Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 8920 (KAR)
SEVANTI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WA/200011/2025 · 2025-02-11
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8920 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8920 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! " #$% !&
#$% %
""' ( )
""' ( )
!"!#
$ %&#
'
!# ( & (
##&& !#
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"#
!!#
)#
&* !( & !!#
# +(( && #
#
#&
((
!"!#
# +
&
!"!#
,#
&
!"!#
#
&
!"!#
- 3 -
-#
+
&
!"!#
!#
&
!"!#
!!#
&
!"!#
!"#
&
!"!#
!)#
&
!"!#
!#
- 4 -
&
!"!#
!#
&
!"!#
! #
&&
&
!"!#
!,# &
&
!"!#
!# &
&
!"!#
!-#
&#&
&
!"!#
- 5 -
"#
&
&
!"!# $
%&
#&##(!). #&(,'
(( ( (%'/ %' (
!,#!"#""
&
###"),
"" & ( & &( & (
(#
)
!"!# $ %&#
'
- 6 -
!# ( & (
##&& !#
"#
!!#
)#
&* !( & !!#
# +(( && #
#
#&
((
!"!#
# +
&
!"!#
,#
&
!"!#
- 7 -
#
&
!"!#
-#
+
&
!"!#
!#
&
!"!#
!!#
&
!"!#
!"#
&
!"!#
!)#
- 8 -
&
!"!#
!#
&
!"!#
!#
&
!"!#
! #
&&
&
!"!#
!,# &
&
!"!#
!# &
&
- 9 -
!"!#
!-#
&#&
&
!"!#
"#
&
&
!"!# $
%&
#&##(!). #&(,'
(( (
!#!#"" & ###"-! "" & #"-! "" ( & &( & (
( #
&
(
(
(
0&
##
0&
#
- 10 -
&%$ %0&
##'
123 44567 8#"!! "" 96: ;55< =275> ;? 395 6445776<3@6772<A2<BC5:328<481328<8=39581>518=7561<5> 2<A75C>A5>635>!,#!"#""634616:*%2D'6<>%D'2< ##8#"),
""# < 351E: 8= 395 :62> >215@328<: 398CA93957561<5>2<A75C>A596>:536:2>5395<832@5 2::C5> ;? ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 6: 15A61>: @8<D5<2<A 395 E5532<A 38 @8<:2>51 395 E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@5 72;513? F6: 15:51D5> 38 395 4532328<51 38 E8D5 =15:9 E8328<8=<8*@8<=2>5<@52<6@@81>6<@5F23976F#
"# ##8#"!"
"" 96: ;55< E8D5> ;? 395 15:2>5<3 8= 395
676A96< 16E6 6<@96?63 @96775<A2<A 395 81>51 8= 7561<5> 2<A75 C>A5 >635> !#!#"" 46::5> 2< ##8#"-! "" F9515;? 395 7561<5> 2<A75 C>A5 96> >2:E2::5> 395 123 532328< @6772<A 2< BC5:328<395<832@563<<5GC15*H(IF9515;?395::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 96> :8CA93 38 @8<D5<5 6 E5532<A 38 @8<:2>51 395 E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@5 F92@9 418@5:: F6:
- 11 -
2<232635> @8<:5BC5<3 38 395 72;513?
15:51D5> 2< 395 81>51 46::5>2< ##8#"),
""# )# : ;839 395 123 44567: 157635 38 E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@5 6: 15A61>: 395 15:2>5<3 8= 16E6 6<@96?63F982:3956445776<32<;839395E63351:;839 395 123 44567: 615 36J5< C4 =81 @8<:2>516328< 38A53951 6<>>2:48:5>8==;?6@8EE8<KC>AE5<3# # 95 =6@3: 756>2<A 38 =272<A 8= ##8#"!! "" 615 3963 395 6445776<3 F6: 575@35> 6: 5E;51 8= 676A96< 16E6 6<@96?63 6<> :C;:5BC5<37?575@35>6:>9?6J:968<!##"")# # 3 2: E6>5 8C3 =18E 395 =6@3: 3963 @51362< 5E;51: 8= 16E6 6<@96?63 96> :C;E2335> 6 15415:5<36328< 38395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 2K6?64C16 3918CA9 395 6<@96?63 5D5784E5<3 ==2@51 %' =81 @8<D5<2<A 8= 395 E5532<A 38 @8<:2>51 395 E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@56A62<:3>9?6J:966<>46>9?6J:968=395 16E6 6<@96?63# 95 D672>23? 8= <832@5 2::C5> ;? 395 ::2:36<38EE2::28<51@6E538;5@96775<A5>8<D6128C:
- 12 -
A18C<>:F92755D5<3C677?6778F2<A395 123532328<2<395 =8778F2<A351E:* *"+
,-),
!" #
$
%
& '
!(
& # ) * )
+) +
!"
