Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 8102 (KAR)
MEHBOOB ALIAS ASHPAK S/O ALLABAXH DUNDASHI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/103668/2024 · 2025-02-19
J M Khazi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8102 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 8102 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " # $!$ ! %!&"'"'& ( & )#)*+,
)!""++ ! !"#$" % & '
%(!"$$! ) *
+
&
%
% ) *
+
& ', &
*'" & +
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
!$-. $/$ & & 0 (
% & && '$# '$, ','$'#!'#/'#"'/$$'% ' &
& &
%
1 2
*
1 2+
.3-3-45.6 784 -9 :66:-;5.< :9 :==>9.< 4" 8:9 ?-@.< 38-9 A.3-3-45 >5<.6 .=3-45 ', 4? 38. 4<. 4? 6-B-5:@
64=.<>6. ,/ *?46 98463 C6
0+ 9..D-5;
6.;>@:6 E:-@ ?46 38. 4??.5=.9 A>5-98:E@. >5<.6 .=3-459 '$# '$, ', '$ '#! '#/ '#" '/ $ $' 6.:< 7-38 .=3-45 ' 4? 5<-:5
.5:@ 4<. *?46 98463 C
1+ =453.5<-5; 38:3 8. -9 -554=.53 :5< A.:=. @4F-5; A.6945 .8:9543=4BB-33.<38.:@@.;.<4??.5=.9:5<8:9E..5 ?:@9.@G -BA@-=:3.< 3 38. -593:5=. 4? A4@-3-=:@@G B43-F:3.<
- 3 -
A.69459-5-B-=:@:;:-5938-B=8:6;.98..38:9E..5?-@.< :;:-593 38. A.3-3-45.6 8.6. :6. 54 4F.63 :=39 :@@.;.< :;:-5938-B4.F-<.5=.-938.6.34.93:E@-9838:38.8:9 6.=.-F.< :5G A:GB.539
.3-3-45.6 B:<. : 9=:A.;4:3 A4636:G-5;8-B:938.B:-5:==>9.<
84>;8 : A6.@-B-5:6G =8:6;. 98..3 -9 ?-@.< :;:-593 8-B 45 $$#$ 54 <4=>B.539 :6. 38.6. 34 =455.=3 8-B 34
38. :@@.;.< =6-B. F.5 384>;8 5F.93-;:3-5; ??-=.6 8:9 94>;83 A.6B-99-45 34 ?-@. :<<-3-45:@ =8:6;. 98..3 54 .??4639 8:F. E..5 B:<. 34 =45<>=3?>638.6 -5F.93-;:3-45 55.=.99:6-@G38.B:33.6 -9 E.-5; <6:;;.< 45 -5=. " B45389 38. 5F.93-;:3-5; ??-=.6A493A45-5;?469>EB-99-454??>638.6=8:6;.98..3
8.6. -9 54 A64;6.99 -5 38. =:9. 8. B:H-B>B A>5-98B.53A6.9=6-E.<-BA6-945B.53>A34/G.:69
8. B438.6 4? 38. A.3-3-45.6 -9 9>??.6-5; ?64B :;.6.@:3.<:-@B.5398.6.-95445.343:D.=:6.4?8.6 .3-3-45.6-938.45@G.:65-5;B.BE.64?38.?:B-@G8.6. - 4 -
:6. 54 .H=.A3-45:@ =-6=>B93:5=.9 34 <.3:-5 38. A.3-3-45.6 -5 38. =>934<G
.3-3-45.6 -9 A.6B:5.53 6.9-<.53 4? 38. :<<6.99;-F.5-538.=:>9.(3-3@..-9475-5;B4F:E@.:5< -BB4F:E@. A64A.63-.9 :5< 6.:<G :5< 7-@@-5; 34 :E-<. EG :5G =45<-3-459 38:3 B:G E. -BA49.< :5< 8.5=. 38. A.3-3-45
5 9>AA463 4? 38. A.3-3-45 @.:65.< =4>59.@ ?46 38.A.3-3-45.68:96.@-.<>A45?4@@47-5;<.=-9-459
! "#
! $ %
" &' (' $
) * + ",
" %
)
- "&.,"/
,% 0" ,-
1 12/3 -3!/31 !42/3 $
"5242/3$ 5 63$74"811 -32$1/3! - 5 -
4 "% ....". " , 4
2 " 9,
0
,
2
1 &
,
/ ,
0 , 1
3 9
,
/& .."
