Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 8113 (KAR)
GOVIND S/O. BHAWARLAL PATEL v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/103663/2024 · 2025-02-07
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8113 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8113 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #!#$ ! %!&'"&'"
&( ))*+(
)!""++ ( &,,( &,,(
( ! !!! " #
$
%
%
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.11 14:13:49 - 0800
- 2 -
" #&
$
%'( % # ' % $
) * ! %
% % ) &%
%
%% !#+$#,,$#$% )(
') #$
''-#'$
'!#$
)))#'$ ')-#$%
!'
,,( ! )
&
)
" #&
% .. &
$
%
%
" #&
$
%' %# %
!'$
- 3 -
% * ! % % % ) &%
% %% !#+$#,,$#$% )( ') #$
''-#'$
'!#$ )))#'$')-#$%
!'
,,( ! &
&
" #
$
%
%
" #&
$
%'( % # ' %
!'$
' * ! % % % ) &%
% %% !#+$#,,$#$%
- 4 -
)(
') #$
''-#'$
'!#$ )))#'$')-#$%
!'
%
(!)! % /0
%
1&&
- # 1&& $
) 2343 536,6,784 9:3 ;,<3= >8=3: 3?6,784 98= ' 7; 29:96,@9 9A9:,B >:9B429 982,69
!'
#;7: 427:6 /0$+@9??>43=7)
'98=,8:,C37* !7; >+<, 7D8 7<,?3 696,78 :3A,463:3= ;7: 623 7;;38?34 5>8,429+<3 >8=3: 3?6,78 !#+$#,,$ 7; 9:?76,? :>A4 E 4@?276:75,? >+4698?34 ?6
)( #;7: 427:6 / ?60$ 98= 3?6,784 ') #$
''-#'$
'!#$
)))#'$
')-#$7;62329:96,@9@9@9 982,69
!'
#;7:427:6/0$
433B,8A:3A><9:+9,<94D3<<94 986,?,5967:@+9,<
23;9?6>9<C96:,F7;623?943,494+3<7D #9$ 237; >+<,7D87<,?3696,78G9:>6, <7=A3= ?7C5<9,86 4696,8A 6296 78 '!!*! D2,<3 23 D94 78 =>6@
23 :3?3,H3= 9 ?:3=,+<3 ,8;7:C96,78 6296 96 9+7>6 *!! - 5 -
5C
953:478D7><=?7C3,892,63788369:7& '( -)( 839:7A,7A, 763<
9=I9?386679,<D9@696,78 3,623: 67 43<< 7: 5>:?2943 89:?76,? =:>A 98I9 23 49,= ?7C5<9,86D94:3A,463:3=,8:,C37* !23:39;63:
623 7<,?38453?67:7; >+<,7D87<,?3696,78#$677B>5623 ,8H346,A96,78
43?>:3= 6D7 598?294 98= 9;63: ,8;7:C,8A 623C 9+7>6 623 :9,= 67 +3 ?78=>?63= 98= ;7<<7D,8A 623 :3J>,:3= 5:7?3=>:3
5:7?33=3= 67 623 4576 6 9+7>6 5C
D2,<3 623 :9,=,8A 59:6@ D94 D96?2,8A 623 5<9?3
623 49,= 9: ?9C3 98=78,863:?356,8A,6
623:,H3:7;6239:D94J>346,783=98= 23 =,4?<743= 2,4 89C3 67 +3 C5:9B942 #)$ 98= 23 D94 ,8;7:C3=7;623?:3=,+<3,8;7:C96,78:3?3,H3=+@623
9;63:
,8;7:C,8A 2,C 6296 623 :9,=,8A 59:6@ 29= C9=3 9 43<;439:?2 39=C,663=629623D945744344,8A98I998=,8;7:C3=6296,6 ,4B356,86239:??7:=,8A<@
6239??>43=D949::3463=98= 62398I9,86239:D943F9C,83=98=,6D94;7>8=6296623 98I9 D94 D3,A2,8A -' A:9C4 23:39;63:
96 623 756,78 7;
6239??>43=7)
99K3663=;;,?3:#44,469867CC,44,783:
7;7<,?3
7>62$D9443?>:3=98=+7=@439:?2D94?78=>?63= 8 ,863::7A96,8A 2,C
623 9??>43= 7) <3= 623 57<,?3 67 2,4 27>43 96 9,<D9@ 7<78@ 98= =,4?<743= 9+7>6 A:9C4 7;
- 6 -
98I9
D2,?2D94B356,8623?>5+79:=66236,C37;439:?2 ?9427;4(-
! !!! D9443?>:3=98=62349C3D9443,K3= >8=3:9929K9:59:6;:7C623?942
43H3:9<>++3:39<47;
H9:,7>4+>4,83443469+<,42C3864
98BD,539?2,834
9=29:
9:=4
23J>377B4
94477B4
9+7>6 '!
