Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 8783 (KAR)
MATABSAB S/O ISMAIL CHOUDARI AND ORS v. SRI. RAJABAKSHAR S/O MAHABOOBSAB MOMIN AND ANR
MFA/200149/2019 · 2025-01-31
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8783 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8783 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#"
$
#
# %%&' (
! "
## ! #$ ##%
&' (&#%!)*
+## ,#( -
&
! LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.04 15:45:34 - 0800
- 2 -
&' (&#%!)*
(
(&#%!)*
+#
,#(( . '( -
*,-
#
# #
#
& *!**) #
( &
#
#
* *! ##
&(
/&
&
# ,# /&
& -
012345673615893:;63<45=6739:>>3:;?6@85;A512 123 >:;1?37 123 B:113; ?7 1:C36 => 85; 8?6:9 <?7>57:9 125=@2?1?779:13<85;<B?77?56
2?7 :>>3:9 ?7 <?;3413< :@:?671 123 D=<@B361 :6< :E:;<<:13<*!**)?6
5* *!>:773<A0123 93:;63< 36?5; ?F?9 &=<@3 :6< 5BB?77?563; 85;
- 3 -
B>950337
5B>367:1?56?6<:@?,23;3?6:813;;383;;3<15 :7G H85;725;1-
0 123 ?B>=@63< D=<@B361 :6< :E:;< 123 5BB?77?563; 2:7 :995E3< 123 49:?B >31?1?56 ?6 >:;1 :6< :E:;<3< : 7=B 58 7!!!* % :7 45B>367:1?56 :6< <?;3413< A512 123 5E63; :6< 67=;:643
5B>:60 15 <3>57?1 123 45B>367:1?56 :B5=61 5E3F3; 23 2:7 8:71363< 123 9?:A?9?10 15 >:0 123 ?613;371 :B5=61 56 123 5E63;:9563@@;?3F3<A01237:?<D=<@B361:6<:E:;< 123>31?1?563;7:;3A385;312?7
5=;1733C?6@362:643B361 5845B>367:1?56:7E399:742:9936@?6@1239?:A?9?1015>:0 123?613;371:B5=618:71363<56;37>56<3615
3:;< 123 93:;63< 45=6739 :>>3:;?6@ 85; 123 :>>399:617 :6< 123 93:;63< 45=6739 :>>3:;?6@ 85; 123 ;37>56<3617
23 7=A71:61?:9 I=371?567 58 9:E 12:1 :;?73 85; 4567?<3;:1?56?612?7:>>3:9:;3 - 23123; 123 93:;63< 5BB?77?563; E:7 D=71?8?3< ?6 8:7136?6@ 123 9?:A?9?10 15 >:0 123
- 4 -
?613;371 56 123 45B>367:1?56 :B5=61 56 123 5E63;58123F32?493?3;37>56<3615J - 23123; 123
5BB?77?563; E:7 D=71?8?3< ?6 ;3<=4?6@ 123 E:@37 58 123 <343:73< 15 7*** %?61238:435851?8?4:1?56?77=3<A0 123
361;:95F3;6B361=6<3;341?56,-58 123 B>950337
5B>367:1?56 41 ,85; 725;1 G
H-J ! 23 8?6<?6@ 56 123 :A5F3 1E5 7=A71:61?:9 I=371?567589:EE5=9<651259<12?7
5=;185;956@58:; :78:7136?6@581239?:A?9?10561235E63;58123F32?493?7 45643;63< 123 >3K
5=;1 ?6 123 4:73 58
2:7239<:7A395E
! " ! # " # ! $
%&'()
1 ,**-! "
- 5 -
! ! #
*+ # ,---#%&'()
. //////////
# #
! # -
0
! # #
#
1
2 , &34 # 5 6 % # ! #
#
# -
#
#
#
#
! 1 2 ! # #
7
#
! "# #$ %"8(99: ;,(99<
1 # #
! ! #
%2 =
- 6 -
&'()
! ! %
1
! ! ! 1 !! %2 =
! #
! - ! ! #
,! ! ! ! 2 ! # -
# ! ##
# ! 2
! 2 1
> . ,
&4 #
%2 =
! ! 2
$ ! #
# ! #
7! # # ! # ! # ! ! ! ?
