- 1 - !"##" $ %%&%' ( ! "" # " " #$% &$'&$&$ " & &$( " " Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " ) *+ #" ) *+ ",-./01230,45,670680650./092-.8012-0-040--0: .,;<./08--2631;04,-0./0-82=,>-. & /81-0?>=2-48-1.29902=48=0:>6:0-05.8,6# ,4 ./0 ,:0 ,4 878= -,50:>-0 @./0 A 4,- 1/,-. 81 ;< ./0 9=286.844 5/2==06?86? ./0 B>:?C06. 26: :05-00 :2.0: &$'&$&$86 ,& &$(92110:;<./0068,-878= >:?026: "2127262?072:8@-82=,>-.A4,-1/,-. D/0-0;<1>8.48=0:;</8C4,-1905848590-4,-C2650,412=0 2?-00C06.:2.0:'$&$2?2861../0:0406:26.52C0 .,;0:81C8110: ' . 81 5,6.06:0: ;< ./0 9=286.844 ./2. :0406:26. ;086?./0,D60-,41>8.15/0:>=09-,90-.<2?-00:.,10== ./012C0.,/8C4,-21>C,41$$$$$ E26:-050870: - 3 - 2:72650 ,4 1$$$$$ E 0 2?-00: ., 0F05>.0 -0?>=2- 12=0 :00: 21 26: D/06 -0G>01.0: ;< ./0 9=286.844 ;< -0508786? ;2=2650 12=0 5,618:0-2.8,6 26: ., 9>. /8C 86 9,110118,6 0406:26. 2=1, 2?-00: ., 5=02- ./0 065>C;-26501,70-./01>8.15/0:>=09-,90-.<190-./0 861.->5.8,61 ,4 ./0 :0406:26. 12=0 2?-00C06. D21 9-092-0: ;< ./0 15-8;0 86 ./0 9-010650 ,4 /81 D840 26: 2..01.86? D8.601101 4.0- -0508786? 2:72650 ,4 1$$$$$ E:0406:26.0F05>.0:./012=02?-00C06.86 ./09-010650,49=286.84426:D8.601101..01.86?D8.601101 /270 2=1, 18?60: ./0 :,5>C06. ,D070- :0198.0 -0902.0: -0G>01. 26: :0C26: ;< ./0 9=286.844 86 ./0 9-010650 ,4 D8.601101 :0406:26. 428=0: ., -050870 ./0 ;2=26505,618:0-2.8,626:0F05>.0./012=0:00:==2=,6? 9=286.844 D21 -02:< 26: D8==86? ., 90-4,-C /81 92-. ,4 5,6.-25. 0 ?,. 811>0: =0?2= 6,.850 :2.0: $H$&$( 52==86? >9,6 ./0 :0406:26. ., 0F05>.0 ./0 12=0 :00: 61.02: ./0 :0406:26. /21 106. 26 0721870 -09=< 26: /0650./01>8. - 4 - ( 0406:26. 48=0: D-8..06 1.2.0C06. 2:C8..86? ./2. /0 81 ./0 ,D60- 86 9,110118,6 ,4 1>8. 15/0:>=0 9-,90-.< ;>. :0680: ./2. /0 /21 0F05>.0: ./0 12=0 2?-00C06. :2.0: '$&$ 26: -050870: 2:72650 ,4 1$$$$$ E0/212==0?0:./2../012=02?-00C06.812 5,65,5.0::,5>C06. ! :0406:26. /21 .2306 >9 2 :040650 ./2. ,6 &H$!&$$ /0 0F05>.0: 2 -0?81.0-0: 12=0 2?-00C06. 86 427,>- ,4 8:2?,6:2992E./0 ;-,./0- ,4 9=286.8442?-0086?.,10==1>8.15/0:>=09-,90-.<190-./0 128: 2?-00C06. 