- 1 - !" # $ " # %&'%()*+%)) $ ! " # $ % & ! " # $ ' !(% ) *' $ ' $ + * **, ,! Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + , ,! ' ' + ' **,, ,, ++' , , *% ' ' ) - +)+ # - +)+$ ./0/1212&3/4256/7&4/1.25&841839/4/:12&3!(% 4/;9<21./:12&3 *&74 <21.;04;=/41&5/1;529/ 1./>89?@/31;39&49/4&7:&3A2:12&3;395/31/3:/0;55/9 6= 1./ &841 &7 423:20;B 2A2B +89?/ ;39 +' 29;4 #7&4 5.&41 C42;B &841D$ 23 42@23;B ;5/ &, , *% 9;1/9 **,, ,, ;39 1./ >89?@/31 ;39 &49/4 9;1/9 * **, ,! 0;55/9 23 42@23;B 00/;B & , ,! 6= 1./ &841 &7 423:20;B 25142:1 ;39 /552&35 +89?/ 29;4 #7&4 5.&41C72451;00/BB;1/&841D$ , /;49B/;43/9:&835/B7&41./0;412/5 - 3 - ! ./4/50&39/31./4/23.;923212;1/904&://923?5 ;?;2351 1./ 0/1212&3/4 6/7&4/ 1./ 42;B &841 23 &, , *% 7&4 1./ &77/3:/ 08325.;6B/ 839/4 /:12&3*!&71.//?&12;6B/35148@/315:1**#7&4 5.&41 C:1D$ 1 25 1./ 50/:272: :;5/ &7 1./ 4/50&39/31 1.;1./.;90;29;58@&7 5!, 1&1./0/1212&3/4 ;5.;39B&;3;391&<;4954/0;=@/31&71./5;29;@&831 1./ 0/1212&3/4 .;9 2558/9 ; :./E8/ 6/;423? & * 9;1/9* , *%94;<3&31;1/&7=5&4/29;44;3:. 7&4 ; 58@ &7 5!, ./ 5;29 :./E8/ &3 04/5/31;12&3 7&4 4/;B2F;12&3 <;5 925.&3&84/9 6= 1./ 94;<//;3G<21.;5.;4;C2358772:2/3178395D./4/;71/4 1./ 4/50&39/31 .;9 :&@0B2/9 1./ 51;181&4= 4/E824/@/315 6= 255823? B/?;B 3&12:/ 1& 1./ 0/1212&3/4 ;39 23 5021/ &7 5/4A2:/ &7 5;29 3&12:/ 1./ 0/1212&3/4 .;9 7;2B/9 1& 4/0;= 1./;@&831:&A/4/9839/41./:./E8/23E8/512&3;392125 23 1.25 6;:G?4&839 1./ 4/50&39/31 .;9 23212;1/9 04&://923?5 ;?;2351 0/1212&3/4 7&4 1./ &77/3:/ 08325.;6B/ 839/4/:12&3*!&71./:16/7&4/1./42;B&841 - 4 - 3 1./ 5;29 04&://923?5 1./ 4/50&39/31 :&@0B;23;31 .;5 /H;@23/9 .2@5/B7 ;5 )* ;39.;9?&1@;4G/91.4//9&:8@/315;5H5 *1& !3 6/.;B7 &7 1./ 9/7/3:/ 3& &4;B &4 9&:8@/31;4= /A29/3:/ <;5B/9 ./42;B&8411./4/;71/4./;491./;4?8@/315 ;994/55/9 &3 6/.;B7 &7 6&1. 1./ 0;412/5 ;39 A29/ 1./ 2@08?3/9>89?@/31;39&49/4:&3A2:1/91./0/1212&3/47&4 1./ &77/3:/ 08325.;6B/ 839/4 /:12&3 *! &7 1./ :1 ;39 5/31/3:/9 .2@ 1& 0;= 723/ &7 5! ;39 23 9/7;8B1./5.;BB839/4?