- 1 - ! " # $ " %&'(%)*+&(%** $ !" # $% & ' ( ( !) # $ ' ( ) ( $ ' ( ( & ( ! ! ( Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( (( )!" ) ( "! ( ( * %( ! ! ( +% &% $ +% &% ' ,,-./0 1 23 425/ 1 ! 4/62.7/4/0 89 :02 :2;<:9 1;2,/ 7:7213 :2,=-4 >14 7=/ 1>>/3,/ ?-32.=:8;/-30/4/,7213.)!"4/:0<27=/,7213)1> 2. 8/>14/ 7=2. 1-47 -30/4 /,7213 1> !) .//@236:372,2?:71498:2; /:40;/:43/0,1-3./;>147=/?:472/. ) (23425/1 !<:.4/62.7/4/089:02 :2;<:9 1;2,/ 7:7213 :2,=-4 >14 7=/ :>14/.:20 1>>/3,/ :6:23.77=/ ?/727213/4 :307<1 17=/4. 13 7=/8:.2.1> 7=/ >24.7 23>145:7213 0:7/0 ! ! 4/,/2A/0 >415 - 3 - 4/.?130/37 1 =/4/23 <=1 2. <2>/ 1> 7=/ 0/,/:./0 1=:55/0 B2:-0023 ??4/=/30236 :44/.7 23 7=/ .:20 ,:./?/727213/4=:0>2;/04;2.,1 C !8/>14/7=/ D-42.02,7213:; /..213. 1-47 <=2,= <:. 4/D/,7/0 13 !! =/4/>14/=/2.8/>14/7=2.1-47 /:43/0 ,1-3./; >14 7=/ ?/727213/4 =:A236 4/27/4:7/07=/641-30.-46/0237=/?/727213?4:9.71:;;1< 7=/?/727213 /4 ,1374: ;/:43/0 26= 1-47 1A/435/37 ;/:0/4 =:. 1??1./0 7=/ ?/727213 13 7=/ 641-30 7=:7 7=/ 0/,/:./0 =:0 ;/>7 8/=230 : 0/:7= 317/ 5/37213236 7=/ 3:5/ 1> :,,-./0 ?/4.13. :. 7=/ ,:-./ >14 =2. 0/:7=:30 7=/4/>14/ ,-.7102:; 237/4416:7213 1> 7=/ ?/727213/4 2. 3/,/..:49,,140236;9.=/?4:9.7102.52..7=/?/727213 " /4-.:; 1> 7=/ 5:7/42:; :A:2;:8;/ 13 4/,140 <1-;06171.=1<7=:77=/?/727213/42.:042A/423 :30 :,,140236 71 ;/:43/0 ,1-3./; >14 7=/ ?/727213/4 7=/ ?/727213/4 =:0 ?:20 : .-5 1> . !!! 71 7=/ - 4 - 0/,/:./0>147=/?-4?1./1>?-4,=:./1>:3:-7142,@.=:< :30 71 187:23 : ?/4527 >14 7=/ .:5/ =/ 0/,/:./0 1=:55/0 B2:-0023 <:. : .:;/.5:3 :7 42@:;9:3 ..1,2:7/.71<=157=/?/727213/4=:0?:207=/:>14/.:20 :51-3737=/:;;/6/00/:7=317/0:7/0 ! !.:20 71 =:A/ 8//3 ;/>7 8/=230 89 7=/ 0/,/:./0 =/ =:. 5/37213/07=:7:,,-./01. 71)3:5/0237=/(:4/ 4/.?13.28;/>14=2.:,7E,/?77=/.:5/=/=:.3175:0/ :3917=/4:;;/6:7213:6:23.77=/:,,-./0>147=/?-4?1./1> 23A1@2367=/1>>/3,/?-32.=:8;/-30/4/,7213)!"1> =/:;;/6/0:,71>7=/:,,-./0.=1-;0=:A/:024/,73/E-. <27= 7=/ 0/:7= 1> 7=/ 0/,/:./0 :30 7=/ :,,-./0 .=1-;0 =:A/ :8/77/0 14 23.726:7/0 7=/ 0/,/:./0 71 ,15527 .-2,20//,/..:492364/02/37.1:.7123A1@/7=/:;;/6/0 1>>/3,/ 2. 317 >1-30 23 7=/ 0/:7= 317/ 1> 7=/ 0/,/:./0 302.?-7/0;9 ?/727213/4 =:. 31 17=/4 ,42523:; :37/,/0/37. =/ :;;/6/0 1>>/3,/ 2. 317 /E,;-.2A/;9 ?-32.=:8;/ <27= 0/:7= 14 ;2>/ 25?42.135/37 :30 7=/ ?/727213/4=:.-30/47:@/371,11?/4:7/<27=7=/?1;2,/>14 - 5 - 7=/ ?-4?1./ 1> 23A/.726:7213 ,,140236;9 >1;;1<236 140/4 2.?:../0 =/?/7272132.:;;1</0 =/ 4/.?130/37 1;2,/ 14 :39 17=/4 ?1;2,/ 23 7=/ 7:7/1>:43:7:@::4/024/,7/0714/;/:./7=/?/727213/423 7=//A/371>=2.:44/.723425/1 !4/62.7/4/089 :02 :2;<:9 1;2,/ 7:7213 :2,=-4 >14 7=/ 1>>/3,/ ?-32.=:8;/ -30/4 /,7213. )!" 4/:0 <27= /,7213 ) 1> ?/30236 8/>14/ 7=/ 1-47 1> 423,2?:; %( :;:8-4:62.-8D/,7717=/>1;;1<236,13027213. /727213/4.=:;;/E/,-7/:?/4.13:;8130>14 :.-51>. !!!!! <27=7<1.-4/72/.>147=/ ;2@/.-5 71 7=/ .:72.>:,7213 1> 7=/ 23A/.726:7236 1>>2,/4 /727213/4.=:;;4/6-;:4;9:??/:48/>14/7=/ 42:;1-47<27=1-7>:2;-3;/../E/5?7/0897=/ 42:;1-47>14A:;204/:.13. ) /727213/4 .=:;; 317 7:5?/4 <27= 7=/ ?41./,-7213 <273/../. :30 =/ .=:;; ,11?/4:7/ - 6 - <27= 7=/ ?1;2,/ >14 23A/.726:7213 :30 :??/:4 8/>14/7=/5<=/3/A/4,:;;/0-?13 /727213/4 .=:;; 317 23A1;A/ 23 .252;:4 1>>/3,/.23>-7-4/ ,+ %# $ * 2.71 ;1