- 1 - ! "# !$ %! # &'(&)*+'&** % ! ! "#$# %& '''' ! !()! ($ ! ($ ! (%( ! ! Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * !" ! +(%( ! !! &+&+, #%+! (+ ! ! - .*- * .*- * //0123 4, 52/467 612 8+(%( 52,34,9 :2;8<2 =>2 334=48,67 41=<4/= ? 21148,1 *0392 6,3 !" 676:0<694 6<414,9 80= 8; <4@2 8(%( <2941=2<23 :A 67B>23 874/2 =6=48, 676:0<694 ;8< 8;;2,/21 50,41>6:72 0,32< 2/=48,1 &+ &+,?#%+8; 6,32/=48,1(+? 8; /= 41 :2;8<2 =>41 /80<= 0,32< 2/=48, () 8; < 122B4,9<29076<:647 26<3726<,23/80,127;8<=>252=4=48,2<6,3726<,23 49> 80<= 8C2<,@2,= 72632< ;8< <2158,32,= 8 - 3 - 2158,32,= 8 D>8 41 12<C23 4, =>2 @6==2< >61 <2@64,230,<25<212,=23:2;8<2=>4180<= !4,<4@2 8 %%(D614,4=4677A<2941=2<23:A 276@6,9676 8D, 874/2 =6=48, 6,9678<2 ;8< 8;;2,/21 50,41>6:72 0,32< 2/=48,1 &+ ? &+, 8; 6,3 2/=48,1(?+8; /=6964,1==>252=4=48,2<>2<24, 8, =>2 :6141 8; =>2 ;4<1= 4,;8<@6=48, 36=23 %&%#%( <2/24C23 ;<8@ =>2 C4/=4@ 94<7 D>8 41 =>2 3609>=2< 8; <2158,32,= 8 >2<24, >2 1643 ! D61 10:12E02,=7A =<6,1;2<<23 =8 =>2 67B>23 874/2 =6=48, 676:0<694 ;8< D6,= 8; F0<4134/=48, 6,3 ! 4, <4@2 8(%( D61 <2941=2<23 :A 67B>23 874/2 =6=48, 676:0<694 ;8< =>2 6;8<216438;;2,/216964,1==>252=4=48,2< ( 0<4,9 =>2 /80<12 8; 4,C21=496=48, 8; =>2 /612 =>2 52=4=48,2< >2<24, D61 6<<21=23 8, +%&%( 6,3 <2@6,323=8F034/467/01=83A,C21=496=48,8;=>2/61241 /8@572=236,3/>6<921>22=>61:22,;47236964,1=>4@;8< =>26;8<216438;;2,/21 - 4 - # 64765574/6=48,;4723:A=>252=4=48,2<:2;8<2=>2<467 80<= 4, <741/ 8 + %( D61 <2F2/=23 8, ) %%(>2<2;8<2>241:2;8<2=>41/80<= + 26<,23 /80,127 ;8< =>2 52=4=48,2< 10:@4=1 =>6= 52=4=48,2< 41 6 A80,91=2< 6923 6:80= A26<1 >6C4,9 ,8 /<4@4,67 6,=2/232,=1 1 8, =>2 36=2 8; <2941=<6=48, 8; !C4/=4@94<7D616@6F8<=65526<1=>6=2C2,8,=>2 36=28;67729234,/432,=8;12G067611607=8,>2<1>2D616 @6F8< 4/=4@ 94<7 >61 :22, 2G6@4,23 :2;8<2 =>2 <467 80<= 61 - >2<2;8<2 =>2<2 /6,,8= :2 6, 655<2>2,148, =>6= 52=4=48,2< 41 74B27A =8 =6@52< D4=> =>2 @6=2<467/>6<921>22=23D4=,211 //8<34,97A>25<6A1=8 6778D=>252=4=48, & 2< /8,=<6 726<,23 49> 80<= 8C2<,@2,= 72632< >618558123=>252=4=48,210:@4=1=>6=C4/=4@94<7>61 10558<=23=>2/6128;=>25<812/0=48,6,31>2>616772923 =>6= 52=4=48,2< >63 12G067 4,=2</80<12 D4=> >2< D>2, 1>2 D611=03A4,94,'6,3=>2<26;=2<>2/8,=4,08017A>63 - 5 - 12G067 4,=2</80<12 61 6 <2107= 1>2 :2/6@2 5<29,6,= //8<34,97A>25<6A1=8341@411=>252=4=48, $ ! D61 4,4=4677A <2941=2<23 6964,1= =>2 52=4=48,2< 4, <4@2 8 %%( :A 276@6,9676 8D, 874/2 =6=48, 6,9678<2 8, =>2 :6141 8; =>2 ;4<1= 4,;8<@6=48, <2/24C23 ;<8@=>2C4/=4@94<7>2C4/=4@94<7>611=6=234,=>2;4<1= 4,;8<@6=48,=>6=>2<236=28;:4<=>41% % %%+6,31>2 D61 6/E064,=23 =8 =>2 52=4=48,2< D>8 D61 >2< <276=4C2 >2>611=6=23=>6=4,=>2@8,=>8; 8C2@:2<%D>2, 1>2 >63 98,2 =8 ;2=/> ;4<2 D883 =>2 52=4=48,2< D4=> 6 5<8@412 =8 @6<<A >2< 67729237A >63 6 12G067 4,=2</80<12 D4=> >2< 6964,1= >2< D41>21 2 <2526=23 =>2 1643 6/= =>2<26;=2< =D8 =8 =><22 =4@21 6,3 61 6 <2107= 1>2 98= 5<29,6,= , %&%#%( 14,/2 1>2 >63 /8@5764,23 8; 1=8@6/> 564, >2< @8=>2< >63 =6B2, >2< =8 8C2<,@2,= 8154=67 6= 276@6,9676 D>2<2 1>2 D61 63@4==23 6,3 D>2, 1>2 D61 4, =>2 >8154=67 1>2 10;;2<23 6, 6:8<=48, >2<26;=2<1>2>63655<86/>23=>2 874/26= 276@6,9676 8,%&%#%(6=6:80= %<10:12E02,=7A=>2! - 6 - D61 =<6,1;2<<23 =8 67B>23 874/2 =6=48, ;8< D6,= 8; F0<4134/=48,6,36;=2<4,C21=496=48,/>6<921>22=>61:22, ;4723 6964,1= =>2 52=4=48,2< ;8< =>2 6;8<21643 8;;2,/21 0<4,9 =>2 /80<12 8; 4,C21=496=48, =>2 52=4=48,2< D61 6<<21=23 8, +%&%( >2 5874/2 30<4,9 =>2 4,C21=496=48, >6C2 /8772/=23 38/0@2,=1 4, 10558<= 8; 692 5<88;8;=>2C4/=4@94<76,36152<5<812/0=48,=>236=28; :4<=> 8; C4/=4@ 94<7 41 )%$%%# 4/=4@ D>8 >61 :22, 2G6@4,23 :2;8<2 =>2 <467 80<= 61 - >61 6718 1=6=23 30<4,9 >2< 2G6@4,6=48, 4, />42; =>6= >2< 36=2 8; :4<=> 41 )%$%%# ; =>6= 41 18 61 8, $%$% 1>2 D8073 >6C2 /8@572=23 $ A26<1 8; 692 77296=48, 4, =>2 ;4<1= 4,;8<@6=48, 41 =>6= 52=4=48,2< >63 12G067 4,=2</80<12 D4=> =>2 C4/=4@ 94<7 4, =>2 @8,=> 8; 8C2@:2< % 0<4,9 =>2/80<128;325814=48,C4/=4@ - >611=6=23=>6=1>2 >61 10;;2<23 6:8<=48, 4, =>2 @8,=> 8; 6A %( 6,3 =>2 38/=8< >63 4,;8<@23 >2< 61 8, =>2 1643 36=2 1>2 D61 5<29,6,=:A;4C2@8,=>1>2<2;8<2;4,318@2;8</24, =>26<90@2,=1 633<21123 8,:2>67; 8; =>2 52=4=48,2<=>6= 61 8, =>2 6772923 36=2 8; 4,/432,= =>2 C4/=4@ 94<7 D61 6 - 7 - @6F8< 1 <49>=7A /8,=2,323 :A 726<,23 /80,127 ;8< =>2 52=4=48,2< 14,/2 =>2 C4/=4@ 94<7 >61 67<263A :22, 2G6@4,23:2;8<2<46780<=61 - =>2<2/6,,8=:26,A 655<2>2,148, =>6= =>2 52=4=48,2< @6A =6@52< D4=> =>2 @6=2<4675<812/0=48, 2=4=48,2<69236:80=A26<1414, /01=83A;8<=>2761=@8<2=>6,14G@8,=>1 ) ,32< =>2 /4</0@1=6,/21 6@ 8; =>2 854,48, >41 5<6A2< ;8< 9<6,= 8; <29076< :647 ,2231 =8 :2 6,1D2<23 6;;4<@6=4C27AD4=>80=2G5<2114,96,A854,48,8,=>2@2<4=1 6,332@2<4=18;=>2/612 //8<34,97A5<8/223=85611 =>2;8778D4,9 >252=4=48,416778D23 >2 52=4=48,2< 41 34<2/=23 =8 :2 2,76<923 8, :647 4, <4@2 8(%( <2941=2<23 :A 67B>23 874/2 =6=48, 676:0<694 ;8< 8;;2,/21 50,41>6:72 0,32< 2/=48,1 &+ &+,?#%+8; 6,32/=48,1(+? 8; /=4,52/467612 8+(%(8,=>2;4728;=>2 334=48,6741=<4/=?21148,1*03926,3!" 676:0<69410:F2/==8=>2;8778D4,9/8,34=48,1 - 8 - 6>252=4=48,2<1>6772G2/0=252<18,67:8,3;8<6 10@ 8; 1 %%%%%" D4=> =D8 10<2=421 ;8< =>2 74B210@ =8 =>2 16=41;6/=48, 8; =>2 F0<4134/=48,67 80<=H :>2 52=4=48,2< 1>677 65526< <29076<7A 8, 677 =>2 36=218;>26<4,9:2;8<2=>2<46780<=0,7211=>2 <467 80<= 2G2@5=1 >41 65526<6,/2 ;8< C6743 <2618,1H / >2 52=4=48,2< 1>677 ,8= 34<2/=7A 8< 4,34<2/=7A =><26=2, 8< =6@52< D4=> =>2 5<812/0=48, D4=,21121H 3>2 52=4=48,2< 1>677 ,8= 4,C87C2 4, 14@476< 8;;2,/214,;0=0<2H 2>2 52=4=48,2< 1>677 ,8= 726C2 =>2 F0<4134/=48, 8; =>2 <467 80<= D4=>80= 52<@41148, 8; =>2 1643 80<= 0,=47 =>2 /612 <2941=2<23 6964,1= >4@ 41 341581238;; ,+ &$ %! * ! 41= 8 7 8