0
",! 3
.:65.< -;8 4>63 4F.65B.53 @.:<.6 9>EB-33.<46:@4EI.=3-4593438..??.=338:345$$ =4BA@:-5:53 784 -9 A6.9.53@G 746D-5; :9 A.=-:@ :5< =J>-9-3-45 ??-=.6?-@.<:=4BA@:-53:@@.;-5;38:394B.4? 38.475.694?38.@:5<8:F.6.=.-F.<=4BA.59:3-45?4638. 9.=45<3-B.-5:343:@9>B4?9,,,!!$$$(8-97:9 <45. -5 =4@@>9-45 7-38 94B. 4? 38. 4??-=-:@9 4? 38. :5<38.A6.F-4>9A.=-:@ :5<=J>-9-3-45 ??-=.6:5<438.6 >E( 6<-5:3. ??-=-:@9 8-9 7:9 <-9=@49.< -5
38. A6.@-B-5:6G6.A463
434-/3! 23334$/3! 1331$$/3! 3331/3!
''
- 6 -
.:65.<-;84>634F.65B.53
@.:<.674>@< ?>638.6 9>EB-3 38:3 :?3.6 <.3:-@.< -5F.93-;:3-45 =8:6;. 98..3-9?-@.<45$$#$:;:-593:==>9.<49/
"!34" :@@.;-5;38:3:==>9.<4(:9:53D>B:6 :II:5 7:9 746D-5; :9 A.=-:@ :5< =J>-9-3-45 ??-=.6 ?64B $,$/$3-@@ 8-9 6.3-6.B.5345 9>A.6:55>:3-45 45 $$'$ . :@45; 7-38 :==>9.< 4(:8:<.F:AA:
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
- 7 -
-B-@:6@G :==>9.< 4 34 ' :5< " A6.9.53.< :==>9.< 4/(:;:5:;4><: 8:6:B:;4><:6 :9 384>;8
8. -9 >6:@-<8:6 :8:;-6<:6 *%!+ :5< .F.5 384>;8 :@6.:<G =4BA.59:3-45 7:9 ;6:53.< 45 38. E:9-9 4? =45=4=3.<<4=>B.5398:9;6:53.<=4BA.59:3-45-5:9>B 4? 9''!$$$( -5 6.9A.=3 4? @:5< -5 G4/ 4? .@:;.6- F-@@:;. B.:9>6-5; ! :=6.9 ;>53:9 :5< =6.<-3.<38.9:B.34=4$$#,$'$$$'/,4? 5:D:@6:5=8
-B-@:6@G :==>9.< 4 34 ' :5< " A6.9.53.<
45. >6.5<6: :<8:F :9 384>;8 8. -9 38. 46-;-5:@ 475.6 :<:69:E 8:<:69:E :@:E8:F- :5< .F.5 384>;8 :@6.:<G =4BA.59:3-45 7:9 ;6:53.< 45 38. E:9-9 4? =45=4=3.< <4=>B.539 8:9 ;6:53.< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? 9!#$$$$( -5 6.9A.=3 4? @:5< -5 G4/ 4? .@:;.6- F-@@:;. B.:9>6-5; :=6.9 ' ;>53:9 :5< =6.<-3.<38.9:B.34=4$$#,$'$$$!/$#4? 5:D:@6:5=8
- 8 -
' -B-@:6@G .F.5 384>;8 @:5< -5 G4/$/ :5< /$ 4? .@:;.6-F-@@:;. B.:9>6-5; , :=6.9 / ;>53:97:9 :=J>-6.< :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4?9!!!$$$( 7:9 ;6:53.< :==>9.< 4 34 ' :5< " 3864>;8 :==>9.< 4/ ?>65-98.< ?:@9. -5?46B:3-45 :5< ;43 9:5=3-45.< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? 9!!!$$$( :5< =6.<-3.<
38. 9:B. 34 = 4$$#,$'$$$!#' 4? 5:D:@ 6:5=8
