- 1 - ! "" #$% & '% " $& ' ! " # $%$&' " ( $%&&# ! " # ) )&*&% $**&$ &&&*&$ **) ' ( Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + , + " , +# & -./012./.34516.6.34./7.819:49101;6.34)01<9=.6- & 37 0 <//<.8.4> 6-1 ?:9>@146 <49 30910 37 ;342.;6.34 <49 /14614;1 9<619 &&&*&$ 5<//19 AB 6-1 3:06 37 .2.8 :9>1 <42..43**)<496-1?:9>@146<4930910 9<619 )&*&% 5<//19 AB 6-1 3:06 37 08 ./60.;6 C 1//.34/:9>1 <.;-:0.4083$**&$ * 1<096-181<04193:4/187306-15<06.1/ 16.6.3410 -101.4 =</ ;-<0>1/-11619 AB <2.6<8 38.;1 6<6.34 <42..40.@13&$*%7306-137714;15:4./-<A81 :49101;6.34' 6 ./ 6-1 ;</1 37 6-1 503/1;:6.34 6-<6 6-1 516.6.3410 <;;:/19 =</ 6-1 /:A;3460<;630 37 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46 D / 81;60.;<83460<;630/<49-1=</<=<09196-1=30E 3701;349.6.34.4>37&&8.41<6 <42.<49 129:0><<8:E/ - 3 - <49 <;;309.4>8B < /:A;3460<;6 <>011@146 =</ 1F1;:619 <6 14><8:0:34&&* $ 6./6-1;</1376-1917<;63;3@58<.4<466-<66-1B-<21 A114 01>:8<08B .//:.4> && 8.41 @<610.<8/ 703@ 6-1.0 @<.4 /6301<6 <.;-:0636-1/:A;3460<;630=-3-<96=3/6301/341 <6 12<9:0>< <496-136-10<6<2.6<8 -1<881><6.34 <><.4/6 6-1 /:A;3460<;630 ./ 6-<6 =-.81 210.7B.4> 6-1 /6301 6-1 ;3@58<.4<46 73:49 /-306<>1 37 @<610.<8/ .46-1 /63;E 033@ 37 6-1 <;;:/19 6 =</ 73:49 6-<6 6-1 @<610.<8/ .//:19 <49 6-1 @<610.<8/:/197306-1=30E93419.771019<4934210.7.;<6.3437 /63;E 34 &**% .6 =</ 73:49 6-<6 @<610.<8/ =306- /$$$$ =</ 73:49 /-306 6 ./ :4910 6-1/1 ;.0;:@/6<4;1/ 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46 -<9 <5503<;-19 6-1 538.;1 <49 839>19 6-1 ;3@58<.46 34 &**% =-.;- =</ 01>./61019.40.@13&$*%<><.4/66-1516.6.3410<;;:/19 7306-137714;15:4./-<A81:49101;6.34' ' -1 538.;1 <7610 .421/6.><6.34 -<21 7.819 ;-<0>1 /-116 <><.4/66-1516.6.34107306-1<7301/<.937714;1-1516.6.3410 =-3 -<9 <551<019 A17301 6-1 0.<8 3:06 .4 01/534/1 63 6-1 /:@@34/ .//:19 63 -.@ -<9 ;8<.@19 63 A1 60.19 -1 - 4 - 503/1;:6.34 6-1017301 -<9 1F<@.419 4.41 ;-<0>1/-116 =.641//1/ </ +/& 63 ) <49 >36 @<0E19 93;:@146/ </ F/&63<49;83/19.6//.91-101<76106-1/6<61@146 37 6-1 <;;:/19 =</ 01;30919 :4910 1;6.34 & 0 3=12104391714;112.914;1=</81934A1-<87376-1<;;:/19 430=</<4B93;:@146@<0E19.4/:5530637-./91714;1 -10.<83:06<7610-1<0.4>6-1<0>:@146/<9901//1934 A36- /.91/ 2.91 6-1 .@5:>419 ?:9>@146 <49 30910 9<619 &&&*&$5<//19.43**);342.;6196-1516.6.3410 730 6-1 37714;1 5:4./-<A81 :4910 1;6.34 ' <49 /14614;19-.@63:4910>3/.@581.@50./34@146730<510.3937 341B1<0<495<B7.4137 /$<49.4917<:8663:4910>3 /.