- 1 - ! "#!$ %! # &' &()*'+&)) % !"#$ % & ' ( ( )"$ #$ * !"+ % & ( ' Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( +# (& '+"# ( &' , $+ ( ( (( #-&' ,+&'&.' ,&' # ( $# + , ( $ ( ( / " $+ ( 0 & 0 ' 112345 67 84169: 934 ;" $+ 847567< =4>;?4 @A4 ;2?@ ;> 63@?61@ 975 4336;73 25<4 95<6?6 9?6367< ;2@ ;> 1?6.4 ;, $+ ?4<63@4?45 =B A;?982? 8;:614 3@9@6;7 95<6?6 563@?61@ >;? @A4 ;>>47143 82763A9=:4 2754? 41@6;73 #-&' ,+&'&.' ,&' # ;> A9?9@6B9 B9B997A6@9$#&>;?3A;?@C$#/'97541@6;73+ 975,;>@A4?;@41@6;7;>A6:5?47>?;.4D29: >>61431@ $ &>;? 3A;?@ C 1@/ $/' 63 =4>;?4 @A63 ;2?@ 2754?41@6;7+"#;>A9?9@6B99<9?6E92?9E3A997A6@9 $#344E67<?4<2:9?=96: - 3 - 49?5 @A4 :49?745 1;2734: >;? @A4 84@6@6;74? 975 @A4 :49?745 6<A ;2?@ ;F4?7.47@ :4954? >;? @A4 ?438;7547@; # 438;7547@;6334?F4567@A4.9@@4?975A93 ?4.9674527!?48?4347@45=4>;?4@A63;2?@ + ( 67 ?6.4 ;, $+ G93 ?4<63@4?45 =B A;?982? ;:614 @9@6;7 95<6?6 563@?61@ 9<9673@ 27E7;G7 84?3;73 676@69::B >;? @A4 ;>>4714 82763A9=:4 2754? 41@6;7 #-&';>@A4$#2?67<@A41;2?34;>67F43@6<9@6;7 @A484@6@6;74?975@A4F61@6.!<6?:GA;63@A4592<A@4?;>@A4 >6?3@ 67>;?.97@ G4?4 @?9145 975 @A4 84@6@6;74? G93 9??43@45 ;7 $"$+ 975 32=34H247@:B ?4.97545 @; @A4 I256169: 123@;5B A467F43@6<9@6;7;>@A41934631;.8:4@45975@A4 1A9?<4!3A44@ A93 =447 >6:45 9<9673@ @A4 84@6@6;74? >;? @A4 9::4<45 ;>>47143 A4 =96: 988:619@6;7 >6:45 =B @A4 84@6@6;74? =4>;?4 @A4 @?69: ;2?@ 67 84169: 934 ;" $+ 63 ?4I41@45;7$$+ A4?4>;?4A463=4>;?4@A63;2?@ 49?745 1;2734: >;? @A4 84@6@6;74? 32=.6@3 @A9@ @A484@6@6;74?639B;27<3@4?9<459=;2@B49?3A9F67<7; - 4 - 1?6.679:97@414547@3 A4?4637;.9@4?69:;7?41;?5@;3A;G @A9@ @A4 84@6@6;74? A93 1;..6@@45 @A4 ;>>4714 GA61A G;2:5 9@@?91@41@6;73+975,;>@A4 1@11;?567<:BA4 8?9B3@;9::;G@A484@6@6;7 , 4? 1;7@?9 :49?745 6<A ;2?@ ;F4?7.47@ :4954? A93 ;88;345 @A4 84@6@6;7 A4 32=.6@3 @A9@ @A4 F61@6.!<6?:63 9 .67;? 975 @A484@6@6;74? 975 @A4F61@6.!<6?: G4?4 @?9145 @;<4@A4? 975 @A4B A95 3@9B45 @;<4@A4? >;? 9 84?6;5;>749?:B>;2?59B311;?567<:B3A48?9B3@;563.633 @A484@6@6;7 - A4>6?3@67>;?.97@A95988?;91A45@A48;:614;7 $,$-$+9::4<67<@A9@A4?.67;?592<A@4?GA;A951;.4 9:;7< G6@A A4? >9.6:B .4.=4?3 @; A;?982? =23!3@975 G93 >;275.63367<;7$$-$+>>;?@3.954@;@?914A4?A95 >96:45 4? .;=6:4 8A;74 G93 9:3; 3G6@1A45 ;>> A4?4>;?4 @A4>6?3@67>;?.97@A95988?;91A45@A48;:614 A4F61@6.!<6?: G93 @?9145 67 @A4 A;234 ;> @A4 84@6@6;74?/3 ?4:9@6F4 ;7 $$-$+ A4 84@6@6;74? G93 32=34H247@:B 9??43@45 ;7 $"$+ 975 ?4.97545 @; I256169: 123@;5B A4 67F43@6<9@6;7;>@A41934631;.8:4@45975@A41A9?<4!3A44@ - 5 - A93 =447 >6:45 A4 F61@6.!