- 1 - !"# $"% &% "'' () * ! " # $ % $ $$ $ # # & ! $ ' ( "%$$ $ ' $ ()) $$) ' ' $ '$ $$ $$ ' ''$ ( ' $ # $ ' # # * $ * + $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %" ,-. /001/2 -. 3-214 56 7,1 /00122/879:;02/-8/87 51-8</<<=-1>14567,1?@4<;187:3/9A@-77/24/714()) 0/..14-8$$:) 567,1 442$->-2 @4<1/84 '$# ,-B/=-0@=/"3:=.,:=7C7,17=-/2$:@=7C% ,1 :8+521 @0=1;1 $:@=7 -8 7,1 9/.1 :3 $' $ > $=10:=714-8 )$$$()#/70/=/<=/0,):37,1?@4<;187# ,/.:5.1=>14/.@841=* C ! " # $ ! ! % & ! % ! ' ! ! ( )*+ , C ( 87,12-<,7:3 7,1:8+521@0=1;1$:@=7+.=19187 92/=-3-9/7-:8 :3 7,1 21</2 0:.-7-:8# -7 -. 8:D 1>-4187 7,/7 7,1 /00122/87# 51-8< 7,1 9:;02/-8/87 @841= 197-:8 ( :3 - 3 - 1<:7-/521 8.7=@;187. 97# # -. /2.: 187-7214 7: 3-21 /8 /001/2 /</-8.7 7,1 ?@4<;187 :3 /9A@-77/2 0/..14 56 7,1 7=-/2 $:@=7513:=17,11..-:8.$:@=7#.-891,1-.9:8.-41=147:51/ >-97-; 3 7,-. $:@=7 D1=1 7: 0=:9114 7: ,1/= /84 419-41 7,1 /001/2/77,-..7/<1#-79:@24410=->17,10/=7-1.:3/8/>/-2/521 3:=@;#-17,-.$:@=7#3:=3@=7,1=9,/2218<1 -;-2/= >-1D ,/. 5118 7/B18 56 7,1 -<, $:@=7 :3 84,=/ =/41., -8 $ ' =10:=714-8)$$ E567,1-<, $:@=7 :3 /4,6/ =/41., -8 > =1841=14 -8 $=-;-8/2 001/2 :&):3)419-414:8)(=4 @26#)E/84-87,19/.1:3 > =10:=714-8 ) $$ E /84 -8 > =1841=14$=-;-8/2 001/2: :3) 419-414 :8 .7 @26# )E 7,1 419-.-:8 :3 -<, $:@=7 :3 $,/77-.</=, -8 > =1841=14 -8 $F : () :3 ) 419-414 :8 7, @26# ); /84 -8 > =1841=14-8 $F :& :3)&419-414:87, @26#)E7,1?@4<;187:37,-.$:@=7 - 4 - -87,19/.1:3 > ' =1841=14-8 $ :))) 419-414:8(.7 @26#) /84-8 > =1841=14 -8 $=-;-8/2 001/2::3)419-414:8(=4 @26#)E7,1 419-.-:8:3-<,$:@=7:3 12,--87,19/.1:3 $ > =1841=14 -8 $=-;-8/2 001/2 :& :3 ) 419-414 :8 (7, :>1;51=# ) /84 7,1 419-.-:8=1841=14567,1$:G:=4-8/71189,:37,-.$:@=7-87,1 9/.1 :3 > =1841=14 -8 $=-;-8/2 001/2 :)) :3 )419-414:87,:>1;51=#) 8:>1=/22/..1..;187 :3 7,1 /3:=1.7/714 419-.-:8. =1>1/2. 7,/7 7,1 419-.-:8 :3 7,1 :8+521 @0=1;1 $:@=7 -8 7,1 9/.1 :3 $ ' $ ".@0=/% ,/. 5118 =12-14 @0:8 56 7,-. $:@=7# /. D122 /. :7,1= -<,$:@=7./9=:..7,19:@87=6 $:8.-41=-8< 7,1 /5:>1# -7 -. 411;14 3-7 7,/7 7,1 0=1.187/001/2517=/8.31==147:7,19:891=814/00122/71$:@=7 :31..-:8./84519:8.-41=14/./8/001/2@841=7,10=:>-.: 7:197-:8(:3#)("3:=;1=26197-:8(:3$=$% - 5 - /848@;51=14/99:=4-8<26 99:=4-8<26#0=:91147:0/..7,1 3:22:D-8<* - 1<-.7=6 -. 4-=19714 7: 7=/8.31= 7,1 187-=1 =19:=4 :3 7,1 9/.1# -892@4-8< 7,1 =1A@-.-7-:814 9:0-1. :3 7,1 7=-/2 9:@=7 19:=4.# 7: 7,1 9:891=814 =-89-0/2 -.7=-97 H 1..-:8. @4<1# D,: ;/6 /..-<8 -7 7: 7,1 9:891=814 00122/71 $:@=7 ,/>-8< 7,1 ?@=-.4-97-:8 /84 3:= D,-9, 0@=0:.1#-7D:@24512-.714513:=17,1=-89-0/2 -.7=-97H1..-:8. @4<1E -- ,1 9:891=814 7=/8.31=11 9:@=7 -. 4-=19714 7: -..@1$:@=78:7-917:5:7,7,10/=7-1.7:/001/= 513:=17,19:891=814$:@=7#/847,19:891=814 $:@=7# 7,1=1/371=# .,/22 0=:9114 D-7, 7,1 9/.1 -8/99:=4/891D-7,2/DE --- 8 9/.1 7,1=1 /=1 /002-9/7-:8. 0184-8< 3:= 9:84:8/7-:8 :3 412/6 := /86 :7,1= 0184-8< /002-9/7-:8.# 7,1 ./;1 /2.: 51 7=/8.31==14 7: 51 9:8.-41=14 56 7,1 21/=814 @4<1 :3 7=/8.31=11$:@=7#-8/99:=4/891D-7,2/DE -> $:8.-41=-8<7,13/977,/77,1;/771=,/.5118 0184-8< 3:= 9:8.-41=/521 7-;1# 7,1 00122/71 $:@=7 -. =1A@1.714 7: ;/B1 /8 1841/>:@= 7: - 6 - 4-.0:.1 :3 7,1 ;/771= /. 1I014-7-:@.26 /. 0:..-521E > ,1 /00122/87 -. 01=;-7714 7: 9/==6 :@7 8191../=6 /;184;187 -8 7,1 9/@.1G7-721 /84 /2.:7,10=:>-.-:8.7,1=1:3E >-7-.;/41921/=7,/77,-.$:@=7,/.8:7;/41 /86 :5.1=>/7-:8 /. 7: 7,1 ;1=-7. :3 7,1 9/.1 /84/22=-<,7./849:87187-:8.:37,10/=7-1./=1 2137 :018 7: 51 /<-7/714 513:=1 7,1 $:@=7 9:891=814 87,12-<,7:37,1/5:>1:5.1=>/7-:8/844-=197-:8.# /001/2.7/84.4-.0:.14:3 +, ( &%) % -.7:*(2:*&