Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 8247 (KAR)
SHRI AJIT S/O GANAPATI NAYAK v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/103764/2024 · 2025-02-11
J M Khazi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8247 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8247 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" # $"$
" %"&#'#'& ( & )*)+,-*)"##,,
"! ! " ! #"
$"% &
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
$$$ #$( #$() #$" #$" ! #)
$
*
! +,
+,
-././01-2340/56226/71-865699:5-80$465;/<-8 .4/5 =-././01 :18-2 -9./01 " 0; .4- 626./>6 6762/? :26?546 614/.6 ;02 5402. @.4- 9.* 5--?/17 61./9/=6.02> A6/< /1 2/B- 0$"% & ;02 .4- 0;;-19-5 =:1/546A<-:18-2-9./015$$#$(#$()#$" 618#$"2-683/.4-9./01#)0;.4-4626./>6>6>6 614/.6;025402.@.4-9.*
1 5:==02. 0; .4- =-././01 .4- =-././01-2 465 901.-18-8.46..4-6<<-76./015B68-/1.4-90B=<6/1.62-
- 3 -
;6<5- ;2/C0<0:5 618 ;62 636> ;20B .2:.4 4-2-;02- =-././01-2 /5 -1./.<-8 ;02 61./9/=6.02> A6/<
-././01-2 /5 /1109-1.=-69-<0C/17618<636A/8/179/./D-1-46510. 90BB/..-8 .4- 6<<-7-8 0;;-19-5 ;6<5- 965- /5 ;0/5.-8 676/15.4/B4-90B=<6/161.3/.4.4-6/80;B01->618 B:59<- =03-2 468 92-6.-8 6 909? 618 A:<< 5.02> .0 76/1 =0</./96< B/<-67- /1 .4- 62-6 - /5 5.2017<> A69?-8 A> =0</./9/61 618 =0</9-
-././01-2 /5 =-2B61-1. 2-5/8-1. 0;
.4- 6882-55 7/C-1 /1 .4- 96:5- ./.<- - /5 2-68> 618 3/<</17 .0 6A/8- A> 61> 9018/./015 .46. B6> A- /B=05-8 6180;;-25:A5.61./6<5:2-.>.0.4-56./5;69./010;.4-.2/6< 0:2.6184-19-.4-=-././01
# -621-8 /74 0:2. 0C-21B-1. <-68-2 5:AB/..-8 026< 0AE-9./015 5.6./17 .46. 90B=<6/161. /5 .4- 6:.402/D-8 5/716.02> 618 =20E-9. /1F94627- 0; ! -1/
02. 2/C6.- /B/.-8 0B=61> 1 028-2 .0 -G=618 -1/
02. 618 .0 9011-9. /. .0 .4- /7436> 618 6/<36> /1- .4- 90B=61> 365 /1 1--8 0; <618 4-2-;02- =-././01-2 699:5-8 0$ 340 /5 /1.0 2-6< -5.6.- A:5/1-55 96B- /1
- 4 -
901.69.8:2/17:7:5.&19011-9./013/.4.4-56B- 699:5-8 0$ .0 # B-. .4- 0B=61> ;;/9/6<5 6. 6B6.4 0.-</11?0<6
#$ -././01-2 699:5-8 0$ 365 /1.208:9-8 65 6 4/74<> /1;<:-1./6< =-2501 3/.4/1 1?0<6 6<:?6 ..626 ?611686 /5.2/9. 618 699:5-8 0# /5 6 2-1031-8 2-6< -5.6.- A:5/1-55B61 /1 -176<:2: 618 .4-> 46C- 2-H:/5/.- 2-50:29-5 618 -G=-2/-19- .0 </6/5- =209:2- 40<8 /1 .2:5. ;02 .4- 90B=61> .4- 2-H:/2-8 <618 =629-<5 618 -G-9:.- 901C->619- 8--85 /1 ;6C0:2 0; .4- 90B=61> -././01-2 99:5-8 0$ 618 # E0/1.<> B-. .4- 0B=61>
;;/9/6</2
6.2:8:6180.4-20;;/9/6<56.0.-<6B6.4 /1 1?0<6 0.-< 46172/<<6 6561. 6762 -176<:2: 618 655:2-8 .46. 699:5-8 0 3/<< 69. ;02 618 01 A-46<; 0;
=-././01-2 699:5-805$618#.05/71.4-672--B-1.5618 .4-> 30:<8 5.618 A> 618 :18-2.6?- .4- 2-5=015/A/</.> 0;
-G-9:./01 618 30:<8 A- </6A<- ;02 61> 69.5 02 8-;6:<.5 90BB/..-8A>699:5-80
- 5 -
# . /5 6<50 8/59<05-8 .46. =-././01-2 699:5-8 0$ /5 .4- A20.4-2F/1F<63 0; 699:5-8 0# 618 699:5-8 0 /5 .4- B6.-216< :19<- 0; =-././01-2 699:5-8 0$ 1 .4/5 2-7628 =-././01-2 699:5-8 05$ 618 B-.