+ ,
!(-
&
%%
%
% %
% . ( , / ! + 0 1 2
% .3 4 + ! &
+
% 1 51 + 6 2
% .7 88 ) 9 ) %
!"
!(-
&
7
!(
&
%)
%+ %%
%
- 13 -
+
% $% 8-
%
)
0 1 6 $ 3 2
% .3% 788(
:
(
%)
!(7
&
2
% ;) <++% + 7 %
+
%) 2
%
;) <++% 7% %% 9
+
%
7
) +
!(7
%
%+
!( +
% +
%
& =2 ! (>:,
3% 7 +
!( +%
+
%
& =2 ! (>:, % + +
+
%
+
%
+
% 7
%
+
+ +
> &
# 7
? - 14 -
# &? D213C5 8= 395 81>51 46::5> 2< 5==5@3 395 7561<5> 2<A75 C>A5 F9275 A16<32<A 4613267 15725= 96> <8 >8C;3 :53 6:2>5 395 <832@5 2::C5> ;? 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51;C396>A16<35>72;513?38395
5E;51:8= 16E6 6<@96?63 38 E8D5 6 =15:9 E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@52<351E:8=3958;:51D6328<:E6>5# ,# <:8=61 6: :C@9 81>51 8= 395 7561<5> 2<A75 C>A5 395 4532328<51 96: @96775<A5> 395 A16<3 8= 72;513?
6::5132<A396339515F6:<8418D2:28<38A16<3:C@972;513?# # <351E:8=5@8<>18D2:8385@328<-8=395 61<636J6 16E F616K 6<> 6<@96?63 @3 !--) LH395 @3I =81 ;15D23?M 39515 615 15:312@328<: 6: 15A61>: 38 E8D2<AE8328<8=<8*@8<=2>5<@5# %2' 2392<395=21:339213?E8<39:%2<351E:8= =21:3418D2:8385@328<-%!'M. %22' <@5 6 5:87C328< 96: ;55< <5A632D5> ;? 395 16E6 6<@96?63 <8 =15:9 <832@5 8= <8* @8<=2>5<@5@6<;5A2D5<F2392<3F8?561:=18E395
- 15 -
>635 8= 395 >5@2:28< 8= 395 16E6 6<@96?63 %2< 351E:8=921>418D2:8385@328<-%!'M -# 8 @6:5 2: E6>5 8C3 3963 395 E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@5 E8D5> 2: 2< D2876328< 8= 5@8<> 6<> 921> 418D2:88=5@328<-%!'8=395@36:<815:87C328<=81<8 @8<=2>5<@5F6:5D51<5A632D5>6<>6@@81>2<A7?F5=2<><8 A18C<>: =81 2<351=515<@5 2< 395 81>51 8= 7561<5> 2<A75 C>A5>635>!#!#""46::5>2< ##8#"-! ""# !# <:8=61 6: ##8#"!"