<6?: GA; G93 347@ >;? .45619: 4D9.679@6;7 A95 67>;?.45 @A4 ;1@;? @A9@ 3A4 E74G @A4 84@6@6;74?>;?@A4:93@@G;B49?3@A?;2<A73@9<?9.975=;@A 5416545 @; .9??B 975 @A4B @;<4@A4? G47@ @; 9::9?6 975 3@9B45 67 @A4 A;234 ;> @A4 84@6@6;74?/3 363@4? >?;. $$-$+ @; $ $-$+ 7 $$-$+ @A4 8;:614 =?;2<A@ A4? =91E ;G4F4? @A4 F61@6.!<6?: A93 7;@ 1;! ;84?9@45 G6@A @A4 ;1@;? >;? A4? .45619: 4D9.679@6;7 A4 3@9@4.47@ ;> @A4 F61@6.!<6?: 2754? 41@6;7 ,+ ;> ? G93?41;?545=B@A4I2?63561@6;79:9<63@?9@497567@A43965 3@9@4.47@ @A4 F61@6.!<6?: A93 3@9@45 @A9@ 3A4 A95 <;74 @; 9::9?6 >?;. A;?982? =23!3@975 975 @A4?49>@4? 3A4 A95 <;749:;7<G6@A@A484@6@6;74?67A63@G;GA44:4?@;9 4.8:4 975<;@.9??645 A4?49>@4?GA47@A4BG47@@;84@6@6;74?/3 89?47@3/ A;234 @A4B G4?4 7;@ 9::;G45 673654 @A4 A;234 2=34H247@:B @A4B 3@9B45 67 @A4 A;234 ;> @A4 84@6@6;74?/3 363@4?>;?984?6;5;>>;2?59B3975@A48;:61419.4@A4?4975 =?;2<A@ A4? =91E ;7 $$-$+ A4 A93 3@9@45 @A9@ 3A4 A95 8AB3619: 1;7@91@ G6@A @A4 84@6@6;74? GA6:4 3A4 3@9B45 G6@AA6.9@9::9?6A4A937;@.95497B38416>619::4<9@6;7 - 6 - ;>34D29:67@4?1;2?34=B@A484@6@6;74?9753A4A939:3;7;@ 1;!;84?9@45 G6@A @A4 ;1@;? >;? .45619: 4D9.679@6;7 A4 84@6@6;74? 63 9<45 9=;2@ B49?3 4 63 67 @A4 123@;5B >;? @A4:93@.;?4@A97>6F4.;7@A3 A467F43@6<9@6;7;>@A41934 631;.8:4@45975@A41A9?<4!3A44@A93=447>6:45;7@67245 54@47@6;7;>@A484@6@6;74?GA;639B;27<3@4?9<459=;2@ B49?3 63 :6E4:B @; A9F4 95F4?34 6.891@ ;7 A63 >2@2?4 8?;3841@397519?44?754?@A416?12.3@971439.;>@A4 ;8676;7@A9@@A48?9B4?.954>;?<?97@;>?4<2:9?=96:74453 @; =4 973G4?45 9>>6?.9@6F4:B 11;?567<:B @A4 >;::;G67< ;?54? A484@6@6;7639::;G45 A4 84@6@6;74? 63 56?41@45 @; =4 47:9?<45 ;7 =96: 67 ?6.4 ;, $+ ;> A;?982? ;:614 @9@6;7 95<6?6 563@?61@ ?4<63@4?45 >;? @A4 ;>>47143 82763A9=:4 2754? 41@6;73 #-&' ,+&'&.' ,&' # ;> $# 975 41@6;73 + 975 , ;> 1@ $ 847567< 67 84169: 934 ;" $+ ;7 @A4 >6:4 ;> @A4 63@?61@ 975 4336;73 25<4;2?@95<6?632=I41@@;@A4>;::;G67<1;756@6;73 - 7 - 9' A4 84@6@6;74? 3A9:: 4D412@4 84?3;79: =;75 >;? 9 32. ;> 3$$$$$ ! G6@A @G; 32?4@643 >;? @A4 :6E432. @; @A4 39@63>91@6;7 ;> @A4 I2?63561@6;79: ;2?@J =' A4 84@6@6;74? 3A9:: 98849? ?4<2:9?:B ;7 9:: @A4 59@43;>A49?67<=4>;?4@A4 ?69:;2?@27:433@A4 ?69: ;2?@ 4D4.8@3 A63 98849?9714 >;? F9:65 ?493;73J 1' A4 84@6@6;74? 3A9:: 7;@ 56?41@:B ;? 6756?41@:B @A?49@47;?@9.84?G6@A@A48?;3412@6;7G6@743343J 5' A484@6@6;74?3A9::7;@67F;:F46736.6:9?;>>47143 67>2@2?4J 4' A484@6@6;74?3A9::7;@:49F4@A4I2?63561@6;7;>@A4 ?69: ;2?@ G6@A;2@ 84?.6336;7 ;> @A4 3965 ;2?@ 27@6: @A4 1934 ?4<63@4?45 9<9673@ A6. 63 5638;345 ;>> ,* &$ %! ) ! 63@;:;+