&52@0B/2@0425&3@/317&4;0/42&9 &71.4//@&31.5./0/1212&3/4<;5;B5&924/:1/91&0;=; 58@&7 5!, ;5:&@0/35;12&31&1./4/50&39/31 <21.23;0/42&9&71<&@&31.574&@1./9;1/&71./&49/4 ./5;29>89?@/31;39&49/4&7:&3A2:12&3;39 5/31/3:/ 0;55/9 6= 1./ 42;B &841 <;5 :&3724@/9 23 42@23;B 00/;B & , ,! 6= 1./ 72451 ;00/BB;1/ &841 /23? ;??42/A/9 6= 1./ 5;@/ 1./ 0/1212&3/4 ;::85/9 25 6/7&4/1.25&841 - 5 - % ./ B/;43/9 :&835/B 7&4 1./ 0/1212&3/4 .;A23? 4/21/4;1/9 1./ ?4&8395 84?/9 23 1./ 0/1212&3 586@215 1.;1 1./ 0/1212&3/4 .;5 3&1 6//3 ?2A/3 04&0/4 &00&418321= 6/7&4/ 1./ 42;B &841 1& B/;9 9/7/3:/ /A29/3:/ / 586@2151.;11./:./E8/23E8/512&3<;52558/9234/50/:1 &7 ; /;4B2/4 14;35;:12&3 &7 1./ =/;4 , *! ;39 1.&8?. 1./ ;@&831 839/4 1./ /;4B2/4 14;35;:12&3 <;5 0;29 1./ 4/50&39/31 .;9 3&1 4/1843/9 1./ :./E8/ ;39 21 <;5 04/5/31/9 5865/E8/31B= ;39 6;5/9 &3 1./ 5;@/ 1./ 04/5/3104&://923?52523212;1/9;?;23511./0/1212&3/4 /4 :&314; B/;43/9 :&835/B 7&4 1./ 4/50&39/31 .;5 ;4?8/9 23 5800&41 &7 1./ 2@08?3/9 >89?@/31 ;39 &49/4 &7 :&3A2:12&3 ;39 5/31/3:/ 0;55/9 6= 1./ &8415 6/B&< ( ./ 2558;3:/ &7 :./E8/ 23 E8/512&3 ;39 1./ 52?3;184/7&839231./:./E8/23E8/512&3253&123925081/ 1 25 ;B5& 3&1 23 925081/ 1.;1 1./ :./E8/ 23 E8/512&3 <;5 94;<3 74&@ 1./ ;::&831 @;231;23/9 6= 1./ 0/1212&3/4 23 1;1/;3G&7=5&4/29;44;3:../5;29:./E8/&3 - 6 - 04/5/31;12&3 7&4 4/;B2F;12&3 <;5 925.&3&84/9 6= 1./ 94;<//;3G<21.;5.;4;C2358772:2/3178395D35021/&7 5/4A2:/&751;181&4=3&12:/1./0/1212&3/4.;97;2B/91&0;= 1./ ;@&831 :&A/4/9 839/4 1./ :./E8/ ./4/7&4/ ; 04/58@012&3 ;425/5 ;?;2351 1./ 0/1212&3/4 839/4 /:12&3 *!(&71./:1;3983B/551./5;@/254/6811/96=.2@ 6= 081123? 7&4<;49 ; 04&6;6B/ 9/7/3:/ ./ 25 B2;6B/ 1& 6/ :&3A2:1/97&41./&77/3:/08325.;6B/839/4/:12&3*!&7 1./:1 * 1 25 1./ 9/7/3:/ &7 1./ 0/1212&3/4 1.;1 1./ :./E8/ 23 E8/512&3 <;5 2558/9 6= .2@ 23 ;3 /;4B2/4 14;35;:12&398423?1./=/;4, *!;391./5;@/.;56//3 @2585/96=1./4/50&39/315865/E8/31B=231./=/;4, *% ./ 5;29 9/7/3:/ &7 1./ 0/1212&3/4 .;5 3&1 6//3 04&6;6B25/9&404&A/96=.2@231./@;33/4G3&<31&B;< 6/7&4/ 1./ 42;B &841 ./ 0/1212&3/4 .;5 3&1 /H;@23/9 .2@5/B7 6/7&4/ 1./ 42;B &841 3&4 .;5 ./ /H;@23/9 ;3= &1./4<213/55235800&41&7.259/7/3:/./&772:/4&71./ 94;<// ;3G <.