- 1 - !" # $ " %&'%()*+&%)) $ !" #$ % & ! ! % !! ' (## & )! !# % ! #%$ Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % *)+% $ *) % ! & ! & ,''*% % %% ), $ * $ -$ % ! ') % & % % .! " ,+'* % & /!"# &" /!"# &" $ 00123456730589823 :,+'*736456;<3=:>3 ?@3 :1>? := ?@3 52?>50? 864 3225:62 "14;3 84;5> 8>5256; :1? := >5-3 :,''* >3;52?3>34 <A :43B89 :9503 ?8?5:6 84;5> =:> :==36032 71652@8<93 1643> 30?5:62), $* $ -$:=! ')86430?5:6:= 0?'52<3=:>3?@520:1>?1643>30?5:6*)+:= >233B56;>3;198><859 38>4?@3938>6340:16239=:>?@378>?532 - 3 - ) %56>5-3 :,''*C82>3;52?3>34<A:43B89 :9503?8?5:684;5>8;8562??@373?5?5:63>@3>356565?5899A =:>:==360371652@8<931643>30?5:6):=! ') * 1>56;?@30:1>23:=56D32?5;8?5:6?@373?5?5:63>864 ?@3D50?5-C3>3?>8034864?@373?5?5:63>C828>>32?34:6 '','* 6D32?5;8?5:6 := ?@3 0823 52 0:-793?34 864 0@8>;32@33?@82<336=59348;8562?@5-=:>?@38=:>32854 :==36032!8598779508?5:6=5934<A@5-<3=:>3?@3?>5890:1>? 56730589823 :,+'*C82>3E30?34:6'+'* @3>3=:>3@352<3=:>3?@520:1>? 38>634 0:16239 =:> ?@3 73?5?5:63> 21<-5?2 ?@8? 73?5?5:63> 864 ?@3 D50?5- ;5>9 8>3 56 9:D3 @3 78>36?2 := ?@3 D50?5- ;5>9 C3>3 :77:256; ?@3 2854 >398?5:62@57 864 ?@3>3=:>3 8 =8923 0:-79856? @82 <336 =5934 8;8562? ?@3 73?5?5:63> @3 D50?5- ;5>9 @82 6:? -843 86A 8993;8?5:6 8;8562? ?@3 73?5?5:63> C@: 52 8 A:16;2?3> 8;34 8<:1? A38>200:>456;9A@37>8A2?:899:C?@373?5?5:6 - 4 - 3> 0:6?>8 938>634 5;@ :1>? :D3>6-36? 93843> 864 938>634 0:16239 87738>56; =:> >327:6436? : @8D3 :77:234?@373?5?5:6 , 38>634 0:16239 87738>56; =:> >327:6436? : 21<-5?2 ?@8? D50?5- C82 =:164 ?: <3 7>3;686? C@593 2@3 C82 -3450899A 3F8-5634 @3>3=:>3 ?@3>3 52 8 ?@>38? := 73?5?5:63> ?8-73>56; C5?@ ?@3 -8?3>589 0@8>;3 2@33? C5?63223200:>456;9A@37>8A2?:452-522?@373?5?5:6 % 56 ?@3 7>3236? 0823 C82 565?5899A >3;52?3>34 8;8562??@373?5?5:63>=:>:==360371652@8<931643>30?5:6 ) := ?@3! 0? ') 8=?3> ?@3D50?5- ;5>9 C@: 52 ?@3 481;@?3>:=?@3>327:6436? :C82=:164-52256;=>:- ?@35> @:123 :6 ')','* %5>2? 56=:>-86? @84 877>:80@34 ?@3 7:9503 :6 '*,'* 864 21<-5??34 8 ?A734=5>2?56=:>-8?5:6<8234:6C@50@%C82>3;52?3>34 8;8562??@373?5?5:63> 1>56;?@30:1>23:=56D32?5;8?5:6 73?5?5:63> 864 ?@3 D50?5-2 C3>3 ?>8034 ?:;3?@3> #50?5- @82 6:? 0::73>8?34 <3=:>3 ?@3 4:0?:> =:> @3> -345089 3F8-568?5:6 3> 2?8?3-36? 1643> 230?5:6 * := > - 5 - C82 >30:>434 :6 +','* 6 ?@3 2854 2?8?3-36? 2@3 @82 2854 ?@8? @3> 78>36?2 C3>3 7>378>56; ?: 73>=:>- @3> -8>>58;38;8562?@3>C52@32864?@3>3=:>3:6')','* 8?8<:1?)''2@3@84?3937@:634?:?@373?5?5:63>864 089934@5- @3>38=?3> ?@3AC36??:;3?@3> 864 2?8A34 56 !828D8668 ?3-793 56 ?@35> D5998;3 @3 7:9503 C@: 08-3 ?@3>3<>:1;@??@3-<80B?:7:95032?8?5:6@3@822?8?34 ?@8? 2@3 52 56 9:D3 C5?@ ?@3 73?5?5:63> 864 ?@3 73?5?5:63> @82 6:? 0:--5??34 86A C>:6; @3 @82 6:? -843 86A 8993;8?5:6828;8562??@373?5?5:63>56@3>2?8?3-36?1643> 230?5:6 * := > C@50@ C:194 8??>80? ?@3 0@8>;3 2@33?34:==36032@373?5?5:63>C@:@826::?@3>0>5-5689 86?303436?5256012?:4A=>:-'','*6D32?5;8?5:6:= ?@30823520:-793?348640@8>;32@33?@82<336=5934 + 643> ?@3 05>01-2?86032 8- := ?@3 :7565:6 @52 7>8A3>=:>;>86?:=>3;198><85963342?:<3862C3>34 8==5>-8?5D39A 00:>456;9A 7>:0334 ?: 7822 ?@3 =:99:C56; - 6 - @373?5?5:652899:C34 @3 73?5?5:63> 52 45>30?34 ?: <3 3698>;34 :6 <859 56 >5-3 :,''* >3;52?3>34 <A :43B89 :9503 ?8?5:6 84;5> =:> :==36032 71652@8<93 1643> 30?5:62 ), $ * $ -$:=! ')86430?5:6:=0?' 736456;5656730589823 :,+'*:6?@3=593:=?@3 52?>50? 864 3225:62 "14;3 84;5> 21<E30? ?: ?@3 =:99:C56;0:645?5:62 8$@373?5?5:63>2@8993F301?373>2:689<:64=:>8 21- := 2''''' C5?@ ?C: 21>3?532 =:> ?@3 95B321- ?: ?@3 28?52=80?5:6 := ?@3 E1>52450?5:689 :1>?G <$@3 73?5?5:63> 2@899 87738> >3;198>9A :6 899 ?@3 48?32:=@38>56;<3=:>3?@3>589:1>?169322?@3 >589 :1>? 3F3-7?2 @52 87738>8603 =:> D8954 >382:62G 0$ @3 73?5?5:63> 2@899 6:? 45>30?9A :> 5645>30?9A ?@>38?36 :> ?8-73> C5?@ ?@3 7>:2301?5:6 C5?632232G - 7 - 4$@3 73?5?5:63> 2@899 6:? 56D:9D3 56 25-598> :==3603256=1?1>3G 3$@3 73?5?5:63> 2@899 6:? 938D3 ?@3 E1>52450?5:6 := ?@3 >589 :1>? C5?@:1? 73>-5225:6 := ?@3 2854 :1>? 16?59 ?@3 0823 >3;52?3>34 8;8562? @5- 52 4527:234:== ,* %# $ ) 52? :9 :