Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 83933 (KAR)
MR GUNAKARA SHETTY v. THE COMMISSIONER
WP/22723/2025 · 2025-12-12
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 83933 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 83933 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"% %
& '
!"
!#
$ % & &
'
"
%&'
"
( (&
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
$
%
&
( &
&
( )
&
& (
"'
(
(
(
*
"! +
(
, , -. . /0 1023234506 /78 9/7::05;0< 7 542390 =07635; 4 <720<0 /78 7:84 84>;/2 ?46 7 @632 46 <36092345 24 2/0 608145<0528 24 ;6752 /3A 2/0 63;/2 4? ?3682 60?>87: 4B06 2/0 10232345 89/0<>:0 1641062C 78 106 2/0 4B065A052 5423?3972345 9369>:76 <720<
/01023234506@78106A3220<24499>1C7160A3808 =07635; 27::4"832>720352/0;64>5<?:4464?2/094AA06937:
- 3 -
94A1:0D 3E7A17<C 5<>82637: 607 1148320 ??390 73E7A17<C75;7:>6>
7:>E7E8/357 7557<7%/0590?462/ 60?0660<2478-2/0160A3808-'=0:45;35;242/0608145<0524 /0 1023234506 @78 945<>9235; =>835088 35 2/0 160A3808 83590 2/0 :782 # C0768 2 38 945205<0< 2/72 2/0 608145<052 4 35205<0< 24 945<>92 75 7>92345 35 6081092 4? ?3B0 8/418 359:><35; 2/0 160A3808 499>130< =C 2/0 1023234506 78 106 2/0 084:>2345 =07635; 4"! <720< " 75< 1641480< 24 0B392 2/0 1023234506 ?64A 2/0 160A3808 84 2/72 7 205<06 94>:< =0 97::0< ?46 75< 450 4? 2/0 8/418 94>:< =0 7::4220< 24 7 106845 =0:45;35; 24 9/0<>:0< 7820
/0 1023234506 945205<8 2/72 45
" 2/0 F457:
4AA38834506 75;7:>6> 32C 4614672345 388>0< 7 542390 =07635; 4 827235; 2/72 7 205<06 38 35B320< ?46 7::42A052 4? ?3B0 8/418 35 3E7A17<C A76E0275<352/3860;76<7A00235;@7897::0<?46352/0F457: 4AA38834506G84??39045"727A2494583<062/0 63;/2 4? ?3682 60?>87: 4? 2/0 1023234506 75< 83A3:76:C 832>720< 2057528
/0 1023234506 945205<8 2/72 54 A00235; @78 945<>920< =C 2/0 F457: 4AA38834506 45 " 75< /0590 2/0 1023234506 <3< 542 /7B0 75 411462>532C 24 1>2
- 4 -
?46@76</38711:397234524809>60/3863;/24??368260?>87:
/0 608145<052 4 2/05 <093<0< 24 945<>92 7 :42206C 24 3<0523?C 2/0 8/41 2/72 94>:< =0 7::4220< 24 7 60806B0< 9720;46C /0607?206 2/0 608145<052 4 388>0< 7 542390 <720< 97::35; >145 2/0 1023234506 24 B79720 2/0 10232345 160A3808 =0?460 "
/0 1023234506 945205<8 2/72 2/4>;/ /38 205>60 97A0 24 75 05< /0 @78 945235>0< 35 2/0 160A3808781062/04B065A0529369>:76<720<75< 2/72/03805232:0<2460806B0/3863;/24??368260?>87:=0?4602/0 1641062C 38 7>923450<
/0 1023234506 97>80< 7 542390 <720< 352/3860;76<242/0608145<0524@/4388>0<7 601:C<720<60H09235;2/060I>0824?2/01023234506 75<2/6072050<2427E0:0;7:792345
/01023234506382/060?460 =0?4602/384>629/7::05;35;2/0542390<720<
" 07650< 94>580: ?46 2/0 1023234506 8>=A3220< 2/72 2/01023234506387205752352/0160A3808=C/4:<35;4B063578 A>9/780B057?206/38205>6097A0247505<2/0608145<052 4 =780< 45 2/0 9369>:76 388>0< =C 2/0 2720 4B065A052 <720< /7< 106A3220< 2/0 1023234506 24 60A735 35 14880883454?2/0160A3808=C17C35;2/005/7590<60520 2/060?460 945205<8 2/72 2/0 1023234506 /78 7 63;/2 4? ?3682
- 5 -
60?>87: 75< /0 38 05232:0< 24 60A735 35 1488088345 4?