& <&8B9 .;A/ 6//3 1./ 6/51 <213/55 1& - 7 - 04&A/1./9/7/3:/&71./0/1212&3/425;B5&3&1/H;@23/9 231./:;5/ ** ./4/:&495&71./42;B&841<&8B94/A/;B1.;1 23 5021/ &7 0/1212&3/4 6/23? ?4;31/9 &00&418321= 1& B/;9 9/7/3:/ /A29/3:/./.;9 7;2B/9 1&9& 5& ./0/1212&3/4 .;9 1;G/3 ;B@&51 1.4// =/;45 7&4 1./ 0840&5/ &7 :4&55 /H;@2323? )*;391./4/;71/41.&8?../<;5?4;31/9;3 &00&418321= 6/7&4/ 1./ 42;B &841 1& B/;9 9/7/3:/ /A29/3:/./.;53&1:.&5/31&9&5&./4/7&4/1./42;B &841.;9:B&5/91./9/7/3://A29/3:/&3,* !, ,,;39 0&51/91./@;11/47&4;4?8@/315./723;B>89?@/31<;5 0;55/9 6= 1./ 42;B &841 23 &, , *% &3 **,, *% '4&@ ,* !, ,, &3<;495 12BB **,, ,, 1./ @;11/4 <;5 ;9>&843/9 6/7&4/ 1./ 42;B &841 &3 38@6/4&79;1/56811./0/1212&3/4.;93&1:.&5/31&72B/ ;3=;00B2:;12&31&0/4@21.2@1&B/;99/7/3://A29/3:/ *, ./ 72451 ;00/BB;1/ &841 .;A23? 1;G/3 231& :&3529/4;12&3 1./ ;7&4/5;29 ;50/:15 &7 1./ @;11/4 .;5 42?.1B= 925@255/9 1./ ;00/;B 72B/9 6= 1./ 0/1212&3/4 - 8 - :.;BB/3?23? 1./ >89?@/31 ;39 &49/4 &7 :&3A2:12&3 ;39 5/31/3:/ 0;55/9 6= 1./ 42;B &841 23:/ 1./ 0/1212&3/4 .;93&10817&4<;49;3=04&6;6B/9/7/3:/6/7&4/1./42;B &841 1./ 04/58@012&3 1.;1 ;4&5/ ;5 ;?;2351 .2@ 51&&9 834/6811/9 ;39 1./4/7&4/ /A/318;BB= ./ 25 B2;6B/ 1& 6/ 08325./97&41./&77/3:/08325.;6B/839/4/:12&3*!&7 1./:1./42;B&841;5</BB;51./72451;00/BB;1/ &841 .;A23? ;004/:2;1/9 1./ &4;B ;39 9&:8@/31;4= /A29/3:/ ;A;2B;6B/ &3 4/:&49 .;A/ 42?.1B= :&@/ 1& ; :&3:B852&3 1.;1 1./ 04/58@012&3 1.;1 ;4&5/ ;?;2351 1./ 0/1212&3/4 51&&9 834/6811/9 6/7&4/ 1./ 42;B &841 ;39 ;::&4923?B= .;A/ 42?.1B= :&3A2:1/9 .2@ 7&4 1./ &77/3:/ 08325.;6B/839/4/:12&3*!&71./:1 *! 39/4 1./ :24:8@51;3:/5 1./ 2@08?3/9 >89?@/31;39&49/4&7:&3A2:12&3;395/31/3:/0;55/96= 1./ &8415 6/B&< 9& 3&1 5877/4 74&@ ;3= 2BB/?;B21= &4 244/?8B;421=<.2:.:;BB57&4;3=231/47/4/3:/6=1.25&841 23/H/4:25/&72154/A252&3;B0&</45839/4/:12&3!(%4/;9 - 9 - <21./:12&3 *&74 ::&4923?B=7&BB&<23?&49/425 0;55/9 ./:42@23;B4/A252&30/1212&325925@255/9 ./4/50&39/31 :&@0B;23;31250/4@211/91&<21.94;< 1./;@&8319/0&521/96=1./0/1212&3/427;3=6/7&4/1./ 42;B&841 ,* %# $ ) 251&*B&%