Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 8844 (KAR)

AMBANNA AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

WP/200183/2025 · 2025-01-23

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! " !!#$# % &$"$ ' ( ! " # # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka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