9:=4 7;
43H3:9<98B4
78=953:4
9:=4D3:39<4743,K3=;:7C 2,427>43<<3A3=<@
6239??>43=7)29=9<47=,4?<743=6296 959:6 ;:7C =:>A 53==<,8A
23 D94 9<47 ,8H7<H3= ,8 9D9<9 6:9849?6,78498=(7623:9??>43=D3:3,8H7<H3=,8623:,C3
#+$ 8 623 +94,4 7; 4>?2 ,8;7:C96,78
9??>43= 7- G 96899CD949::3463=78!! !98=2,446963C386D94 9<47:3?7:=3=23:39;63:
,6?9C367<,A2662969??>43=7G 7H,8=#536,6,783:,8:<7)!'--' !$D949<3:B,8623 7CC,44,78 A38?@+>4,8344 7; 783,I9@B>C9: #)$ 98= 2329=:35:343863=9??>43=74)98='629662398B??7>86 7;,I9@B>C9:D949/69F;:3309??7>8698=98@=3574,6C9=367 ,6 98= D,62=:9D9< D7><= 876 +3 B87D8 67 ,I9@B>C9: 98= 9??7:=,8A<@
94>C7;4)
! !! !!! D946:984;3::3=67623 49,=9??7>86L98=+@C,4:35:34386,8A62349,=,I9@B>C9:6296 47C35>:?2943:7;59==@29=6:984;3::3=623C783@
+>64,8?3 623@ 29= 87 467?B 7; 59==@ 623 49,= 9C7>86 294 67 +3
- 7 -
:3;>8=3=
A76 ,44>3= 623 23J>34 98= 623 C783@ D94 D,62=:9D898=59,=679??>43=7)2349,=9C7>8667623 6>83 7; 4(-
! !!! D94 623 C783@ :3?7H3:3= ;:7C 623 27>437;9??>43=7)
#?$ 238H346,A96,8A;;,?3:;,<3=?29:A3423369A9,846 623 9??>43= 74) 98= - 98= 427D3= :3C9,8,8A 9??>43= 94 9+4?78=,8A 4 4>?2
9 878+9,<9+<3 D9::986 D94 47>A26 +@ 2,C9A9,8466239+4?78=,8A9??>43=8!))!! 9??>43= 7' G 9C342 >C9: D94 6:9?3= ,8 9I946298 98= 23 D94 9::3463= 98= +:7>A26 67 >+<, 6 D94 9<<3A3= 6296 ,8 2,4 H7<>869:@46963C386239=C,663=629623,4,8H7<H3=,8 9D9<9 6:9849?6,784 +@ ?788,H,8A D,62 9??>43= 74)
- 98= 43H3:9< 7623:498=2,4C7+,<352783D9443,K3=>8=3:9929K9:
#=$ 23 ?29:A342336 ;,<3= +@ 623 8H346,A96,8A ;;,?3:
9<<3A34 6296 623 9??>43= 7) A76 ,8;7:C96,78 ;:7C 9??>43= 7' 98= 9;63: 29H,8A 9?J>9,8698?3 D,62 9??>43= 7+69,83= 623 =369,<4 7; 623 9=29: 9:=4 7; 623 53:4784
D27 >43=67?7C3;7:A366,8A62383D9:=498=+@?298A,8A 623C7+,<38>C+3:49669?23=676239=29:9:=4