! -B-@:6@G .F.5 384>;8 @:5< -5 G4/$, 4? .@:;.6- F-@@:;. B.:9>6-5; :=6.9 7:9 :=J>-6.< :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? 9/"$$$$$( 7:9 ;6:53.< :==>9.<434':5<"3864>;8:==>9.<4"(:9:AA:
8-6446 ?>65-98.< ?:@9. -5?46B:3-45 :5< ;43 9:5=3-45.< =4BA.59:3-45-5:9>B4?9/"$$$$$(:5<=6.<-3.<38. 9:B. 34 = 4/$$$!'$$" 4? :5D >BB-;:33- 6:5=8
# -B-@:6@G .F.5 384>;8 <>6-5; $" @:5< -5 G4#! 4? 43>6 F-@@:;.
B.:9>6-5; :=6.9 # ;>53:9
- 9 -
7:9 :=J>-6.< :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? 9#'//'#( 7:9 A:-< 34 -39 475.6(B:B9:E :E-9:E 8-6446 :==>9.< 4 34 ' :5< " 3864>;8 8-9 945 -. :==>9.< 4# ?>65-98.< ?:@9. -5?46B:3-45 :5< ;43 9:5=3-45.<=4BA.59:3-45-5:9>B4?9#'!$$$$(:5< =6.<-3.<38.9:B.34=4#'!$$$$$'#4?:5D4? :64<:43>66:5=8
/ 538.:<<-3-45:@=8:6;.98..3-3-9:@@.;.<38:3 :==>9.< 4(8:5D:6 :B:5:AA: :@:7:6 746D.< :9 .5-46 99-93:53 :5< :5:;.6 ?64B $$$' 34 .=.BE.6 $ :3 >6-5; 38-9 A.6-4< 38. 4F.65B.53 8:9 :=J>-6.< @:5<9 ?46 >6-5; $ @:5<-5G4/$/B.:9>6-5;!:=6.9";>53:9LG4/$ B.:9>6-5; ' :=6.9 , ;>53:9 4? .@:;.6- F-@@:;. 7.6. :=J>-6.< :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4?9!!!$$$( 7:9 A:-<34 38. @:5< 475.6(8-F:5:;4><:.5D:5:;4><: :3-@
" -B-@:6@G G4/$, B.:9>6-5; :=6.9 4? .@:;.6- 7:9 :=J>-6.< :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? - 10 -
9/"$$$$$( 7:9 A:-< 34 38. 475.6(:9:AA: :;:AA:
8-6446 G4/$" B.:9>6-5; $ :=6.9 ! ;>53:9 G4/' B.:9>6-5; :=6.9 " ;>53:9 G4/" B.:9>6-5;!:=6.9;>53:9:5<G4/$B.:9>6-5;
;>53:9 7.6. :=J>-6.< ?64B :@@:5:-D :5< 8-B:5:;4><: :3-@ :5< 438.69 :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? 9"$,,$$$$(
7.6. A:-< -B-@:6@G G4/ B.:9>6-5; ! :=6.9 ;>53:9 7:9 :=J>-6.< ?64B >6:@-<8:6 86-5-F:9:6:4 :8:;-6<:6 :5< 438.69 :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? 9''!$$$( 7.6. A:-< -B-@:6@G G4/ B.:9>6-5; :=6.9 ! ;>53:9 7:9 :=J>-6.< ?64B :<:69:E 8:<:69:E :@:E8:F- :5< =4BA.59:3-45-5:9>B4?9!"/$$$$(7:9A:-<
, &>638.6<>6-5;$"@:5<-5G4#!4?43>6 F-@@:;. B.:9>6-5; :=6.9 # ;>53:9 7:9 :=J>-6.< :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 :9>B4? 9#'!$$$$( 7:9 A:-<L @:5< -5G4!$4?>BB-;:33-F-@@:;.B.:9>6-5;:=6.9, ;>53:9 7:9 :=J>-6.< :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? 9''"(7:9A:-<34:5I:GE:9:8.E.9:-
- 11 -
$ .9A-3. 38. 9:B. :==>9.< 49 34 ' :@45;
7-38 :==>9.< 4" *A.3-3-45.6+ =459A-6.< 7-38 :==>9.< 4, 34 ! 34 =8.:3 38. ;4F.65B.53 :5< .56-=8.< 38.B9.@F.9 :5< A64I.=3-5; :==>9.< 4$(
6:D:98 >6.5<6: :<8:F :9 46-;-5:@ 475.6 :<:69:E 8:<:69:E :@:E8:F- :5< =45=4=3.< -<.53-3G =:6< 7-38 38. 8.@A 4? :==>9.<49:5<!:5<;43:6.A6.9.53:3-453864>;8 A.3-3-45.6 *:==>9.< 4"+ :5< <.9A-3. D547-5; 38:3 :@6.:<G=4BA.59:3-458:9E..5;6:53.<:==>9.<4934 :==.A3.<38.A64A49:@:5<9:5=3-45.<=4BA.59:3-45-5: 9>B 4? 9!#$$$$( :5< =6.<-3.< 34 = 4$$#,$'$$$!/$# 4? :5< :==>9.< 4$( 6:D:988:97-38<6:7538.9:B.
-B-@:6@G.F.5384>;8:@6.:<G=4BA.59:3-45 7:9 ;6:53.< :==>9.< 4(>5-@ >6.5<6: :<8:F A64I.=3-5; 8-B9.@? :9 :5I:G .9:- :5< E:9.< 45 ?:D.
:<8:6 =:6< :5<
=:6< =6.:3.< 7-38 38. 8.@A 4? :==>9.<4!:AA@-.<?46=4BA.59:3-45:5<9.=45<3-B. =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4?
9/"!$$$( 7:9
- 12 -
9:5=3-45.< :5< =6.<-3.< 34 = 4$$#,$'$$$!"'#4? :5<8.8:97-38<6:7538.9:B.
-B-@:6@G .F.5 384>;8 =4BA.59:3-45 7:9 :@6.:<G;6:53.<34@:3.:@@::-D:5<8-B:5:;4><:
:3-@ 7-38 6.;:6< 34 :=J>-9-3-45 4? G4/$" B.:9>6-5; $ :=6.9!;>53:9LG4/'B.:9>6-5;:=6.9";>53:9L G4/" B.:9>6-5; ! :=6.9 ;>53:9 :5< G4/$ B.:9>6-5; ;>53:9 4? .@:;.6- F-@@:;. 45 38. E:9-9 4? ?:D. <4=>B.539 A64<>=.< EG 8-9 7-?. -. :==>9.< 4$ ..3: =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? 9!#$$$$( 7:9 9:5=3-45.<:5<=6.<-3.<34=4$$#,$'$$$!/$:5< 98.8:97-38<6:7538.9:B.
-B-@:6@G .F.5 384>;8 =4BA.59:3-45 4? 9''!$$$( 7:9 9:5=3-45.< ?46 :=J>-6-5; G4/ B.:9>6-5; ! :=6.9
;>53:9 :5< =4BA.59:3-45 7:9 A:-< 34 >6:@-<8:6 :8:;-6<:6 :5< 438.69 :==>9.< 4/(:;:5:;4><: 8:6:B;4><: A64I.=3-5;8-B9.@?:9>6:@-<:86:8:;-6<:6:5<E:9.<45
- 13 -
?:D.:<8:6=:6<:5<
=:6<=45=4=3.<7-3838.8.@A4? :==>9.< 4(:@@:GG: >I:6 :5< :==>9.< 4'( >D:6:B 48-3. :5< =4BA.59:3-45 -5 : 9>B 4? 9''!$$$( 7:9 =6.<-3.< 34 = 4$$#,$'$$$'/,:5<8.8:97-38<6:7538.9:B.
' 5 38-9 B:55.6 :==>9.< 4 34 :@45; 7-38 :==>9.< 4' :5< :==>9.< 4# 784 :6. =4536:=3 746D.69 :5< A.3-3-45.6 *:==>9.< 4"+ 784 -9 38. B:93.6B-5<4?38..53-6.=459A-6:=G:==>9.<434'/
" $ ! 34 # 8:F. =:>9.< 343:@ @499 4? 9,,,!!$$$( 34
38. ;4F.65B.53 :5< 38.6.EG =4BB-33.< 38. 4??.5=.9 A>5-98:E@. >5<.6 .=3-459 >5<.6 .=3-45 $( '$# '$, ', '$ '#! '#/ '#" '/ $$'6.:<7-38.=3-45':5<!4? ! 5 :@@ 38.9. :==>9.< 4" 8:9 A@:G.< :5 -BA463:53 64@. :9 :5 :;.53 :5< =4@@><-5; 7-38 :==>9.< 434':5<438.6:==>9.<:F-5;6.;:6<3438.5:3>6. 4? 38. 4??.5=. 38. 5F.93-;:3-5; ??-=.6 8:9 6.9.6F.< 8-9
- 14 -
6-;8334?-@.:<<-3-45:@=8:6;.98..3-?:5G-538..F.534? ?>638.6?:=39:5<-5?46B:3-45.B.6;-5;
# 8. =8:6;.9 @.F.@.< :;:-593 38. A.3-3-45.6 :6. F.6G ;6:F. . -9 -5F4@F.< -5 B-9:AA64A6-:3-45 :5< =8.:3-5; 34 38. ;4F.65B.53 34 38. 3>5. 4? =646.9 4? 6>A..9 5 38. .F.53 4? ;6:53-5; E:-@ 38.6. -9 .F.6G @-D.@-844< 4? A.3-3-45.6 386.:3.5-5; 3:BA.6-5;
38. 7-35.99.9 . B:G :@94 :E9=45< :5< 38.6.EG <.@:G :5< <.?.:338.-5F.93-;:3-45:5<36-:@:5<A6:G34<-9B-9938. A.3-3-45
' .:6<:6;>B.539:5<A.6>9.<38.6.=46<
! 4BA@:-5:53 -9 B3:B:3: 49:;4><:6 A6.9.53@G 746D-5; :9 A.=-:@ :5< =J>-9-3-45 ??-=.6 8:67:<:9.<4538.:@@.;:3-45938:3-56.9A.=3 4?38.@:5<:=J>-9-3-45=4BA.59:3-458:9E..5A:-<37-=. 38. 8.:< 4??-=. 8:9 =45<>=3.< : A6.@-B-5:6G .5J>-6G :5< 9>EB-33.<6.A463-BA@-=:3-5;:==>9.<4934'E.-5;38. .BA@4G..94?:5<:@94:;:-59338.E.5.?-=-:6-.9
- 15 -
# 538.E:9-94?38.9:-<6.A46338.=4BA@:-53-9 ?-@.< 93:3-5; 38:3 384>;8 =4BA.59:3-45 8:9 E..5 ;6:53.< ?46:=J>-9-3-454?@:5<9:3.@:;.6->BB-;:33-:5<43>6 4? 8:67:< <>6-5; $( $( :5< $" 45=. :;:-5:343:@9>B4?9,,,!!$$$(-9A:-<EG:==>9.< 4-5=4@@>9-457-38:==>9.<4934'538.=4BA@:-53 -3 -9 93:3.< 38:3 78-@.