2/0 160A380823::/3863;/24??368260?>87:380D/7>820<083<082/38 /0 945205<8 2/72 2/0 3A1>;50< 542390 38 350??0923B0 78 2/0 608145<052 4 /78 542 A0523450< 2/0 6078458 ?46 353237235;
0B392345 164900<35;8 >5<06 2/0 164B383458 4? 2/0 765727E7 >=:39 60A3808 %B392345 4? 57>2/463J0< 99>17528' 92 !0945205<82/72@/72@78A0523450<352/0542390@78 2/72 2/0 1023234506G8 206A /7< 94A0 24 75 05< :45; =79E 75< 2/722/0608145<05241641480<24945<>92757>9234575< 2/7232383AA35052240B3922/010232345060945205<82/7235 2/0711:3972345%4'?3:0<=C2/0608145<05248 75< ?46 B797235; 2/0 352063A 46<06 <720< # 32 38 82720< 2/72 2/0 160A3808 35 499>172345 4? 2/0 1023234506 @78 076A76E0<352/0:42206C?4689/0<>:0<978200945205<82/72 2/38<3<542?35<A052345352/0542390@/39/383A1>;50<352/38 @632 10232345 0 7:84 945205<8 2/72 2/0 608145<052 4 38 26C35; 24 0B392 2/0 1023234506 75< 2/060=C <0163B0 /3A 4? 2/0 63;/24??368260?>87:07:84945205<82/722/0603854A720637: 240827=:38/2/722/08/4135I>0823453860806B0<?4689/0<>:0< 9782052/3860;76</035B320<2/07220523454?2/04>622475 711:3972345 ?3:0< =C 2/0 1023234506 >5<06 2/0 3;/2 24
- 6 -
5?46A7234592800E35;?462/07><3475<B3<04;671/4? 2/0164900<35;84?2/0A00235;/0:<45"727A 24 076A76E 2/0 8/41 35 73E7A17<C A76E02 ?46 89/0<>:0< 97820 0 945205<8 2/72 2/0 >=:39 5?46A72345 ??3906 75< 0B05>0 ??3906 F457: ??390 %' >672E7: 75;7:>6> 32C 4614672345 /78 388>0< 7 601:C 827235; 2/72 54 7><34 46 B3<04;671/ 4? 2/0 873< 164900<35;8 38 7B73:7=:0 0 945205<8 2/72 2/38 38 35 8276E 94526782 24 2/0 601:C 8>=A3220< =C 2/0 608145<0524247542390388>0<=C2/01023234506@/0603532 38 A0523450< 2/72 2/0 1649088 4? 80:092345 4? 8/41%8' 2/64>;/ :42206C @78 B3<04;671/0< 0 2/060?460 945205<8 2/72 2/0 052360 164900<35;8 35323720< =C 2/0 608145<052 4 38 45:C 35205<0<240B3922/01023234506?64A2/0160A380835I>082345 ! 069452672/0:07650<94>580:?46608145<0524 8>=A3220<2/722/03A1>;50<54239038388>0<>5<06 092345! 4? 2/0 765727E7 >=:39 60A3808 %B392345 4? 57>2/46380< 99>17528' 92 ! 0 945205<8 2/72 2/0 1023234506 /78 8>=A3220< 7 601:C 75< 2/72 2/0 87A0 @4>:< =0 94583<060< 35 79946<7590@32/:7@ 4?76782/063;/24??368260?>87:4?2/0 1023234506 38 94590650< /0 945205<8 2/72 2/0 7>92345 5423?397234538542C02388>0<75<2/722/063;/24??368260?>87:38
- 7 -
@32/<67@5=C2/0 27204B065A0520945205<82/7278106 2/014:39C4?2/0 27204B065A052#K4?2/0160A3808/78 =00560806B0<?46 9/0<>:0<7820875< 9/0<>:0<
63=0875< 352/7260;76<7:42206C@78/0:<243<0523?C2/0160A38082/72 /7<24=060806B0<?46 9/0<>:0<782075<722/0:42206C2/0 160A3808 35 499>172345 4? 2/0 1023234506 @78 076A76E0< ?46
