- 1 - !"# $ %& '%(!(! )!* ! " # $ % & ' " $# ( )*+,-.,./0.,1234 13.,3.-4,.5 %5 5 )*+,-.,./0.,1234 13.,3.-4,.55 5 ! 67,34,./0.,123413.,3.-4,.5% 5 5 Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # 5 # # # # & '! ( $ 55 55 8 5 5 5 5 # 9 :: $ ; ;: " " !,+,4,./0.,123413.,3.-4,.5% 5 5 - 3 - <, *,404016,3 <-7 =0+,. 4<07 >304 *,404016 7,,?06@ - >304 1= A,34013-30 41 B2-7< 4<, 13.,3 .-4,. 5 5 5 *-77,. CD 3,7*16.,64 15*,A0-+ ,*24D 1))077016,3 -7 *,3 66,E23,: : -6. -+71 7,,?06@ .03,A4016 41 3,7*16.,64 17 -6. 41 43-67=,3 -6. 3,7413, 4<, 3,/,62, 3,A13.7 06 3,7*,A4 1= D1F 1= 2)C-+-@1.2#0++-@,41-6,E4,641=-A3,7064<,6-), 1=*,404016,3 5 <, @30,/-6A, 1= 4<, *,404016,3 07 4<-4 <07 *3,.,A,7713 >-7 4<, @3-64,, 1= -A3,7 1= +-6. 06 D1F 7042-4,. -4 2)C-+-@1.2 #0++-@, ,6@-+232 124<-+2?'=13C3,/04D:72CG,A4+-6.:(/0.,3-643.,3 .-4,.5 %%-6.3-64,340=0A-4,.-4,. % =4,3 <07 .,)07, 4<, *,404016,3 A164062,. 06 *177,77016 -6. A2+40/-4016 1= 4<, 72CG,A4 +-6. AA13.06@+D 4<, )24-4016 *31A,,.06@7 06 1% ,==,A4,. 06 4<,6-),1=*,404016,3 - 4 - <06@7 7411. 4<27 4<, -<70+.-33,7*16.,64 1 A-6A,++,. 4<, )24-4016 -6. 3,/,62, ,6430,7 06 4<, 6-),1=4<,*,404016,3063,7*,A41=72CG,A4+-6.C-7,.16 4<, .03,A4016 1= 4<, 77074-64 1))077016,3 06 *31A,,.06@7 /0., 13.,3 .-4,. 5 %%F 1>,/,3 4<, 7-0. 13.,3 <-7 C,,6 A<-++,6@,. CD 4<, *,404016,3 C,=13, 4<07 1234 06 $1 F 5 % -+16@ >04< 14<,3 >304 *,4040167 -6. 4<, 7-), A-), 41 C, -++1>,. /0., 13.,3 .-4,. %5 % -6. 3,)044,. 4<, )-44,3 C-A? 41 3,7*16.,6414<,-<70+.-341A1670.,34<,A+-0)1=4<, *,404016,3=1343-67=,31=<-4<-063,7*,A41=72CG,A4+-6. 06-AA13.-6A,>04<+-> =4,3 72A< 3,)-6. 4<, -<70+.-3 3,G,A4,. 4<, A+-0) 1= 4<, *,404016,3 ><0A< >-7 A<-++,6@,. CD 4<, *,404016,3 C,=13, 4<, *,A0-+ ,*24D 1))077016,3 -7 *,366,E23, -6.4<,*,A0-+,*24D1))077016,3 -=4,3A16.2A406@-6,6B203D16A,-@-063,G,A4,.4<,A+-0) 1= 4<, *,404016,3 06 3,7*,A4 1= 72CG,A4 +-6. /0., 13.,3 .-4,.5 5 5 -6.-+71.03,A4,.4<,-<70+.-3414-?, - 5 - 6,A,77-3D74,*741)-?,3,/,62,,6430,706=-/1231=4<, 1/,36),64 <-++,6@, 41 4<, 7-), 07 C,=13, 4<07 1234 ,-3. 4<, +,-36,. ,6013 1267,+ 30"-D-?2)-3 -40+ =13 +,-36,. A1267,+ 30 >-311* =13 4<, 0)*+,-.06@ *,404016,3 -6. +,-36,. ..04016-+ 1/,36),64./1A-4,=134<,3,7*16.,647 <, *30)-3D A164,64016 1= 4<, +,-36,. ,6013 1267,+ =13 4<, *,404016,3 07 4<-4 4<, *,A0-+ ,*24D 1))077016,3 @3177+D ,33,. ><0+, *-7706@ 4<, 0)*2@6,. 13.,3 >04<124 A1670.,306@ 4<, =-A47 -6. A03A2)74-6A,1=4<,A-7,06-30@<4*,37*,A40/,,=234<,3 A164,6.,. 4<-4 4<, 3,-71606@ 1= 4<, *,A0-+ ,*24D 1))077016,3 06 4<, 0)*2@6,. 13.,3 07 =-A42-++D 06A133,A44<-44<,*,404016,3<-7=-0+,.41*31.2A,130@06-+ .1A2),647 06 3,7*,A4 1= 43,-723D A<-++-6 -6. 14<,3 130@06-+ .1A2),647 AA13.06@ 41 4<, +,-36,. ,6013 1267,+ 4<,*,404016,3 <-7 *+-A,.4<,3,@074,3 ,E43-A4 06 - 6 - 3,7*,A41=4<,-@2/-+0<040772,.06<07=-/123>-DC-A? 06 4<, D,-3 % <, 7-), A+,-3+D .07A+17,7 4<-4 4<, *,404016,3<-.*-0.4<,*30A,-6.