- 1 - !" # ! $%&'$()*%+&$)) # ! "# $ %&& ' %&& & $( )"' ( '" " %$# Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % *+%#*% ' $ ' " $$, (* % % %% -,#.#-,# '*% *,$-% +$($$ %" ((,' % % / ! -* (* " % ' " " 0 "! '! 0 "! '! # $ 112345 6$ 7. 84179: 934 6-* (* 84.57.; <4=6>4 ?@4 62>? 6= 73?>71? 9.5 43376.3 !25;4 9.5 84179: !25;4 95;7>7 9>737.; 62? 6= >7A4 6$$, (* >4;73?4>45 <B @9@982> 6:714 ?9?76. 95;7> =6> ?@4 6==4.143 82.73@9<:4 2.54> 41?76.3 -,#.# -,# >495 C7?@ 41?76. * 6= 9.5 41?76.3*,$-6= 1?($9.5 41?76.3+$( 9.5$$6=>6@7<7?76.6=@7:5"9>>79;41?((,73<4=6>4 ?@73 62>? 2.54> 41?76. *+ 6= > 344D7.; >4;2:9> <97: - 3 - 49>5?@4:49>.45162.34:=6>?@484?7?76.4>9.5 ?@4 :49>.45 7;@ 62>? 6E4>.A4.? :4954> =6> ?@4 >4386.54.? 63$ 9.5 @62;@ ?@4 ;29>579. 6= ?@4 E71?7A;7>: @93 <44. 34>E45 7. ?@4 A9??4> ?@4>4 73 .6 >48>434.?9?76.6.<4@9:=6=?@4;29>579.6=?@4E71?7A;7>: <4=6>4?@7362>? % 7. >7A4 6$$, (* C93 >4;73?4>45 <B @9@982> 6:714 ?9?76. 95;7>7 573?>71? 9;97.3? ?@4 84?7?76.4> @4>47. 9.5 ?C6 6?@4>3 7.7?79::B =6> ?@4 6==4.143 82.73@9<:4 2.54> 41?76.3 + $( 9.5 $$ 6= ?@4 @7:5 "9>>79;443?>97.?1?6.?@4<93736=?@4=7>3?7.=6>A9?76. >4147E45 =>6A >4386.54.? 6 284>7.?4.54.? ==714 6= ?@4@7:54E4:68A4.?>6F41?==714>9? @9@982>2>7.; ?@4162>346=7.E43?7;9?76.?@484?7?76.4>C939>>43?456. ($(-(* @4 7.E43?7;9?76. 6= ?@4 1934 73 16A8:4?45 9.5?@41@9>;43@44?@93<44.=7:459;97.3??@>4484>36.3 @484?7?76.4>739>>97;.459391123456$7.?@41@9>;4 3@44? @4 <97: 988:719?76. =7:45 <B @7A <4=6>4 ?@4 ?>79: - 4 - 62>? 7. 84179: 934 6-* (* C93 >4F41?45 6. (,$$(*@4>4=6>4@473<4=6>4?@7362>? * 49>.45162.34:=6>?@484?7?76.4>32<A7?3?@9? 2.57382?45:B ?@4 E71?7A;7>: C93 3?9B7.; 7. @4> A6?@4>/3 @6234 =6> ?@4 :93? A6>4 ?@9. 6.4 9.5 @9:= B49> 8>76> ?6 ?@459?46=>4;73?>9?76.6=?@4%@4E71?7A;7>:@93.6? 16684>9?45 C7?@ ?@4 "45719: ==714> =6> @4> A45719: 4G9A7.9?76. @4 84?7?76.4> C@6 @93 .6 6?@4> 1>7A7.9: 9.?41454.?3 73 7. 123?65B =6> ?@4 :93? A6>4 ?@9. 37G A6.?@3116>57.;:B@48>9B3?69::6C?@484?7?76. 4> 16.?>9 :49>.45 7;@ 62>? 6E4>.A4.? :4954> @93 6886345 ?@4 84?7?76. 4 32<A7?3 ?@9? ?@4 E71?7A;7>:C93A7.6>936.?@459?46=?@4A9>>79;49.5 3@4C9334G29::B93392:?45<B?@484?7?76.4>7.@73@6234 9=?4> ?@4 A9>>79;4 @4 E71?7A;7>: C93 9:36 7::?>49?45 7. @4> A9?>7A6.79: @6234 9.5 ?@4>4=6>4 3@4 @95 :4=? ?@4 16A89.B6=?@484?7?76.4>9.5?9D4.3@4:?4>7.@4>89>4.?3/ @6234.?@44E4.??@484?7?76.4>734.:9>;456.<97:@4 - 5 - 73:7D4:B?6?9A84>C7?@?@4A9?4>79:8>63412?76.C7?.43343 116>57.;:B@48>9B3?6573A733?@484?7?76. , . ?@4 =7>3? 7.=6>A9?76. 32<A7??45 <B ?@4 >4386.54.? 6 6. ((,(* 7? 73 3?9?45 ?@9? 6. ($(,(*?@4E71?7A;7>:@9519::45?@473?>71?4:8:7.4 95;7>7 9.5 7.=6>A45 ?@4A ?@9? @4> A9>>79;4 C7?@ ?@4 84?7?76.4> C93 84>=6>A45 6. $$( <B @4> 89>4.?3 9.5?@489>4.?36=?@484?7?76.4>9.53@4C93A7.6>9??