@581 .@50./34@146 730 < 510.39 37 341 @346- -1 /<.9 ?:9>@146 <49 30910 37 ;342.;6.34 <49 /14614;1 =</ :4/:;;1//7:88B ;-<8814>19 AB 6-1 516.6.3410 A17301 6-1 ?:0./9.;6.34<8 1//.34/ 3:06 .4 083$**&$ =-.;- =</ 9./@.//19AB?:9>@146<49309109<619)&*&%;347.0@.4> 6-1?:9>@146<493091037;342.;6.34<49/14614;15<//19AB 6-10.<83:061.4><>>0.1219AB6-1/<@16-1516.6.3410./ A173016-./3:06 - 5 - % 1<0419 3:4/18 730 6-1 516.6.3410 -<2.4> 01.610<619 6-1 >03:49/:0>19.46-1012./.34516.6.34/:A@.6/6-<66-1;3:06/ A183= -<21 10019 .4 ;342.;6.4> 6-1 516.6.3410 730 6-1 <881>19 37714;11/:A@.6/6-<630<8<4993;:@146<0B12.914;158<;19 34 01;309 931/ 436 ;34;8:/.218B 50321 6-1 ;-<0>1 <><.4/6 6-1 516.6.3410 -101 ./ 43 @<610.<8 63 /-3= 6-<6 516.6.3410 -<9 @./:/19 <49 @./<550350.<619 6-1 @<610.<8 /:558.19 AB 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46 6 ./ 348B <7610 < 9./5:61 <03/1 A16=114 6-1 5<06.1/ =.6- 01><09 63 5<B@146 37 A.88/ 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<467301F60<413:/01</34/-</7.819<7<8/1;3@58<.46 <><.4/6 6-1 516.6.3410 -1 ;3:06/ A183= -<21 7<.819 63 <5501;.<61 6-./ </51;6 37 6-1 @<6610 <49 -<21 10019 .4 ;342.;6.4> 6-1 516.6.3410 730 6-1 ;-<0>1/-11619 37714;1 ;;309.4>8B-150<B/63<883=6-1516.6.34 ) 10 ;3460< 81<0419 -</ 3553/19 6-1 516.6.34 1 /:A@.6/6-<66-10.<83:06</=188</6-155188<613:06-<21 01;30919 ;34;:00146 7.49.4>/ <><.4/6 6-1 516.6.3410 -1 12.914;137+&C+01<9=.6-6-193;:@146<0B12.914;1 =3:89;34;8:/.218B503216-1;-<0>1<><.4/66-1516.6.3410<49 6-1 503/1;:6.34 -</ 503219 .6/ ;-<0>1/ A1B349 01</34<A81 - 6 - 93:A6 <><.4/6 6-1 516.6.3410 ;;309.4>8B -1 50<B/ 63 9./@.// 6-1516.6.34 & -1503/1;:6.34.4309106350321.6/;-<0>1/<><.4/66-1 516.6.3410-</1F<@.4194.41;-<0>1/-116=.641//1/</+/& 63 ) +& 63 + =101 6-1 1@583B11/ 37 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<469:0.4>6-101812<46510.39+&=-3=</=30E.4> </<03?1;6 <4<>10376-1917<;63;3@58<.4<46<49+=-3 =</=30E.4></<.614>.4110-<21/:55306196-1;</1376-1 503/1;:6.34 =-.81 +* -</ 436 /:5530619 6-1 ;</1 37 6-1 503/1;:6.34<49-1-</A114601<619</<-3/6.81=.641// && +&C+-<21/53E1463<A3:66-1/:558B37&& 8.41 @<610.<8/ 63 6-1 516.6.3410 -101.4 703@ 50.8 * 63 321@A10 * <49 6-1B -<21 /6<619 6-<6 6-1 @<610.<8/ /:558.19 =101 01;1.219 AB + D 35<8 =-3 =</ 6-1 01501/146<6.21 37 6-1 /:A;3460<;630 D / 011 0.>18< 34/60:;6.34/ <49 01;1.56 37 6-1 /<@1 =</ <;E43=819>19 AB -.