- 1 - ! "# !$ %! # &'&()*'+&)) *% #'+ &'+&()*'+&)) * % !"#$ % & ' ()) Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *(( ) !"#"$+ % & ## , $*) ( ,( &',#( &' $, ( (( $"&'#&'#&'&'#&' &'&' " ( $ ( ( * ( * ( '+* % +$ -) " % & ' ()) - 3 - *(( ()) ) % & ## , $*) ( ,# ( &' ,#( &' ( $, ( (( $ "&' #&'"&'#&'#&'&'#&'&'&'&' " ( $ ( ( * ( * ( ( . & . ' //012341546786924$,82:6152823 ;< =;=>21?@=8 4>6/25=56476A=<=B08C485?24CC27/21 B0761?=;>2 07328 2/56471 $ "&' #&' #&' &' #&' &'&' =73 " 4C $ =82 - 4 - ;2C482 5?61 4085 67 5?212 5@4 B25656471 C6>23 07328 2/56471,#=73,#4C $=735?282C4825?2< =82 ?2=83 54:25?28 =73 361B4123 4CC ;< 5?61 /49947 48328 2=83>2=8723/40712>C485?2B=85621 ( 67 8692 4$, @=1 82:6152823 ;< =;=>21?@=8 4>6/2 5=5647 6A=<=B08 =:=6715 5?2 B2565647281?28267C485?2=C4821=634CC27/21475?2;=1614C C6815 67C489=5647 3=523 +$, 82/26D23 C849 47:861=; 4 0301=; =:=82 0867: 5?2 /40812 4C 67D2156:=5647 =//0123 41 =73 " @282 =8821523 47 $$,?2;=6>=BB>6/=5647C6>23;<5?29;2C4825?2 A086136/5647=>21164714085678> 61/4#"$,@=1 82A2/523 47 $, ?282C482 5?2< =82 ;2C482 5?61 4085 67 86967=> 2565647 4$$$$" //0123 41,=73=BB82?27367:5?268=88215675?21=63/=12 ?=3 C6>23 8> 61/4#$, ;2C482 5?2 A086136/5647=> 2116471 4085 @?6/? @=1 82A2/523 47 $, - 5 - ?282C482 5?2< =82 ;2C482 5?61 4085 67 86967=> 2565647 4$$$,#$" , 2=8723/40712>C485?2B256564728110;96515?=5 =//01234615?2C=5?28=73=//01234154=82?61 /?6>3827 7 821B2/5 4C 5?2 67/63275 67 E0215647 5?=5 ?=3 5=F27 B>=/2 47 $, = /=12 =73/407528/=12?=1 ;227 82:6152823 ?282 61 = /6D6> 361B052 ;25@227 5@4 C=96>621 @?6/? ?=1 8210>523 67 5?2 929;281 4C 5?2 5@4 C=96>621C6:?567:=:=67152=/?45?2847$,D27 =//0123 B281471 67 5?2 B821275 /=12 ?=D2 10CC2823 :862D40167A08621675?267/6327567E0215647?2<34745 ?=D2 =7< /86967=> =752/232751 //48367:>< ?2 B8=<1 54 =>>4@5?2B25656471 " 28 /4758= >2=8723 6:? 4085 4D2879275 >2=328 =BB2=867: C48 821B473275 4 ?=1 4BB4123 5?2 B25656471?210;96515?=567D2156:=56474C5?2/=1261156>> 07328 B84:8211 =73 ?27/2 /015436=> 6752884:=5647 4C 5?2 =;1/47367: =//0123 B281471 61 72/211=8< //48367:>< 1?2B8=<15436196115?2B25656471 - 6 - 2801=> 4C 5?2 9=5286=> =D=6>=;>2 47 82/483 @40>3 :4 54 1?4@ 5?=5 =//0123 B281471 67 8692 4$, =73 5?2 C6815 67C489=75 =73 45?28 67A0823 B281471 =82 =>> />412 82>=56D21 ?282 61 = /6D6> 361B052 ;25@227 5?2 5@4 C=96>621 @?6/? 61 B27367: ;2C482 5?2 A086136/5647=> 6D6> 4085 5 =BB2=81 5?=5 67 5?2 ;=/F:84073 4C 5?2 /6D6> 361B052 ;25@227 5@4 B=85621 47 $, =5 =;405 #$$ B9 5?2< ?=3 C40:?5 =:=6715 2=/?45?28=73675?21=6367/63275929;2814C;45?5?2 C=96>621?=D210CC2823:862D40167A08621?2(678692 4$, @=1 82:6152823 ;< =;=>21?@=8 B4>6/2 =:=6715 19=71=;=73?61/?6>3827475?2;=1614C5?2C6815 67C489=564782/26D23C84947:861=;75?2;=1614C5?2 C6815 67C489=5647 82/26D23 C849 19=71=; ( 67 8692 4$$$, @=1 82:6152823 ;< =;=>21?