- 1 - ! "# !$ %! #&& '()'*&+,-'++ % !"#$## % "&#'# ( ' )")!) * "&#'# ( * Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - +!& ')#$$'$+ &$)$'#& #+& , !# , -./ 01120345627 289.:5 +!& :; 7./ ;.326 <= 9-2 0112330598:>130.5059 0//0.3.5? 9-2 46?>259 056 :7627 :; 08@4.9903 60926 ')#$$'$+ 10//26 <= 9-2 66.9.:503 .A.3 46?2 056 :479 09 030<470?. .5 :&$)$'#& $ 2076 9-2 3207526 8:45/23 ;:7 9-2 011233059 -272/1:56259B-:.//27A26.59-2>09927-0/72>0.526 45"72172/25926<2;:729-./:479 + -2 8:>130.5059 -06 .5.9.0926 17:8226.5?/ 0?0.5/9 9-2 72/1:56259 ;:7 9-2 :;;2582 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5 #+& :; 2?:9.0<32 5/97489.:5/ 89 #&&# ;:7 - 3 - /-:79C 89D<2;:729-297.03:479.5 :&$)$'#& 9 ./ 9-2 /128.;.8 80/2 :; 9-2 8:>130.5059 9-09 9-2 72/1:56259-06<:77:B260/4>:;/'''''";7:>9-2 8:>130.5059 ;.50582 8:>105= 647.5? 9-2 =207 $'#! 056 9:B076/ 7210=>259 :; 9-2 <:77:B26 0>:459 -2 -06 .//42608-2@42<207.5? :'+)60926$'$'#&;:7 0/4>:;/'''''"670B5:5E./05F412707F29 7058- 030<470?. -2 /0.6 8-2@42 :5 172/25909.:5 9: 9-2 05F B0/ 6./-:5:4726 B.9- 05 256:7/2>259 0/ C/.?509472 6.;;27/D -2720;927 9-2 8:>130.5059 -06 ?:9 .//42632?035:9.829:9-272/1:56259056/.582.5/1.92:; /27A.82 :; 32?03 5:9.82 9-2 72/1:56259 -06 ;0.326 9: 10= 9-2 0>:459 8:A2726 45627 9-2 8-2@42 .5 @42/9.:5 9-2 8:>130.5059 -06 .5.9.0926 17:8226.5?/ 0?0.5/9 9-2 72/1:56259 ;:7 9-2 :;;2582 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5 #+& :; 89 47.5?9-28:47/2:;97.03.5/411:79:;.9/80/2 9-2 8:>130.5059 -06 2E0>.526 .9/ 1079527 0/ # 056 - 4 - 050?27:;9-205F0/ $056#$6:84>259/B272?:9 >07F260/E#9:E#$ 5/411:79:;-./62;258252.9-2705=2A.62582 B0/ 326 5:7 05= 6:84>259/ B272 >07F26 <= 9-2 72/1:56259 -2 97.03 :479 <= 9-2 .>14?526 46?>259 056 :7627 08@4.9926 9-2 72/1:56259 ;:7 9-2 :;;2582 145./-0<3245627289.:5#+&:; 890560??7.2A26<= 9-2/0>29-28:>130.5059./<2;:729-./:479 ) 207526 8:45/23 ;:7 9-2 8:>130.5059 /4<>.9/ 9-099-29705/089.:5<29B2259-21079.2/-0/<22517:A26 <=17:648.5?5282//07=6:84>25907=2A.62582<2;:729-2 97.03 :479 -2 .//40582 :; 8-2@42 .5 @42/9.:5 ./ 5:9 .5 6./1492 -2 172/4>19.:5 9-09 07:/2 0?0.5/9 9-2 72/1:56259-0/5:9<22517:1273=72<499269-272;:729-2 97.03 :479 :4?-9 9: -0A2 8:5A.8926 -.> ;:7 9-2 0332?26 :;;25822/4<>.9/9-09623.<270923=9-272/1:56259-0/ 0;;.E260B7:5?/.?509472:59-28-2@42.5@42/9.:5B.9- 05 .59259.:5 9: 8-209 9-2 8:>130.5059 ;.50582 8:>105= 88:76.5?3=-2170=/9:033:B9-2011203 - 5 - ! 2;:72 9-2 97.03 :479 9-2 1079527 :; 9-2 8:>130.5059";.50582 8:>105= ./ 2E0>.526 0/ # 056 050?27 :; 9-2 05F B-: -0/ .