Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 8876 (KAR)

HANAMANT @ HANAMANTAPPA S/O RAMAGONDAPPA v. PARASHURAM S/O BASAPPA HOSPETI AND ANR

MFA/200075/2019 · 2025-02-03

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! " # # $$% & ' ( ! " #$$ % $ & $ $' ! & $ ( $ $' ! " #$ ( &) $ % LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.04 15:45:25 - 0800 - 2 - ( ( *+ #% ( ( ' &!*&! ++&! ( ( ( $ $ , ' ( -....! $ $( /$ ( ' 0$ # # 0$ % 123456171238149:;8-17<:35612==177285284561 71238149:;8-17<:356131-=:84185:& !& '>56 561 9:8-185 :< 7123814 9:;8-17 2==123>8? <:3 @:56 561 =235>1- 56>- A25513 >- 52B18 <:3 4>-=:-27 56:;?6>5>--72514<:324A>-->:8 - 3 - !+ $1>8?2??3>1C14@D561E;4?A1852842F234@D 561 3>@;827 >8 :++&! 42514 &!*&! 2F234>8? 9:A=18-25>:8 :< -& !!! 561 =15>5>:813 >- >82==127613>@;8272F234149:A=18-25>:82-;8413 7 : 124- :A=18-25>:8 F23414 8E;3D=2>8284-;<<13>8?- -&!!!! & 14>9271G=18-1- -&&!!! + 551842859623?1-9:8C1D2891 9623?1-<::42848:;3>-6A185 -&!!! :--:<2A18>5>1- -&!!!! :527 -& !!! ! 61 92-1 =;5 <:356 @D 561 2==177285 @1<:31 561 3>@;827F2-5625:8&&!+&! 252@:;5*+!=AF6>71 61 F2- 3>4>8? 6>- A:5:39D971 2 23 @123>8? 1?: &+*!:F814@D56131-=:84185:284>8-;314@D 31-=:84185:&92A1>832-628481?7>?185A28813284 42-6145:561=15>5>:81331-;75>8?>8561299>41851F2- 24A>5514 5: $ :-=>527 25 >E2D2=;32 284 5618 :-=>527 25 $17?2;A 61312<513 561 =15>5>:813 62- 2==3:29614 561 3>@;827 -11B>8? 9:A=18-25>:8 <3:A 561 :F813284>8-;313:<561:<<184>8?923 - 4 - ! 61 31-=:84185 :& >8-;32891 9:A=28D 31->-514561=15>5>:89:85184>8?562556143>C13:<561923 F2- 8:5 6:74>8? 2 C27>4 43>C>8? 7>918-1 284 56131 F131 C>:725>:8 :< 513A- 284 9:84>5>:8- :< 561 =:7>9D 284 27-: 5625 561 9:A=18-25>:8 972>A14 >- 6>?67D 1G:3@>5285 >A2?>823D284;85182@71 ! <513 <32A>8? :< 561 2==3:=3>251 >--;1- 1C>41891F2-714284561=15>5>:813F2-1G2A>8142- ' 284 G 5: . F131 A23B14 >8 561 1C>41891 61 31-=:84185-4>48:5712428D1C>41891 !* <513 6123>8? @:56 561 =235>1- 561 3>@;827 62- 2F234145619:A=18-25>:82-2@:C1 ! 6171238149:;8-172==123>8?<:3561=15>5>:813 F:;74 -;@A>5 5625 561 9:A=18-25>:8 2F23414 @D 561 3>@;827>-:85617:F13->41613>@;82762-414;95142 -;A:<-&!!!:;5:<561A14>927@>77-F6>96>-8:5 -;-52>82@71 >8 72F 1 27-: =:>85- :;5 5625 561 9:A=18-25>:8;84135616124:<7:--:<2A18>5>1-F2-8:5 2F234145:561=15>5>:813 - 5 - !. 13 9:8532 561 7123814 9:;8-17 2==123>8? <:3 561 31-=:84185 :& F:;74 41<184 561 >A=;?814 E;4?A185 9:85184>8? 