:==>9.< 49/ " :5< $ :6. 38. E.5.?-=-:6-.9 :==>9.< 4 34 ' :6. 38. :5D 4??-=-:@ -5F4@F.< -5 38. 9:-< =8.:3-5; 8. =4BA.59:3-45 -9 :@94 ;6:53.< -5 38. 5:B. 4? 45. :<:6:9:E :@:E8:F- :66:-;5.< :9 :==>9.< 4! >6-5; -5F.93-;:3-45 -3 -9 6.F.:@.<38:38.<-.<@45;E:=D:5<-5?:=38.8:<94@<8-9 @:5<:5<38.A>6=8:9.68:96.=.-F.<38.=4BA.59:3-45:5< 8-95:B.-9:@94>9.<34=8.:3
/ 47 A.3-3-45.6 784 -9 :66:-;5.< :9 :==>9.< 4" -9 9..D-5; E:-@ =@:-B-5; -554=.5=. 47.F.6 38. =8:6;. 98..3 =@.:6@G -5<-=:3. 38:3 8. -9 38. 45. 784 8:9 :=3.< :9 :5 :;.53 :5< 9.3 >A A.69459 34 =@:-B =4BA.59:3-45?4638.9.=45<3-B.5E438=8:6;.98..39
- 16 -
38.:=3-F.A:63A@:G.<EG8-B-9?4638=4B-5;538.@-;83 4? ;6:F-3G 4? :@@.;:3-459 B:<. :5< .546B-3G 4? :@@.;:3-45 B:<.38-94>63-94?38.=459-<.6.<4A-5-4538:3A.3-3-45.6 -9543.53-3@.<?46E:-@
" >6-5; 38. =4>69. 4? :6;>B.539 @.:65.< =4>59.@?4638.A.3-3-45.68:9A64<>=.<B.<-=:@=.63-?-=:3. <:3.<$#$':5<$$$!-99>.<EG6:;- 459>@3:53 -:E.34@4;-93 93:3-5; 38:3 38. B438.6 4? A.3-3-45.6 EG 5:B. &:3-B: >5<:98- :;.< '' G.:69 -9 9>??.6-5;?64B8.:63<-9.:9.*E@4=D:;.9-538.8.:63+:5< 6.J>-6.9 36.:3B.53 :3 :6:G:5 6><G:@:G: H=.A3 38. =.63-?-=:3.38.6.:6.54B:3.6-:@34984738:398.-9:-@-5;
:5< 7:9 >5<.6 36.:3B.53 7-38 6:;- :5< 6.J>-6.9 9>6;.6G538.E:-@A.3-3-45.F.5384>;8-3-993:3.<38:3 38.B438.64?A.3-3-45.6-99>??.6-5;?64B4@<:;.:-@B.539 54 <.3:-@9 :6. ?4638=4B-5; 9 4? 547 38. =.63-?-=:3.9 9.=>6.<EG38.A.3-3-45.6:AA.:6934E.:5:?3.6384>;83? 6.:@@G 38. B438.6 4? A.3-3-45.6 6.J>-6.9 :5G 9>6;.6G A.3-3-45.6B:G9..DA:64@.?4638.6.@.F:53A.6-4<:5<;.3
- 17 -
8.6 4A.6:3.< 4 ?:6 :9 38. =-3:3-459 6.@-.< >A45 EG 38. A.3-3-45.6 :6. =45=.65.< 38.G :6. 543 :AA@-=:E@. 34 38. ?:=39:5<=-6=>B93:5=.94?38.A6.9.53=:9. , &46 38. :E4F. 6.:9459 38-9 4>63 -9 4? 38. =459-<.6.< 4A-5-45 38:3 A.3-3-45.6 -9 543 .53-3@.< ?46 E:-@ :5<:==46<-5;@G38.?4@@47-5;
8.A.3-3-45?-@.<EG38.A.3-3-45.6(:==>9.< 4" >5<.6 .=3-45 ', 4? 4<. 4? 6-B-5:@ 64=.<>6.-98.6.EG6.I.=3.<
"-,
)'& (+ '
,