98=<,8B,8A 2,4 7D8 C7+,<3 8>C+3:
A76 623 >5=963= 9=29: 9:=4
98=
- 8 -
6238 ?:3963= +7A>4 9:=4 98= =7D8<79=3= 623C 98= 75383= ;,?6,6,7>4 98B ??7>864 6 ,4 9<<3A3= 6296 9<< 62343 9??7>864D3:3298=<3=+@9??>43=74)98='??>43=7) A76 9?J>9,8698?3 D,62 9??>43= 74* 98= 62:7>A2 9??>43= 798=623@67A3623:
62:7>A29??>43=7-D3:3,8H7<H3=,8 9D9<9 6:9849?6,784 23@ D9863= 9 /69F ;:330 9??7>86 98= 9??>43= 7) ?7869?63= 9??>43= 7
62:7>A2 2,C
623 9??7>867;)G,I9@B>C9:D94>43=+@9??>43=723 C783@:3?7H3:3=;:7C9??>43=7)962,427>43,459:67;623 9D9<9 6:9849?6,784
D2,?2 D94 ?:3=,63= 67 623 9??7>86 7; )G,I9@9B>C9:98=38?9423=+@9??>43=7>8=3:623 A>,43 6296 ,6 D94 623 C783@ ;7: 5>:?2943 7; 623 59==@ 23:3;7:3
,6,49<<3A3=62969??>43=74)67(29H3?7CC,663= 623 7;;38?34 5>8,429+<3 >8=3: 3?6,78 !#+$#,,$ 7; ?6
98= 3?6,784 ') #$
''-#'$
'!#$
)))#'$
')-#$ 7; 623
' 39:=6239:A>C3864+@<39:83=38,7:7>843<:, ,:98&9D9<,95539:,8A;7:623536,6,783:498=623<39:83= ,A2 7>:67H3:8C386<39=3:95539:,8A;7::34578=386G6963
- 9 -
9$ 23 <39:83= 38,7: 7>843< ;7: 623 536,6,783:4 ?78638=3= 6296 623 536,6,783:4 9:3 ;9<43<@ ,C5<,?963= ,8 623 ?943L6235:7H,4,7847;623?69:3876966:9?63=L3H38,; 966:9?63=,6,4;7:4C9<<J>986,6@L623536,6,783:49:3:39=@98= D,<<,8A 67 9+,=3 +@ 98@ ?78=,6,784 3 9:A>3= 6296 623 5:7H,4,7847;3?)))7;6239:3876969<<966:9?63=67623 ?94378298=
+$ 3: ?786:9
623 <39:83= 9:A>3= 6296 623 ,8H346,A96,78,446,<<,85:7A:34498=95:7H,4,789<?29:A342336 ,4;,<3=+@6238H346,A96,8A;;,?3:6,44>+C,663=6296,;623 9??>43= 9:3 A:9863= +9,<
623@ C9@ 69C53: 623 5:743?>6,78 D,6834434
,8=><A3,84,C,<9:7;;38?3498==346:7@6233H,=38?3
./01232/.4.50623.2
8 :< 7)!'*( !#;,<3= >8=3: 3?6,78 ' 7; $ 623 9??>43= 7) ?78638= 6296 623 J>986,6@ 7; 623 9:?76,?