@ -1B -<21 /53E14 <A3:6 6-1 /:558B 37 @<610.<8/ 730 6-1 510.39703@321@A10*63<4:<0B*%</5106-1610@/ 37 6-1 ;3460<;6 D F$ <49 6-1B -<21 /6<619 6-<6 .6 =</ 436.;19 AB 6-1 ;3@58<.4<46;3@5<4B 6-<6 730 6-1 510.39 703@ - 7 - 321@A10*63<4:<0B*%6-1=30E1460:/619=</436 ;3@581619 <49 6-101 =</ < -:>1 9.771014;1 .4 6-1 @<610.<8/ /:558.19 <49 6-1 =30E ;3@581619 <49 6-101<7610 34 210.7.;<6.34 37 /63;E .6 =</ 73:49 6-<6 @<610.<8/ =306- /$$$=<//-306 &* +D35<8-</9153/19<A3:601;1.2.4>6-1@<610.<8/ /:558.19 AB 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46 <6 <2.6<8 /6301 033@ 37 6-1 /:A;3460<;630 F/' 63 *' <01 6-1 93;:@146/ =-.;- 50.@< 7<;.1 /-3= <A3:6 6-1 /:558B 37@<610.<8 AB 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46636-1/6301033@37/:A;3460<;630<6<2.6<8<49 01;1.56376-1@<610.<8/-</A114<;E43=819>19AB+6./ 436.49./5:616-<6-1=</6-1<:6-30.G19510/346301;1.216-1 @<610.<8 34 A1-<87 37 6-1 /:A;3460<;630 + =-3 -</ 9153/19 <A3:6 01;1.2.4> 6-1 @<610.<8 .4 6-1 /6301 033@ <6 <2.6<8-</436/6<619<4B6-.4><A3:66-1:/<>137@<610.<8/ <49346-136-10-<49-1-<//6<6196-<6-1-<9/:A/1H:1468B >341634<46-<5:063<66149=30E<49-1931/436E43=@:;- <A3:6 6-1 :/<>1 37 @<610.<8/ -3:>- 6-./ =.641// =</ ;03// 1F<@.419AB6-103/1;:630436-.4>@<610.<8-</A11418.;.619 703@-./@3:6-=.6-01><09636-1:/<>1376-1@<610.<8/-./ =.641//9:0.4>6-1;3:0/137;03//1F<@.4<6.34-<//6<6196-<6 - 8 - ;106<.4 @<610.<8/ =101 016:0419 63 6-1 ;3@58<.4<46;3@5<4B -10173016-./=.641//=</5<06.<88B601<619</-3/6.81 & +$C+'<016-15<4;-=.641//1/63F&D/536 @<-<G<0-1/1=.641//1/-<21436/:55306196-1;</1376-1 503/1;:6.34 <49 6-1017301 6-1B =101 601<619 </ -3/6.81 =.641//1/ & + =</ =30E.4> </ ;;3:46<46 .4 6-1 377.;1 37 6-1 917<;63;3@58<.4<46-./=.641//-</9153/196-<6.46-1B1<0 *'-1-<901;1.219A.88/7306-1=30E9341AB6-1<;;:/19 <49<7610210.7.;<6.34-1-<9730=<09196-1/<@1636-1.01<9 77.;1 <6 14><8:0: -./ =.641// -</ 7:06-10 /6<619 6-<6 -1 931/ 436 E43= <4B6-.4> 7:06-10 <A3:6 6-1 /<.9 A.88/ <49 6-1017301 6-./ =.641// =</ 601<619 </ -3/6.81 =.641// <49 ;03//1F<@.419AB6-1:A8.;03/1;:630 :0.4>6-1;3:0/137 ;03//1F<@.4<6.34AB6-103/1;:630-1-</.9146.7.196-1A.88/ <6F/*63=-.;-=101730=<0919AB-.@636-1.01<9 77.;1<614><8:0: :0.4>6-1;3:0/137;03//1F<@.4<6.3437 6-./=.641//34A1-<87376-191714;1-1-<//6<6196-<6-1-<9 4365015<0196-1A.88/</510F/*63 - 9 - &$ +% ./ 6-1 37 <2.6<8 38.;1 6<6.34 =-3 -<9 01>./61019 6-1 .4 0.@1 3&$*% <49 ;349:;619 6-1 5018.@.4<0B .421/6.