@4 ?7A46=?@4A9>>79;4=?4>>4147E7.;321@8@6.419::=>6A ?@4E71?7A;7>:6.($(,(*?@4==714>39.56?@4>3=>6A ?@473?>71?4:8:7.4@95;6.4?6?@4@62346=?@4E71?7A ;7>:9.5>431245@4>9.5<>62;@?@4>?6?@4 9:9A9.57>9 95;7>7.4.H27>B?@4E71?7A;7>:9::4;45:B7.=6>A45?@9? @4> A9>>79;4 C93 84>=6>A45 C7?@ ?@4 84?7?76.4> 9;97.3? @4> C73@ C@4. 3@4 C93 9 A7.6> 9.5 7? 73 7. ?@73 <91D;>62.5 ?@4 =7>3? 7.=6>A9?76. C93 32<A7??45 6. ((,(* 2>7.; ?@4 162>34 6= 7.E43?7;9?76. ?@4 84?7?76.4> C93 9>>43?45 6. ($(-(* @4 7.E43?7;9?76. 7.?@419347316A8:4?459.51@9>;43@44?@93<44.=7:45 - 6 - @4 9112345 6 73 ?@4 A6?@4> 6= ?@4 84?7?76.4> 9.5 9112345673?@4A6?@4>6=?@4E71?7A;7>:@49112345 63 9.5 @9E4 <44. ;>9.?45 9.?71789?6>B <97: <B ?@4 F2>73571?76.9: 43376.3 62>? @4 84?7?76.4> C@6 @93 .6 6?@4>1>7A7.9:9.?41454.?3737.123?65B=6>?@4:93?A6>4 ?@9.37GA6.?@3@41934<4=6>4?@4?>79:62>?733?7::9? ?@4 3?9;4 6= =>9A7.; 1@9>;4 @4 8>63412?76. 7. 9:: @93 17?45 $ 1@9>;43@44?45 C7?.43343 9.5 ?@4>4=6>4 ?@4 1@9.143 6= ?@4 ?>79: <47.; 16A8:4?45 7. ?@4 .49> 366. 73 E4>B>4A6?4 7.14?@4E71?7A;7>:@93:4=??@416A89.B6= @4> @23<9.5 C@6 73 ?@4 84?7?76.4> @4>47. 9<62? 6.4 9.5 @9:= B49> 8>76> ?6 ?@4 59?4 6= ?@4 >4;73?>9?76. 6=?@4 % ?@4>4 19..6? <4 9.B 988>4@4.376. ?@9? ?@4 84?7?76.4> 73 :7D4:B?6?9A84>C7?@?@4A9?4>79:8>63412?76.C7?.43343 - @4 A9?4>79: 6. >416>5 C62:5 9:36 ;6 ?6 3@6C ?@9? ?@4 E71?7A;7>: @93 .6? 16684>9?45 C7?@ ?@4 61?6> =6> @4> A45719: 4G9A7.9?76. @4 @93 3?9?45 <4=6>4 ?@4 61?6> ?@9? 3@4 @95 34G29: 7.?4>162>34 9<62? $,$ A6.?@3 8>76> ?6 ?@4 59?4 6= ?@4 >4;73?>9?76. 6= ?@4 % - 7 - .54> ?@4 17>12A3?9.143 9A 6= ?@4 687.76. ?@9? ?@4 8>9B4> A954 <B ?@4 84?7?76.4> =6> ;>9.? 6= >4;2:9> <97: .4453 ?6 <4 9.3C4>45 9==7>A9?7E4:B 116>57.;:B ?@4 =6::6C7.;6>54> @484?7?76.739::6C45 @4 84?7?76.4> 73 57>41?45 ?6 <4 4.:9>;45 6. <97: 7. >7A4 6$$, (* 6= @9@982> 6:714 ?9?76. 95;7>7 >4;73?4>45 =6> ?@4 6==4.143 82.73@9<:4 2.54> 41?76.3 -,#.# -,# >495 C7?@ 41?76. * 6= 9.5 41?76.3*,$-6= 1?($9.5 41?76.3+$( 9.5$$6=>6@7<7?76.6=@7:5"9>>79;41?((,7. 84179: 9346-* (*6.?@4=7:46=?@473?>71?9.5 43376.3 !25;462>?95;7>732<F41??6?@4=6::6C7.;16.57?76.3 9#@484?7?76.4>3@9::4G412?484>36.9:<6.5=6>9 32A 6= 3$((((( C7?@ ?C6 32>4?743 =6> ?@4 :7D432A ?6 ?@4 39?73=91?76. 6= ?@4 F2>73571?76.9: 62>?I - 8 - <#@4 84?7?76.4> 3@9:: 98849> >4;2:9>:B 6. 9:: ?@4 59?436=@49>7.;<4=6>4?@4>79:62>?2.:433?@4 >79: 62>? 4G4A8?3 @73 98849>9.14 =6> E9:75 >4936.3I 1# @4 84?7?76.4> 3@9:: .6? 57>41?:B 6> 7.57>41?:B ?@>49?4. 6> ?9A84> C7?@ ?@4 8>63412?76. C7?.43343I 5#@4 84?7?76.4> 3@9:: .6? 7.E6:E4 7. 37A7:9> 6==4.1437.=2?2>4I 4#@4 84?7?76.4> 3@9:: .6? :49E4 ?@4 F2>73571?76. 6= ?@4 >79: 62>? C7?@62? 84>A73376. 6= ?@4 3975 62>? 2.?7: ?@4 1934 >4;73?4>45 9;97.3? @7A 73 573863456== ,* $" # ) 73?6$ :6$ &