: =3<<6> >340 31E3<>3?06735>899A6:<B:6E8586< 67>/05>3>@>0A664>6 =6<>0<1 >/3> >/0 :0B:050<>3>86< ;@5> A0 8< 3==6:13<=0 D8>/>/0:@905% % /3E0 =6<5810:01 >/0 5@A;85586<5 67 >/0 903:<01=6@<50976:>/0B0>8>86<0:3<1>/0903:<01=6@<509 76:>/0:05B6<10<>5% $% /0:3;3<=/323>67/8498=6;B:850567 *#;0;A0:5%/0B0>8>86<0:D35090=>0135>/0:05810<> 67 >/0 3<=/323> 6< )%)!%*)*+% @> 67 *# ;0;A0:5 # 5@A;8>>01 3 :0B:050<>3>86< 8< 6:; 6%# 6< )#%)#%*)* :0I@05>8<? :05B6<10<> 6%* >6 =6<E0<0 3 ;00>8<? 67 >/0 ;0;A0:5>6=6<5810:3G<6=6<7810<=0;6>86<C3?38<5>>/0 B0>8>86<0:% 05B6<10<> 6%* 0<16:501 6< >/0 5381 :0B:050<>3>86< >/3> ;0;A0:5 D/6 /31 58?<01 6:; 6%#3BB03:01A076:0/8;3<15@A;8>>018>%<<0H@:0
- 11 -
D/8=/856:;6%#1605<6>=6<>38<350396:58?<3>@:067 :05B6<10<> 6%+ 35 =938;01 A2 903:<01 =6@<509 76: >/0 B0>8>86<0:%/058?<3>@:076@<16<6:;6%#=6::05B6<15 >6 >/0 58?<3>@:0 67 :05B6<10<> 6%* 6< >/0 <6>8=0 13>01 )+%)#%*)* 855@01 >6 >/0 B0>8>86<0: B:6B658<? 3 ;00>8<? 6<**%)#%*)*%/0:076:0>/0=938;67>/0B0>8>86<0:>/3> :05B6<10<>6%+/313778H01/8550396:58?<3>@:06<6:; 6%#85D8>/6@>3<2A3585% !% < 56 73: 35 >/0 =6<>0<>86< >/3> 6:; 6%# 6@?/> >6 =6<>38< 3990?3>86<5 3?38<5> >/0 B0>8>86<0: >/0 ;0;A0:5 67 >/0 B0>8>86<0: /3E0 5@A;8>>01 3 :0B:050<>3>86< 0HB:0558<? 93=4 67 =6<7810<=0 8< >/0 B0>8>86<0: D/8=/ >/02 /3E0 0<>8>901 >6 8< E80D 67 >/0 0=>86<",67>/0=>67#,,+%/0:076:0>/0=938;67>/0 B0>8>86<0: >/3> >/0:0 ;@5> /3E0 A00< 3990?3>86<5 3?38<5> >/0 B0>8>86<0: >6 ;6E0 3 <6>8=0 67 G<6 =6<7810<=0C 85 3 ;85=6<=0B>86<670=>86<",67>/0=>67#,,+%0=>86<", 67 >/0 => 67 #,,+ B0:;8>5 #+:1 67 >/0 ;0;A0:5 67 >/0 3<=/323> >6 5@A;8> 3 :0B:050<>3>86< 0HB:0558<? 93=4 67
- 12 -
=6<7810<=0 8< >/0 1/2345/3 6: B31/2345/3 D8>/6@> ;348<?3<23990?3>86<53?38<5>>/0;%73:0I@05>85;310 >/0< >/0 B:6=01@:0 35 =6<>0;B93>01 @<10: @905 #,," 5/399A076996D01% ,% B0:@539 67 6:; 6%# 5@A;8>>01 A2 # ;0;A0:55/6D5>/3>;6:0>/3<#+:167>/0;0;A0:5/31 5@A;8>>01 8> 3<1 ;0;A0:5 D/6 /31 58?<01 6:; 6%# /31 3BB03:01 A076:0 :05B6<10<> 6%* 76996D8<? D/8=/ :05B6<10<> 6%* 855@01 3 <6>8=0 13>01 )+%)#%*)* B:6B658<? >6 =6<E0<0 3 ;00>8<? 6< **%)#%*)*% /0:076:0 >/0:0 85 <6 B:6=01@:39 0::6: 8< 855@8<? >/0 <6>8=0>6>/0B0>8>86<0:% #)% <5673:35>/0=6<>0<>86<>/3>56;0;0;A0:5 /31 <6> 58?<01 6:; 6%# 3<1 >/3> >/02 D0:0 ;85901 8< 3778H8<?>/08:58?<3>@:05>/85I@05>86<=3<<6>A00H3;8<01 8< 3 B:6=0018<?
@<10: :>8=90 ** 67 >/0 6<5>8>@>86< 67 <183% /0 B0>8>86<0: /35 6< 6<0 /3<1 =938;01 >/3> :05B6<10<> 65% #) >6 #+ #$ 3<1 #, >6 *+ /31 <6> 58?<01 6:; 6%# A@> 6< >/0 6>/0: =6<>0<101 >/3>
- 13 -
:05B6<10<>65%"$>6,#">6#3<1#!/31;85901 >/0 93>>0: 85 3 ;@>@3992 105>:@=>8E0 5>3>0;0<>% 7 >/0 B0>8>86<0: 85 5@:0 >/3> ;3<2 D6;0< ;0;A0:5 /31 <6> 58?<01 6:; 6%# >/0< >/02 B6558A92 D6@91 5@BB6:> >/0 B0>8>86<0:3>>/0;00>8<?5=/01@9016<**%)#%*)*%8<=0 >/0:0 85<6 0::6: 8< >/00<>8:0 B:6=055<6 8<>0:70:0<=085 D3::3<>01 D8>/ >/0 8;B@?<01 <6>8=0% 0<=0 >/0 D:8> 85 %
!()
&#' #
85>6%*96%*