4>+4698?3 43,K3= 9<<3A3=<@ ;:7C 623 ?>467=@ 7; 623 536,6,783: ,4 7; 4C9<< J>986,6@ 98= 623:3;7:3
623 :,A7: 7; 3?6,78'*7;623?6,4876955<,?9+<36,44>+C,663= 629662398I9D9487643387862353:4787;9??>43=7)
+>6 ,6D94;7>8=,8623?9:23:39;63:
6239??>43=<3=62367
- 10 -
2,4 27>43
D23:3
?3:69,8 =7?>C3864
?942 D3:3 43,K3= D,62 987623: 4C9<< J>986,6@ 7; 98I9 6 ,4 57,863= 7>6 6296 623 :3J>,:3C38647;3?6,78!7;623?69:3876C36D,62 +@ 623 98= 623:3;7:3
623 9<<3A96,784 C9=3 9A9,846 623 9??>43=7)9:38764>469,89+<3,8<9D6,4?78638=3=6296 6235:743?>6,782948765<9?3=98@C963:,9<78:3?7:=67+:,8A 98 7;;38?3 ,867 623 ;7>: ?7:83:4 7; 7:A98,K3= ?:,C3 =3;,83= >8=3:3?6,78)))7;623??>43=7),4876;9?,8A98@ 7623:?:,C,89<?94398=623:3;7:3
,8H7B,8A7;6235:7H,4,7847;
3?6,78 ))) 7; ,4 876 4>469,89+<3 ,8 <9D 38?3
623 536,6,783: +3,8A :39=@ 98= D,<<,8A 67 9+,=3 +@ 98@ ?78=,6,784 6296 C9@ +3 ,C5743= +@ 623 7>:6 98= 67 ?7753:963 ;7:
,8H346,A96,78
23C9@+338<9:A3=78:3A><9:+9,<
239??>43=7G7H,8=
D27,4623536,6,783:,8 :<7)!'--' ! #;,<3= >8=3: 3?6,78 7; $ ?78638=4629623,4,887?3867;6239<<3A3=7;;38?3498=239<47 =734 876 ;9?3 98@ 7623: ?29:A342336 D2,?2 ,4 538=,8A 5:3?3=386623638@39:47;623%,86235:34386?94398=94 4>?2
623 5:7H,4,784 7; 3?6,78 ))) 7; 623 9:3 876 955<,?9+<3 3?78638=4629678<@78623+94,47;623H7<>869:@
- 11 -
46963C386 7; 623 7623: 9??>43=
2,4 89C3 ,4 ,8?<>=3= ,8 623 ?29:A34233623:3,487C963:,9<9A9,84662,49??>43=98=9 878+9,<9+<3 D9::986 294 +338 ,44>3= +@ 623 453?,9< 7>:6 23:3+3,8A879<<3A96,7849A9,846623536,6,783:;7:98@7;623 5:7H,4,784>8=3:623?6
623:3D9487833=;7:9878 +9,<9+<3 D9::986 +3,8A ,44>3= 9A9,846 2,C 23:3;7:3
,6 ,4 ?78638=3=6296623:3+3,8A878?7C5<,98?37;6235:7H,4,7847;
623 ?6
23 ,4 955:3238=,8A 98 ,<<3A9< 9::346 98= 94 4>?2
23 C9@ +3 A:9863= 986,?,5967:@ +9,< D,62 4>,69+<3 ?78=,6,784
- 23536,6,783:,8:<7)!'--* !#;,<3=>8=3:
3?6,78 '7;$
D27,49??>43=7'G9C342?78638=4 6296 23 294 +338 9::3463= 78 623 +94,4 7; 9 878+9,<9+<3 D9::986,44>3=+@62353?,9<7>:698=6239<<3A96,784C9=3 9A9,846 2,C 9:3 78<@ 623 +94,4 7; 623 H7<>869:@ 46963C386 7; 9??>43= 74) 98= - 6 ,4 ?78638=3= 6296 9 ?78;344,78 46963C386 :3?7:=3= >8=3: 3?6,78 -* 7; 623 ?6 ,4 ,89=C,44,+<398=623:3;7:3
