- 1 - !" # ! $$ %&'%(( # !"!#$ % & ' ( )!"!#* +* !"!#$ % & ( ( ' Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( +&'&' ( &' ( , +&'&' ( -#+ ( ( ( & ' -+#+ ( (( "-&'-&'&,'!&'"&'#-,! #,&'-# (#, ,&'&.'&/',&'&0' ( ( 1 ! & 1 ' 223/45 6, 78 9427:; :/4 & ' 6-+#+ 948578< =4>6.4 ?@4 263.? 6> 55; 7/?.72? A 4//768/ 35<4 :;:=3.:<7 :.7/78< 63? 6> .7B4 6-#+ .4<7/?4.45 =C 8704./7?C 6;724 ?:?768 :;:=3.:<7 >6. 6>>48/4/ 9387/@:=;4 3854. /42?768/ "-&' -&'&,' !&' "&' #- ,! #,&' .D -# 6> @:.:?7C: C:C: :8@7?: #, :85 3854. /42?768 ,&'&.'&/' A ,&'&0' 6> 2? -"* 7/ =4>6.4 ?@7/ 63.? 78 :994:; >7;45 3854. 42?768 +&'&' 6> 2? - 3 - ://:7;78<?@46.54.5:?45,##+9://45=C?@4263.? 6>55;7/?.72?A4//768/35<4:;:=3.:<7789427:; :/4& '6-+#+D@4.478?@4:99;72:?768>7;45=C ?@4 :994;;:8? 3854. 42?768 +", 6> @:.:?7C: :<:.7E 3.:E/@: :8@7?: #, /44E78< .4<3;:. =:7; @:/ =448 .4F42?45 4:.5?@4;4:.8452638/4;>6.?@49:.?74/ , ( 78 .7B4 6-#+ D:/ .4<7/?4.45 =C 8704./7?C6;724?:?768>6.?@46>>4824/9387/@:=;43854. /42?768/"-&'-&'&,'!&'"&'#-,!.D -# 6> @:.:?7C: C:C: :8@7?: #, :<:78/? 684 :.38 3B:.:85>7046?@4./68?@4=:/7/6>?@4>7./?78>6.B:?768 5:?45 #-#+ .4247045 >.6B .4/968548? 6 @4.478 D@67/?@4B6?@4.6>5424:/453B44?994;;:8?@4.478 7/:..:C45:/:223/456,78?@4(3.78<?@4263./4 6> 7804/?7<:?768 @4 D:/ :..4/?45 68 #-#+ :85 /3=/4G348?;C .4B:8545 ?6 F35727:; 23/?65C 804/?7<:?768 6>?@42:/47/26B9;4?45:852@:.<4/@44?@:/=448>7;45 :<:78/?47<@?94./68/:85:994;;:8?7/:..:C45:/:223/45 - 4 - 6, 78 ?@4 2@:.<4 /@44? :7; :99;72:?768 >7;45 =C ?@4 :994;;:8? =4>6.4 ?@4 ?.7:; 263.? 78 9427:; :/4 & ' 6-+#+D:/.4F42?4568,##+ @4.4>6.4@47/ =4>6.4?@7/263.?78?@7/:994:; + 4:.845 2638/4; >6. ?@4 :994;;:8? @:078< .47?4.:?45 ?@4<.6385/3.<4578?@4:994:;@:/9.:C45?6:;;6D?@4 :994:; ! 4. 268?.: ;4:.845 7<@ 63.? 604.8B48? ;4:54. :85 ;4:.845 2638/4; :994:.78< >6. .4/968548? 6 @:04 6996/45?@49.:C4.B:5478?@4:994:;:85/3=B7?/?@:? :994;;:8? D:/ 9.4/48? :;68< D7?@ ?@4 6?@4. :223/45 94./68/:??@4/96?6>2.7B4:85:;;?@4:223/4594./68/ @:5:..7045:??@4/96?6>2.7B4D7?@:26BB6878?48?768 226.578<;C9.:C/?657/B7//?@4:994:; $ 4.3/:;6>?@4B:?4.7:;:0:7;:=;468.426.5D63;5<6 ?6/@6D?@:?>7./?78>6.B:8?H//68:2@78D:/78;604D7?@ ?@4:223/456*):7/@8:07D@67/?@4/7/?4.6>:223/45 6 :.383B:.223/456:85@7/>:B7;CB4B=4./ - 5 - D4.46996/78<?@4.4;:?768/@79:85?@4.4>6.4?@4.4D:/: >7<@? =4?D448 ?@4 ?D6 >:B7;74/ 68 -#-#+ 8 ##-#+:223/456:;68<D7?@:223/456/ ?6+ :85 :223/45 6" @:5 :..7045 84:. ?@4 @63/4 6> >7./? 78>6.B:8? 78 :8 :3?6 .72E/@:D :85 :/E45 ?