5625 561 3>@;827 624 314;914 561 A14>927@>77-->89191352>824C2891@>77-F13127-:>897;414 >8 561 7>-5 1 -;@A>5- 5625 561 9:A=18-25>:8 2F23414 ;8413 561 31A2>8>8? 6124- >- 2==3:=3>251 284 8: >84;7?1891>-31H;>314 ! 61=13;-27:<561319:34-F:;74-6:F5625561 =15>5>:813 624 -;-52>814 <3295;31 :< 561 7:F13 184 :< 561 5>@>2284<>@;726:;?6>A=;?814E;4?A1854:1-8:5>8 4152>7A185>:82@:;5561825;31:<561>8E;3>1--;<<1314>5 2--1--1-5619:A=18-25>:8972>A142842F23414561-2A1 2-2@:C16141=:->5>:8:<561=15>5>:813F:;74-6:F5625 61624-;<<1314<3295;31:<56171<5<1A;3<3295;31:<71<5 5>@>29:A=31-->:8<3295;31:<284&61=13;-27:< G F:;84 9135><>9251 F:;74 -6:F 5625 56131 F2- <3295;31 :< A>4 -62<5 :< 561 71<5 <1A;3 F>56 4>-=7291A185 <3295;31:<5614>-527+34:<71<55>@>29:AA>8;514<3295;31 :<A>4-62<5:<56171<5<>@;7228427-:5619:A=31-->:8:< 561 284 & C1351@32 6131<:31 61 F2- 24C>-14 5: 52B153125A185256>?613<29>7>5>1-284561-1>8E;3>1-F131 ?3>1C:;->8825;31 - 6 - 5 >- =135>8185 8:51 5625 561 825;31 :< 561 >8E;3>1- -;<<1314 @D 561 =15>5>:813 62- 8:5 @118 =3:=137D 9:8->41314@D5613>@;827>8561>A=;?814E;4?A1858 ;A=5118 8;A@13- :< E;4?A185- :< 561 3>@;827- 56>- :;35 :@-13C1- 5625 561 825;31 :< 561 >8E;3>1- 284 561 A288136:F>5F:;745328-7251>85:<;895>:8274>-2@>7>5D231 -174:A 4>-9;--14 61 3>@;827- 231 E;A=>8? 5: 561 9:897;->:8 :8 561 @2->- :< 561 4>-2@>7>5D -52514 @D 2 A14>927 :<<>913 8:8 A185>:8>8? :< 561 825;31 :< 561 >8E;3>1--;<<1314):341-93>@>8?561A->A=7D2-?3>1C:;-:3 ->A=71) F:;74 8:5 31<7195 5625 561 3>@;827- 624 2==7>14 561>3 A>84 5: 561 825;31 :< 561 >8E;3>1- 6131<:31 >5 >- 1G=19514<3:A5613>@;827-5625561825;31:<561>8E;3>1- -;<<1314 284 561 A28813 6:F >5 F>77 5328-7251 >85: <;895>:827 4>-2@>7>5D >- 5: @1 -52514 >8 561 <295- 284 9>39;A-52891- 1-=19>277D F>56 31<131891 5: 561 2C:925>:8 :< 561 =15>5>:813 5 >- 27-: :@C>:;- 5625 561 A14>927 :<<>913-F:;74?>C1561>3:=>8>:8>831-=195:<561=6D->927 4>-2@>7>5D@;5561D2318:592=2@71:<?>C>8?561<;895>:827 4>-2@>7>5D 2- 561 2C:925>:8 :< 561 >8E;314 >- 8:5 @3:;?65 - 7 - @1<:31 561A 61-1 2-=195- 62C1 @118 172@:32517D 4>-9;--14 @D 561 :8@/71 =1G 9:;35 >8 561 92-1 :< 6131<:31 >5 >- 8191--23D5625561:<<>913-F6:231A288>8?5613>@;827- 231 5: @1 -18->5>I14 F>56 561 31H;>31A185 :< A185>:8>8? 561 825;31 :< 561 >8E;3>1- -;<<1314 @D 561 >8E;314 >8 561 E;4?A185- '>56:;5 561 41-93>=5>:8 :< >8E;3>1- 284 9: 31725>8?