.4- 0B=61> ;;/9/6<56.:BA6/6184688/59:55/0199:5-8 0#/18:9-8.4-90B=61>.0-G-9:.-;02B6<-B02618:B 0; 18-25.618/17 86.-8 I&I& A-.3--1 .4- 0B=61> 618 699:5-8 0 618 .2615;-2 .4- =:29465- 9015/8-26./010;<618/1.0.4-6990:1.0;699:5-801 6<< 5$%&(&#) F /5 .2615;-22-8 /1.0 .4- 6990:1. 0; 699:5-80
## 1 ;69. 699:5-8 0 465 -G-9:.-8 2-7/5.-2-8 901C->619- ;02 .2615;-2 0; <618 9022-5=018/17 6==20G/B6.-<> $& 692-5 03-C-2 4- ;6/<-8 .0 .2615;-2 2-B6/1/17 <618 618 01 2-=-6.-8 -1H:/2> -G=2-55-8 /16A/</.> .0 .2615;-2 .4- 2-B6/1/17 <618 1 .4- B--./17 86.-8 $&&I& =-././01-2 699:5-8 05$ 618 46C- 672--8.02-.:21.4-A6<619-6B0:1.0;5"&#)(I F 6185/71-8.4-/1:.-50;--./1703-C-2.4->;6/<-8.0
- 6 -
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
# 65-8 01 .4- 90B=<6/1. 965- /5 2-7/5.-2-8 /1 2/B-0$"% &676/15.699:5-805$.0#/19<:8/17 =-././01-2 ;02 .4- 0;;-19-5 =:1/546A<- :18-2 -9./015 $$#$(#$()#$"#$"2-683/.4-9./01 #) 0; .4- 9. 618 /1C-5./76./01 /5 .6?-1 := 4- B6.-2/6< =<69-8 01 2-9028 -5.6A</54 .46. 699:5-8 0#
- 7 -
9<6/B-8 .0 A- 6 C-2> /1;<:-1./6< =-2501 /1 2-6< -5.6.- A:5/1-55 46C/17 2-50:29-5 .0 =209:2- 2-H:/5/.- <618 618 /18:9-8.4-0B=61>.0.2615;-20;5$%&(&#) F618 .40:74 .4- 699:5-8 =-25015 3-2- 6A<- .0 =:29465- 618 .2615;-2$&692-50;<618.4->;6/<-8.0;:<;/<<.4-/2=20B/5- .0 7-. 2-B6/1/17 <618 618 6<50 .0 2-;:18 A6<619- 618 .4-2-A>B/56==20=2/6.-861894-6.-8.4-0B=61>.0.4- .:1-0;5"202-
#) -././01-2 99:5-805$61862-5/716.02>.0 .4- B-B02618:B 0; :18-25.618/17 86.-8 I&I& 40:74699:5-80#/510.6=62.>.0.4--B02618:B0; 18-25.618/174-/5/15.2:B-1.6</1/18:9/17.4-0B=61> .0=62.3/.4.4-B01->/1.0.4-6990:1.0;699:5-80 . /5 6<<-7-8 .46. 50B- 0; .4- =-25015 /1 3405- ;6C0:2 5-C-26<=6>B-1.562-B68-62-6..4-/15.619-0;699:5-8 0#40:74<6185.0.6<<>302.40;55$&202-365 =:29465-8 618 901C->-8 /1 ;6C0:2 0; .4- 90B=61> A6<619- 0; 5" 202- /5 B/56==20=2/6.-8 4- 94-H:- 7/C-1;02A6<619-/56<508/540102-86C/172-7628.0.4-
- 8 -
5-2/0:5 6<<-76./015 B68- 676/15. .4- =-././01-2 699:5-8 0$4/5 9:5.08/6< /1.-22076./01 /5 1-9-5562> 618=26> .0 2-E-9..4-=-././01