@4 >7./? 78>6.B:8??69.65324@4./68:2@78=4>6.4?@4B??@:? ?7B4:223/456/!$A*:;/6:..704584:.?@4@63/46> >7./? 78>6.B:8? ? 7/ :;;4<45 ?@:? ?@4 :223/45 94./68/ G3:..4;45 D7?@ ?@4 >7./? 78>6.B:8? :85 ://:3;?45 @4. ? ?@:? ?7B4 5424:/45 3B44? D@6 7/ ?@4 C638<4. /68 6> >7./? 78>6.B:8? ?.745 ?6 78?4.>4.4 :85 :;; ?@4 :223/45 94./68/:;;4<45;C://:3;?45@7BD7?@?@47.@:85/223/45 6:/E45:223/456?6=.78<?@4E87>4D@72@D:/E49? 78 ?@4 :3?6 .72E/@:D 78 D@72@ ?@4C @:5 :..7045 226.578<;C :223/45 6 =.63<@? ?@4 E87>4 D@72@ D:/ E49? 78 ?@4 :3?6 .72E/@:D :85 :223/45 6 ://:3;?45 3B44? D7?@ ?@4 /:75 E87>4 :85 :/ : .4/3;? 3B44? D@6 /3>>4.45<.74063/78F3.C>4;;56D868?@4<.63854D:/ /3=/4G348?;C /@7>?45 ?6 : <604.8B48? @6/97?:; :? :;:=3.:<7 3? @4 5745 68 #-#+ ;;4<:?768 6> - 6 - ://:3;?78< 5424:/45 3B44? D7?@ ?@4 E87>4 7/ 68;C :/ :<:78/? :223/45 6 223/45 6, :;;4<45;C @:5 ://:3;?455424:/45D7?@@7/@:85/ 857/93?45;C:223/45 6, :994;;:8?@:/866?@4.2.7B78:;:8?424548?:85@47/ 7823/?65C>.6B#-#+804/?7<:?7686>?@42:/47/ 26B9;4?45:852@:.<4/@44?@:/=448>7;45 @4.4>6.4 :B6>?@46978768@4@:/B:5463?: 2:/4>6. <.:8? 6> .4<3;:. =:7; 8445/ ?6 :8/D4.45 :>>7.B:?704;C 226.578<;C?@4>6;;6D78<6.54. .7B78:;994:;7/:;;6D45 @46.54.5:?45,##+9://45=C?@4263.?6> 55; 7/?.72? A 4//768/ 35<4 :;:=3.:<7 78 9427:; :/4& '6-+#+D@4.478?@4:99;72:?768>7;45=C ?@4 :994;;:8? 3854. 42?768 +", 6> @:.:?7C: :<:.7E 3.:E/@::8@7?:#,/44E78<.4<3;:.=:7;7/@4.4=C/4? :/754 - 7 - 994;;:8? :223/456,7/57.42?45?6=448;:.<4568 =:7; 78 9427:; :/4 & ' 6-+#+ 948578< =4>6.4 ?@4263.?6>55;7/?.72?A4//768/35<4:;:=3.:<7 :.7/78<63?6>.7B46-#+.4<7/?4.45=C 8704./7?C 6;724 ?:?768 :;:=3.:<7 >6. 6>>48/4/ 9387/@:=;4 3854. /42?768/ "-&' -&'&,' !&' "&' #- ,! #,&' .D -# 6> @:.:?7C: C:C: :8@7?: #, :85 3854./42?768,&'&.'&/'A,&'&0'6> 2?-"* /3=F42??6?@4>6;;6D78<26857?768/ :' @4 :994;;:8? :223/45 6, /@:;; 4I423?4 94./68:; =685 >6. : /3B 6> /##### D7?@ ?D6 /3.4?74/ >6. ?@4 ;7E4/3B ?6 ?@4 /:?7/>:2?768 6>?@4F3.7/572?768:;63.?J =' @4 :994;;:8? :223/45 6, /@:;; :994:. .4<3;:.;C 68 :;; ?@4 5:?4/ 6> @4:.78< =4>6.4 ?@4 .7:; 63.? 38;4// ?@4 .7:; 63.? 4I4B9?/ @7/ :994:.:824>6.0:;75.4:/68/J 2' @4:994;;:8? :223/456,/@:;;86?57.42?;C6. 7857.42?;C ?@.4:?48 6. ?:B94. D7?@ ?@4 9.6/423?768D7?84//4/J - 8 - 5' @4 :994;;:8? :223/45 6, /@:;; 86? 7806;04 78 /7B7;:.6>>4824/78>3?3.4J 4' @4 :994;;:8? :223/45 6, /@:;; 86? ;4:04 ?@4 F3.7/572?7686>?@4 .7:;63.?D7?@63?94.B7//768 6>?@4/:7563.?38?7;?@42:/4.4<7/?4.45:<:78/? @7B7/57/96/456>> )& %" # ( 7/?6;6