- 1 - ! ! "# $ $# % &#! ' ! "#$#% & ' !( )! ! "#$#* & ' ! ! !( ! +')( *%**%* Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )$ *%$ ! , ' , ( - ./01 2340105-63.0.05- 70839 :-9323;.05- +')(57 <=08>5:2.1;.63.0.05-32?@07301133A0-B3-/<-;3=3-. 57 ./3 =<0-.3-<-;3 B2<-.39 C> ./3 <=08> 5:2. <B<0-1. 23165-93-.?/:1C<-9 * 52 ./3 1<A3 57 ;5-43-03-;3 6<2.031 <23 23732239.5C>./3022<-A1C37523./320<85:2. 3.0.05-32 <6625<;/39 ./3 <=08> 5:2. @0./ < 63.0.05-:-9323;.05-*#575935720=0-<8 25;39:23 '7521/52.D2 E(@0./<62<>32.5B2<-.=<0-.3-<-;3<. *%%%%632=5-.//3;5-.3-939./<./32=<220<B3@0./ - 3 - 23165-93-. @<1 632752=39 5- *#*% /3 1.<>39 0- ./3 =<.20=5-0<8 /5=3 5-8> 752 ./233 =5-./1 /3 /<1 1.<.39./<.9:20-B./01 63205923165-93-. <-9/01 =5./32 088?.23<.39 /32 752 <990.05-<8 95@2> 3165-93-. 0- ./3 92:-A3-1.<.3:139.5<11<:8./32<-9:8.0=<.38>1/3@<1 5:1.39 725= ./3 =<.20=5-0<8 /5=3 7.32 011:0-B 83B<8 -5.0;31/3708395 *%752231.0.:.05-57;5-F:B<8 20B/.1 <-9 01 63-90-B 3.0.05-32 01 -5. <C83 .5 =<0-.<0- /321387 - ./3 5./32 /<-9 23165-93-. 01 < B5432-=3-. 1324<-. @52A0-B <1 < 3<;/32 3 01 92<@0-B 1<8<2> 57 )%%%%632=5-./ ) 3165-93-. <663<239 <-9 ;5-.31.39 ./3 ;<13 C> 7080-B 5CF3;.05-1 3 /<1 <9=0..39 ./3 238<.05-1/06 C3.@33- ./3 6<2.031 C:. 93-039 231. 57 ./3 <883B<.05-1 @/0;/ <23 =<93 752 ./3 6:26513 57 =<0-.<0-0-B ./3 63.0.05-. 01 ./363.0.05-32 @/593132.39 ./323165-93-. <-9708395 *%752231.0.:.05-57;5-F:B<820B/.1 <-99:20-B./363-93-;>57./31<=31/3/<1<815;5=3 - 4 - :6 @0./ 63.0.05- :-932 3;.05- *# 57 2 752 =<0-.3-<-;3 ) 3.0.05-32/<1;5=683.39.2<0-0-B<-91/301 < 1A08839 .<0852 32 7<./32 01 < 23.0239 3<;/32 /<40-B 0220B<.39 8<-9 =3<1:20-B $ <;231 * B:-.<1 B25@0-B ;5==32;0<8 ;2561 1:;/ <1 2<631 0=3 <-9 :B<2;<-3 - ./3 6<2.0.05- 1/3 B5. ) <;231 B:-.<1 57 8<-9 <-9 B25@0-B ;5==32;0<8 ;2561 /3 C25./321 57 63.0.05-32 <23 <815@52A0-B<-9B3..0-B/<-915=31<8<2><-915:B/.752 901=011<857./363.0.05- # :20-B ./3 ;5:213 57 34093-;3 63.0.05-32 3G<=0-39/321387<1 <-9/327<./32<1 *<-9B5. =<2A39G1 .5 ) H - ./3 5./32 /<-9 23165-93-. 3G<=0-39 /0=1387<1 <-9B5.=<2A39G1.5$ !093 ./3 0=6:B-39 F:9B=3-. <-9 52932 ./3 20<8 5:2. 