- 1 - ! ! "# $% &$ ! # '(')*+('** & ! " # # $%&%"'( ! )' ! $%&%"'* !# " Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # )*+ # )&* # %* ') ! "'& ') # $ # # #$ # # ## ** * *( # )&" # ! # ! ! ,! ,! --./01 23 40-256 5/0 7%* ') 403123890:7;0<=0112<273562/<;2-<5310//273/.180 531 #$ 5< 5659.;582 5;2/238 7.< 7: ;2>0 7"'& ') ;082/<0;01 9? <=0 .9 ;953 762-0 <5<273 5659.;582 :7; <=0 7::03-0/ 4.32/=5960 .310; 0-<273/ ****(@37:5310-<273/)&531" 7: -< 2/ 90:7;0 <=2/ 7.;< .310; 0-<273 )&* 7: =5;5<2?5 585;2A5 .;5A/=5 53=2<5 '* /00A238 ;08.65;9526 - 3 - 05;1 <=0 605;301 54405;238 :7; ;0/473103< 7" 0/473103< 7 B=7 2/ /0;C01 23 <=0 >5<<0;=5/;0>52301.3;04;0/03<0190:7;0<=2/7.;< * # 23 ;2>0 7"'& ') B5/ ;082/<0;01 9? <=0.9;953762-0<5<273 5659.;5822<?232<2566?:7; <=0 7::03-0 4.32/=5960 .310; 0-<273 ** 7: 58523/< .3A37B3 40;/73 73 <=0 95/2/ 7: <=0 :2;/< 23:7;>5<273 15<01*"'%');0-02C01:;7>;0/473103<7B=72/ <=0 :5<=0; 7: <=0 C2-<2>$82;6 5801 "( ?05;/ 3 <=0 :2;/< 23:7;>5<2732<2//<5<01<=5<<=0C2-<2>$82;6B=7=518730 <7 -766080 73 "+'%') =51 37< ;0<.;301 =7>0 =0 0::7;</ >510 <7 <;5-0 =0; 9? <=0 :2;/< 23:7;>53< 531 =2/ ;065<2C0/=51:52601.9/0D.03<6?73*"'%')=0=51 544;75-=01<=0762-0531/.9>2<<01<=0:2;/<23:7;>5<273 95/01 73 B=2-= 53 # 23 ;2>0 7"'& ') B5/ ;082/<0;01 58523/< .3A37B3 40;/73 :7; <=0 7::03-0 4.32/=5960.310;0-<273**7:.;238<=0-7.;/07: 23C0/<285<273<=040<2<2730;531<=0C2-<2>$82;6B0;0<;5-01 <780<=0;5319;7.8=<<7<=04762-0/<5<273=040<2<2730; - 4 - B5/ 5;;0/<01 73 '('') 531 /.9/0D.03<6? ;0>53101 <7 @.12-256 -./<71? =0 23C0/<285<273 7: <=0 -5/0 2/ -7>460<01 531 <=0 -=5;80$/=00< =5/ 9003 :2601 2/ 9526 54462-5<273 90:7;0 <=0 <;256 7.;< 23 46 5/0 7%* ')B5/;0@0-<0173*'&')=0;0:7;0=02/ 90:7;0<=2/7.;< ) 05;301-7.3/06:7;<=040<2<2730;/.9>2</<=5< <=0 40<2<2730; 2/ 5 ?7.38/<0; =5C238 37 -;2>2356 53<0-0103</531=02/23-./<71?:7;<=065/<028=<>73<=/ =040<2<2730;531<=0C2-<2>$82;6B0;02367C0531/=0=51 C76.3<5;26?5--7>453201<=040<2<2730;=0C2-<2>$82;6=5/ 900356;051?0E5>230190:7;0<=0<;2567.;<5/"531 <=0;0:7;0 <=0;0 -5337< 90 53? 544;0=03/273 <=5< <=0 40<2<2730;2/62A06?<7<5>40;B2<=<=0>5<0;2564;7/0-.<273 B2<30//--7;12386?=04;5?/<75667B<=040<2<273 % 0; -73<;5 605;301 /.9>2</ <=5< <=0 C2-<2>$82;62/5>237;531=5/>510566085<273/58523/<<=0 40<2<2730;23=0;/<5<0>03<;0-7;101.310;0-<273")7: ; 531 /=0 =5/ 56/7 /.447;<01 <=0 -5/0 7: <=0 - 5 - 4;7/0-.<2731.;238<=0-7.;/07:=0;1047/2<27390:7;0<=0 <;2567.;<5/"--7;12386?=04;5?