- 1 - ! "# !$ %! # &'(&)*+',&** % ! " # $ % & ' & (% ))) ! " # & % # & $ &* + & " $ * & ' % ' % * Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & & && , -," $ , & * & ' & & . ,%* & ' / #' " / #' $ % 001234 5% 67 83069: 923 5,%* 837467;<3=5>3?@351>?5=62?>60?9743226572 14;39? 94;6> 9>6267; 51? 5= >6A3 5% * >3;62?3>34 <B @5>981> 5:603 ?9?657 94;6> 462?>60? =5> ?@3 5==3703 81762@9<:31743>30?6572 , -,"$"7$974,5= 974 1743> 30?657 * 5= ?@3 >5?30?657 5= @6:4>37 =>5A 3C19: ==370320?%"=5>2@5>?D 0?.$62<3=5>3 ?@62 51>? 1743> 30?657 * + 5= > 233E67; >3;1:9> <96: 39>4?@3:39>734051723:=5>?@389>?632 & 67 >6A3 5% * F92 >3;62?3>34 <B @5>981> 5:603 ?9?657 94;6> 462?>60? 676?69::B =5> ?@3 - 3 - 5==3703 81762@9<:3 1743> 30?657 , 5= 9;9672? 97 17E75F783>25757?@3<92625=?@3=6>2?67=5>A9?65749?34 -** >3036G34 =>5A >32857437? 5 F@5 62 ?@3 =9?@3> 5= ?@3 G60?6A;6>: 9;34 9<51? %,B39>2 7 ?@3 =6>2? 67=5>A9?65749?34-**6?622?9?34?@9?57?@376;@? 5=**9?9<51?%8A?@3=6>2?67=5>A97?974 @62 =9A6:B A3A<3>2 @94 2:38? 67 ?@36> @5123 974 57 ?@3 73C? 49B A5>767; 9? 9<51? , 9A @3 =5174 ?@9? @62 A675>491;@?3>F@562?@3G60?6A67?@38>3237?0923F92 A62267; ==5>?2 A943 ?5 ?>903 @3> <1? =96:34 @3>3=5>3 57-**@3@94988>590@34?@385:6031>67;?@3 051>23 5= 67G32?6;9?657 ?@3 83?6?6573> 974 ?@3 G60?6A;6>: F3>3 ?>9034 9? 37;9:1>1 3?6?6573> F92 9>>32?34 67 ?@3 8>3237? 0923 57 %** 974 21<23H137?:B >3A97434 ?5?@3I146069:012?54B * 39>734 051723: =5> ?@3 83?6?6573> @9G67; >36?3>9?34 ?@3 ;>51742 1>;34 67 ?@3 83?6?657 8>9B2 ?5 9::5F?@383?6?657 - 4 - 3> 057?>9 :39>734 6;@ 51>? 5G3>7A37? :3943> 98839>67; =5> >32857437? 5% 974 :39>734 051723:98839>67;=5>>32857437?5@9G35885234?@3 83?6?657 @3B 21<A6? ?@9? 67 ?@3 3G37? ?@3 83?6?6573> 62 37:9>;34 57 <96: @3 62 :6E3:B ?5 ?9A83> F6?@ ?@3 8>52301?657 F6?732232 005>467;:B ?@3B 8>9B ?5 462A622 ?@383?6?657 , 1>67; ?@3 051>23 5= 67G32?6;9?657 ?@3 83?6?6573> 974 ?@3 G60?6A ;6>: F3>3 ?>9034 9? 37;9:1>1 @3 83?6?6573> F92 9>>32?34 67 ?@3 8>3237? 0923 57 %** 974 21<23H137?:B >3A97434 ?5 I146069: 012?54B @3 2?9?3A37? 5= ?@3 G60?6A ;6>: 1743> 30?657 %,* 5= > F92 >305>434 <B ?@3 I1>62460?6579: 9;62?>9?357,*@3G60?6A;6>:@922?9?34?@9? @3> 89>37?2 F3>3 A9E67; 3==5>?2 ?5 ;3? @3> A9>>634 ?@51;@2@3F9275?F6::67;@3>3=5>357**2@3 @94 ?>9G3:34 ?5 37;9:1>1 9:57; F6?@ ?@3 83?6?6573> 67 9 ?>967 974 ?@3B @94 2?9B34 9? 3A89789:B9 67 37;9:1>1 =5> 9 83>654 5= ?F5 49B2 @3 85:603 F@5 09A3 ?@3>3 - 5 - <>51;@? ?@3A <90E C038? ?@3 9=5>32964 2@3 @92 75? A94397B9::3;9?6579;9672??@383?6?6573>@3>3=5>36? 629889>37??@9??@39::3;9?6572=517467?@32?9?3A37?5= ?@3G60?6A;6>:1743>30?657%,*5=>4575?9??>90? ?@3 0@9>;3 2@33?34 5==37032 92 9;9672? ?@3 83?6?6573> @3 83?6?6573> 9;34 9<51? B39>2 F@5 @92 75 5?@3> 0>6A679:97?303437?26267012?54B=>5A%** - 743> ?@3 06>01A2?97032 ?@3 8>9B3> A943 <B ?@3 83?6?6573> =5> ;>97? 5= >3;1:9> <96: 73342 ?5 <3 972F3>34 9==6>A9?6G3:B 005>467;:B =5::5F67; 5>43> 62 892234 @383?6?657629::5F34 @3 83?6?6573> 62 46>30?34 ?5 <3 37:9>;34 57 <96: 67 >6A3 5% * 5= @5>981> 5:603 ?9?657 94;6> >3;62?3>34=5>?@35==3703281762@9<:31743>30?6572 , -," $ 974 , 5= 974 1743> 30?657 * 5= ?@3 >5?30?657 5= @6:4>37 =>5A 3C19: ==37032 0? % 837467; 57 ?@3 =6:3 5= :39>734 446?6579: 3226572 14;3 - 6 - 974 62?>60? 974 3226572 14;3 94;6> 67 83069: 923 5,%*21<I30??5?@3=5::5F67;05746?6572 9$ 3?6?6573>2@9::3C301?383>2579:<574=5>9 21A 5= 2% F6?@ ?F5 21>3?632 =5> ?@3 :6E321A ?5 ?@3 29?62=90?657 5= ?@3 I1>62460?6579: 51>?J <$ 3?6?6573> 2@9:: 98839> >3;1:9>:B 57 9:: ?@3 49?325=@39>67;<3=5>3?@3>69:51>?17:322?@3 >69: 51>? 3C3A8?2 @62 98839>9703 =5> G9:64 >392572J 0$ 3?6?6573> 2@9:: 75? 46>30?:B 5> 6746>30?:B ?@>39?37 5> ?9A83> F6?@ ?@3 8>52301?657 F6?732232J 4$ 3?6?6573> 2@9:: 75? 67G5:G3 67 26A6:9> 5==3703267=1?1>3J 3$ 3?6?6573>2@9::75?:39G3?@3I1>62460?6575= ?@3 >69: 51>? F6?@51? 83>A622657 5= ?@3 2964 51>? 17?6: ?@3 0923 >3;62?3>34 9;9672? @6A 62 462852345== -+ &$ %! * ! # 62?5%:5%*