%2 =
- 7 -
56
! #
! # -
! ! #
! #
#
! #! #
! %2 =
-
#
! ! # # ! #
! ##
0 2 #56 %2 =
#
#
! #
!#
#
1
#
%2 =
#! ! #
#! ! ! #
- 8 -
! %2 =
# ! #! ! ! #
%2 =
1 #
-
! ! #
! 12
#! /////////// @ #
7
-
! 1
1
#
2! ! #
-
#
#
A
1 ?7 >3;1?6361 15 6513 12:1 ?6 : 7=A73I=361 D=<@B361 ?6 123 4:73 58 &
123 >3K
5=;1 2:7 :975 49:;?8?3<12:1?64:735812345B>367:1?56A3?6@5;<3;3<15 A3>:?<45643;6?6@:5;CB:6#59?40?1?71233B>9503;
2 ,**"-
)
- 9 -
E25?79?:A9315>:0123?613;371>5;1?56:6<>36:9106123 7:?<D=<@B361?1E:7239<:7A395E AB
- > -
6 8(99: ; , &'(< 6 2 C 8 &''4 B , &<
#
-
! # #
#
! # 5 6 &'BB
56. &'
D #
! #-
8&')B
*-
+ <
0
! # #
8<
1
2, &34 # 5 6
%
# ! # D #
# -
#
# 8< # #
D ! . 1
E >! 0
#- 8(99: ;,(99<
-
- 10 -
## 1
$
#
#56! %
!#
#
> -
6 8(99: ; , &'(< ! #
1#-
! !
A
6 12:1 F?3E 58 123 B:113;123>59?40 ?6F59F3< ?6123>;373614:73A3?6@:B515;F32?493>:4C:@3>59?40 123 67=;:643
5B>:60 ?7 239< 9?:A93 15 >:0 123 ?613;371 >5;1?56 :975 3643 123 ?B>=@63< D=<@B361 2:7 15 A3 B5<?8?3<1512:1388341 ) 58:;:712373456<7=A71:61?:9I=371?56589:E ?7 45643;63< 123 51?8?4:1?56 ?77=3< A0 123
361;:9 5F3;6B361 =6<3; 341?56 ,- 58 123
41 >;374;?A37 123 E:@37 :1 7)*** % >3; B5612 5; 123 >=;>573 58 45B>=1:1?56 58 123 45B>367:1?56 =6<3; 123 >;5F?7?567 58 123
41 ?1 ?7 7=42 651?8?4:1?56 58 123 361;:95F3;6B361E2?422:715A3:443>13<231?B390 ;3F?7?5658123E:@37651?8?3<=6<3;341?56,-58123
- 11 -
41 A3?6@ ?6 456756:643 E?12 123 ?6?B=B :@37 41 4567?<3;?6@ :60 93773; :B5=61 12:6 7)*** % B:0 651A3>3;B?77?A9323;385;3123
5BB?77?563;45=9<651 2:F3 1:C36 : 93773; :B5=61 12:6 7)*** % E236 123 361;:95F3;6B3612:7?77=3<651?8?4:1?561512:1388341 3643 56 12?7 45=61 :975 123 ?B>=@63< D=<@B361 <373;F3715A3?613;83;3<E?12
" 6 123 9?@21 58 123 :A5F3 <?74=77?56 123 45B>367:1?56?74:94=9:13<:77)***K!*LK) M7)* %6:<<?1?561512:1:7=B587!*** % 2:7 15 A3 :<<3< 15E:;<7 8=63;:9 3K>36737 2=7 123 :>>399:617 >31?1?563;7 :;3 361?193< 85; 151:9 45B>367:1?56 587)* % * 5;123:85;37:?<;3:7567123:>>3:9<373;F37 15A3:995E3<364312385995E?6@
,?- 23:>>3:9?7:995E3< ,??- 23 ?B>=@63< D=<@B361 :6< :E:;< >:773< A0123
5BB?77?563;?7B5<?8?3<
- 12 -
,???- 23 :>>399:617 :;3 361?193< 85; 151:9 45B>367:1?56587)* %15@3123;E?12 ?613;371:1L>:8;5B*<:07:813;123 <:1358?64?<3611?99?17;3:9?N:1?56 ,?F- 37>56<361 5%67=;:643 5B>:60 ?7 <?;3413< 15 <3>57?1 123 361?;3 45B>367:1?56 :B5=61:956@E?12?613;371E?12?6:>3;?5<58 85=;E33C78;5B123<:135812?75;<3; ,F- 23 93:;63<
5BB?77?563; ?7 :1 9?A3;10 15 5;<3; 123 :>>5;1?56B361 :B56@ 123 >31?1?563;7 :1 123 1?B3 58 123 <?7A=;7:9 58 12345B>367:1?56:B5=61
< % &
# ' #
?71595