- 1 - ! "# ## #$$ % ! "# $%&&& ' " && ( !!! #)* "%! ! " ! ! " ( ! !! #)* ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! + ! !" !!" (!!! "% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! + ! ! ! ' $ $ ,' # -./0012.3456" &&657-.849.687-.9./:5.3 3347465/9 .224652 '13;. /7 <21:1 42 4=>1;545; 7-. ?13;=.57 68 065@407465 /53 6:3.: 68 2.57.50. 3/7.3 %&&& 065@40745; -4= 86: 7-. 688.50.2 >1542-/A9. 153.: .074652 #)*( /53 "% 68 B /53 2.57.5045; 76 153.:;6 :4;6:612 4=>:4265=.57 86: / >.:463 68 7-:.. <./:2 /53 76 >/< 845. 68 2" ( 86: 7-. 688.50. >1542-/A9. 153.: .07465 #)*( 68 B /53 76 153.:;6 :4;6:612 4=>:4265=.57 86: / >.:463 68 7-:.. <./:2 /53 76 >/< 845. 68 2" ( 86: 7-. 688.50. >1542-/A9. 153.: .07465 "% 68 C47- 3.8/197 2.57.50.2 :4.88/072687-.0/2./2=/3.617A<7-.>:62.017465 /:.7-/77-.3.0./2.3/5?19/C/2=/::4.3767-./0012.365 - 3 - #& -.:./87.: 2-. 27/:7.3:.24345; C47- 7-. /0012.3 45 7-. =/7:4=654/9 -612. 7 42 7-. 0657.57465 68 7-. >:62.017465 7-/7 4==.34/7.9< /87.: 7-. =/::4/;. 7-. /0012.3 C/2 499(7:./745; 7-. 3.0./2.3 A67- >-<240/99< /53 =.57/99< 153.: 7-. 45891.50. 68 /906-69 /53 12.3 76 A./7 -.: -.:.A< 06==477.37-.688.50.>1542-/A9.153.:.07465#)*( 68 7 42 /926 7-. 0657.57465 68 7-. >:62.017465 7-/7 /0012.3 C/2 /A.7745;7-.06==42246568214043.A<7-.3.0./2.3/53/2/ :.2197 2-. 06==477.3 214043. A< -/5;45; 45 -42 -612. 65 #)& /7 #" >= /53 7-.:.A< -. -/2 06==477.3 7-. 688.50.>1542-/A9.153.:.07465"%68-.8/7-.:687-. 3.0./2.3963;.37-.84:274586:=/7465/2>.:D&!0/=.76 A. :.;427.:.3 /2 >.: D* -. 45@.274;/7465 C/2 06=>9.7.3 /53 7-. 0-/:;. 2-..7 0/=. 76 A. 849.3 86: 7-. /A6@. 2/43 688.50.2 " -. 9./:5.3 /;427:/7. 766E 06;54F/50. 68 7-. 688.50.2 /53 06==477.3 7-. =/77.: 76 7-. 9./:5.3 .224652 '13;. -. :4/9 61:7 21==65.3 7-. /0012.3 . />>./:.3 A.86:. 7-. :4/9 61:7 >9./3.3 567 ;1497< /53 09/4=.3 76 A. 7:4.3-.>:62.017465-/2.D/=45.3 2&76&";67=/:E.3 - 4 - D2& 76 &" /53 43.57484.3 2& 76 &* 45 21>>6:7 68 472 0657.57465 -. /0012.3 -/2 3.54.3 /99 7-. 450:4=45/745; =/7.:4/92 /@/49/A9. 65 :.06:3 45 -42 27/7.=.57 153.: .07465 "&":A17-/25670-62.5769./3/5<.@43.50.4521>>6:7 68-423.8.50.-.:4/961:7/87.:7/E45;4576065243.:/7465 /99 7-.2. =/7.:4/92 65 :.06:3 0/=. 76 7-. 0650912465 7-/7 7-. >:62.017465422100.2281945>:6@45;7-.;1497687-./0012.3/53 /006:345;9< 065@407.3 -4= 86: 7-. 688.50.2 >1542-/A9. 153.: .074652#)*( /53"%68.45;/;;:4.@.3A<7-.2/=. /0012.342A.86:.7-4261:7 # ./:3 :4 /=>/5;4 /=/4/- 9./:5.3 =4012 1:4/. 86: 7-. />>.99/57 /53 :4 /:42- /5/>/7-4 9./:5.3 86: 7-. :.2>653.57(7/7. .:12.3 7-. =/7.:4/92 65 :.06:345091345;7-.:4/961:7:.06:32 5 @4.C 68 7-. :4@/9 0657.574652 1:;.3 A< 9./:5.3 06152.986:A67-7-.>/:74.27-.>64577-/7C6193/:42.86:=< 065243.:/746542/2153.:$ - 5 - </52C.:767-./A6@.>645742,>/:79<457-./884:=/74@., 86:7-.86996C45;$ % 7 42 7-. 0657.57465 68 7-. >:62.017465 7-/7 7-. 