8:2?,6:2992 D21 -0G>8-0: ., 92< ;2=2650,41!$$$ E26:?0.-0?>=2-12=0:00:0F05>.0: D8./86 ' C,6./1 4.0- ' C,6./1 D/06 :0406:26. -0G>01.0:8:2?,6:2992.,92<./0;2=2650,41!$$$ E 26: ., ?0. ./0 12=0 :00: 0F05>.0: /0 :8: 6,. 5,C0 4,-D2-: 26: ./0-04,-0 :0406:26. 52650==0: ./0 128: .-26125.8,6 ! ">-./0- :0406:26. /21 2==0?0: ./2. 8:2?,6:2992:8:6,..23026<1.091.8==09.0C;0-&$' - 5 - 6 ./0 ./8-: D003 ,4 09.0C;0- &$' ./0 128: 8:2?,6:299226:/81;-,./0-262?,>:2D8././0/0=9,4 ?,,6:2 0=0C06.1 .-80: ., 38:629 ./0 :0406:26. 26: ?0. 12=0 :00: 0F05>.0: ;< 4,-50 6 ./81 -0?2-: :0406:26. 48=0:5,C9=286./068:2?,6:299226:262?,>:2.-80: ., ,;1.->5. ./0 9,110118,6 ,4 :0406:26. /0 48=0: ,!& &$' 26: 105>-0: .0C9,-2-< 86B>65.8,6 =286.844 816, ,./0-./26./0 ;-,./0- ,4 8:262?,>:2 26: 262?,>:2 == ,4 ./0C 5,==>:86? .,?0./0- /270 5-02.0: ./0;,?>112=02?-00C06.26:48=0:./01>8.26:1,>?/.4,- :81C8112=,4./012C0 210: ,6 ./0 9=02:86?1 ./0 -82= ,>-. /21 4-2C0:6050112-<811>01 H . ./0 .-82= 9=286.844 /21 0F2C860: /8C10=4 21 26:,60D8.601121&0/21-0=80:>9,6F., ( % 6 ./0 ,./0- /26: :0406:26. /21 ?8706 078:06502126:-0=80:>9,6F.,! - 6 - # 8:0 8C9>?60: B>:?C06. 26: :05-00 ./0 -82= ,>-.:81C8110:./01>8. $ ??-8070: ;< ./0 12C0 9=286.844 81 ;04,-0 ./81 ,>-.5,6.06:86?./2../0<2-08==0?2=2-;8.-2-<5,6.-2-< ., =2D 26: 425.1 /0 -82= ,>-. /21 5,C9=0.0=< 8?6,-0: ./0 ,-2= 26: :,5>C06.2-< 078:0650 . 81 ;210: ,6 865,--05. 425.1 26: 211>C9.8,61 /0 -82= ,>-. 5,CC8..0: ?-270 0--,- 86 6,. 25509.86? ./0 ,-2= 26: :,5>C06.2-< 078:0650 ,6 -05,-: . /21 2=1, 0--0: 86 5,618:0-86?./0:,5>C06.190-.28686?., ,!& &$' D/85/8148=0:2?2861.8:262?,>:226:8./216,./86?.,:, D8./ ./0 9=286.844 80D0: 4-,C 26< 26?=0 ./0 8C9>?60: B>:?C06.26::05-002-06,.1>1.2862;=026:9-2<.,2==,D ./029902=10.218:0./08C9>?60:B>:?C06.26:2==,D0: ./01>8. 6 ./0 ,./0- /26: =02-60: 5,>610= 4,- :0406:26. 1>;C8..0: ./2. ./0 9=286.844 /21 428=0: ., 01.2;=81/ /81 5210 26: :815/2-?0 ./0 ;>-:06 ,4 9-,786? - 7 - 811>01,.,!26:H 6./0,./0-/26:./0078:0650 =0: ;< ./0 :0406:26. 9-,70 ./0 425. ./2. ./0 12=0 2?-00C06. 81 5,65,5.0: 99-0582.86? ./0 ,-2= 26: :,5>C06.2-< 078:0650 9=250: ,6 -05,-: ./0 -82= ,>-. /21-8?