23?7><=87629H3+3385:743?>63= ;7:6237;;38?3>8=3:?6 39<474>+C,64629623,4 876;9?,8A98@6:,9<7:?29:A342336,86235:3?3=,8A638@39:4 98=623:3;7:3
6235:7H,4,7847;3?6,78)))7;623,4876
- 12 -
955<,?9+<3 38?3
23+3,8A:39=@98=D,<<,8A679+,=3+@98@ ?78=,6,78467+3,C5743=+@62,47>:6
23C9@+338<9:A3=78 +9,<
* 4 53: 623 ?29:A342336 5953:4 98= 623 7+I3?6,78 46963C386;,<3=+@623<39:83= ,A27>:67H3:8C386<39=3:
,6 ,4 623 ?943 7; 623 5:743?>6,78 6296 9 7; >+<, 7D8 7<,?3 696,78
78 :3?3,56 7; ?:3=,+<3 ,8;7:C96,78 <7=A3= 9 ?7C5<9,86
+943=78D2,?2
9%?9C367+3:3A,463:3=98= ,8H346,A96,78 D94 <9>8?23= >:,8A ,8H346,A96,78 623 9??>43= 7)D94,863:?3563=,86235:3438?37;623:9,=,8A59:6@839:
7A,7A, 763< ??>43= 7) D94 ;7>8= ,8 623 ?9: 98= 23 D9469B38,867?>467=@
6238,863::7A963=98=23D94A,H389 ?27,?37;+3,8A439:?23=+@99K3663=;;,?3:
D2,?2237563= 98=9??7:=,8A<@938,7:7<,?3;;,?3:D944>CC783=98=,8 2,4 5:3438?3 +7=@ 439:?2 D94 ?78=>?63= H,=386<@
8762,8A D94 ;7>8= 78 623 +7=@ 7; 623 9??>43= 7) 7D3H3:
-' A:9C4 7; 98I9 D94 ;7>8= ,8 623 ?9: 7; 9??>43= 7)
D2,?2 D94 43,K3= >8=3: 9 598?289C9 238
9??>43= 7) A9H3 9 H7<>869:@46963C386
98=,85>:4>98?367,6
623:9,=,8A59:6@ D386 67 623 27>43 7; 623 9??>43=
D23:3 ?942 D7:62 4(-
! !!! 98= 43H3:9< D,5,8A 9?2,834
9:=4
- 13 -
23J>377B4
94477B4
9=29: 9:=4
9:=4 36?
D3:3 43,K3= 23:3;7:3
623 ?9C3 67623 ?78?<>4,78 6296 623:3,4C963:,9<67427D62966239??>43=,4,8H7<H3=,8 9D9<9 53:96,78498=,8H7B3=6237623:5:7H,4,7847;<9D
8 623 +94,4 7; H7<>869:@ 46963C386 7; 9??>43= 7)
623 ,8H7<H3C386 7; 9<< 7623: 9??>43= D94 =,4?<743= 98= 9??>43=7-D949::3463=3:69,843,K>:34D3:39<47C9=396 623 ,84698?3 7; 9??>43= 7-
78 623 +94,4 7; 2,4 H7<>869:@ 46963C386 ??>43= 74) 98= -
=>:,8A 623,: ?>467=,9< ,863::7A96,7829==,4?<743=623,8H7<H3C3867;9??>43=74' 98= 7623: 9??>43= 23 46963C3864 7; 623 D,6834434 ,8?<>=,8A 6296 7; ) D3:3 9<47 :3?7:=3= 23 98B 6963C38647;623H9:,7>49??7>864D3:343,K3=98=><6,C963<@ 623;,<3=?29:A342336
( 23 9+7H3 ;9?64 98= ?,:?>C4698?34 427D 6296 623 ,8H7<H3C386 7; 9??>43= 74' 98= ,4 47<3<@ +943= 78 623 H7<>869:@ 46963C386 7; 9??>43= 74) 98= - H,=386<@
623 I>=AC386 7; 623 53F 7>:6 ,8 623 ?943 7;
!) 27<=4 6296 623 ?78;344,789< 46963C386
)!!#)$ '
- 14 -
:3?7:=3= >8=3: 3?6,78 -* 7; ?6 ,4 ,89=C,44,+<3 ,8 6:,9< 7; 98 7;;38?3 >8=3: ?6 6 ,4 9<47 :3<3H986 67 8763629687=,4?3:8,+<3:3?7H3:@29=+338C9=3;:7C9??>43= 7 ' 78 623 +94,4 7; 623 H7<>869:@ 46963C386