6<2.8> <885@39 ./3 63.0.05- B2<-.0-B =<0-.3-<-;3<.%%%% ?632=5-./ - 5 - $ BB203439C>./31<=363.0.05-3201C37523./3 5:2. 133A0-B 3-/<-;3=3-. ;5-.3-90-B ./<. ./3 20<8 5:2. 01 -5. F:1.07039 0- 70G0-B ./3 =<0-.3-<-;3 <. %%%% ? 632 =5-./ 343- ./5:B/ 9:20-B /01 ;2511? 3G<=0-<.05-23165-93-./<1<9=0..39./<./30192<@0-B 1<8<2>57%%%% ?632=5-././<1-5.<6623;0<.39./3 7<;. ./<. 23165-93-. 01 -5. /<40-B <-> 5./32 23165-10C080.031 /3 23165-93-. /<1 -5. 6259:;39 <-> 95;:=3-.1.51/5@./<./301C3<20-B./33G63-13157/01 =5./32E1 =390;<8 C0881 <-9 101.32E1 39:;<.05- 3165-93-. 01 -5. 23<9> 752 231.0.:.05- 57 ;5-F:B<8 20B/.1 <-9 5- ./3 5./32 /<-9 15:B/. 752 90452;3 3-;3 62<> .5 <885@ ./3 63.0.05- <-9 3-/<-;3 ./3 =<0-.3-<-;3 .5 *%%%% ? 632 =5-./ + - ./3 5./32 /<-9 83<2-39 ;5:-138 2362313-.0-B ./3 23165-93-. 1:6652.39 ./3 0=6:B-39 F:9B=3-. <-9 52932 <-9 ./3 15:B/. 752 901=011<8 57 ./3 63.0.05- - 6 - % 3<29<2B:=3-.1<-9632:139./323;529 /3 238<.05-1/06 C3.@33- ./3 6<2.031 01 -5. 0- 9016:.3 25= ./3 63.0.05- <432=3-.1 0. 01 34093-. ./<. 63.0.05-32 1.<>39 0- ./3 =<.20=5-0<8 /5=3 5-8> 752 < 632059 57 ./233 =5-./1 /083 1/3 /<1 <883B39 ./<. 1/3 @<1 5:1.39 725= ./3 =<.20=5-0<8 /5=3 23165-93-. /<1 ;5-.3-939 ./<. @0./5:. <-> F:1.070<C83 ;<:13 63.0.05-32 /<1 837. ./3 =<.20=5-0<8 /5=3 <-9 /<1 ;5=3 :6 @0./ <- :-20B/.35:1;8<0=752=<0-.3-<-;3 * 9=0..398> 63.0.05-32 /<1 1.<>39 0- ./3 =<.20=5-0<8 /5=3 5-8> 752 < 632059 57 ./233 =5-./1 /5:B/ 1/3 /<1 <883B39 ./<. 23165-93-. /01 =5./32<-9 101.32:139.5/<2<11<-9088?.23<./32<-923165-93-.:139 .5 <11<:8. /32 0- 92:-A3- 1.<.3 <9=0..398> 1/3 /<1 -5. .<A3-<->83B<8<;.05-<B<0-1../3= -./35./32/<-923165-93-./<1<883B39./<. 63.0.05-32 @<1 -5. @0880-B .5 =<22> ./3 23165-93-. <-9 ./3237523 1/3 837. ./3 =<.20=5-0<8 /5=3 /3 63.0.05-32 - 7 - /<1 ;8<0=39 ./<. 1/3 70839 5 *% 752 231.0.:.05- 57 ;5-F:B<8 20B/.1 <-9 <1 <9=0..39 C> /32 0. ;<=3.5 C3 901=01139752-5-?62513;:.05- ) -7<;../39016:.3C3.@33-./3=@<123732239 .5=390<.05-1632./3=390<.05-23652.23165-93-.@<1 23<9>.583<9=<20.