/.=<:81C8110:./01>8.26:1,>?/.4,-:81C8112=,4 ./029902=2=1, & 02-:2-?>C06.126:90->10:./0-05,-: ' />12??-8070:;<:81C8112=,41>8.48=0:;</8C 4,- 19058485 90-4,-C2650 ,4 >6-0?81.0-0: 12=0 2?-00C06. :2.0:'$&$9=286.84481;04,-0./81,>-.8650./81 81 48-1. 29902= ./81 ,>-.81 -0G>8-0:.,-0E299-0582.0 ./0 078:0650 0406:26. /21 :0680: ./0 06.8-0 5210 ,4 ./0 9=286.8440/215,6.06:0:./2.02-=80-/0/210F05>.0:2 -0?81.0-0: 12=0 2?-00C06. :2.0: &H$!&$$ ., 10== ./0 1>8. 15/0:>=0 9-,90-.< ., 8:2?,6:2992 ./0 ;-,./0- ,4 9=286.844 26: 18650 /0 428=0: ., 92< ;2=2650 12=0 5,618:0-2.8,6 ,4 1!$$$ E 26: ?0. ./0 12=0 :00: 0F05>.0: D8./86 2 90-8,: ,4 ' C,6./1 ./0 128: 12=0 2?-00C06. 52C0 ., ;0 52650==0: 0406:26. /21 4>-./0- - 8 - 2==0?0: ./2. ./0 128: 8:2?,6:2992 .-80: ., 2;:>5. /8C :0406:26. 48=0: -8C862= 5,C9=286. 26: D/06 /0 .-80: ., 86.0-40-0 /0 2=1, 48=0: ,!& &$' 26: 105>-0: .0C9,-2-<86B>65.8,60406:26./212==0?0:./2.D/062== 044,-.1 ,4 8:2?,6:2992 D0-0 4,8=0: /0 /21 10. >9 /81 ;-,./0- 5,65,5.0: 2 12=0 2?-00C06. 26: 48=0: ./81 >6-8?/.0,>11>8. ( F 81 ./0 ,-:0-E1/00. F& 81 ./0 9=286. F'81./0D-8..061.2.0C06.F(81./0-0B,86:0-48=0: ;< 8:2?,6:2992 86 ,!& &$' /0 128: 1>8. D21 48=0: ;< :0406:26. /0-086 4,- 90-C2606. 86B>65.8,6 86 -01905. ,4 1>8. 15/0:>=0 9-,90-.< 2?2861. 8:2?,6:2992 ./0 ;-,./0- ,4 9=286.844 /0-086 6 ./0 128: D-8..06 1.2.0C06. 8:2?,6:2992 /21 .2306 >9 2 :040650 ./2. 9=286.844 /2: ;,--,D0: 2 1>C ,4 1&$$$$$ E 4,- /81 42C8=< 6050118.< 26: 0F05>.0: F! ;< D2< ,4 105>-8.< D8./ 26 >6:0-1.26:86? ./2. D/06 /0 -092< ./0 128: 2C,>6. 8. D,>=: ;0 52650==0: 0 C2:0 2 5,>6.0- 5=28C - 9 - 4,- -04>6: ,4 1&$$$$$ E D8./ 86.0-01. ,D070- ./0 5,6.06.1,4F!2-0,./0-D810 ! /,>?/ ./0 128: 8:2?,6:2992 :819>.0: ./2. F!D21212=02?-00C06.26:,6./0,./0-/26:8.D21 ,6=<2:,5>C06.1>99,-.86? =,26?8706., ./0:0406:26. :>-86?/815-,11E0F2C862.8,69=286.844D/,810F2C860:21 /212:C8..0:./2.8:2?,6:2992/2:,;.2860:212=0 2?-00C06. :2.0: &H$!&$$ 4-,C ./0 :0406:26. 26: 8. 