-+71 =,,1=75 /0., A<-++-6 1% .-4,. 5 % ..04016-++D 4<, *,404016,3-+71*+-A,.)24-4016-6.4<,3,*1340772,. CD4<,,/,62, 67*,A413.-4,.55 %5 C-7,.164<, .03,A40167 1= 4<, *,A0-+ ,*24D 1))077016,3 ,7*04, >04<124 *,327-+ 1= 4<,7, .1A2),647 0)*2@6,. 13.,3<-7C,,6*-77,.AA13.06@+D<,*3-D741-++1>4<, >304*,404016 +,-36,. ..04016-+ 1/,36),64 ./1A-4,72C)0474<-4><0+,*-7706@4<,0)*2@6,.13.,3 4<,*,A0-+,*24D1))077016,3 <-7.,-+44<,)-44,3 06.,4-0+-6.*,327,.-++4<,3,/,62,3,A13.7+0?,-6. @3-643,@074,3-/-0+-C+,064<,1==0A,1=4<,-<70+.-3-6. 4<, *,A0-+ ,*24D 1))077016,3 -6. A16A+2.,. 4<-4 4<,3,>-76172A<@3-64)-.,06=-/1231=4<,*,404016,3 064<,D,-3%AA13.06@+D<,*3-D741.07)0774<,>304 *,404016 - 7 - F <-/, @0/,6 )D -6E0127 A1670.,3-4016 16 4<, 72C)077016 )-., CD 4<, +,-36,. ,6013 1267,+ =13 4<, 0)*+,-.06@*,404016,3 -6.+,-36,. ..04016-+ 1/,36),64 ./1A-4,-6.-+71*,327,.4<,.1A2),647)-.,-/-0+-C+, C,=13,4<071234 % 7 A12+. C, @-4<,3,. =31) 3,A13. 04 07 614 06 .07*24, 4<-4 4<, *,404016,3 <-7 *+-A,. *<141A1*D 1= 4<, 3-64,340=0A-4,0772,.CD4<,-<70+.-3,6@-+232124< -+2? .-4,. % 06 3,7*,A4 1= 72CG,A4 +-6. <,3,-=4,3 4<, )24-4016 ,6430,7 A16.2A4,. 06 1% -6. -++ 4<, 3,/,62, 3,A13.7 >,3, ,64,3,. 06 4<, 6-), 1= 4<, *,404016,3 <12@< 4<, -<70+.-3 A-6A,++,. 72A< ,6430,7 4<, *,404016,3 -**31-A<,.4<071234-6.4<071234<-7-++1>,.4<,>304 *,404016 -6. 3,)044,. 4<, )-44,3 C-A? 41 4<, *,A0-+ ,*24D 1))077016,3 -6.4<, 77074-64 1))077016,3 41A1670.,34<,A+-0)1=4<,*,404016,306-AA13.-6A,>04< +-> - 8 - 6 A-3,=2+ *,327-+ 1= 4<, 0)*2@6,. 13.,3 *-77,.CD4<,*,A0-+,*24D1))077016,3 4<,7-), .,*0A47 4<-4 4<, *,404016,3 <-7 =-0+,. 41 *31.2A, -6D 3,+,/-64.1A2),6470,4<,@3-64A,340=0A-4,A<-++-6*-0. =134<,*30A,-6.-+714<,-@2/-+0,@074,3 E43-A4,4A ,-36,. ,6013 1267,+ =13 4<, *,404016,3 CD *+-A06@ 4<, -@2/-+0 772, ,@074,3 06 3,7*,A4 1= 72CG,A4 +-6.)24-4016,E43-A4-6.3,A13.71=30@<47=134<, D,-3%FF-3@2,.4<-4-=4,3*-7706@4<,13.,3CD4<07 1234 06 $1 F 5 % C-7,. 16 4<, .03,A4016 1= 4<, ,*24D 1))077016,3 4<, 3,/,62, 067*,A413 A16.2A4,. -7*14)-<-H-3 -6.=0+,.- .,4-0+,. 3,*134 16 55 %5 ><0A< A+,-3+D 3,/,-+7 4<-4 4<, 72CG,A4 +-6. >-7@3-64,.06=-/1231=4<,*,404016,3-6.-++4<,3,/,62, 3,A13.7 -3, -/-0+-C+, 06 4<, 6-), 1= *,404016,3 <,7, .1A2),647 -3, 614 *31*,3+D -**3,A0-4,. CD 4<, *,A0-+ ,*24D1))077016,3><0+,*-7706@4<,0)*2@6,.13.,3 - 9 - 5 6 72A< A03A2)74-6A,7 06 )D A1670.,3,. /0,> 4<-4 4<, )-44,3 3,B203,7 3,A1670.,3-4016 -4 4<, <-6.7 1= 4<, 1)*,4,64 24<1304D AA13.06@+D *-77 4<, =1++1>06@; 0 <,>304*,40401607 00 <, 13.,3 .-4,. 5 5 5 *-77,. CD4<,*,A0-+,*24D1))077016,3 -7 *,366,E23, 07B2-7<,. 000<, )-44,3 07 3,)044,. C-A? 41 4<, 1)*,4,64 24<1304D =13 =3,7< A1670.,3-4016 <, 1)*,4,64 24<1304D 7<-++ A1670.,3 4<, )-44,3 CD ,E4,6.06@ 1**1342604D414<,*,404016,3741*24=134< 4<,03A+-0)CD*+-A06@3,+,/-64.1A2),647 ><0A<-3,*+-A,.C,=13,4<07123413-6D 14<,3 .1A2),647 >04<06 -6 124,3 +0)04 1= 70E)164<7 0/++A164,640167-3,+,=41*,6 !+, )(!* ( 0741;+1;F