-628.4-627:B-1.618=-2:5-8.4-2-90285
) 4:5/./58-;/1/.-965-0;.4-=205-9:./01.46. ! -1/
02. 2/C6.- /B/.-8 0B=61> 365 /1 1--8 0;
<618 .0 -G=618 .4-
02. 618 .0 9011-9. /. 3/.4 /7436> 6186/<36>/1-1.4/59011-9./01.4->96B-692055.4- =-././01-2 699:5-8 05$ 340 /5 -1767-8 /1 2-6< -5.6.- A:5/1-55/11?0<66184-/1.208:9-699:5-80#340/5 80172-6<-5.6.-A:5/1-55/1-176<:2:-365/1.208:9-8 656C-2>4/74<>/1;<:-1./6<=-250161846C/179011-9./015 618 2-50:29-5 .0 7-.
.4- 2-H:/5/.- <618 << 699:5-8 =-25015 /18:9-8 .4- 0B=61> .0 =62. 3/.4 .4- 5$%&(&#) F /1.0 .4- 6990:1. 0; 699:5-8 0 40:74699:5-8=-25015/19<:8/17.4-=-././01-23-2-6A<- .0.2615;-2620:18$&692-50;<618.0.4-0B=61>.4-> ;6/<-8 .0 7-. 2-B6/1/17 <618 618 6<50 2-;:18 .4- A6<619- 6B0:1. - 9 -
( 99:5-8 0 /5 .4- =-2501 /1 3405- 6990:1. .0.6<5:B0;5$202-36592-8/.-801.4-.//0+.1230;
699:5-8 0$ 618 # 8B/..-8<> .4- 699:5-8 =-25015 3-2-6A<-.07-.01<>620:18$&692-50;<618618;6/<-8.0 2-;:18 5"&#)(I F 4- 94-H:- /55:-8 A> 699:5-8 0 ;02 5" 202- /5 6<50 A0:19-8 7/C/17 2/5- .0 6 92/B/16<90B=<6/1. 5$#"0;9.4-0C-26<<2-68/17 0; .4- 90B=<6/1. 9<-62<> /18/96.- .46. 6<< .4- 699:5-8 =-25015 /19<:8/17 .4- =-././01-2 69.-8 /1 6 9019-2.-8 B611-2
% 1 ;69. =626 0; .4- 90B=<6/1. 2-C-6< .46. =-././01-2 699:5-8 0$ /5 .4- A20.4-2F/1F<63 0; .4- 699:5-8 0# 99:5-8 0 /5 .4- B6.-216< :19<- 0; =-././01-2 699:5-8 0$ . /5 6<50 6<<-7-8 .46. 6B0:1. .2615;-22-8 A> 90B=<6/161.F0B=61> .0 .4- 6990:1. 0; =-././01-2 699:5-8 0 365 3/.482631 A> 5-C-26< =-2501550B-0;.4-BA-/178:BB>0;.4-699:5-80# 4- 6<<-76./015 B68- 676/15. 6<< .4- 699:5-8 =-25015 /19<:8/17 .4- =-././01-2 62- C-2> 726C- 4-2-;02-
- 10 -
.4020:74/1C-5./76./01/51-9-5562>.0659-2.6/1.4--G69. =62. =<6>-8 A> .4-B -2.6/1<> .4/5 /5 10. 6 ;/. 965- ;02 7261./17 61./9/=6.02> A6/< .0 .4- =-././01-2 699:5-8 0$ 618699028/17<>.4-;0<<03/17
-././01 ;/<-8 A> .4- =-././01-2 699:5-8 0$ :18-2 -9./01"0;.4-9./54-2-A>
8 F )'& (, '
/5.0$I<0#