52C0 ., ;0 52650==0: 24.0- ./-00 C,6./1 26: 8:2?,6:2992:8:6,..23026<1.091.,?0../012=0:00: 0F05>.0:.8==&$'0/212:C8..0:./2.:0406:26.48=0:2 5,C9=286.2?2861.8:2?,6:299226:262?,>:226:2=1, 105>-0:.0C9,-2-<86B>65.8,6;<48=86?1>8. ,D070- 86 ./0 9-0106. 12=0 2?-00C06. ./0 9=286.844/211,>?/..,9>-5/210./01>8.15/0:>=09-,90-.< 2. ./0 -2.0 ,4 1&H!$$$ E 90- 25-0 D/85/ 81 /8?/=< 0F,-;8.26. /0-04,-0 ./0 :0406:26. /21 5/,106 ., C230 ./0 1>??01.8,6 ./2. :>-86? ./0 <02- &$$ ./0 =26:1 86 6?2=01/D2-2D0-0D,-./1(!$$$ E.,!$$$$ E90-25-0 - 10 - 26: 86 255,-:2650 D8./ ./0 12C0 8:2?,6:2992 /2: ?,. ./0 12=0 2?-00C06. D/85/ 81 2:C8..0: ;< /81 2:C8118,6 5-02.01 :,>;. 21 ., D/0./0- -02==< 9=286.844 2?-00: ., 9>-5/210 1>8. 15/0:>=0 9-,90-.< 4,- 1$$$$$ E 26: 928: 1$$$$$ E 21 2:72650 0190582==< D/06 /0 /21 428=0: ., 9-,70 ./2. /0 /2: 1$$$$$ E 2. /81 :819,12= 26: 928: ./0 12C0 ., ./0 :0406:26. 706 /0 /21 428=0: ., 9-,70 ./2. D/06 /0 299-,25/./0:0406:26.D8./2-0G>01..,0F05>.0-0?>=2- 12=0:00:/0D21/2786?1!$$$$$ E26:/0D21-02:< 26: D8==86? ., 4>=48== /81 92-. ,4 ./0 5,6.-25. ., 92< ./0 12C026:?0../012=0:00:0F05>.0: H F( :,01 6,. -040- ., ./0 02-=80- .-26125.8,6 ;< :0406:26. D8./ 8:2?,6:2992 8650 9=286.844 81 ./0 ;-,./0- ,4 8:2?,6:2992 26: ./0< 2-0 6,. /2786? 26< 5,64=85.86?86.0-01.8.81-021,62;=0.,0F905../2./0D21 2D2-0,4./09-078,>1.-26125.8,66425../02:C8118,61 ?8706 ;< 078:0650 ./81 425. /06 ./0 02-=80- 12=0 2?-00C06. 52C0 ., ;0 52650==0: ;< ./0 :0406:26. ,6 - 11 - 255,>6. ,4 8:2?,6:2992 /2786? 428=0: ., ?0. ./0 12=0 :00: 0F05>.0: D8./86 ./-00 C,6./1 8. 5-02.01 :,>;. D/0./0- ,650 2?286 9=286.844 D,>=: 706.>-0 ., 06.0- 86., 18C8=2- 2?-00C06. 6,D 2. ./0 -2.0 ,4 1$$$$$ E D8./86 2 90-8,: ,4 ,60 <02- /21 2=1, 2:C8..0: ./2. D/06 ./0 2==0?0: .-26125.8,6 .,,3 9=250 ./0 D840 26: 5/8=:-06 ,4 :0406:26. D0-0 /2786? 1/2-0 86 ./0 1>8. 15/0:>=0 9-,90-.< /06 G>01.8,60: 21 ., D/< ./0 12=0 2?-00C06.D216,.-0?81.0-0:0190582==<D/06./002-=80- 12=02?-00C06.86427,>-,48:2?,6:2992D21-0?81.0-0: /21-09=80:./2.18650:0406:26.8170-<9,,-/0:8: 6,. D26. ., ;>-:06 /8C D8./ -0?81.-2.8,6 0F906101 ,-C2==< 8.81./0;><0-D/,81-0G>8-0:.,1906:4,-./0 -0?81.