>55:5614>-2@>7>5D>5>-8:5=:-->@715:>8<135625561 3>@;827- 624 2==7>14 561>3 A>84 5: 2--1-- 561 <;895>:827 4>-2@>7>5D & 8 561 92-1 :8 6284 >5 >- 8:5 561 92-1 :< 561 =15>5>:813 5625 61 62- -;<<1314 2 =13A28185 4>-2@>7>5D 31-;75>8? >8 314;95>:8 :< >89:A1 6131<:31 61 62- 8:5 1G2A>814 28D A14>927 :<<>913 5: 2--1- 561 4>-2@>7>5D 284 =72914 28D A2513>27 >8 5625 31?234 8413 561-1 9>39;A-52891-5613>@;82762-5:-51=>85:561-6:1-:< 561=15>5>:8132842--1--5614>-9:A<:3561A2D-;<<131>8 6>-C:925>:8 1 (2011) 1 SCC 343 - 8 - + :8->413>8? 561 825;31 :< 561 >8E;3>1- -;<<1314 2- 41-93>@14 -;=32 >5 F:;74 @1 =3:=13 5: 2F234 2 9:A=18-25>:8 :<-!!!! ;8413 561 6124:<=2>8284 -;<<13>8? >8-5124 :< -&!!!! 2- 2F23414 @D 561 3>@;827 61 =15>5>:813 972>A- 5625 61 >- 2 8;3-1 >8 2 6:-=>527 @;5 81>5613 >89:A1 62- 8:5 @118 =3:C14 8:3 314;95>:8>8>89:A1>-1-52@7>-61461299>418562452B18 =7291>8561D123&! :8->413>8?5618:5>:827>89:A1:< -*! =13 A:856 >5 928 -2<17D @1 -2>4 5625 61 F2- ;82@71 5: 31-;A1 6>- F:3B 25 712-5 <:3 2 =13>:4 :< !& A:856-6131<:3161>-185>5714<:32-;A:<-*!G &J-*!!;84135616124:<7:--:<>89:A14;3>8? 56172>4;==13>:4 613>@;82762-2F234142-;A:<-&!!! 5:F234-5612551842859623?1-9:8C1D28919623?1-<::4 284 8:;3>-6A185 C>41857D 561 =15>5>:813 F2- -6><514 5: $ :-=>527 25 >E2D2=;32 284 5618 :-=>527 25 $17?2;A56:;?661>-62>7>8?<3:A>E2D2=;326131<:31 - 9 - 2-;A:<-+!!!!>8-5124:<-&!!!>-2F234145: 6>A ;8413 561 6124 :< 255184285 9623?1- 9:8C1D2891 9623?1-<::42848:;3>-6A185 613>@;82762-2F234142-;A:<-&!!!! 9:A=18-25>:8;84135616124:<7:--:<2A18>5>1->87><1 C>41857D61@1>8?28;3-1>82:-=>527F:;74-;<<1331-5 :<6>-7><1F>564>-2@>7>5>1-23>->8?:;5:<561<3295;31-5:561 <1A;35615>@>2284<>@;726131<:31>5F:;74@1=3:=13 5: 2F234 2 -;A :< - !!!! >8-5124 :< -&!!!! ;84135616124:<7:--:<2A18>5>1->87><1 * 61 9:A=18-25>:8 2F23414 @D 561 3>@;827 ;841356131A2>8>8?6124-4:8:531H;>3128D>8513<131891 @D56>-:;35 1891 561 =15>5>:813 >- 185>5714 <:3 2 5:527 18628914 9:A=18-25>:8 :< -. !! ;8413 561 <:77:F>8?6124- - 10 - 7 : 124- :A=18-25>:8 F23414 @D56>-:;35 2>8284-;<<13>8? -!!!! & 14>9271G=18-1- -&&!!! + 551842859623?1- 9:8C1D28919623?1- <::42848:;3>-6A185 -+!!!! :--:<2A18>5>1- - !!!! :--:<>89:A14;3>8? 72>4;==13>:4 -*!! :527 1--F23414@D561 3>@;827 -+&!! -& !!! :5271862891A185 -. !! . 1891 2==127 41-13C1- 5: @1 277:F14 >8 =235 6131<:31561<:77:F>8?) 612==127>-277:F14>8=235 612==177285>-185>5714<:32-;A:<-. !!>8 244>5>:8 5: F625 62- @118 2F23414 @D 561 3>@;827 27:8?F>56>85131-5255613251:< K=2<3:A4251 :<=15>5>:85>775614251:<41=:->5 - 11 - 1-5 :< 561 :3413 =2--14 @D 561 3>@;827 31?234>8? 41=:->515931A2>8;82751314 1?>-53D 5: -184 2 9:=D :< 56>- E;4?A185 5: 561 238252B2 ;4>9>27 9241AD <:3 >8<:3A25>:8 >8 41C>->8? 532>8>8?=3:?32AA1- 4 % # ' # >-5:7: