- 1 - !" # $ " %&'()* +,&-')+. $ !" # $ % & " " " " & !" # $" "% "& '(& " #%'& #% " " " $ ) ) " & && '( '# % '&" * Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '& " " & + ), ) )' $ ) ) & " & && ' '( & " " $ & $ $ - $ #"- $ % ../012345 3), ) )'61524578193:1;<1 3/:; 39 224;435=> 40;:4.; =52 1004350 /271 =>=8/:=74=:404573/;39 :4?13 ) ) :1740;1:128@ 1>374 "3>4.1 ;=;435 =>=8/:=74 93: 39915.10 6/540<=8>1 /521: 1.;435 ' =52 '( :1=2 A4;< 1.;435 ' 39 " =52/521:1.;4350=52'393A:@":3<484;435.; (* 40 8193:1 ;<40 3/:; /521: 1.;435 ' 39 ) )011B457:17/>=:8=4> ) 1=:2>1=:512.3/501>93:;<16=:;410 & 45 :4?1 3 ) ) A=0 :1740;1:12 8@ 1>374"3>4.1;=;435=>=8/:=7493:;<1=93:10=4239915.10 - 3 - =7=450;;<1 61;4;4351: =52;A3 3;<1:0 35 ;<18=04039 ;<1 94:0; 4593:?=;435 2=;12 )* )) ) :1.14C12 9:3? <4?=0<=5B=:;<18:3;<1:3921.1=012 <=7@=C=5;<45 ;<10=42.=0161;4;4351:A=0=::10;1235)* ,) )'<1 8=4> =66>4.=;435 94>12 8@ <4? 8193:1 ;<1 D/:4024.;435=> 1004350 3/:; 45 :>$40.3) '( ) )' A=0 :1D1.;12 35 )) )'<1:193:1<1408193:1;<40 3/:; ' 1=:512 .3/501> 93: ;<1 61;4;4351: <=C457 :14;1:=;12 ;<1 7:3/520 /:712 45 ;<1 61;4;435 0/8?4;0 ;<=; ;<1 61;4;4351: A<3 40 ;<1 </08=52 39 ;<1 21.1=012 <=2 =>030/991:12' E8/:545D/:410A<15<1?=21=;;1?6;;3 :10./1<40A491<161;4;4351:A<3<=0533;<1:.:4?45=> =5;1.1215;0 40 45 ./0;32@ 93: ;<1 >=0; ?3:1 ;<=5 94C1 ?35;<0../0123)<=081157:=5;12=5;4.46=;3:@8=4> =52 =../012 3 <=0 8115 7:=5;12 :17/>=: 8=4> 45 ;<1 6:1015;.=01..3:2457>@<16:=@0;3=>>3A;<161;4;435 "1: .35;:= >1=:512 47< 3/:; 3C1:5?15; ">1=21: <=0 3663012 ;<1 61;4;435 1 0/8?4;0 ;<=; 61;4;4351: A=0 =80.352457 93: =61:432 39?3:1;<=5 93/: - 4 - @1=:045;<16:1015;.=015;<11C15;<14015>=:71235 8=4> 4; A3/>2 81 24994./>; ;3 01./:1 <40 6:1015.1 ..3:2457>@<16:=@0;3240?400;<161;4;435 * "1:/0=> 39 ;<1 ?=;1:4=> =C=4>=8>1 35 :1.3:2 A3/>273;30<3A;<=;?=::4=7139;<121.1=012A4;<;<1 61;4;4351:A=061:93:?12=83/;;A3=52<=>9@1=:06:43:;3 ;<12=;139:1740;:=;43539&5;<194:0;4593:?=;4354; 40=>>1712;<=;35) )) ) =;=83/;, 6?;<194:0; 4593:?=5; A=0 4593:?12 3C1: 6<351 ;<=; <40 040;1: <=7@=C=5;<4 <=2 0/991:12 8/:5 45D/:410 45 <1: ?=;:4?354=><3/01??124=;1>@;<194:0;4593:?=5;=>357 A4;< <40 :1>=;4C10 A15; ;3 ;<1 ?=;:4?354=> <3/01 39 <40 040;1:=5293/52;<=;<40040;1:<=20/991:1201:43/08/:5 45D/:410 <1:1=9;1: ;<1@ <=2 0<49;12 <=7@=C=5;<4 =52 ;<161;4;4351:<1:145A<3=>03<=20/991:128/:545D/:410 45 =5 =?8/>=5.1 ;3 = <3064;=> =52 =2?4;;12 ;<1? /801F/15;>@ =; =83/; 6? 35 ) )) ) <=7@=C=5;<4 <=2 2412 45 ;<1 <3064;=> A<4>1 /521:73457 ;:1=;?15;5;<10=?12=@;<161;4;4351:=>>1712>@<=2 - 5 - 10.=612 9:3? ;<1 <3064;=> 5 ;<1 8=040 39 ;<1 94:0; 4593:?=;435 :1.14C12 9:3? <4?=0<=5B=: A<3 40 ;<1 8:3;<1:39;<121.1=012&<=08115:1740;1:12=7=450; ;<161;4;4351:<40?3;<1:=52@3/571:8:3;<1:9;1:;<1 45C10;47=;435 .<=:71 0<11; <=0 8115 94>12 =7=450; ;<:11 61:0350 93: ;<1 =93:10=42 39915.10 ../012 3 A=0 7:=5;12 :17/>=: 8=4> 8@ ;<40 3/:; 45 :4?45=> "1;4;435 3) ) ) ) 240630123935 ) )=52=../012 3) <=0 8115 7:=5;12 =5;4.46=;3:@ 8=4> 8@ ;<1 D/:4024.;435=>1004350 3/:;45 :>$40.3 ' ) )' , <1 =>>17=;4350 45 ;<1 & =52 45 ;<1 .<=:71 0<11; =0 =7=450; =../012 30 ;3 =:1 04?4>=: <1 ?=;1:4=> 35 :1.3:2 A3/>2 73 ;3 0<3A ;<=; 61;4;4351: <=2 =>030/991:128/:545D/:410..3:2457;3;<16:301./;435 045.1;<121.1=012A=0814574>>;:1=;1245<1:?=;:4?354=> <3/01 8@ =../012 30 ;3 0<1 =>>1712>@ 63/:12 B1:3015135<1:01>9=;=83/;* 6?35) )) ) =52 <=2 .3??4;;12 0/4.421 <1 9=.; ;<=; 61;4;4351: <=0 =>03 0/991:128/:545D/:410A3/>273;30<3A;<=;<1<=2?=21 - 6 - =;;1?6;0 ;3 :10./1 ;<1 21.1=012 52406/;12>@ ;<1 61;4;4351: <=0 53 .:4?45=> =5;1.1215;0 =52 40 45 ./0;32@ 93:;<1>=0;?3:1;<=594C1?35;<0<1;:4=>45;<1.=0140 @1;;381.3??15.12 521: ;<1 .4:./?0;=5.10 =? 39 ;<1 3645435 ;<=; ;<1 6:=@1: ?=21 8@ ;<1 61;4;4351: 93: 7:=5; :17/>=: 8=4> 51120 ;3 81 =50A1:12 =994:?=;4C1>@ ..3:2457>@ 93>>3A457 <161;4;43540=>>3A12 <1 61;4;4351: 40 24:1.;12 ;3 81 15>=:712 35 8=4> 45 :4?1 3 ) ) 39 1>374 "3>4.1 ;=;435 =>=8/:=74 :1740;1:12 93: ;<1 39915.10 6/540<=8>1 /521: 1.;4350 ' =52 '( :1=2 A4;< 1.;435 ' 39 " =52 /521: 1.;4350=52'393A:@":3<484;435.;(*6152457 35 ;<1 94>1 39 >1=:512 224;435=> 40;:4.; =52 1004350 /271 =>=8/:=74 45 3), ) )' 0/8D1.; ;3 ;<1 93>>3A457.3524;4350 - 7 - =% "1;4;4351:0<=>>1G1./;161:035=>835293:= 0/? 39 0 A4;< ;A3 0/:1;410 93: ;<1 >4B10/? ;3 ;<1 0=;409=.;435 39 ;<1 D/:4024.;435=> 3/:;H 8% "1;4;4351: 0<=>> =661=: :17/>=:>@ 35 =>> ;<1 2=;1039<1=:4578193:1;<1:4=> 3/:;/5>100;<1 :4=> 3/:; 1G1?6;0 <40 =661=:=5.1 93: C=>42 :1=0350H .% "1;4;4351: 0<=>> 53; 24:1.;>@ 3: 4524:1.;>@ ;<:1=;15 3: ;=?61: A4;< ;<1 6:301./;435 A4;510010H 2% "1;4;4351: 0<=>> 53; 45C3>C1 45 04?4>=: 39915.10459/;/:1H 1% "1;4;4351:0<=>>53;>1=C1;<1D/:4024.;43539 ;<1 :4=> 3/:; A4;<3/; 61:?400435 39 ;<1 0=42 3/:; /5;4> ;<1 .=01 :1740;1:12 =7=450; <4? 40 24063012399 /, ) # $ + 40;3>3( "