-2.8,626:./810F5>10:,016,.29902=.,-021,6 % &E>->=86?2992332=881,60,4./02..01.86? D8.6011 ., F( 0 81 2 90-C2606. -018:06. ,4 6?2=01/D2-2 /0 1>8. 15/0:>=0 9-,90-.< 81 >-70< ,$( ( ,4 6?2=01/D2-2 78==2?0 ,D070- & /21 1.2.0: 1>8. 15/0:>=0 9-,90-.< 81 18.>2.0: 86 212;862= - 12 - 78==2?0 26: /0 D06. ., 212;862= 26: 1006 ./0 1>8. 15/0:>=0 9-,90-.< >-86? /81 5-,11E0F2C862.8,6 /0 /21 1.2.0:./2./0:,6,.36,DD/0-0./012=02?-00C06.D21 D-8..06 D/, D-,.0 8. 26: D/, ?270 861.->5.8,61 4,- 9-092-86?./0128::,5>C06. # . 81 90-.8606. ., 6,.0 ./2. 255,-:86? ., ./0 9=286.844 :0406:26.A1 D840 /21 2448F0: /0- ., F( >-86?/815-,11E0F2C862.8,6/212:C8..0:./2../0 90-1,6D/,/218:06.8480:./0128: /216,.2448F0:/81 18?62.>-0 0198.0 ./0 425. ./2. /21 :0680: ./0 1>??01.8,6 ./2. 24.0- ./0 12=0 2?-00C06. 86 427,>- ,4 8:2?,6:2992D2152650==0:./08-044,-.1.,./-02.06./0 :0406:26.26::819,11011/8C4-,C./01>8.9-,90-.<D06. 86 7086 ./0 1>8. 2?-00C06. 52C0 ., ;0 5,65,5.0: ./0 078:0650 9=250 ,6 -05,-: 1>99,-.1 ./0 128: 1>??01.8,6 4.0- 52-04>= 5,618:0-2.8,6 ,4 ./0 ,-2= 26: :,5>C06.2-< 078:0650=0:;<;,./92-.801./0-82=,>-./215,C0.,2 5,--05.5,65=>18,6./2.9=286.844/21428=0:.,:815/2-?0./0 - 13 - ;>-:06 ,4 9-,786? ./0 811>01 , ., ! 26: H 26: :81C8110:./01>8. &$ >-86? ./0 5,>-10 ,4 ./0 2-?>C06.1 =02-60: 5,>610=4,-9=286.8449-,:>50:5,9<,4B>:?C06.26::05-00 86 ,!& &$'/0-82=,>-./21:81C8110:./01>8. 48=0: ;< :0406:26. 26: 2==,D0: ./0 5,>6.0- 5=28C ,4 8:2?,6:2992 4,- -05,70-< ,4 1&$$$$$ E D8./ 86.0-01. I J 92 706 D/0-0 ./81 425. 81 .2306 86., 5,618:0-2.8,6 ./81 D,>=: 6,. 8C9-,70 ./0 5210 ,4 9=286.844 /0-086D/,/21428=0:.,9-,70/815210/0486:86?126: ./05,65=>18,612--870:2.;<./0-82=,>-.2-05,6181.06. D8././0078:0650,6-05,-:/81,>-.486:16,90-70-18.< .,86.0-40-0D8././012C0 & 6 ./0 -01>=. ./0 29902= 428=1 26: 255,-:86?=< ./04,==,D86? 8 /0 29902= 48=0: ;< ./0 2990==26.E 9=286.84481/0-0;<:81C8110: - 14 - 88 /0 8C9>?60: B>:?C06. 26: :05-00 :2.0: &$'&$&$ 92110: 86 ,& &$( ,6 ./0 48=0 ,4 068,- 878= >:?0 26: " 2127262 2?0D2:82-0/0-0;<5,648-C0: 888 /0 0?81.-< ., 106: ;253 ./0 -82= ,>-. -05,-:1 2=,6? D8./ 5,9< ,4 ./81 B>:?C06. ., ./0 5,650-60: ,>-. 4,-./D8./ : E &#" $' # * 1:> !$