@=8 4>6/2 5=5647 6A=<=B08 C48 5?2 4CC27/21 B0761?=;>2 07328 2/56471#&'#&'#&'&'&,'=73 "4C $=:=671547:861=;=7316G45?281 - 7 - + 2801=>4C5?2(6786924$$$,@40>3 82D2=> 5?=5 19=71=; =73 ?61 5@4 /?6>3827 ?=3 10CC2823 67A08621675?267/6327567E0215647054C5?82267A0823 5@4 4C 5?29 ?=D2 10CC2823 :862D401 67A08621 7 5?2 B821275/=12=//012341=73"?=D2;227=8821523 47 $$, =73 9=A48 B485647 4C 5?2 67D2156:=5647 61 =>82=3</49B>2523 7361B0523><B256564728134745?=D2 =7< /86967=> =752/232751 =73 5?2< ?=D2 073285=F27 54 /44B28=52@65?5?2B4>6/2C485?2B08B4124C67D2156:=5647 # 7328 5?2 /68/0915=7/21 =9 4C 5?2 4B67647 5?=5 5?2 B8=<28 9=32 ;< 5?2 B2565647281 C48 :8=75 4C 82:0>=8 ;=6> =73 =756/6B=548< ;=6> 72231 54 ;2 =71@2823 =CC689=56D2><//48367:><C4>>4@67:4832861B=1123 ?2B25656471=82=>>4@23 ?2 B2565647281=//0123 41 =73 " 67 86967=> 2565647 4$$$$" =82 3682/523 54 ;2 27>=8:23 47 ;=6> 6786924$,4C =;=>21?@=8 4>6/25=5647 6A=<=B08 82:6152823 C48 5?2 4CC27/21 B0761?=;>2 07328 - 8 - 2/56471 $ "&' #&' #&' &' #&' &'&' =73 " 4C $ B27367: 47 5?2 C6>2 4C >2=8723 3365647=> 6D6> 03:2 =73 ( 6A=<=B08 10;A2/5545?2C4>>4@67:/473656471 =' 2565647281=//0123 41 =73 " 1?=>> 2G2/052 B28147=> ;473 C48 = 109 4C 1$$$$$! 2=/? @65? 5@4 10825621 C48 5?2 >6F2109 54 5?2 1=561C=/5647 4C 5?2 A086136/5647=> 4085H ;' 2565647281=//0123 41 =73 " 1?=>> =BB2=8 82:0>=8>< 47 =>> 5?2 3=521 4C ?2=867: ;2C482 5?2 86=> 4085 07>211 5?2 86=> 4085 2G29B515?268=BB2=8=7/2C48D=>6382=1471H /' 2565647281=//012341=73"1?=>>745 3682/5><48673682/5><5?82=527485=9B28@65?5?2 B8412/05647@65721121H 3' 2565647281=//012341=73"1?=>>745 67D4>D2671696>=84CC27/2167C05082H 2' 2565647281=//012341=73"1?=>>745 >2=D2 5?2 A086136/5647 4C 5?2 86=> 4085 @65?405 B289611647 4C 5?2 1=63 4085 0756> 5?2 /=12 82:6152823=:=67155?2961361B41234CC - 9 - ?2 821B473275 ! 4>6/2 48 =7< 45?28 B4>6/2 67 5?2 5=52 4C )=87=5=F= =82 3682/523 54 82>2=12 5?2 B2565647281=//0123 41 , =73 67 86967=> 2565647 4$$$,#$" 67 5?2 2D275 4C 5?268 =88215 67 8692 4$, 82:6152823 ;< =;=>21?@=8 B4>6/2 15=5647 6A=<=B08C485?24CC27/21B0761?=;>2073282/56471$ "&' #&' #&' &' #&' &'&' =73 " 4C $ B27367: ;2C482 5?2 4085 4C 3365647=>6D6>03:2=73 (6A=<=B0810;A2/5545?2 C4>>4@67:/473656471 =' 2565647281=//0123 41 , =73 1?=>> 2G2/052 = B28147=> ;473 C48 = 109 4C 1$$$$$! 2=/? @65? 5@4 10825621 C48 5?2 >6F2109 54 5?2 1=561C=/5647 4C 5?2 67D2156:=567: 4CC6/28H ;' 2565647281=//0123 41 , =73 1?=>> 82:0>=8>< =BB2=8 ;2C482 5?2 86=> 4085 @65?405 C=6>07>2112G29B523;<5?286=>4085C48D=>63 82=1471H /' 2565647281=//0123 41 , =73 1?=>> 745 5=9B28@65?5?2B8412/05647@65721121=735?2< - 10 - 1?=>>/4!4B28=52@65?5?2B4>6/2C4867D2156:=5647 =73=BB2=8;2C4825?29@?272D28/=>>230B47H 3' 2565647281=//012341,=731?=>>745 67D4>D2671696>=84CC27/2167C05082 -* &$ %! ) ! 6154>4 )