- 1 - !" ! #$ "% &" ! $ '(')*+,'** & !"# $ % %% & %% % % % #"' $ %% !( ! & "()")! %% Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' #( )"# * & + *&* + *&* # ,,-./0 12 314/ 5"()")! 3/61.7/3/0 89 %:32:7:;:5;:9-;7: 5<1,/ 10:3=535==/2,/.>-21.?:8</ -20/3/,7152':5= 3/@/271525=533->7152,7#(1. 8/=53/ 7?1. ,5-37 -20/3 /,7152 ! 5= ?:3:719: :6:31; -3:;.?::2?17:)").//;1263/6-<:38:1< ) /:307?/</:32/0,5-2./<=537?/>:371/. 12 314/ 5"()")! A:. 3/61.7/3/0 89 %:32:7:;: 5;:9-;7: 5<1,/ 10:3 :6:12.7 7?/ >/717152/3 ?/3/12 52 7?/ 8:.1. 5= 7?/ =13.7 12=534:7152 0:7/0 #B#))")! 3/,/1@/0 =354 7?/ 5?:44/0 <1 2 7?/ .:10 ,:./ 7?/ >/717152/3 A:. :33/.7/0 52 #(#))")! :20 .-8./C-/27<9 3/4:20/0 75 - 3 - D-01,1:< ,-.7509 :1< :>><1,:7152 =1</0 89 7?/ >/717152/3 8/=53/ 7?/ 31:< 5-37 12 314/ 5"()")! A:. 3/D/,7/0 52"("#)") ?/3/=53/>/717152/31.8/=53/7?1.,5-37 ! /:32/0,5-2./<=537?/>/717152/3.-8417.7?:7 7?/ 4:E14-4 >-21.?4/27 =53 7?/ :<</6/0 5==/2,/ 1. 14>31.524/27 =53 : >/3150 5= ./@/2 9/:3. ?/ >/717152/3 A?5 : 5@/324/27 ./3@:27 1. 12 7?/ ,-.7509 =53 7?/ <:.7 453/ 7?:2 52/ 4527? ?/ 4:D53 >537152 5= 7?/ 12@/.716:71521.,54></7/0,,530126<9?/>3:9.75:<<5A 7?/>/717152 /:32/0 ,5-2./< :>>/:3126 =53 7?/ 3/.>520/27 A?5 ?:. =1</0 .7:7/4/27 5= 58D/,7152. ?:. 5>>5./0 7?/ >/717152/.-8417.7?:77?/12@/.716:71525=7?/,:./1. -20/3 >3563/.. :20 :7 7?1. .7:6/ 7?/ >/717152/3F. >3:9/3 =5363:275=3/6-<:38:1<2//0.758/3/D/,7/0 B ?/ ,54><:12:27 ?:0 :>>35:,?/0 7?/ >/717152/3A?51.:-3@/953:77:,?/0757?/-3@/9==1,/ 5= -3:0 10:3 7:<-;: =53 7?/ >-3>5./ 5= ,520-,7126 - 4 - .-3@/9 5=?1.<:20 :207?/ >/717152/3 :<</6/0<90/4:20/0 8318/ :45-27 5= .# """" =354 7?/ ,54><:12:27?/,54><:12:27A?5010257127/20 75 >:9 7?/ 8318/ :45-27 ?:0 :>>35:,?/0 7?/ 5;:9-;: 5<1,/ 52 #B#))")! :20 .-84177/0 : =13.7 12=534:7152 :=7/33/,530126?1.,52@/3.:7152.A17?7?/>/717152/312?1. 4581</ >?52/ =7/3 3/61.7/3126 :. :6:12.7 7?/ >/717152/3 7?/ 73:> A:. .-,,/..=-<<9 <:10 52 #(#))")! :20 7?/ >/717152/3 ?/3/12 A:. ,:-6?7 3/0 ?:20/0 A?1</ 3/,/1@126 7?/ 8318/ :45-27 5= .' """ =354 7?/ ,54><:12:27?/8318/:45-27A:.3/,5@/3/0=534 7?/ >/717152/3 -20/3 : 4:?:G:3 :20 7?/3/:=7/3 7?/ >/717152/3 A:. :33/.7/0 :20 >350-,/0 8/=53/ 7?/ 731:< 5-37 ?/ >/717152/3 A?5 1. : 5@/324/27 /3@:27 1. 12 7?/,-.7509.12,/<:.7453/7?:252/4527?:D53>537152 5=7?/12@/.716:715212:73:>,:./1.,54></7/0527?/0:7/ 5= 7?/ 73:> 17./<= ?/ 4:E14-4 >-21.?4/27 =53 7?/ :<</6/0 5==/2,/ 1. 14>31.524/27 =53 : >/3150 5= ./@/2 9/:3.12,/7?/>/717152/31.:5@/324/27/3@:277?/3/ ,:22578/:29:>>3/?/2.1527?:7?/1.<1;/<975=<//:A:9 - 5 - =354 7?/ D-.71,/ 20/3 7?/ ,13,-4.7:2,/. :4 5= 7?/ 5>121527?:77?/>3:9/3=5363:275=3/6-<:38:1<2//0.75 8/:2.A/3/0:==134:71@/<9,,530126<97?/=5<<5A126530/3 ?/>/7171521.:<<5A/0 ?/ >/717152/3 1. 013/,7/0 75 8/ /2<:36/0 52 8:1< 12 314/5()")!5=5;:9-;7: 5<1,/ 10:33/61.7/3/0=53 7?/5==/2,/>-21.?:8</-20/3/,7152':5= 3/@/271525= 533->7152,7#(>/201268/=53/7?/ 312,1>:<1.731,7 :20 /..152. *-06/ 5-37 :7 10:3 .-8D/,7 75 7?/ =5<<5A126,52017152. :?/>/717152/3.?:<</E/,-7/>/3.52:<8520=53: .-4 5= .#""""" A17? 7A5 .-3/71/. =53 7?/ <1;/.-4 75 7?/ .:71.=:,7152 5= 7?/ D-31.01,7152:< 5-37H 8?/ >/717152/3 .?:<< :>>/:3 3/6-<:3<9 52 :<< 7?/ 0:7/.5=?/:31268/=53/7?/31:<5-37-2</..7?/ 31:< 5-37 /E/4>7. ?1. :>>/:3:2,/ =53 @:<10 3/:.52.H - 6 - , ?/ >/717152/3 .?:<< 257 013/,7<9 53 12013/,7<9 7?3/:7/2 53 7:4>/3 A17? 7?/ >35./,-7152 A172/../.H 0?/ >/717152/3 .?:<< 257 12@5<@/ 12 .141<:3 5==/2,/.12=-7-3/H /?/ >/717152/3 .?:<< 257 </:@/ 7?/ D-31.01,7152 5= 7?/ 31:< 5-37 A17?5-7 >/341..152 5= 7?/ .:10 5-37 -271< 7?/ ,:./ 3/61.7/3/0 :6:12.7 ?14 1. 01.>5./05== -+ '% &" !* " 1.75#<5#B %