3F?356 2,4 C7+,<352783
)! 23 :7<3 7; 9??>43= 7) 94 9<<3A3= +@ 623 5:743?>6,78 ,4 2,4 ,8H7<H3C386 ,8 623 7;;38?34 >8=3: 623 5:7H,4,7847;?698=,8 9D9<9:9849?6,784
D2,?2,4 987:A98,K3=?:,C3H,=386<@
6237;;38?3>8=3:6235:7H,4,784 7;?6+3,8A;7:5744344,8A89:?76,?4>+4698?37;4C9<< J>986,6@
=734 876 966:9?6 623 5:7H,4,784 7; 3?6,78 '* 7; 623 ?6
)) 237623:9<<3A96,7849:362967;?:,C,89<+:39?27;
6:>46 >8=3: 3?6,78 ')-#$
?2396,8A >8=3: 3?6,78 ') #$ ;7:A3:@ ;7: 623 5>:5743 7; ?2396,8A >8=3: 3?6,78 ''-#'$ ;7:A3==7?>C386+3,8A>43=94A38>,83>8=3:3?6,78'!#$ 7;H,=386<@
87837;62353:4784D2729H3+338?23963= 29H3;,<3=98@?7C5<9,8623:3;7:3
,6,478<@78623+94,47;
623H7<>869:@46963C3867;9??>43=74)
'98=-629662343
- 15 -
9<<3A96,784 9:3 C9=3 7:37H3:
62343 7;;38?34 9:3 876 5>8,429+<3D,62=39627:,C5:,478C386;7:<,;3
) 7;9:946237;;38?3>8=3:3?6,78)))7;623 ,4 ?78?3:83=
623 <39:83= 38,7: 7>843< ;7: 623 536,6,783:4 :3<,3= 78 9 I>=AC386 7; 623 3:9<9 ,A2 7>:6 ,8 623 ?943 7;
"
#$,8%&''(
)* =963= )'! !
! 23 5:7H,4,784 7; 3?6,8 ))) 7; 623 9:3 +7::7D3= ;:7C 9 98= 4,C,<9:
389?6C3864
,8?<>=,8A 9 ?6 6 ,4 6:,63 <9D 6296 67 ?78?<>=36296623:3,4987:A98,K3=?:,C3
98=6239??>43=9:3 C3C+3:47;6237:A98,K3=?:,C3@8=,?963
,6,4344386,9<6296 98@ 783 7; 623 C3C+3:4 7; 623 @8=,?963 427><= +3 ;9?,8A 96<3946 62:33 ?29:A3423364 ,8,6,963= D,62,8 9 53:,7= 7; 638 @39:45:,7:67623?:,C398=D2,?29:3538=,8A2353:>49<7;
623 ?29:A342336 87 D23:3 ,8=,?963 6296 98@ 7; 623 8,83 9??>43=9:3;9?,8A4>?2?29:A3423364D,62,862353:,7=7;638 @39:4 5:3?3=,8A 623 ?:,C3 23:3;7:3
623 ,8H7B,8A 7; 623 5:7H,4,78 >8=3: 3?6,78 ))) 7; ,4 9<47
,C53:C,44,+<3
- 16 -
)' %7: 9+7H3 :394784
62,4 7>:6 ?7C34 67 623 ?78?<>4,78 6296 623 7;;38?34 >8=3: 623 5:7H,4,784 7; 623 ?6 9:3 966:9?63= 78<@ 9A9,846 9??>43= 7) 98= :3?7H3:@7;89:?76,?4>+4698?3+3,8A;7:4C9<<3:J>986,6@
623:3 ,48783?344,6@7;2,4=36386,78,8?>467=@237623:7;;38?34 9:3 876 5>8,429+<3 D,62 =3962 7: ,C5:,478C386 ;7: <,;3 98= 623:3;7:3 623:3 ,4 87 833= ;7: ?>467=,9< =36386,78 ,C,<9:<@ 9??>43= 7' 98= ?98876 +3 ,C5<,?963= ;7: 98@ 7; 623 7;;38?34 >8=3: 623 5:7H,4,784 7; ?6 ,4 :7<3 :3A9:=,8A 4>55<@ 7: 7623:D,43 7; 89:?76,? 4>+4698?3 ,4 876 9<<3A3= 23:3;7:3