3.0./2.3 C/2 =/::4.3 76 7-. /0012.3 65 #& -.:./87.:2-.27/:7.3:.24345;457-.=/7:4=654/9-612.-. 06==477.3214043.65#)&45-.:=/7:4=654/9-612.A< -/5;45;-.2.8/072/:.56745342>17.7427-.0657.5746568 7-.>:62.0174657-/7/87.:7-.=/::4/;.7-./0012.3C-6C/2 /33407.3 76 3:45E2 12.3 76 A./7 7-. 3.0./2.3 /53 7:./7 -.: C47-0:1.97<7-.:.A<-./A.77.306==42246568214043.A<7-. 3.0./2.3-.2.8/072/:.3.>62.3A< (7-.=67-.:687-. 3.0./2.3-.-/227/7.345-.:.@43.50.7-/7/A617& 3/<2 ./:94.:767-.45043.577-.3.0./2.3-/306=.767-.>/:.57/9 -612.7-./0012.3-/3/92606=./53 &-/3/3@42.37-. /0012.3567767:./77-.3.0./2.3C47-0:1.97<6C.@.:C47-45 & 3/<22-.06==477.3214043. - 6 - 427-..93.:2427.:687-.3.0./2.3-.-/2/926 3.>62.34524=49/:945.2 &427-.453.>.53.57C475.22-. -/227/7.37-/7-.-/3>/:7404>/7.3457-.=/::4/;.7/9E2/53 /926 2>./E2 /A617 0:1.97< =.7.3 617 A< 7-. /0012.3 76 7-. 3.0./2.3 &427-.8/7-.:687-.3.0./2.3C-6-/2849.37-. 84:274586:=/7465/2>.:D&.27/7.27-/7-.0/=.76E56C /A617-423/1;-7.:A.45;21A?.07.3760:1.97<A<7-./0012.3 -.2.=/7.:4/9265:.06:315(=427/E.59<>64572/001245;845;.: 76C/:327-./0012.3@.57-61;-7-.2.C475.22.2C.:.0:622( .D/=45.3/79.5;7-567-45;-/2A..5.94047.38:6=/5<687-.2. C475.22.276342A.94.@.7-.4:@.:2465 *5474/99<!0/=.76A.:.;427.:.386:7-.688.50.2 >1542-/A9. 153.: .074652 #)*( /53 " 68 -. /99.;/74652=/3.A<7-.4586:=/57/5367-.:C475.22.2427-/7 7-.3.0./2.3-/32127/45.32.@.:/9A6349<45?1:4.2/77-.74=. 68-.:3./7-/5347C/2/0/2.68=1:3.:17C-49.84945;7-. 0-/:;.2-..77-.5@.274;/745;8840.:-/245@6E.3.07465"% 684527./368"68 ) & 42 7-. 36076: C-6 0653107.3 >627 =6:7.= .D/=45/7465/534221.37-.:.>6:7/2>.:D& 2>.:7-42 - 7 - :.>6:7 3./7- C/2 31. 76 /2>-<D4/ /2 / :.2197 68 -/5;45; D0.>77-.94;/71:.=/:E7-.:.C.:.56.D7.:5/945?1:4.286153 65 7-. 3./3 A63< && 42 7-. /-2493/: C-6 0653107.3 45G1.27=/-/F/:/2>.:D"74256740.37-/77-.:.C.:.56 .D7.:5/9 45?1:4.2 86153 65 7-. 3./3A63< 6C.@.: -. 27/7.2 7-/7 7-.:. C.:. A9663 =/:E2 65 7-. A/0E 68 7-. 3.0./2.3 6C.@.: 7-. 2/=. C/2 567 567.3 31:45; >627 =6:7.= .D/=45/7465 -.:.86:. 47 42 09./: 7-/7 7-. 3.0./2.3 -/2 06==477.3 214043. C47-45 861: =657-2 68 -.: =/::4/;. 45 7-. =/7:4=654/9-612.A<-/5;45; & &427-.8/7-.: #42=67-.: 427-..93.: 2427.:/53 &427-.453.>.53.57C475.22C-6-/23.>62.3 /A6177-.0:1.97<=.7.3617A<7-./0012.3767-.3.0./2.37 42 21;;.27.3 76 7-. C475.22.2 7-/7 7-. 3.0./2.3 C/2 567 C49945;76=/::<7-./0012.3/537-.:.86:.2-.-/206==477.3 214043.-.2.21;;.274652/:.3.54.3A<7-.C475.22.2-.:. /:.5667-.::./265/A9..D>9/5/7465688.:.3A<7-./0012.3/2 76 C-< -42 C48. 06==477.3 214043. C47-45 861: =657-2 68 -.: =/::4/;. -.:. 42 /A26917.9< 56 :./265 76 342A.94.@. 7-. @.:24652 68 2# /53 & C-6 3.>62.3 :.;/:345; 0:1.97< - 8 - 53.: 210- 04:01=27/50.2 /= 68 7-. 6>45465 7-/7 7-. >:62.017465422100.2281945>:6@45;7-.;1497687-./0012.386: 7-.688.50.2>1542-/A9.153.:.074652#)*( /53"%68 /53-.4294/A9.86:065@407465 && 7 7-42 27/;. 