"" 395 @96775<A5 2: 38 395 <832@5 8= ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 15A61>2<A 395 E8328<8=<8*@8<=2>5<@5E8D5>@8<:5BC5<33839572;513? A16<35> ;? 395 7561<5> 2<A75 C>A5 2< ##8#"),
""# 95 7561<5> 2<A75 C>A5 ;? 6 >536275> 81>51 96: @8<:2>515> 677 395 @8<35<328<: 6<> 15K5@35>395 123532328<E6J2<A8;:51D6328<:6:=8778F:* %2' 95 15415:5<36328< ;? 395 5E;51: F6:
15@52D5> ;? 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 6<> <83 395 6<@96?63 5D5784E5<3 ==2@51 6<> 6@@81>2<A7? 395 @8<35<328< 15A61>2<A 395 1875 8= 6<@96?63
- 16 -
5D5784E5<3==2@51:2<@8<:2>512<A395E8328<8=H<8* @8<=2>5<@5I96:;55<<5A632D5>. %22' : 15A61>: 395 @8<35<328< 3963 3F8
5E;51:
96> <83 451:8<677? :C;E2335> 15415:5<36328< 38 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 23 F6: 957> 3963 39515 2: <8 E635126738:C44813395:62>@8<35<328<. !!# 95 :62> 81>51 96: ;55< @96775<A5> 162:2<A D6128C: @8<35<328<:F92@9615@8<:2>515>6:;578F* %2' 95E8328<8=H<8*@8<=2>5<@5I2:6775A5>3896D5 ;55< @8<:2>515> @8<3161? 38 C75 )%!' 8= 395 61<636J6 6<@96?63 6K %E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@5 6A62<:3 >9?6J:96 6<> 46>9?6J:96 8= 16E6 6<@96?63' C75: !-- 2<:8=61 6: 395 6<@96?63 5D5784E5<3 ==2@51 96: 2<D87D5> 92E:57= 2< :C@9 418@5::>5:4235C75:<83451E2332<A2<D87D5E5<38= 395 6<@96?63 5D5784E5<3 ==2@51# : 15A61>:
:C@9 @8<35<328< 23 EC:3 ;5 <832@5> 3963 7561<5> >>2328<67 8D51<E5<3 >D8@635 96: =275> 6< ==2>6D23 678<AF239 >8@CE5<3:# 3 2: 38 ;5 <832@5>
- 17 -
3963E8328<8=H<8*@8<=2>5<@5I2::8CA9338;5E8D5> ;? 6 15415:5<36328< 38 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 >635> )!#!"#"" 6<> :C@9 <832@5 96: ;55< 6@J<8F75>A5> ;? 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 92E:57=#(C13951<832@5F6:2::C5>C<>51C75)%"' 2<(81E*";?395::2:36<38EE2::28<513918CA9395 5E;51: 6<> 6@@81>2<A7? 395 1875 8= 6<@96?63 5D5784E5<3 ==2@51 2: <83 >5E8<:31635># D5< 83951F2:5 6<? =6@27236381? 6@328< ;? 395 6<@96?63 5D5784E5<3==2@51F92@9>85:<8396D53955==5@3 8= 2<351=512<A F239 395 5G51@2:5 8= 48F51 ;?
395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 81 =C<@328<6125: 6C39812N5> 386@3C<>51395418D2:28<:8=395@381C75:@6<<83 ;5351E5>38;56<2775A675G51@2:58=48F51# %22' 3 F6: @8<35<>5> 3963 395 E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@5 F6: <83 :C;E2335> 451:8<677? ;? 3F8 81E815
5E;51:6:F6:15BC215>C<>51C75)%"' 8= 395 C75:# : 15A61>: :C@9 @8<35<328< 395 7561<5> >>2328<67 8D51<E5<3 >D8@635 F6:
- 18 -
>215@35>38=275==2>6D238=395@8<@51<5>#<4616*" 8=395==2>6D23=275>;?395::2:36<38EE2::28<51 23 2: :3635> 3963 !)