9/0<>:0<782002/060?460945205<82/722/38@7845:C75 3593<0527: 607845 75< 542 2/0 84:0 607845 ?46 0B392345 4? 2/0 10232345060945205<82/723?2/01023234506-8206A/7894A0 24 75 05< /0 /78 54 42/06 412345 2/75 24 I>32 75< <0:3B06 B79752 1488088345 A460 176239>:76:C 35 2/0 :3;/2 4? 2/0 <0B0:41A05257A0:C@32/<67@7:4?2/063;/24??368260?>87:
/7B0 94583<060< 2/0 8>=A3883458 4? 2/0 :07650< 94>580:?462/0102323450678@0::782/0:07650<94>580:?462/0 608145<0524
8 63;/2:C 945205<0< =C 2/0 :07650< 94>580: ?46 608145<052 4 @/72 38 9/7::05;0< 38 75 35549>4>8 542390 388>0<>5<06 092345!4?2/092! /094520523454?2/0 1023234506 2/72 2/0 542390 <408 542 802 4>2 ;64>5<8 78 94520A1:720<>5<06 092345!%'4?2/092!38A381:790<
- 8 -
3578A>9/782/054239081093?397::C35<39720<2/722/0205>604? 2/0 1023234506 /7< 94A0 24 75 05< 75< 2/72 608145<052 4 <08360<24605423?C2/0160A3808
/0 @46< L>57>2/463J0< 499>172345L 38 <0?350< >5<06 092345%;'4?2/092!78?4::4@8,
/060?460 2/0 542390 388>0< =C 2/0 608145<052 4 9:076:C8>=8963=0<24 092345!%'4?2/092! />82/0 9452052345 4?
2/0 :07650< 94>580: ?46 2/0 1023234506 2/72 2/0 542390@78<0?0923B0385427990127=:0 # 5 84 ?76 78 9452052345 4? 2/0 :07650< 94>580: ?46 2/010232345062/722/063;/24??368260?>87:4?2/01023234506@78 <0530< =C B362>0 4? 2/0 3A1>;50< 164900<35;8 32 38 60:0B752 5420 2/72 2/0 2720 4B065A052 /78 54@ 27E05 7 <0938345 24
- 9 -
@32/<67@ 2/0 63;/2 4? ?3682 60?>87: 75< /78 <360920< 2/0 :497:
=4<308 24 076A76E #K 4? 2/0 160A3808 =0:45;35; 24 32 ?46 7::42A052 24 1068458 =0:45;35; 24 9/0<>:0< 78208 75<
9/0<>:0<
63=08 2 7:84 7110768 ?64A 2/0 164900<35;8 2/72 608145<052 4 /0:< 7 :42206C 72 @/39/ 2/0 160A3808 35 499>172345 4? 2/0 1023234506 @78 84>;/2 24 =0 5423?30< ?46
9/0<>:0<78208
/060?4602/01023234506975542A7E075C ;630B7590 7=4>2 /38 160A3808 =035; 076A76E0< ?46 9/0<>:0< 7820(>62/06A4602/063;/24??368260?>87:@/39/@782/0 63;/2 945?0660< =C 2/0 2720 4B065A052 >145 2057528 35 499>172345 4? 2/0 160A3808 =0:45;35; 24 2/0 :497: 7>2/4632308 /7854@=035;@32/<67@575<2/0 27204B065A052/7854@ 1641480<247::422/0160A3808=0:45;35;24327A45;82B7634>8 809234584?2/0849302C
/060?4605406646975=0?4>5<4>235 2/014:39C4?2/0 27204B065A05235076A76E35;2/0160A3808 =0:45;35;242/0:497:=4<308?467::42A052241068458=0:45;35; 24 9/0<>:0<782075< 9/0<>:0<
63=08
? 2/0 1023234506 38 05232:0< 24 75C 42/06 63;/2 /0 A7C@46E4>2/3860A0<C3579946<7590@32/:7@84457?2062/0 601:C ?3:0< =C /3A 24 2/0 3A1>;50< 8/4@97>80 542390 38 94583<060<75<7116416372046<063817880<
- 10 -
5 2/72 B30@ 4? 2/0 A72206 2/38 @632 10232345 38 <38A3880<=>28>=H092244=806B72345A7<07=4B0
() &%' %
17674824" ?64A17674!23::2/005< 3824, :4,