//426 9-2 8-2@42 729475 >2>: 09 E ./ 2E0>.526 0/ $ E# ./ 9-2 8-2@42 .5 @42/9.:5 E$ 056 E+ 072 9-2 3:05 0113.809.:5 056 7282.19 :; 9-2 3:05 /0589.:526 E ./ 9-28-2@42729475>2>:E./9-232?035:9.82.//426 :5 <2-03; :; 9-2 8:>130.5059 056 E) ./ 9-2 1:/903 7282.19056E!./9-217:;2//.:5038:47.27D/7282.19056 E& ./ 9-2 1:/903 08F5:B326?2>259 EG ./ 9-2 9705/089.:5.5@4.7=056E#'./9-2049-:7.H09.:5329927 :; #E##./9-2:0526?27056E#$./9-2 7213=5:9.82 & -28-2@42.5@42/9.:5-0/<22572947526B.9- 0 <05F27D/ 256:7/2>259 C/.?509472 6.;;27/D 9 ./ 9-2 /128.;.8 62;2582 :; 9-2 72/1:56259 9-09 -2 -06 .//426 0 8-2@42099-29.>2:;<:77:B.5?9-23:050//2847.9=056 9-2/0.68-2@42-0/<225>./4/26<=9-28:>130.5059056 9-217:8226.5?/B272.5.9.09260?0.5/9-.>;:79-2:;;2582 - 6 - 145./-0<3245627289.:5#+&:; 8947.5?9-28:47/2 :;87://"2E0>.509.:5:; #.9.//128.;.8033=/4??2/926 9-09 09 9-2 9.>2 :; /0589.:5.5? 9-2 3:05 9B: <305F 8-2@42/B2727282.A26<=9-2;.505828:>105=0//2847.9= ;:7 9-2 3:05 /0589.:526 056 9-2 /0.6 8-2@42/ B272 >./4/26<=9-2;.505828:>105= -28-2@42.5@42/9.:5 -0/5:B<22572947526<=9-205FB.9-05256:7/2>259 C/.?509472 6.;;27/D -272;:72 9-2 62;2582 149 ;:7B07626 <= 9-2 72/1:56259 ?29/ 17:<0<.3.H26 056 2A2594033= 9-2 172/4>19.:59-0907:/20?0.5/9-.>45627289.:5#+G:; 89?29/72<49926 G E ./ 9-2 8-2@42 729475 >2>: 056 456./149263=9-2/0.68-2@426:2/5:9<2079-2/.?509472 056 /203 :; 9-2 05F -272 ./ 0 /128.;.8 /4??2/9.:5 9: $<=9-262;25829-090/1279-28.784307.//426<=9-2 2/27A2 05F :; 56.0 9-2 05F 8055:9 .//42 8-2@42 729475>2>:B.9-:49/203056/.?509472 $-0//90926 9-09-2./5:90B072:;05=/48-8.784307<49/0.68.784307 B0/ 17:64826 <2;:72 9-2 7.03 :479 <= 9-2 62;2582 056 - 7 - 9-2 7.03:479-0/2E97089269-28:59259/:;9-28.784307.5 1070?701- : ## :; .9/ I46?>259 7206.5? :; 9-2 8.784307B-.8-././/426:5$'!$'##B:436?:9:/-:B 9-099-205F/B272/128.;.8033=06A./269:/.?5.5.9.039-2 8-2@42 729475 >2>:/ 056 .//4.5? 8-2@42 729475 >2>:/ B.9-:49 /203 056 /.?509472 ./ /0.6 9: <2 .5 A.:309.:5 :; .5/97489.:5/ 8:590.526 .5 5.;:7> 2?4309.:5/ 056 432/ ;:7 05F27/D 3207.5? :4/2/ B-.8- ./ .//426 45627 10=>259056/29932>25989$''!7206B.9-0=>259056 29932>259 =/92>/ 2?4309.:5/ $''& 9 ./ .5 9-./ <08F?7:4569-2 7.03:479-0/08@4.99269-272/1:56259 ;:79-2:;;2582145./-0<3245627289.:5#+&:;9-2 89 056 9-272;:72 .9 8055:9 <2 /0.6 9-09 9-2 I46?>259 056 :7627:;08@4.990310//26<=9-2 7.03:479./17.>0;08.2 .332?03:7127A27/2.5509472 #' 5627 9-2 8.784>/90582/ 0> :; 9-2 :1.5.:5 9-099-2.>14?526I46?>259056:7627:;08@4.99038055:9 <2 .5927;2726 B.9- 88:76.5?3= 9-2 ;:33:B.5? :7627 ./ 10//26 - 8 - -287.>.503011203./ ., '$ %! + ! ./9 :#3 :$