><6.34 1 -</ /6<619 6-<6 =-.81 01>./610.4> 6-1 -1 -<9 436 210.7.19 6-1 93;:@146/ 37 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46 &' +)./6-137<2.6<838.;16<6.34=-3-<96<E14 3210 6-1 .421/6.><6.34 703@ +% <49 <7610 ;3@5816.4> 6-1 .421/6.><6.34-<97.8196-1;-<0>1/-116<><.4/66-1<;;:/19 & 16.6.3410 -</ A114 ;-<0>1/-11619 .4 6-1 501/146 ;</1 730 6-1 37714;1 5:4./-<A81 :4910 1;6.34 ' -1 =309 I;0.@.4<8 A01<;- 37 60:/6J ./ 917.419 :4910 1;6.34 $ =-.;-01<9/</:4910 K! ()*)+,- .(/,01 2(342 +-31210 A1.4> .4 <4B @<4410 1460:/619 =.6- 5035106B 30 =.6- <4B 93@.4.34 3210 5035106B 9./-341/68B @./<550350.<61/ 30 ;342106/ 63 -./ 3=4 :/1 6-<6 5035106B 30 9./-341/68B :/1/ 30 9./53/1/ 377 6-<6 5035106B.42.38<6.3437<4B9.01;6.34378<=501/;0.A.4> 6-1@391.4=-.;-/:;-60:/6./63A19./;-<0>193037 <4B 81><8 ;3460<;6 1F501// 30 .@58.19 =-.;- -1 -</ @<91 63:;-.4> 6-1 9./;-<0>1 37 /:;- 60:/6 30 =.87:88B /:7710/ <4B 36-10 510/34 /3 63 93 ;3@@.6/ K;0.@.4<8 A01<;-3760:/6L - 10 - &% 1;6.34 ' 5032.91/ 730 5:4./-@146 730 ;0.@.4<8 A01<;-3760:/6 &) 03@6-1@<610.<812.914;13401;309.6./210B;81<06-<6 6-1 503/1;:6.34 -</ <6 A1/6 503219 6-<6 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46-<91460:/619;106<.4@<610.<8/37.6/636-1/:A ;3460<;630 =-3 =</<=<0919 6-1 =30E 37 01;349.6.34.4> 37 && 8.41<6 <42.<49 129:0><<8:E/3=12106-130<8<49 93;:@146<0B 12.914;1 58<;19 34 01;309 34 A1-<87 37 6-1 503/1;:6.34931/436;34;8:/.218B503216-<66-15035106B=-.;- =</ 1460:/619 63 6-1 /:A;3460<;630 -</ A114 9./-341/68B @./<550350.<619 AB -.@ <49 6-<6 -1 -<9 ;34210619 6-1 /<.9 5035106B 730 -./ 3=4 :/1 30 9./-341/68B :/19 30 9./53/19 37 6-<65035106B.42.38<6.3437<4B9.01;6.34378<=501/;0.A.4>6-1 @391.4=-.;-/:;-60:/6./63A19./;-<0>191.6-10+&430 + -<21 /53E14 <A3:6 6-1 @./<550350.<6.34 37 @<610.<8/ 1460:/619636-1/:A;3460<;630 * -1<881><6.34<><.4/66-1/:A;3460<;630./6-<66-1=30E ;3@581619AB-.@9:0.4>6-101812<46510.39;3@5<019636-1 @<610.<8/ /:558.19 =</ 9./5035306.34<61 <49 6-1017301 .6 ./ <881>19 6-<6 6-1 @<610.<8/ /:558.19 -</ A114 @./:/19 AB -.@ - 11 - /.4;1 /-306<>1 37 @<610.<8 =</ <881>198B 73:49 .4 6-1 /6301 033@376-1<;;:/19 *& -1@<610.<83401;309=3:89>363/-3=6-<6@:;-50.30 636-1917<;63;3@58<.4<46@<E.4><881><6.3437;0.@.4<8A01<;- 3760:/6<><.4/66-1<;;:/196-1<;;:/19-<9/:A@.6619A.88/.4 01/51;6376-1=30E9341AB-.@A:66-1/<.9A.88/<551<0/63 -<21 436 A114 5<.9 AB 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46 =-3 ./ 6-1 ;3460<;630<49346-136-10-<49/:A/1H:1468B-1-</@<91 <4 <881><6.34 6-<6 6-1 @<610.