9./:5.3 =4012 1:4/. 21A=472 7-/7 7-. />>.99/57 C/2 45 012763< 86: / >.:463 68 24D =657-2 -.:4/961:7-/24=>62.3=/D4=1=2.57.50.687-:..<./:2 68 :4;6:612 4=>:4265=.57 /53 C47- 845. 68 2" ( 86: 7-. 688.50. >1542-/A9. 153.: .07465 #)*( 68 4=49/:9< -. C/22.57.50.376153.:;6:4;6:6124=>:4265=.5786:/>.:463 68 7-:.. <./:2 /53 76 >/< 845. 68 2" ( 86: 7-. 688.50. >1542-/A9. 153.: .07465 "% 68 C47- 3.8/197 2.57.50.2 /537-.:.86:.-.>:/<286:2-6C45;9.54.50< & -/@. ;65. 7-:61;- 7-. 4=>1;5.3 ?13;=.57 68 065@407465/536:3.:682.57.50.>/22.3A<7-.:4/961:77 -/2065243.:.3=/7.:4/9265:.06:3/53065@407.37-./0012.3 86:7-.688.50.>1542-/A9.153.:.07465#)*( /53"%68 53.: .07465 #)*( 65 >:668 68 06==422465 68 7-. 688.50. A.<653 :./265/A9. 361A7 A< 7-. >:62.017465 7-. /0012.3 42 94/A9.86:>1542-=.57C47-4=>:4265=.5786:/7.:=C-40-=/< - 9 - .D7.53767-:..<./:2/532-/99/926A.94/A9.86:845.-.:4/9 61:7 -/2 4=>62.3 =/D4=1= 2.57.50. 65 7-. /0012.3 4=49/:9<86:7-.688.50.153.:.07465"%687-./0012.3 06193A.>1542-.3C47-4=>:4265=.5768.47-.:3.20:4>746586:/ 7.:=C-40-=/<.D7.53767.5<./:2/532-/99/926A.94/A9.76 845. -. /0012.3 C/2 2.57.50.3 76 153.:;6 :4;6:612 4=>:4265=.57 86: 7-:.. <./:2 36 567 8453 /5< :./265 76 4=>62.7-.=/D4=1=2.57.50.657-./0012.3-.45043.5745 G1.27465-/36001::.331:45;&-./0012.3C/2065@407.3 A<7-.:4/961:7@43.?13;=.573/7.3%&&&/53/A617 861:7..5<./:2-/@./9:./3<9/>2.353.:210-04:01=27/50.2 /=687-.6>454657-/79.54.50<=/<A.2-6C5458/@61:68 /0012.3(7-. />>.99/57 -.:.45 C-49. 4=>6245; 7-. 2.57.50. 006:345;9</52C.:7-./A6@.>6457,>/:79<457-./884:=/74@., /53>:60..376>/227-.86996C45;$ 4-./>>./942&''()*+,-&./B 44 -. ?13;=.57 68 065@407465 3/7.3 %&&& >/22.3 45 .224652 /2. 6" && A< 7-. 9./:5.3 3347465/9 .224652 '13;. <21:1 42 -.:.A<06584:=.3 - 10 - 444-.6:3.:682.57.50.>/22.3A<7-.:4/961:7 42=63484.3/2153.:$ / -. />>.99/57 42 2.57.50.3 76 153.:;6 24=>9. 4=>:4265=.57 86: / >.:463 68 24D =657-2 86: 7-. 688.50. >1542-/A9. 153.: .07465 #)*( 68 C47- 845. 68 2" (53.8/19776>/<845.-.2-/99153.:;624=>9. 4=>:4265=.5786:/>.:463687C6=657-2B A . 42 2.57.50.3 76 153.:;6 :4;6:612 4=>:4265=.5786:/>.:46368.4;-7=657-286:7-.688.50. >1542-/A9. 153.: .07465 "% 68 C47- 845. 68 2" (53.8/19776>/<845.-.2-/99153.:;624=>9. 4=>:4265=.5786:/>.:463687-:..=657-2B 0-.21A27/574@.2.57.50.2-/99:1506501::.579< 3 -. /0012.3 42 .57479.3 86: 2.7 688 153.: 2.07465 #*68:86:7-.>.:463-.-/2/9:./3<153.:;65.7-. 2.57.50. . -. 0650.:5.3 '/49 17-6:474.2 /:. 34:.07.3 76 @.:48< 7-. 9.5;7- 68 4=>:4265=.57 153.:;65. A< 7-. />>.99/57 /53 48 -. -/2 /9:./3< 153.:;65. 7-. 2.57.50. 4=>62.3A<7-4261:776:.9./2.-4=4==.34/7.9<48-.42 567:.G14:.345/5<67-.:0/2.2/53487-.845./=615742 3.>6247.3 - 11 - .;427:<762.53A/0E7-.:4/961:7:.06:32/965;C47-06><68 7-42?13;=.57767-.:4/961:786:4586:=/7465/535.0.22/:< /074654.764221.065@407465C/::/5748567/9:./3<4221.3 3 ( 0##1 $