Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 83805 (KAR)
MR DOMINIC ALEXANDER D SOUZA v. MR ROSHAN JOEL ROCHE
CRL.A/1098/2024 · 2025-12-17
G Basavaraja
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 83805 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 83805 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%&%
"''
()
*
! "
" #
$ % &"' (
#
" # !) %
*
+)$&(
"
' *
"
"
,
*
**
+$*
)$!+
" * ' #
* -
'
. . /"
"'
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%"
012 344536 12 71658 9: ;05 3445663<;=>?4631<3<; 951<@3@@A15B589:;05CD8@?5<;>73=ED1;;3683;58 432258 1<
>)$!+ 9: ;05 * ' >DA; 3<@36DAD #&7>A20>A;F;05;A136 >DA;F(
05 ></965 D4A5?5 >DA; 1< ;05 =325 >7
* B
# A54>A;581< ! +3;43A3@A340>7;05CD8@?5<;
032>925AB5832D<85A. F
! " # $
! ! %
&
! %
! '
! ! ( )*+ , F + <;0561@0;>7 ;05></965D4A5?5 >DA;/2A5=5<;
=63A171=3;1>< >7 ;05 65@36 4>21;1>< 1; 12 <>G 5B185<; ;03; ;05 3445663<; 951<@ ;05 =>?4631<3<; D<85A 5=;1>< +$ >7
- 3 -
5@>;13965 <2;AD?5<;2 =; $$ 12 362> 5<;1;658 ;> 7165 3< 344536 3@31<2; ;05 CD8@?5<; >7 3=ED1;;36 432258 9: ;05 ;A136
>DA;957>A5;055221><2 >DA;21<=50512=><2185A58;>953 B1=;1? 7 ;012 >DA; G5A5 ;> 4A>=558 ;> 053A 3<8 85=185 ;05 3445363;;0122;3@51;=>D68854A1B5;0543A;152>73<3B3163965 7>AD?15;012 >DA;7>A7DA;05A=03665<@5
1?163A B15G 032 955< ;3H5< 9: ;05 1@0 >DA; >7 <80A3 A38520 1<
"
'
* A54>A;581<! $!I9:;051@0
>DA; >7 380:3 A38520 1< # #
B # # A5<85A58 1< A1?1<36 44536 >! >7!85=1858><+A8D6:!I3<81<;05=325>7 #
-#
B A54>A;581< ! $$I 3<8 1< B A5<85A58 A1?1<3644536 >$)>7 85=1858 >< 2; D6: !I ;05 85=121>< >7 1@0 >DA; >7
03;;12@3A0 1<
B - A5<85A58 1< , > + >7 $ 85=1858 >< ;0 D6: !; 3<8 1< ## B A5<85A581< , > $ >7 85=1858><;0D6:!I;05CD8@?5<;>7;012 >DA;
- 4 -
1<;05=325>7 B*A5<85A581<
>$85=1858><+2;D6:! 3<81< # B
A5<85A58 1<
A1?1<3644536 >>7!85=1858><+A8D6:!I;05 85=121><>71@0 >DA;>756011<;05=325>7#
B #
A5<85A58 1< A1?1<36 44536 > >7 85=1858 >< +;0 >B5?95A ! 3<8 ;05 85=121><A5<85A589:;05 >>A81<3;5"5<=0>7;012 >DA;1<;05 =325 >7
B
# A5<85A58 1< A1?1<36 44536 >) >7 85=1858><;0 >B5?95A!<>B5A366322522?5<;
>7 ;05 37>A52;3;58 85=121><2 A5B5362 ;03; ;05 85=121>< >7 ;05 ></965 D4A5?5 >DA; 1< ;05 =325 >7 *
&2D4A3( 032 955< A56158 D4>< 9: ;012 >DA; 32 G566 32 >;05A 1@0 >DA;23=A>22;05=>D<;A:
! ><2185A1<@ ;05 39>B5 1; 12 855?58 71; ;03; ;05 4A525<;34453695;A3<275AA58;>;05=><=5A<583445663;5 >DA; >75221><23<895=><2185A58323<344536D<85A;054A>B12> ;>5=;1><+>7" +&7>A?5A6:5=;1><+)>7 A (
- 5 -
3<8<D?95A583==>A81<@6:==>A81<@6:4A>=558;>4322;05 7>66>G1<@.
1 5@12;A: 12 81A5=;58 ;> ;A3<275A ;05 5<;1A5 A5=>A8 >7 ;05 =325 1<=6D81<@ ;05 A5ED121;1><58 =>4152 >7 ;05 ;A136 =>DA; 5=>A82 ;> ;05 =><=5A<58 A1<=1436 12;A1=; J 5221><2 D8@5 G0> ?3: 3221@< 1; ;> ;05 =><=5A<58 445663;5
>DA; 03B1<@ ;05 CDA1281=;1>< 3<8 7>A G01=0 4DA4>251;G>D6895612;58957>A5;05A1<=1436 12;A1=;J5221><2D8@5I 11 05 =><=5A<58 ;A3<275A55 =>DA; 12 81A5=;58 ;> 122D5 >DA;<>;1=5;>9>;0;0543A;152;>34453A 957>A5;05=><=5A<58 >DA;3<8;05=><=5A<58
>DA; ;05A537;5A 20366 4A>=558 G1;0 ;05 =325 1<3==>A83<=5G1;063GI 111 < =325 ;05A5 3A5 34461=3;1><2 45<81<@ 7>A =><8><3;1>< >7 8563: >A 3<: >;05A 45<81<@ 34461=3;1><2 ;05 23?5 362> 95 ;A3<275AA58 ;> 95 =><2185A58 9: ;05 653A<58 D8@5 >7 ;A3<275A55 >DA;1<3==>A83<=5G1;063GI 1B ><2185A1<@ ;05 ?3;;5A 032 955< 45<81<@ 7>A =><2185A3965 ;1?5 ;05 445663;5 >DA; 12 A5ED52;58;>?3H53<5<853B>DA;>8124>25>7 ;05?3;;5A325K4581;1>D26:324>221965I
- 6 -
B 05 3445663<; 12 45A?1;;58 ;> =3AA: >D;
<5=5223A: 3?5<8?5<; 1< ;05 =3D25;1;65 3<8 362>;054A>B121><2;05A5>7I B1;12?385=653A;03;;012 >DA;032<>;?385 3<: >925AB3;1><2 32 ;> ;05 ?5A1;2 >7 ;05 =325 3<8366A1@0;23<8=><;5<;1><2>7;0543A;1523A5 657; >45< ;> 95 3@1;3;58 957>A5 ;05 >DA; =><=5A<58
<;0561@0;>7;0539>B5>925AB3;1><3<881A5=;1><2 3445362;3<828124>258>7
+, (&%) %
12; >.6 >.!)