<8/ /:558.19 AB -.@ -</ A114 @./:/19 30 @./<550350.<619 AB 6-1 /:A;3460<;630 =-3 ./ 6-1 <;;:/19.46-1501/146;</1<496-101AB-1-<//:77101983// 63 6-1 6:41 37 /$$$$ 3=1210 /:;- <4 <881><6.34 @<91 <><.4/6 6-1 <;;:/19 ./ 436 /:5530619 AB <4B 30<8 30 93;:@146<0B 12.914;1 @<91 <2<.8<A81 63 6-1 ;3:06 -1 503/1;:6.34 -</ 348B 503219 6-<6 ;106<.4 @<610.<8/ =101 /:558.19 AB 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46 63 6-1 <;;:/19 =-3 ./ < /:A;3460<;630 -101.4 :6 6-1 503/1;:6.34 -</ 436 503219 A1B349 93:A6 6-<6 6-1 @<610.<8/ /:558.19 AB 6-1 917<;63 ;3@58<.4<46=-3./<;3460<;630636-1<;;:/19=-3./</:A ;3460<;630-</A114@./:/1930@./<550350.<619AB-.@ - 12 - ** 6 ./ 6-1 <881><6.34 37 6-1 ;3@58<.4<46 6-<6 6-1 /:A ;3460<;630-</436;<00.193:66-1=30E/<6./7<;630.8BAB:6.8.G.4> 6-1 @<610.<8/ =-.;- -1 -<9 01;1.219 703@ 6-1 /6301 37 6-1 ;3@58<.4<46 -1 ;3:06/A183= :47306:4<618B -<21 501/:@19 6-<6 6-1 @<610.<8/ /:558.19 -<21 A114 @./:/19 30 @./<550350.<619AB6-1<;;:/19</6-1;3@58<.4<46-<9@<91 <4<881><6.346-<66-101=<//-306<>137@<610.<8/73:49.46-1 /6301 033@ 3=1210 6-101 ./ 43 @<610.<8 63 /-3= 6-<6 =-<6 =</6-1H:<46.6B37@<610.<8/:/19AB6-1<;;:/197306-1=30E 9341 AB -.@ <49 .4 6-1 <A/14;1 37 @<610.<8 63 1/6<A8./- 6-1 /<@1 .6 ./ 9.77.;:86 63 <00.21 <6 < ;34;8:/.34 6-<6 <;;:/19 -</ @./:/196-1@<610.<8//:558.19AB6-1917<;63;3@58<.4<46 * -1 503/1;:6.34 -</ 7<.819 63 1F<@.41 <4B 1F5106 =-3 ;3:89-<21/53E14<A3:66-1@<610.<8/41;1//<0B7306-1=30E 9341 AB 6-1 <;;:/19 :6 :47306:4<618B /:;- <4 1F10;./1 -</ 436 A114 9341 .4 6-1 501/146 ;</1 48B 34 6-1 A</./ 37 6-1 9153/.6.3437+&C+=-3-<21/53E14<A3:66-1/:558B 37@<610.<8/636-1<;;:/196-1;3:06/A183=-<21503;11919 63 ;342.;6 6-1 516.6.3410 730 6-1 <881>19 37714;1/ <49 .4 @B ;34/.91019 2.1= 6-1 /<.9 <5503<;- 37 6-1 ;3:06/ A183= ./ 5<61468B .881><8 <49 6-1017301 6-1 .@5:>419 ?:9>@146 <49 - 13 - 30910 37 ;342.;6.34 <49 /14614;1 5<//19 AB 6-1 ;3:06/ A183= ;<4436 A1 /:/6<.419 <49 6-1 /<@1 91/1021/ 63 A1 /16 </.91 ;;309.4>8B6-173883=.4>30910 * -1012./.34516.6.34./<883=19-1?:9>@146<4930910 37 ;342.;6.34 <49 /14614;1 9<619 &&&*&$ 5<//19 AB 6-1 3:06 37 .2.8 :9>1 <42. .4 3**) <49 6-1 ?:9>@146<49309109<619)&*&%5<//19AB6-13:0637 08 ./60.;6C1//.34/:9>1 <.;-:0.4083$**&$<01 /16</.91-1516.6.3410./<;H:.6619376-137714;15:4./-<A81 :4910 1;6.34 ' -1 7.41 <@3:46 .7 <4B 9153/.619 /-<88A1017:4919636-1516.6.3410 56 7 & '% "8 %