- 1 - !"! #$"% &" ! $ ' ()'*+, ('++ & ! "# $ # % & ## & '( # "# $ ##% #& ) &#$ % ) & $*% # # '(!'! $ +!!'! % # & && # )(+ )!) ' '+) $%*) &## & Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & # & * , * $# , *% --./01234'(!'! 5031236708490:;0 4.9:48112:243<=2/:92-:<310//243/.160<2-;.9 /2::236 <: 231;<3.9 <92/236 4.: 92>0 4+!!'! 9062/:0901 7? </@2 #4=2-0 :<:243 <2-;.9 12/:92-: 849 :;0 48803-0/ 5.32/;<7=0 .3109 0-:243/ )(+ )!) ' '+ ) $% 90<1 A2:; 0-:243 ) 48 # 2/ 708490 :;2/ 4.9: .31090-:243 )48 ;<9<:2?<<6<92@<.9<@/;<<3;2:< !'!)/00@236906.=<97<2= ! 0<91:;0=0<9301-4.3/0=849:;05<9:20/ ) & 23 92>0 4+!!'! A</ 9062/:0901 7? :;0 </@2 #4=2-0 :<:243 <2-;.9 12/:92-: <6<23/: :;0 50:2:24309 ;09023 849 :;0 <8490/<21 48803-0/ 43 :;0 7</2/ 48 :;0 829/: - 3 - 23849><:243 1<:01!'' !'! 90-02B01 894> :;0 B2-:2>629= <601 <74.: ?0<9/ .9236 :;0 -4.9/0 48 23B0/:26<:243 48 :;0 -</0 :;0 50:2:24309 ;09023 A</ <990/:01 43 !' !'! <31 /.7/0C.03:=? 90><3101 :4 D.12-2<= -./:41? ;0 23B0/:26<:24348:;0-</02/-4>5=0:01<31:;0-;<960/;00: ;</ 7003 82=01 <6<23/: :A4 509/43/ ;0 50:2:24309 2/ <99<26301 </ <--./01 4 23 :;0 -;<960/;00: ;0 7<2= <55=2-<:24382=017?:;050:2:24309708490:;0:92<=4.9:239= 2/-4)) !'! 2/90D0-:0143!+'!'! ;0908490;0 2/708490:;2/4.9: 0<9301 -4.3/0= 849 :;0 50:2:24309 /.7>2:/ :;<: :;0 50:2:24309 2/ < /:.103: <601 <74.: ?0<9/ ;0 23B0/:26<:24348:;0-</02/-4>5=0:01<31:;0-;<960/;00: ;</ <=90<1? 7003 82=01 509./<= 48 :;0 ><:092<= 43 90-491 A4.=1 64 :4 /;4A :;<: :;0 50:2:24309 <31 :;0 B2-:2>629= A09023=4B0<31:;0902/<10=<?4884.91<?/23/.7>2::236 :;0 829/: 23849><:243 --491236=? ;0 59<?/ :4 <==4A :;0 50:2:243 #09 -43:9< =0<9301 26; 4.9: 4B093>03: #=0<109 ;</ 4554/01 :;0 50:2:243 0 /.7>2:/ :;<: :;0 - 4 - B2-:2>629= ;</ 34: 43=? ><10 <==06<:243 <6<23/: :;0 50:2:2430923;09829/:23849><:243<3123;09:<:0>03:><10 .3109 0-:243 + 48 9# 7.: <=/4 23 ;09 /:<:0>03: 90-49101 .3109 0-:243 + 48 9# 3 :;0 0B03: :;0 50:2:243092/03=<9601437<2=;02/=2@0=?:4:<>509A2:;:;0 594/0-.:243 A2:30//0/ --491236=? ;059<?/ :4 12/>2// :;0 50:2:243 + 3 :;0 829/: 23849><:243 :;<: A</ /.7>2::01 43 !'' !'! :;0B2-:2>629=<601<74.: ?0<9/ ;</ /:<:01 :;<::;050:2:24309A;42/894>;09B2==<60A</50/:09236;09 :4 =4B0 ;2> ;0 B2-:2>629= <==0601=? ;<1 90D0-:01 ;2/ 59454/<=<3123/52:048:;0/<>0;0A</-4>23670;231;09 <31 50/:09236 ;09 :4 =4B0 ;2> ;0 ;</ /:<:01 :;<: ;09 5<903:/;<1<99<3601;09><992<60A2:;430<6<=236<<31 :;0 ><992<60 A</ /-;01.