/<712/>2//<=0 40<2<273 =0 :2;/< 23:7;>5<273 23 <=0 4;0/03< -5/0 B5/ /.9>2<<01 73 *"'%') 9? <=0 ;0/473103< 7 B=72/ <=0:5<=0;7:<=0C2-<2>$82;60;./567:<=0:2;/<23:7;>5<273 B7.61 87 <7 /=7B <=5< <=0 C2-<2>$82;6 B=7 =51 8730 <7 -76608073"+'%')=5137<;0<.;3015310::7;</>510 <7 <;5-0 =0; =51 :52601 =0;05:<0; 73 *"'%') =0; :5<=0; =51 544;75-=01 <=0 4762-0 .;238 <=0 -7.;/0 7: 23C0/<285<273<=040<2<2730;531<=0C2-<2>$82;6B0;0<;5-01 <780<=0; =0 C2-<2>$82;6 B5/ /.9@0-<01 <7 >012-56 0E5>235<273 531 90:7;0 <=0 7-<7; B=7 =5/ >012-566? 0E5>2301 =0; /=0 =5/ /<5<01 <=5< /=0 2/ 5-D.523<01 <7 <=0 40<2<2730; :7; <=0 65/< >7;0 <=53 <B7 ?05;/ 531 /=0 =51 4;747/01 <7 =2> 531 <=0;05:<0; <=0? /<5;<01 67C238 05-=7<=0;=0=5/56/7/<5<01<=5</=0=51C76.3<5;26? 5--7>453201<=040<2<2730;<7=03352531=51/<5?0123 <=0 ;065<2C0F/ =7./0 7: 40<2<2730; 531 <=0;05:<0; =0 <77A - 6 - =0; <7 03856.;. 531 <=0? =51 ;0<.;301 <7 5659.;582 C03 23 =0; /<5<0>03< .310; 0-<273 ") 7: ; /=0 =5//<5<01597.</=0<;5C0623856738B2<=<=040<2<2730;<7 =03352 531 <=0;05:<0; <7 03856.;. 531 /<5?01 23 <=0 ;065<2C0F/=7./07:<=040<2<2730;=0C2-<2>$82;65801"( ?05;/ B=7 2/ /<.1?238 23 <=0 =5/ 9003 0E5>2301 90:7;0 <=0 <;256 7.;< 5/ " =0;0:7;0 5/ ;28=<6? -73<031019?<=0605;301-7.3/06:7;<=040<2<2730;<=0;0 -5337<9053?544;0=03/273<=5<<=040<2<2730;2/62A06?<7 <5>40; B2<= <=0 >5<0;256 4;7/0-.<273 B2<30// =0 40<2<2730;=5/377<=0;-;2>235653<0-0103</02/23<=0 -./<71? :7; 65/< >7;0 <=53 028=< >73<=/ 310; <=0 -2;-.>/<53-0/ 5> 7: <=0 7423273 <=5< =2/ 4;5?0; :7; 8;53< 7: ;08.65; 9526 3001/ <7 90 53/B0;01 5::2;>5<2C06? --7;12386?<=0:7667B2387;10; =040<2<2732/5667B01 =0 40<2<2730; 2/ 12;0-<01 <7 90 0365;801 73 9526 23 ;2>0 7"'& ') 7: .9 ;953 762-0 <5<273 - 7 - 5659.;582 ;082/<0;01 :7; <=0 7::03-0/ 4.32/=5960 .310; 0-<273/****(@37:5310-<273/) &531"7: 40312382340-2565/0 7%* ')73<=0:2607:112<273562/<;2-<5310//273/ .180 531 #$ 5659.;582 /.9@0-< <7 <=0 :7667B238-7312<273/ 5=040<2<2730;/=5660E0-.<040;/73569731:7;5 /.> 7: /"''''' $ B2<= <B7 /.;0<20/ :7; <=0 62A0/.> <7 <=0 /5<2/:5-<273 7: <=0 @.;2/12-<27356 7.;<G 9=0 40<2<2730; /=566 54405; ;08.65;6? 73 566 <=0 15<0/7:=05;23890:7;0<=0;2567.;<.360//<=0 ;256 7.;< 0E0>4</ =2/ 54405;53-0 :7; C5621 ;05/73/G - =0 40<2<2730; /=566 37< 12;0-<6? 7; 2312;0-<6? <=;05<03 7; <5>40; B2<= <=0 4;7/0-.<273 B2<30//0/G 1=0 40<2<2730; /=566 37< 23C76C0 23 /2>265; 7::03-0/23:.<.;0G 0=0 40<2<2730; /=566 37< 605C0 <=0 @.;2/12-<273 7: <=0 ;256 7.;< B2<=7.< 40;>2//273 7: <=0 /521 - 8 - 7.;< .3<26 <=0 -5/0 ;082/<0;01 58523/< =2> 2/ 12/47/017:: ,+ '% &$ !* $ 2/<7"67+