5E;51: 8C3 8= ! 5E;51:
451:8<677? 6445615> 8< )!#!"#"" 63 !#! 4#E# 6<>96>A2D5<39515415:5<36328<#C@9:36<>36J5< 8<==2>6D2315BC215:38;56@@5435>6<>395152:<8 156:8< 38 >8C;3 :C@9 D51:28< 8= 395 8D51<E5<3 ==2@267#3 F8C7>;56441841263563392:KC<@3C1538 36J5<8358=395D25F8=7561<5>2<A75C>A52<395 @6:5 8= $./.01.23. 145.673 $.8.1 D:# 39 ::4:7.67 ;;4::4691 9/<.=; =2 4>4:46 .6867391!F95152<6:2E2761 @8<35<328<162:5> F6:15K5@35>F92758;:51D2<A396339515BC215E5<3:
C<>51 395 C75: 2<@7C>2<A 15A61>2<A 415:5<@5 8= 5E;51:6339532E58=:C;E2::28<8=<832@538E8D5 395 E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@5 38 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 615 8<7? =81 395 6::C16<@5 8= ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 6<> 8<@5 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 2::C5: <832@5 23 @8C7> ;5 @8<:31C5>
1 (2008) SCC Online Kar 750
- 19 -
3963395418@5>C15:96D5;55<@8E4725>F239#C@9 5G476<6328< ;? 395 7561<5> 2<A75 C>A5 15BC215: 6@@5436<@5# %222' <:8=61 6: 395 @8<35<328< 3963 395 <832@5 8= E8328<8=<8*@8<=2>5<@52:15BC215>38;5:C;E2335> 2<(81E*6:415:@12;5>C<>51C75)%!'8=395C75:
6<>=C13951<832@538395
5E;51:2:15BC215>38;5 2<646132@C761=81EF92@996:<83;55<6>9515>38 :6E5 15BC215: @8<:2>516328<# 95 E515 E5<328< 8= 418D2:28<: 8= 5@328<: - " 6<> ) 2< 395 <832@5 2::C5> ;? 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 F277 <83 36J5 6F6? 23: :C;:36<32D5 @8E4726<@5 F239 395 C75 6<> =81E63 6: 395 :C;:36<@5 8= 395 <832@5 >635> !#!#"" 2< 395 415:5<3 @6:5 2: :C==2@25<3 6: 2: 15BC215>C<>51C75:# %2D' <:8=61 6: 395 @8<35<328< 3963 395 E8328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@5 :C;E2335> 38 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51F6:<836@@8E46<25>F239641848:5> 5:87C328< 8= <8*@8<=2>5<@5 6: 15BC215> C<>51 C75
- 20 -
)%!' 8= 395 C75: 395 415@2:5 BC5:328< 96: ;55< @8<:2>515> 2< 395 @6:5 8= .?;.>>. D:# 7.79 .16.7.5."952D2:28<&5<@98=392:8C132<395 6=815:62>>5@2:28<96:8;:51D5>3963395OE515<8<* 5<@78:2<A41848:67F8C7>;58<7?6<2115AC76123?6<> 2< 8C1 D25F >85: <83 @6C:5 6<? 415KC>2@5 38 395 83951 :2>5P# 92: 8C13 2: 67:8 8= 395 D25F 3963 395 <832@538E8D5395E8328<8=<8*@8<=2>5<@5@8<362<: 395:C;:36<@58=E8328<8=<8*@8<=2>5<@56:F5776<> 6@@81>2<A7?F5=2<>:C;:36<3267@8E4726<@5F239C75 )%!'8=395C75:6<>E515<8<*5<@78:2<A8=@84?8= 41848:5>E8328<8=<8*@8<=2>5<@5@6<<83;5351E5> 38;56<2115AC76123?8=6E6<>6381?15BC215E5<3# %D' <:8=616:395@8<35<328<3963<832@5:F515<83 :51D5>38677395
5E;51:8=39516E66<@96?63 395 ::2:36<3 8EE2::28<51 96: 2< 395 ==2>6D23 6>D5135> 38 2::C6<@5 8= <832@5 8< 395
5E;51: 63 4616*) 8= 395 ==2>6D23 6<> <<5GC15*H"I 678<AF239 395 ==2>6D23 =275> 15=51: 38 5D2>5<@5 8= :51D2@5 8=
2 (2007) 3 AIR KAR R 189
- 21 -
<832@58<395
5E;51:6<>F9515
5E;51:F515<83 415:5<3 8< 395 =6E27? E5E;51: 8= :C@9
5E;51:# 95
5E;51: 96D5 <83 @8E4762<5> 8= :C@9 <8<* :51D2@5 6<> 2< 395 6;:5<@5 8= 6<?
:C@9 :36<> ;? 395E 395 6445776<3 @6<<83 ;5 6AA125D5> ;? <8<* =8778F2<A8=3963418@5>C15# @@81>2<A7? F5 =2<> <8 156:8< =81 2<351=515<@5 F239 395 81>51 8= 7561<5> 2<A75 C>A5 >635> !,#!"#"" 63 4616:*%2D'6<>%D'2< ##8#"),
""# @@81>2<A7?395 12344567:615
8)
' !&( %
8)
'% ( %