=01 :4 70 ;0=1 43 ' !'! 3 +' !'! <: <74.: '' 5> A;03 /;0 A</ A</;236 -=4:;0/ 30<9 < *0== 23 ;09 B2==<60 :;0 50:2:24309 A;4 -<>0 :;090 -<.6;: ;4=1 48 ;09 <31 5.==01 ;09 849-27=? 23/210 :;0 7<:;944> <31 ;<1 /0E.<= 23:09-4.9/0 A2:; ;09 <6<23/: ;09 A2/; *;03 /;0 90/2/:01 :;0 <-: 48 :;0 50:2:24309 ;0 - 5 - <==0601=? <//<.=:01 ;09 <31 :;90<:0301 :4 -4>>2: ;09 >.9109 28 /;0 23849>/ <74.: :;0 23-2103: :4 <3?741? 0<9236 ;09 -9? ;09 5<903:/ -<>0 :4 :;0 5=<-0 <31 :;0 50:2:24309 <==0601=? 9<3 <A<? 3 /52:0 48 :;0 23-2103: <==0601=? ;<1 :<@03 5=<-0 43 +' !'! :;0 829/: 23849><:243 2/ 70=<:01=? /.7>2::01 43 !'' !'! ;0 ><:092<= 43 90-491 A4.=1 64 :4 /;4A :;<: :;0 50:2:24309 <601<74.:?0<9/2/</:.103:<312/23:;0-./:41?894> !' !'! 43A<91/ ;0 23B0/:26<:243 48 :;0 -</0 2/ -4>5=0:01 <31 :;0 -;<960/;00: ;</ 7003 82=01 ;0 -43:23.01 10:03:243 48 :;0 50:2:24309 23 :;0 -./:41? A4.=1 <1B09/0=? <880-: ;2/ 8.:.90 594/50-:/ <31 -<9009 ;0 <==06<:243><1023:;0-;<960/;00:<6<23/::;050:2:243092/ 90C.2901:470594B0123<8.==8=01601:92<=;0:92<=23:;0 -</0 2/ ?0: :4 -4>>03-0 <31 :;0 594/0-.:243 23 <== ;</ -2:01!'-;<960/;00:A2:30//0/23:;0590/03:-</0 ( 3109 :;0 -29-.>/:<3-0/ <> 48 :;0 4523243 :;<:59<?09><107?:;050:2:2430923:;050:2:2433001/:4 70<3/A0901<8829><:2B0=?--491236=?:;084==4A23649109 - 6 - ;050:2:2432/<==4A01 ;0 50:2:24309 2/ 1290-:01 :4 70 03=<9601 43 7<2= 23 92>04+!!'! 48</@2#4=2-0:<:243<2-;.912/:92-: 9062/:0901849:;048803-0/5.32/;<7=0.31090-:243/)(+ )!) ' '+ ) $% 90<1 A2:; 0-:243 ) 48 # 5031236 23 4'(!'! 5031236 708490 :;0 4.9: 48 112:243<=2/:92-:<310//243/.160<2-;.9/2::236<: 231;<3.9/.7D0-::4:;084==4A236-4312:243/ <%;050:2:24309/;<==0E0-.:0509/43<=7431849< /.> 48 /''''' A2:; :A4 /.90:20/ 849 :;0 =2@0/.> :4 :;0 /<:2/8<-:243 48 :;0 D.92/12-:243<= 4.9:F 7%;0 50:2:24309 /;<== <550<9 906.=<9=? 43 <== :;0 1<:0/48;0<9236708490:;092<=4.9:.3=0//:;0 92<= 4.9: 0E0>5:/ ;2/ <550<9<3-0 849 B<=21 90</43/F -% ;0 50:2:24309 /;<== 34: 1290-:=? 49 231290-:=? :;90<:03 49 :<>509 A2:; :;0 594/0-.:243 A2:30//0/F - 7 - 1%;0 50:2:24309 /;<== 34: 23B4=B0 23 /2>2=<9 48803-0/238.:.90F 0%;0 50:2:24309 /;<== 34: =0<B0 :;0 D.92/12-:243 48 :;0 92<= 4.9: A2:;4.: 509>2//243 48 :;0 /<21 4.9: .3:2= :;0 -</0 9062/:0901 <6<23/: ;2> 2/ 12/54/01488 -, '% &" !+ " 2/:4=4+ #