<88073@0././363.0.05-32C:.63.0.05-32 .55A .0=3 .5 ./0-A 5432 <-9 <1 1:;/ ./3 =390<.05- /<1 7<0839 5 7<2 <1 ./3 23165-10C080.> 57 23165-93-. .5 .<A3 ;<23 57 /01 =5./32 <-9 101.32E1 7<=08> @/3- 1:BB31.39 ./<. 7<./32 57 23165-93-. /<1 9039 343- @/083 /3 @<1 1.:9>0-B 63.0.05-32 /<1 3G6231139 0B-52<-;3 /3- 1:BB31.39 ./<. ./3 /:1C<-9 57 23165-93-.E1 101.32 /<1 93132.39/32<-923165-93-.01.<A0-B;<2357/32<-9/32 ;/08923-63.0.05-32/<1-5.93-039./31:BB31.05-<-95- ./35./32/<-91.<.39./<./01101.3201@52A0-B57<2<1 63.0.05-32B3..0-B)<;231B:-.<1578<-90->5$ #0- 6<2.0.05- <-9 0. 01 < @3. 8<-9 @/323 1/3 01 B25@0-B 1:B<2;<-3 B2<631 <-9 83=5- 0-1.3<9 57 93->0-B ./3 - 8 - 1<=3 63.0.05-32 /<1 B043- 34<1043 <-1@32 C> 3G623110-B 0B-52<-;3 # 5@3432G01./323B01.32396<2.0.05-9339 3-.32390-.5C3.@33-63.0.05-32<-9/327<=08>=3=C321 -7<;./327<./32013G<=0-39<1 */<1<9=0..39./3 6<2.0.05-0-./37<=08><-9./<.)<;231<-9*%B:-.<157 8<-9 01 B043- .5 /32 1/<23 3160.3 ./3 7<;. ./<. 23165-93-./<1<9=0..39./<./301B3..0-BB25111<8<2>57 %%%% ?/<40-B23B<29.5./37<;../<./301/<40-B./3 23165-10C080.> 57 .<A0-B ;<23 57 /01 @095@39 =5./32 <-9 101.32 <-9 /32 ;/08923- <-9 <815 .<A0-B 0-.5 ;5-10932<.05- ./3 7<;. ./<. 63.0.05-32 /<1 B5. ) <;231 B:-.<1 57 @3. 8<-9 .5 /32 1/<23 <-9 ./5:B/ 1/3 70839 < 63.0.05- 752 231.0.:.05- 57 ;5-F:B<8 20B/.1 1/3 909 -5. ;/5513 .5 62513;:.3 ./3 1<=3 ./3 20<8 5:2. 20B/.8> /389 ./<. 63.0.05-32 01 3-.0.839 752 =<0-.3-<-;3 <. ./3 2<.3 57 %%%% ? 632 =5-./ /3 ;5-;8:105-1 <220439 <. C> ./3 20<8 5:2. 01 ;5-101.3-. @0./ ./3 34093-;3 839 C> ./3 6<2.031 /01 5:2. 70-91 -5 63243210.> 0- ./3 ;5-;8:105-1 - 9 - <220439 <. C> ./3 20<8 5:2. /323 <23 -5 F:1.070<C83 B25:-91 .5 0-.327323 @0./ ./3 0=6:B-39 52932 <-9 752 3-/<-;0-B./3=<0-.3-<-;3 H - ./3 231:8. ./3 63.0.05- 7<081 <-9 <;;5290-B8> ./375885@0-B 3.0.05- 70839 C> ./3 63.0.05-32?@073 :-932 3;.05- +')(57 ./3<=08> 5:2.1 ;.01 901=01139 * /3 0=6:B-39 F:9B=3-. <-9 52932 9<.39 *%**%* 6<1139 0- 28 01; 5)$ *%$ 5- ./3 7083 57 ?998 28 :9B3 <=08> 5:2. !0F<><6:2< 01 ;5-702=39 3B01.2> .5 13-9 C<;A ./3 .20<8 ;5:2. 23;5291 <85-B @0./ ;56> 57 ./01 52932 752./@0./ () *$# %+ $ )+