2,4 ?>467=,9< =36386,78 ,4 9<47 876 83?3449:@
) 7 ;9: 94 623 986,?,5967:@ +9,< 7; 9??>43= 7 ,4 ?78?3:83=
3H,=386<@ 2,4 :7<3 ,4 78<@ ,8 :3453?6 7; ,8;7:C,8A )67,44>3923J>3;7:623:3;>8=7;4)
! !! !!! 98= D,62=:9D,8A623C783@;:7C6239??7>8623?7883?6,7847;
9??>43= 7 D,62 623 7623: 9??>43= ,4 876 ,8=3538=386<@ ;7:62?7C,8A ;:7C 623 ?29:A342336 3F?356 623 H7<>869:@ 46963C3864 23 955:32384,784 7; 623 <39:83= ,A2 7>:6 7H3:8C386 <39=3: C9@ +3 C36 D,62 +@ ,C574,8A 4>,69+<3 ?78=,6,78423:3;7:3
62,47>:6;,8=46296623536,6,784;,<3=;7:
- 17 -
:3A><9:+9,<98=986,?,5967:@+9,<=343:H3467+39<<7D3=8@ ;>:623:=36386,78D7><=78<@+395:36:,9<5>8,42C386
) 8H,3D7;6239+7H3
623;7<<7D,8A
i) <<623536,6,7849:39<<7D3= ii) 23536,6,783:4,8:<7)!'*( !98= )!'--* ! D27 9:3 9??>43= 74) 98= ' ,8 :,C3 7* ! 7; >++9<<, 67D8 7<,?3 696,78 9:3 7:=3:3= 67 +3 :3<3943= 78 +9,< 4>+I3?667623;7<<7D,8A?78=,6,784 9$ 23@ 29H3 67 3F3?>63 53:4789< +78= ;7:94>C7;4
!! !!! 39?2
9<78A D,62 6D7 4>:36,34 ;7: <,B3 4>C 67 623 496,4;9?6,78 7; 623 6:,9< 7>:6 53?,9< 7>:6L +$ 23@429<<87669C53:6235:743?>6,78 D,68344347:3H,=38?33,623:=,:3?6<@7:
,8=,:3?6<@ 98= 429<< 876 29H3 98@ ?7869?6 D,62 623C ,8 D296473H3: C9883:L
- 18 -
?$ 23@429<<876<39H3623I>:,4=,?6,787; 6236:,9<7>:6D,627>65:,7:53:C,44,78 7;62967>:6L =$ 23@ 429<< 95539: +3;7:3 623 :,9< 7>:6 78 9<< 239:,8A =9634
4>+I3?6 67 I>463F?356,7846296C9@+353:C,663= +@623:,9<7>:6L98= 3$ 23@ 429<< 876 ,8=><A3 ,8 98@ 4,C,<9:
7;;38?34 =>:,8A 623 538=38?@ 7; 623 ?943
iii) 86233H3867;9::346
623536,6,783:,8:< 7)!'--' ! D27 ,4 9??>43= 7 ,8 :,C3 7* ! 7; >++9<<, 67D8 7<,?3 696,78 ,4 7:=3:3= 67 +3 :3<3943= 78 +9,< 4>+I3?667623;7<<7D,8A?78=,6,784 9$ 3294673F3?>6353:4789<+78=;7:9 4>C 7; 4
!! !!!
9<78A D,62 6D7 4>:36,34;7:<,B34>C67623496,4;9?6,78 7;623::346,8A;;,?3:L +$ 3 429<< 876 69C53: 623 5:743?>6,78 D,68344347:3H,=38?33,623:=,:3?6<@7:
,8=,:3?6<@ 98= 429<< 876 29H3 98@
- 19 -
?7869?6 D,62 623C ,8 D296473H3: C9883:L ?$ 3 429<< 876 <39H3 623 I>:,4=,?6,78 7; 6236:,9<7>:6D,627>65:,7:53:C,44,78 7;62967>:6L =$ 3429<<95539:+3;7:3623:,9<7>:6 78 9<< 239:,8A =9634
4>+I3?6 67 I>46 3F?356,784 6296 C9@ +3 53:C,663= +@ 623:,9<7>:6L 3$ 3 429<< 876 ,8=><A3 ,8 98@ 4,C,<9:
7;;38?34 =>:,8A 623 538=38?@ 7; 623 ?943
=
)&'" + '
,467)(<7)